The Untouchable Alpha Bro | EP28: Leave Him Alone, Babe (Patreon)
Content
Recap: Colton stayed over last night.Taylor was at her sister’s until Sunday, and he showed up from the gym in a tank and shorts, sweaty, bag in hand, like the empty house had never been an option. He stripped in my hallway, walked naked into my bedroom, and waited on my bed like he already lived there. I got my mouth on him. Then I rode him. No condom. No one coming home. He kissed me while he came inside me, then asked if it meant something. I told him it didn’t. He stayed anyway. His bag is still by the couch. The arrangement is starting to feel like something else, and neither of us has said it.
────୨ৎ────
EP28: Leave Him Alone, Babe
I woke up with a hand on my stomach.
Big. Warm. Fingers spread wide across my abs like he was keeping something from rolling away. For a second I didn’t know where I was. Then the weight behind me shifted, and a chest pressed into my back, and I remembered the whole night at once.
Colton was spooning me.
In my bed. On a Saturday. His breath slow against the back of my neck.
And his cock hard against my ass.
Morning hard. Pressed right into the crease through his boxers like it had clocked in before the rest of him. I lay very still and tried to decide whether I was allowed to enjoy this, which was a stupid question with my own dick already answering it.
“You’re awake,” he said into my hair. His voice was all gravel.
“I’m not.”
“Your ass just pushed back into me.”
“That was a reflex.”
“Mm.” He rolled his hips, one lazy grind, and his cock dragged along me hot and heavy and in no rush at all. “Reflex again?”
I closed my eyes. My body did want it, and that was the problem. The rest of me had been fucked raw hours ago and was filing a formal complaint.
“Give me some time to rest,” I said. “You might be a fuck machine, but my asshole needs time to recover.”
Colton laughed. It shook his whole chest against my back.
“Fuck machine,” he said. “I’m putting that on the gym’s website.”
“Put it under your headshot.”
“Five stars. Leaves his clients unable to walk.” He ground once more, purely to be a menace, and then stopped. His hand flattened back on my stomach. “Fine. I’ll save it.”
“You always say that.”
“And I always deliver.”
I couldn’t argue with that. I lay there with his forearm across me and his heartbeat behind my shoulder blade and let myself have five minutes. Taylor was at her sister’s until tomorrow. Nobody in the world knew where Colton was except me.
When he rolled onto his back, I turned over and looked at him. Hair flat on one side. Pillow crease on his cheek. Still better looking than every man on my phone.
I looked at his mouth. I couldn’t help it.
Last night was right there. His hand on the back of my neck. His tongue. The sound he made into me when he came.
He caught me looking. He held it for one second.
“Your pillows are too soft,” he said.
“My pillows are fine.”
“I woke up with my face in a cloud. My neck’s fucked.” He sat up and stretched, and his back went through about nine different muscles. “And your radiator ticks. All night. Tick. Tick.”
“You were snoring. You didn’t hear anything.”
“I don’t snore.”
“Like a leaf blower, Colt.”
He grinned and swung his legs off the bed. He talked about the pillows. He talked about the radiator. He asked if I had eggs. He did not talk about the kiss. He went around it the way you step around a wet floor, without even looking down.
I noticed. I didn’t say anything.
I had decided last night I wasn’t going to be the one who said it first. Apparently he’d decided the same thing, just louder.
His clothes were still in the washer.
Neither of us had moved them to the dryer. Colton pulled out the tank, still damp, and looked at me like this was my fault.
“You have a dryer,” he said.
“I had a horny man in my bed.”
“Fair.” He threw the load in the dryer and slammed it shut. Then he walked into my bedroom, opened my dresser like he had a key to it, and came out wearing my t-shirt.
My grey one. The one that fit me fine.
On him it was obscene. The cotton stretched almost see-through over his pecs, his nipples printed right through it. The sleeves gave up halfway around his biceps. The hem ended above his navel. He looked like a stripper doing a bit about being my boyfriend.
“You’re going to rip it,” I said.
He looked down at himself. Flexed. A seam made a noise.
