EP11: Your Boy’s Occupied | Secret Between Frat Bros (Patreon)
Content
The house didn’t turn into a mixer all at once. It filled the way those nights always filled. First the speakers. Then the keg line. Then girls coming up the porch steps in groups, laughing too loud, already a little drunk from whatever they had started before they got here. I was in the main room with a cup I wasn’t drinking fast enough, Ronny at my shoulder, both of us still wearing the work-duty sweat from noon like it counted as a shower.
Pete found us before the first game even started.
“There they are. Married couple. You two clock in together too?”
A couple brothers laughed. I bumped Ronny’s cup with mine and made the face that said this was funny. Ronny did it better than I did. He had been doing it better all day.
“Somebody’s gotta keep him from falling in the keg,” Ronny said.
“Yeah, yeah.” Pete looked between us like he still thought there was a joke he hadn’t gotten yet. Then a pack of girls came through the door and his attention snapped off us the way it always did when there was something easier to chase.
Adam was already in the room. Shirt on now. Red shorts swapped for regular ones. He looked like a senior at his own house, not like the guy who had sat in my desk chair last night with his cock out. That was the problem. He looked normal. He looked good. Every time he moved through the crowd I felt it in my shorts and hated that I felt it. Ronny was right next to me. I still clocked the way Adam’s shirt sat on his chest. I still remembered the trail of hair I had stared at over the keg. I made myself look at the door instead, at the next pack of girls coming up the steps, at anything that was not Adam.
Ronny tipped his drink at the door. “Place is about to get stupid.”
“Yeah.”
“Don’t vanish on me if it does.”
“I’m right here.”
He almost smiled. Then Claire walked in.
Ronny’s smile dropped off his face.
“Ah shit.”
I followed his look. Crop top. Hair up. That same loud mouth from the last house party, the one we had taken upstairs with us.
“Fuck, it’s Claire.”
“Yeah. I see that.” Ronny’s voice went tight. “You think she remembers?”
“Remembers us taking her upstairs, or remembers how weird we got once she was out?”
“Any of it.” He shifted his cup to his other hand. “If she’s coming back for a fuck, you gotta handle her.”
“Why me?”
“Because if she latches onto both of us again, Pete’s gonna smell it. One of us can play it off. Two of us looks like a pattern.”
“She’s walking straight at us.”
“Then say something. Get in front of it.”
I started to. I even took half a step like I was going to cut her off and make it look easy. She never gave me the chance. She spotted Ronny, said his name too bright, and cut through people like the house had been built around her finding him.
“There he is. I was hoping you’d be here.”
Ronny blinked, then played it because he had to. “Claire.”
She hooked her hand around his arm and leaned into him like she already had the right. The house saw a girl on a pledge. That was useful. What I saw was simpler. She had walked in, scanned the room, and gone straight to him. Not me. Him. Last time, she had both of us in that upstairs bed. Tonight she only wanted Ronny.
“You disappeared after,” she said, loud enough for anyone nearby. “Rude.”
“You passed out,” Ronny said.
“So,” She grinned up at him, winked, and squeezed his arm. “You gonna make it up to me tonight or what?”
Ronny looked at me over her hair. Just a flash. I almost laughed. It was kind of funny. She was hanging on him like she wanted to take him home, and he was the same guy who had been begging for my cock last night.
Pete materialized so fast I almost did laugh. Fresh beer. Eyes all over Claire first, then Ronny, like he had just watched the exact thing he wanted walk into the house.
“Claire. You came.” Pete said.
She gave him a look that was friendly and not that friendly. “I came to see him.”
“Even better.” Pete clapped Ronny’s shoulder and kept his hand there, extra warm, extra close. “He’s on my team tonight. Pong table. Don’t even think about wandering off, brother. We are about to run this house.”
Ronny glanced at me again. I gave him nothing he could use. What was I going to say in a packed room? Stay. Come with me. Don’t let Pete turn this into his night. He let Claire keep his arm and let Pete steer him toward the table because that was what it looked like from the outside. A girl who wanted him. A senior who wanted to be in on the action. A pledge getting exactly the kind of attention the house understood.
I stayed near the keg and watched it happen.
Ronny at the table. Claire hanging on him between throws. Pete crowding the same space like he could get in on the action tonight if he stood close enough. Every time Ronny lined up a cup, Claire said something in his ear and he laughed. Every time he laughed I felt that stupid possessive pull in my gut. Last night he had been in my bed. Down here he was a pledge with a girl on his arm and I couldn’t put a hand on him.
He sank the first cup. The table roared. Claire kissed his cheek. Pete howled like he had done it himself and shoved another ball into Ronny’s hand before he could even look around.
“That’s what I’m talking about. Don’t you fucking move. We are on a run.”
Ronny found me over her hair anyway. I lifted my cup. He nodded once. Then Pete was talking again and the look was gone.
Adam ended up next to me with two beers like he had just been getting drinks. He didn’t look at me first. He looked at the table.
“Pete thinks he’s getting in on that,” Adam said, low.
I kept my eyes forward. “On Claire?”
“Yeah. He saw you two take her upstairs last time. Now he thinks it’s his turn.”
I watched Pete’s hand stay on Ronny’s back a second too long.
“He’s going to be waiting a long time,” I said.
