Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout.

Saturday evening started in Miles and Sophie’s car, which already told me I was in my head. I could have driven myself. I didn't . Sitting in the backseat felt easier than arriving alone and standing in a doorway looking for him.

Sophie turned around in the passenger seat and looked me over.

“Okay. You look good tonight.”

Miles glanced at me in the rearview. “He does. That’s a dangerous shirt, Evan.”

It was black, fitted through the shoulders, open just enough at the collar to look like I had tried. Dark blue jeans. The kind of clean I didn’t usually bother with for a birthday dinner. I had stood in front of the mirror longer than I wanted to admit.

Sophie grinned. “You might not be going home alone tonight.”

“Please don’t start,” I said.

“I’m just saying. Riley invites half the class every year. There will be options.”

Miles glanced at me again in the mirror. “Just try not to start a scene before we even get a drink.”

I looked out the window and let them talk. The only option I cared about already had a girlfriend. He was the untouchable alpha of our group, the one everybody looked at without thinking twice, the one who walked into a room and made it tilt. Nobody in that car knew what we had done at the cabin. Nobody knew I was sitting in the backseat already looking for him. He had Taylor. He had the whole group. And I was still dressing like I wanted him to notice.

The place Riley booked was louder than I expected. Not a quiet sit-down. A restaurant she had taken over for the night, lights low, music up, people already in clusters with drinks in their hands. A few faces I hadn’t seen since last year. People laughing too loud. The whole room had that reunion energy, like everybody had decided to pretend they were still 20 for one night.

We spotted them near the bar.

Riley first, bright and moving, the kind of social gravity that made a room orbit her. Zach and Kara next to her. Taylor in a dark dress, already smiling. And Colton.

I saw the shirt before I finished seeing the rest of him. Maroon. Worn looser than he usually wore anything, a few buttons open down the middle. His chest was shaved smooth and easy to see. A silver chain sat against his skin, a small pendant resting in the open V of the shirt. Black pants. Fresh haircut. He looked expensive. He looked like he knew it.

He always wore fitted shirts. This one sat differently. It hung off his shoulders and still somehow made him look bigger. The chain kept catching the light when he turned his head.

Miles let out a low laugh. “Yeah. I’m definitely underdressed.”

Sophie was already pulling us forward. “Come on.”

Colton saw me before we reached them. His eyes went from my face down my chest, down my jeans, then back up to my lips. Slow. Open. The smirk that followed was small and private and meant for me. I couldn’t stop looking at the open shirt. At the chain. At the fact that the man who had been inside me two weeks ago was standing next to his girlfriend looking like that.

Sophie reached Riley and wrapped her in a hug.

“Happy birthday girl. You look hot.”

Riley squeezed her back. “You made it. I was starting to think the boys were going to flake.”

Miles hugged her next. “We contain hunger. We don’t flake on free dinner.”

Riley laughed and then saw me. “Evan. Hey. You actually came.”

“Happy birthday,” I said, and let her hug me. She smelled like perfume and wine. Over her shoulder Colton was still looking at me.

When Riley let go, Miles nodded at Colton’s shirt.

“I see we dressed for a magazine cover. Meanwhile I’m in this.”

Zach pointed his drink at Colton. “If he wasn’t dating Taylor he wouldn’t be going home alone tonight. Look at him.”

Taylor’s hand landed on Colton’s bicep immediately, playful and pointed.

“He’s only going home with me. Sorry to ruin the fantasy, Zach.”

Zach put a hand over his heart. “Devastated. Truly.”

Colton looked at me. I looked at him. The noise of the room sat around that look and didn’t touch it.

Riley leaned into Taylor, smiling. “I had such a huge crush on this man in college. I am not even embarrassed about it anymore. Half my sorority lost their minds every time he walked into a party. We used to make up reasons to stand near him.”

Taylor laughed, a little pink, a little proud.

Riley kept going. “And he was so stuck on you. It was disgusting. It’s nice seeing you two still going strong.”

Taylor smiled like that was the simplest truth in the room.

I stood there with a drink I hadn’t asked for yet and thought about the deck. About his cock pushing into me while she slept upstairs. About him saying he loved her in the same week he told me he would save me a load. Still going strong looked different from the inside.

The night opened up after that. People moved. Riley made the rounds. Music got louder. I stopped tracking the food and just tracked the room. Taylor stayed close to him. Her hand on his arm. His arm around her waist when someone took a photo. He played the part the way he always did, easy and hot and certain, the alpha boyfriend everybody expected him to be.

I couldn’t keep my eyes off him.

Every time I told myself to look at Zach, or the bar, or Riley’s friends, my gaze drifted back to that maroon shirt. To the open buttons. To the chain resting against his chest. And every time I looked, he was already looking at me. Not long enough for anyone else to notice. Long enough that I felt it in my stomach.

Later the seven of us ended up at the bar. I took a stool. Kara had her chin in her hand, eyes narrowed at something over my shoulder.

“Martin’s been checking you out the entire night.”

I turned just enough to see him.

