EP4: The Frat House Party | Secret Between Frat Bros (Patreon)
Content
I arrived at the frat house just after nine. The bass was already thumping through the walls like a heartbeat. The front yard was littered with red cups and guys in hoodies shouting over the music, the usual chaos of a Phi Hawaii Alpha party. Lights flashed from the windows and smoke curled from the porch where someone was still grilling late. I walked in casual, nodding at bros who slapped my back, and grabbed a beer from the keg in the kitchen. The place smelled like cheap lager, weed, and sweat. Perfect cover.
The mission was simple. Find ten minutes alone with Ronny. Any dark room. Any locked door. Anything. Yesterday’s shower was still sitting in my body and the blue balls from the gym earlier had only made it worse. I needed to get my hands on him again without the whole house finding out.
Ronny showed up ten minutes later. He caught my eye across the crowded living room, gave a quick lift of his chin, then blended into the pong table crowd like he belonged there. We didn’t rush it. We played it straight. Separate circles. Talking shit about last week’s game. Laughing at dumb stories. But every time our gazes crossed over someone’s shoulder the air between us crackled. My cock remembered the locker room too well. The way his throat had worked. The way his ass had clenched. His smirk said his body remembered it too.
I was halfway through my second beer when Claire appeared. Sorority girl, crop top riding high, skirt short enough to turn heads. Blonde hair, glossy red lips, the kind who knew exactly what she wanted when she locked eyes on me. We had hooked up a couple of times before. Easy, no strings, the kind of thing that kept my cover solid.
She slid up close, hand brushing my arm, voice low over the music. “You look like you’re having fun, Cade.”
I leaned in just enough so she could hear me. “Could be better.”
She smiled and pressed a little closer. “Yeah? What would make it better?”
I let her flirt for a while. Let her hand stay on my arm. Let her think she was the one steering this. The whole time my eyes kept drifting past her shoulder to where Ronny stood near the pong table, red cup in hand, laughing at something one of the seniors said. The black t-shirt he had on sat tight across his chest and shoulders. The way the fabric stretched every time he moved made it hard to look anywhere else.
Claire followed my gaze. “Who’s that?”
“Ronny. Pledge brother.”
She looked longer this time, eyes moving over him the same way mine had. “He’s hot.”
“Yeah. He is.”
She turned back to me with a small, knowing smile. “You thinking what I think you’re thinking?”
I took a slow drink of my beer and kept my voice casual. “Depends. You down for both of us?”
She glanced at Ronny again, then back at me. The smile widened. “Yeah. Let’s make it wild.”
I nodded toward the stairs. She followed, hips swaying. I caught Ronny’s eye across the room and gave him the smallest lift of my chin. He peeled away from his conversation like it was nothing and trailed behind us. A senior named Adam saw the three of us heading upstairs together and smirked like he knew exactly what was about to happen. In his head it was just two pledges about to tag-team a girl. He had no idea what the real secret was.
The upstairs hallway was dim. Doors closed. Muffled moans leaked from a couple of the rooms. We found an empty bedroom at the end of the hall. Bed unmade. Posters of half-naked girls on the walls. A lock that actually worked. The door clicked shut behind us and the music became a distant thump through the floor.
Claire turned to face us, already reaching for the hem of her crop top. “You two just gonna stand there or what?”
I stepped in first and kissed her, slow enough to look convincing. Behind her I felt Ronny move closer. When I broke the kiss I looked past her shoulder and met his eyes. The look we exchanged lasted a second too long.
She pulled the crop top over her head and let the skirt drop. Naked quick, skin already flushed from the attention. Ronny and I followed slower. Shirts off. Shorts and underwear dropped. My cock was already thick and heavy from the anticipation. Ronny’s matched it. Thick, veined, the head already glistening. We stood there for a moment in the low light, three naked bodies, Claire between us like a bridge we were about to use.
She sat on the edge of the bed and reached for both of us at the same time, one hand wrapping around my cock, the other around his. She stroked us slowly, looking up with a smile like she was enjoying the show. My eyes never left Ronny. His chest rose and fell, hairy pecs flexing, hazel eyes locked on mine over her head. I stepped closer so my cock brushed her cheek as she leaned in and took him into her mouth first.
She moaned around him, loud and wet, but I barely heard it. I watched Ronny’s face instead. The way his lips parted. The way his gaze never left mine. While she sucked his cock I let my hand slide down his back, low, until my fingers found the curve of his ass. I squeezed once, hard enough for him to feel it, then let my fingers drift between his cheeks and press lightly against his hole.
Ronny’s eyes fluttered. He pushed deeper into her mouth with a short thrust and a low sound slipped out of him.
