EP16: Don’t You Dare Think About Him | Secret Between Frat Bros (Patreon)
Content
Recap: Earlier tonight I secretly had sex with a frat senior while the mixer was still going under his floor. Adam shut the door, I rode him, and I wouldn’t kiss him. He came in me and told me to go find my boy. I left his room sore, hole full of his cum, and started down the stairs knowing Ronny still thought the secret was only ours.
The load was already leaking between my cheeks by the time I hit the main room. Ronny found me before I was ready. I lied about the bathroom line. He did not fully buy it, but he let it go long enough to tell me Claire had a thing for firsts and that was why she had moved on to Pete thinking he was a virgin.
Against the side of the house, Ronny kissed me and pinned my hands to the wall. Claire’s kink had gotten into him. He wanted to switch. He wanted to be the one who fucked me, and he had no idea my hole was already full and had been leaking all night. I stopped his hand before he found it. We snuck back to my dorm, locked the door, and got naked. He pushed me onto the bed and sucked my dick, then went lower, licking my balls and saying I tasted really fucking good. He didn’t know he was tasting Adam’s cum. Then he spread me and licked between my cheeks. He pulled back, mouth wet, and looked up at me.
He asked why my ass tasted like cum.
────୨ৎ────
EP16: Don’t You Dare Think About Him
Ronny was still between my legs when he said it, mouth wet from the lick, voice low enough that it didn’t need to be loud.
“Cade. Why the fuck does your ass taste like somebody came in it?”
I was on my back, breathing hard, cock flushed and leaking from his mouth, hole open and shining where he had just had his tongue. The question sat in the room heavier than anything we had done on the way here. I stared at the ceiling for a second because looking at him made it worse. He was hard. He had not moved off me. He was waiting.
“It sort of just happened.”
Even I heard how weak it was. Ronny didn’t laugh. He stayed where he was, hands on my thighs, hazel eyes on my face like he was putting the night together in the wrong order.
“So while I was trying to get Claire off my back,” he said, “you were busy…” He let it hang. “Having sex with Adam.”
I tried to soften it and the words fell apart in my mouth. “It’s not… I… Shit. Yeah. I don’t know. He pulled me up and one thing led to another and—”
“And he fucked you.”
I went quiet. He was close enough that I could see he was still hard, still here, not reaching for his clothes or the door. The silence answered for me.
“And you liked it.”
His hand slid down between us. He found my hole, slick with what Adam had left, and he didn’t pretend it was anything else. One finger pushed in, easy, then a second, and he worked them slowly, spreading the cum, feeling how open I already was. I whimpered the second they sank. The sound came out of me before I could stop it. My cock jumped against his stomach. More of the mess eased out around his fingers, sticky and warm, and he felt it. His own cock thickened against my hip.
“Fuck,” I breathed.
“So I won’t be the first dick you’ll be getting tonight.”
I didn’t have a line for that. He curled his fingers once, mean and curious, and my hips lifted off the mattress. He ground against me while he did it, cock dragging along mine, both of us hard, the friction wet from what I was leaking on both our stomachs. I could feel the cum moving inside me every time his fingers pressed. I could feel him getting harder from the sound I was making.
He came up the bed without taking his hand away. Chest to chest. Face close. Then he kissed me.
It was angry and hot and not sweet at all. Mouth open. A bite on my lower lip that he soothed with his tongue a second later. I kissed him back immediately, hands on his shoulders, grateful and guilty and so hard it hurt. While we kissed he kept fingering me, the wet sound right there between our bodies, and I moaned into his mouth like I couldn’t help it. He groaned back and pressed our cocks together, grinding, thick against thick, while his fingers stayed buried in the mess Adam had left.
He pulled back just enough to talk, breath on my lips. “I’m still going to fuck you tonight.”
I smiled before I could stop it. Shocked. Relieved. “Fuck yeah.”
He took his fingers out. I felt the loss and the slick that followed. He guided the head of his cock against my hole and tapped it there, blunt and hot, right on the place that was already open for him. “Don’t you fucking smile. And don’t you dare think about him while I’m in you.”
“No. Fuck. I won’t.” I shook my head, already pushing down toward him. “Ronny, I won’t.”
He pushed in facing me.
Slow. I was already open, so the head sank easier than it should have, and both of us felt it. There was still a stretch. Different cock. Different weight. Thicker in a way that made my thighs shake even though Adam had just been there. Ronny bottomed out and stayed, hips flush to my ass, and the fullness knocked the air out of me. My legs came up around his waist on their own. I had to look at him. That was the point. His face was right there, jaw tight, eyes on mine, and I couldn’t pretend this was anyone else.
“Fuck,” I said. “You’re… fuck.”
“Yeah.” He rolled his hips once, deep, and I felt every inch of it. “Feel that? That’s me.”