Martin stood near the far end of the bar with two guys I half remembered from classes I didn’t pay attention to. Tall. Built. A strong Black man with a face that had always done damage and a body that filled out a blue t-shirt like it had been pulled on after the fact. Easy smile. He looked good. He looked like every night in college I wasn’t supposed to talk about. When our eyes met he didn’t pretend he hadn’t been watching.

Sophie leaned in, trying to be subtle. “Didn’t you guys… you know.”

Zach wasn’t interested in being subtle. “They boned. Multiple times. Don’t rewrite history.”

“Zach.”

“What? They hooked up. Like a lot. And now we’re all going to pretend Evan’s some shy little virgin?”

I felt heat climb my neck. “Can you not?”

Zach grinned, pleased with himself.

“It was just a no-strings thing,” I said. “It didn’t mean anything.”

I said it to the group. I meant it for him.

Colton had gone still in that way he did when he was paying attention. His drink was in his hand. He hadn’t lifted it.

“Looks like he wants you again tonight,” he said.

His voice was casual. His face wasn’t quite.

I smiled. “Maybe he does.”

Then I got off the stool.

I didn’t have a plan that was smarter than that. I walked over. Martin’s smile widened as I came in.

“Evan. Damn. I was hoping you’d show.”

“Riley would kill me if I skipped.”

He laughed, too long, and his hand landed on my arm. Light. Familiar. The kind of touch that used to lead somewhere. I let it stay. We talked about nothing. Work. The party. How weird it was seeing the same people with better clothes and the same jokes. He leaned in when the music swelled. I smiled like I was enjoying it.

I was, a little. Not because of Martin.

From the side I could see the group. Colton was watching. When our eyes met he looked away first, back toward Taylor, like the bar had suddenly become interesting.

Martin said something about getting another drink. I said maybe later. I touched his arm once, just enough to make it look like I was having a good time, and then I walked back.

Sophie saw my face and immediately pointed. “Oh my god. He’s blushing.”

“I am not.”

Zach lifted his glass. “So. Getting laid tonight?”

I looked at Colton. His jaw had gone tight. Not obvious. Just enough.

“I don’t know,” I said, looking at Colton. “We’ll see what the night has for me.”

Taylor smiled at me, warm and completely unaware. “You should. He seems nice. And you look really handsome tonight.”

That one landed harder than Zach’s joke. I thanked her and took a drink I didn’ taste.

The party kept moving. Riley pulled people into photos. Kara dragged Zach onto the floor for one song and then abandoned him. Miles found a corner and looked like he was studying the room for sport. I stayed near the group and felt Colton close the distance without making a show of it.

He appeared at my shoulder when I went to get water. He ended up on my other side when Zach started a story. His voice came low once, just my name, like he was testing whether I would turn.

I did.

We drifted a few steps off the circle, close enough to still be part of it, far enough that the next part stayed between us.

“So,” Colton said. “Martin.”

“What about him?”

“You two looked comfortable.”

I kept my face easy. “We used to be.”

“Used to.”

“That’s what I said.”

Colton’s eyes flicked past me, then back. He was fishing and trying not to look like he was fishing.

“He’s hot,” I said. “I want dick tonight. If you’re not going to give it, somebody else will.”

The words came out more pointed than I planned. I didn’t take them back.

Colton looked at me for a long second. The smirk that usually sat on his mouth was gone.

“I never said I wouldn’t give you dick.”

That one surprised me enough that I actually laughed, quiet and disbelieving.

“What. Here?”

He leaned in. Close enough that I caught the clean scent of his skin. His breath hit my ear.

“Bathroom. Five minutes.”

Then he stepped away like the conversation had been about the bar tab. He kissed Taylor on the cheek, said something that made her smile, and walked toward the corridor at the back of the room. He looked at me once over his shoulder before the crowd took him.

I stayed where I was.

Martin was still at the far end of the bar. Taylor was laughing at something Kara said. The group was intact. The night was still a birthday dinner. And Colton had just told me to meet him in a bathroom in five minutes after two weeks of almost nothing.

I thought about the photo of him in that black shirt at dinner with her. I thought about the load he said he would save for me. I thought about the way his eyes had gone tight when I walked over to Martin.

I looked at the corridor.

Then I put my drink down and walked.

The hallway was narrower and quieter. Music dulled behind me. A couple passed going the other way, too busy talking to care. The bathroom door was at the end. I pushed it open.

Colton was already there.

He stood at the sink, maroon shirt still open at the chest, chain catching the light, both hands braced on the counter like he had been waiting and trying not to look like he was waiting. Our eyes met in the mirror first. Then he turned his head.

Neither of us said anything.

────୨ৎ────

EP 19

Comments

Dan

I’m so torn between enjoying a slow burn and throwing my credit card at the screen to get the full story!

DanXWrites

I haven’t written much beyond the next few chapters yet, otherwise I would’ve happily given you guys early access to the PDF. I see this one being a much longer story, so it’s going to take a little while to unfold. Hopefully you enjoy the slow burn… with plenty of filth along the way. ;)

Dan

Can’t wait!