“Aahh fuck yeah… just like that. Deeper… shit.”
The words could have been for her. We both knew they weren’t only for her.
I kept the pressure of my finger right there and tapped the head of my cock against her cheek.
“Yeah, fuck. Get some of this too.”
She pulled off him with a wet sound and turned her head, taking me into her mouth instead. The heat of it was good, but it was nothing compared to the feeling of my finger sliding inside Ronny’s tight hole; the dude I had been dying to fuck again since this morning.
Ronny’s hand moved to her hair. He gripped it and guided her deeper onto my cock.
“Fuck… deeper… shit… yeah.”
The words were aimed at her, but the way his eyes locked on mine made it feel like he was telling me to go deeper too. I pushed my finger further inside him and watched his mouth fall open. A low moan slipped out of him before he could stop it.
We were just two pledges standing over a girl, both of us touching each other like the real thing was happening just out of her sight.
She pulled off with a wet sound and looked up. The second her mouth left me I slipped my finger out of Ronny’s hole and let my hand fall away like nothing had happened.
Claire glanced between the two of us, a little smile on her face. “You both can touch each other too, you know.”
I let out a short laugh and shook my head. “Nah. Fuck, that’s gay.”
Ronny huffed from the other side of her. “Nah, I’m good.”
She rolled her eyes like she didn’t fully believe us but also didn’t care. “Okay, whatever. Fuck me then.”
I guided her further onto the bed and had her lie on her back. Ronny moved between her legs. I climbed up near her head, knees on either side of her shoulders, and fed my cock back into her mouth so that my balls rested near her eyes. Her vision was mostly blocked. Perfect.
Ronny pushed into her slowly. She moaned around my cock. I watched his face the entire time. The way his abs tightened. The way his eyes stayed locked on mine while he fucked her.
Every thrust rocked his body a little closer. I shifted my hips and let my balls rest heavier against her mouth so she could suck on them. The change in angle pulled Ronny nearer without either of us saying a word.
He kept fucking her in the same steady rhythm, hips rolling deep, but his upper body started to lean forward at the same time. One hand stayed braced on the bed beside her waist. The other gripped her thigh. Inch by inch he came down over her, still driving into her, until his face was only inches from my cock. I could feel the heat of his breath against my skin.
I looked down at him and spoke in a voice that could have been meant for her.
“Fuck. Take it. Yeah. Just like that.”
Ronny’s eyes flicked up to mine. He understood. He leaned in the last little bit and dragged his tongue once along the base of my cock, right where her lips were stretched around me moments here. The contact was quick and hidden. Then he moved down and kissed her neck instead, deep and distracting, so she stayed lost in it and never noticed what had just happened.
I groaned low. “Fuck, bro.”
The word slipped out before I could stop it. Claire was too busy moaning into my balls to catch the meaning. Ronny heard it clear as day. He fucked her harder, eyes still on me, and reached up with one hand. His fingers found mine where I was braced on the sheets. We laced them together for a second, electric, before he let go and went back to gripping her hip.
She came hard under him, body shaking, moaning around my cock as the orgasm ripped through her. Ronny kept thrusting through it until she went loose and heavy. He pulled out and stroked himself twice, then came across her stomach and tits in thick ropes. I pulled out of her mouth at the same time, wrapped my hand around my cock, and stroked hard like I was right there with him. I let out a loud, rough moan.
“Yeah… fuck… yeah—”
I aimed at her chest and pretended to finish, hips jerking like I was shooting, but nothing came out. My cock stayed rock hard, throbbing in my fist. The only cum that actually hit her skin was Ronny’s. Mine was still locked up tight. It wasn’t going to spill for her. It was only going to spill when it was buried inside Ronny’s ass.
She lay there breathing hard, eyes half closed, a satisfied little smile on her face. “Holy shit,” she mumbled. “You two are dangerous together.”
We both laughed quietly, the sound rough. She stretched, sighed, and rolled onto her side. Her eyes were getting heavier by the second. The orgasm was dragging her under. We watched her for a minute, neither of us moving. Her breathing slowed. The mumbling faded. Eventually she went still, completely out.
The room got quiet except for the distant bass and our own breathing.
Ronny looked at me. I looked at him. Claire was right there between us, naked and sleeping, our cum still drying on her skin. For the first time all night there was no one watching. No one listening. No one who could see what we actually wanted.
I reached over and threw a towel across her body, covering her a bit. Then I looked fully toward Ronny. He did the same. We were close enough that I could feel the heat coming off his skin. His cock was still half hard. Mine was the same.
The secret sat heavy in the space between us.
We were finally alone.────୨ৎ────