Adam’s mouth ticked. “You sure? Your boy looks pretty comfortable.”Ronny missed the next shot and Claire made a show of groaning for him. Pete used it as an excuse to get closer, hand on Ronny’s back, saying something I couldn’t hear. Ronny laughed because he had to. I watched his shoulders stay tight anyway, even with both of them on him.
“He’s stuck,” I said. “Pete’s not letting him breathe.”
“That’s the point,” Adam said. “He’s not letting him off that table unless somebody carries him.”
I looked at Adam then. Really looked. Shirt tight across his chest. That same body from noon, just covered enough to get away with it in a packed room. I told myself I was still talking about the table. I wasn’t. I was staring at the place I had stared at over the keg, except now there was a shirt in the way and it wasn’t helping.
Adam caught it. Of course he did.
“Careful,” he said, low. “Your boy’s right there.”
“I’m watching the game.”
“You’re watching me.”
I looked back at the table like that could undo it. Ronny lined up another cup. Claire was still on his arm. Pete was still glued to both of them.
“Pete can stand there all night,” I said. “He’s not getting her. He’s just hoping Ronny shares.”
Adam’s mouth pulled to one side. “Then why are you over here with me instead of at that table?”
I didn’t answer.
He let the silence sit there like he was enjoying it, then tipped his cup at the table.
“You left him down there on purpose. Don’t act like you didn’t.”
“He couldn’t leave.”
“You didn’t ask him to.”
That one landed because it was true. I had watched Pete lock him onto that table and used it.
Adam watched the pong table for another second, then made a sound like he was done waiting on me to admit anything.
“Your boy’s occupied,” he said. “If you’re done playing boyfriends down here, come find out what a real dick feels like.”
He didn’t wait for an answer. He just cut through the crowd and took the stairs. At the bottom he glanced over his shoulder and found me anyway. Not long. Just enough. Then the senior hall swallowed him.
Ronny didn’t see it. He was mid-throw. Claire had her chin on his shoulder. Pete was already talking about the next game.
I stood there with my cup and felt the night split.
I could stay in the main room and be the guy who figured it out by keeping Adam away. I could go upstairs and be the guy who had been getting hard over his pics for days, the guy who had twitched in his shorts the second those red shorts showed up at noon, the guy who had followed a look up a staircase. Ronny laughed at something Claire said. Pete told him not to even think about leaving.
“Downstairs bathroom is fucked,” a pledge said behind me, louder this time. “Line’s out the door. I’m going up.”
Somebody answered him. “Hall bath. If that’s locked you’re pissing in the yard.”
The downstairs line got longer. My excuse wrote itself.
I set the cup on the speaker.
I told myself I needed to piss. Upstairs. That was all this was.
I didn’t tell Ronny I was going.
By the time I hit the stairs the bass was a floor below me. The senior hall was dimmer, quieter, beer-sour, a closed door leaking somebody’s playlist. The hall bath was occupied. Of course it was. I passed it anyway because that was not the real reason why I had come up.
Adam’s door was open a crack.
I should have kept walking. I put my hand on the wood and pushed it.
He was already inside, standing like he had been listening for the hallway. Room messy in a senior way. Clothes on a chair. A mini fridge humming. Bass coming up through the floor so the party still existed, just not in here.
He reached past me and shut the door.
“There you are, pledge.”
The click of it landing in the frame made my pulse jump. We were dressed. We were upright. It still felt like Friday night for a second, except this time I had walked in on purpose.
“Bathroom’s occupied,” I said.
Adam smiled like I had told a cute lie. “Yeah. That’s why you stopped at my door.”
“I was just… I mean, you said—” I stopped, heat in my face, and tried again. “You said you’d be up here.”
“And here you are.” He didn’t back up at first. He let me have the door at my spine and the rest of the room behind him. Close. Not touching. I could smell him. Soap and beer and warm skin. “You didn’t tell Santos you were coming.”
“He couldn’t leave the table.”
Adam’s eyes dropped to my mouth, then lower. He did not pretend he did not. “You didn’t try that hard.”
I should have denied it. I stared at the space between us instead.
He tipped his chin at my shorts.
“You sure you came up here to piss?”
I followed his look before I could stop myself. The tent was obvious. Stupidly obvious. My cock was fat against the front of my shorts and there was no way to blame the stairs for it.
“That’s not—”
“It is.” He said it mild, almost nice. “Same thing I saw at noon. Same thing I saw last night.”
“I’m into Ronny.”
“I know.” Adam finally stepped back. Not far. Just enough to put air between us and make me watch him do it. His hands went to his shirt.
He popped the first button. Then the next. Slow. Watching my face the whole time.
“That’s why you keep showing up hard every time I take my clothes off.”
The shirt opened down his chest, then his stomach, that dark line of hair coming into view again. Same body from the kitchen doorway. Same body from the chair in my dorm. Except now it was two feet in front of me and there was no porch full of frat bros to hide behind.
I looked.
Adam glanced down at my shorts and let out a quiet breath that was almost a laugh.
“Look at that. Your cock’s already twitching.”
He was right. It jumped again while I stood there, stupid and obvious, like it had been waiting for the next button.
He let the shirt hang open and didn’t take it off the rest of the way. He just stood there in it, chest bare, waiting to see if I was going to reach for the door or keep doing what I was doing.
The party was still going under the floor. Ronny was still at that table.
I didn’t reach for the door.
I kept looking.
────୨ৎ────