He started to move. Long strokes. Out until the head almost slipped, back in until our bodies met and the wet sound got louder. Cum and spit and me. Neither of us pretended not to hear it. He watched my face the whole time. I moaned a lot. I couldn’t keep it quiet. My hands slid over his back, gripped his shoulders, and every time a stroke landed right I heard myself say it.
“Fuck. Right there.”
He did it again. Same angle. Same depth. I tightened around him and he groaned, low and rough, and kept the pace steady like he wanted me to feel all of it. My cock was trapped between our stomachs, leaking, dragging against his skin every time he thrust. I was a mess. He was making it worse on purpose.
“Yeah,” he said, voice gone rough. “You like getting fucked, don’t you, Cade.”
“Fuck. Ronny. Yeah.”
“Pretending you’re the alpha.” He drove in harder and stayed there for a second. “Fucking the shit out of me for weeks. Look at you now.”
I smirked even while I was taking it, legs tight around his waist, hole clenching around him. “If I had known bottoming felt like this, I’d have had you fuck me long before tonight.”
His face changed. The cocky edge slipped. He fucked in harder, hips snapping, and the bed moved under us. “Yeah? So why’d you go to Adam then?.”
I didn’t have a good answer. The truth was messy and he was railing me through it. “I don’t know. He was just there. He wanted it. I… fuck, I don’t know, Ronny.”
“He was there.” Another thrust, deep enough that I gasped. “And you sat on his cock.”
“Ronny—”
“Shut up and take me.”
I did. He set a rougher rhythm and I took every stroke, moaning into the space between our mouths, hands gripping his back hard enough to leave marks. He wrapped a hand around my cock and stroked in time, wet and tight, then stopped when my stomach started to tighten.
He almost pulled out. I felt the head catch at my rim, felt how slick he was with what had already been in me, and he looked down at where we were joined like he wanted to see it. Then he pushed back in, slow and mean, all the way, like he was replacing whatever Adam had left.
“You feel that?” he said. “That’s me. Not him.”
“I feel it.” My voice cracked on it. “Fuck, I feel it.”
He hooked one of my legs higher, still facing me, and got deeper. The angle changed. I moaned louder than I meant to, head tipping back, and he kissed my throat while he fucked me through it. Not sweet. Hungry. His cock dragged over the spot that made my thighs shake, and he noticed, and he stayed there until I was gasping his name and nothing else. The bed kept moving. My cock slapped against my stomach, leaking, and every time he bottomed out I felt the cum shift inside me, his and what was left of Adam’s, until I couldn’t tell them apart.
“This what you wanted when you pinned me outside?” I managed.
“Yeah.” He thrust in and ground there. “This. You. Not a fucking first for show.”
“Then— fuck— then keep going.”
“Take it like you mean it.”
“I’m taking it.” I pushed back to meet him, hole clenching, and the sound that left me was wrecked. “Fuck, Ronny, I’m taking it.”
He fucked me harder for that. Pissed and hard and still the one who had stayed. I said his name. I didn’t say Adam’s. My hands slid down to his ass and pulled him in deeper, and he let me, groaning against my mouth, rhythm going rough at the edges. I could feel him getting close in the way his thrusts shortened and his breathing broke. He dropped his forehead to mine and kept fucking me through it, eyes open, making sure I was looking at him.
“I’m coming in you.”
I nodded, mouth open, already gone. “Do it. Don’t pull out.”
He slammed in and stayed. Hips flush. I felt him pulse, thick and hot, adding his load to what was already there. The stretch of it, the heat, the way my hole clenched around him while he finished, knocked a broken sound out of me. He was staking it. Right there. While he was still throbbing inside me, his hand found my cock again and stripped it fast and wet, thumb rubbing the head, and I did not last.
I came between us. Over my own stomach, over his, moaning into his mouth while my legs shook and my hole kept clenching around his cock. He kissed me through it. Not sweet. He ground in while I finished, letting me feel every pulse, and I held onto him like the bed might disappear.
We stayed like that. Him still inside. Both of us breathing hard. Cum on our stomachs. More of it leaking around his cock now that he had added his own. The room smelled like sex and the lock was still on the door. He didn’t pull out right away. He stayed in me a second longer than he needed to, forehead against mine, and when he spoke it was low.
“Next time you want to bottom for him,” he said, “you ask me.”
I didn’t have a clean answer. My hand was still on his back. My hole was still full of both of them. “Okay.”
It was enough for tonight.
He pulled out slowly. Both of us felt the mess that followed, warm and obscene, slicking my cheeks and the sheet under me. He didn’t get dressed. He did not reach for the door. He stayed on the bed, one arm coming over my waist, heavy and warm, and I let him.
Jim was still gone until Monday.
I was sore from both of them, leaking, and Ronny was still there like a claim and not a promise.
I closed my eyes. The secret was heavier than it had been on the stairs. And I knew, even then, that the next time Adam looked at me, this was the body Ronny had just taken back.
────୨ৎ────