“Then buy a bigger size,” he said. “For next time.”
He walked past me into my kitchen before I could decide what to do with that.
He opened my fridge, stared into it like it had personally let him down, and pulled out the carton.
“Six eggs,” he said. “Evan. That’s breakfast for one.”
“That’s breakfast for two normal people.”
“I’m not a normal people.” He cracked all six into a bowl one-handed and didn’t lose a single shell. I wanted to be less impressed than I was.
I was standing at the counter in my underwear, watching him move around my stove in my shirt, when his phone lit up face-up next to the cutting board.
Taylor.
His hands were wet, and the pan was hot. He glanced at the screen, then at me, and tapped it with a knuckle. Speaker.
“Hey babe.”
I had never heard the voice from this side. Warm, easy, a little lazy. It didn’t sound like a lie. That was the worst part.
“Hiii,” Taylor said. She sounded sleepy and happy, a kettle going somewhere behind her. “Are you up?.”
“I’m up. Making eggs.”
“You’re cooking? Who are you?”
“Somebody’s gotta eat.” He pushed the eggs around with a spatula. My spatula. “You good? How’s your sister?”
“Exhausting. She’s making me do a farmers market. Did you eat the leftovers I left you? The pasta?”
Colton looked straight at me.
“Yeah, babe. Ate everything. Didn’t leave a thing.”
I picked up a dish towel and folded it, because my face had to do something.
“Good. Don’t live on protein shakes all weekend. What about dinner tonight?”
“No, no. I’ll order something. Don’t worry about me.”
“Did you sleep okay? I always sleep like shit when you’re not there.”
“Slept great,” he said. His eyes didn’t move off me. “Best sleep in weeks.”
“Rude.” She laughed. “What are you doing today?”
“Gym later. I’m dragging this skinny one with me.” He tipped his head at me like she could see it. “Evan’s here. He’s making me breakfast.”
“You just said you were making breakfast.”
“We’re making it together.”
“Evan’s hitting the gym with you?” Taylor’s voice went up in delight. “Oh my god. Leave him alone, babe, don’t kill him. Hi Evan!”
My mouth went dry. “Hi, Tay.”
“And make him feed you after. He forgets other people need carbs.”
“I will.”
“He’s all yours today,” she said, cheerful, and I had to put the towel down.
Colton slid the eggs onto two plates. “Have fun at the market.”
“Okay. Love you.”
“You too, babe.”
He hung up. You too. Not the words, just the receipt for them. I noticed that, and I hated that I noticed it, and I hated that a small, mean part of me liked it.
I wiped the counter. It was already clean.
“You’re wiping a clean counter,” he said.
“It’s a habit.”
He put a plate in front of me anyway and pushed a fork into my hand. “Eat. Taylor’s orders.”
I ate. Taylor had asked me to make sure he fed me. He did. The universe had a sense of humor and it was a prick.
My phone buzzed against the counter while I was rinsing the pan.
Zach: Was cleaning out my phone. Forgot how unhinged my birthday was lol
The pool. The backyard. A white linen shirt hitting the grass.
Me: It was a lot.
I put the phone down. Colton was flicking water at me from the sink, and I forgot about it.
The afternoon went soft in a way I didn’t see coming.
We went to the grocery store because Colton refused to “survive another meal out of that fridge.” He pushed the cart like he owned the place. Chicken. More eggs. Greek yogurt in a size I didn’t know they made. I slipped in a pint of ice cream. He found it at the checkout and held it up like evidence.
“What’s this?”
“Carbs. Taylor’s orders.”
He laughed so loud the cashier looked up. Then he carried every bag up my stairs in one trip, because two trips is for people who skip back day.
After that we did nothing at all, which turned out to be the best part.
He took my couch the way he took everything. All of it, feet in my lap. A show played that neither of us watched. At some point I opened my laptop because a work email had been sitting in my head since Thursday.
Colton reached over without looking and closed the lid.
“It’s Saturday.”
“It’s one email.”
“It’s Saturday, Evan.” He pushed his heel into my thigh. “Rub my feet if you need a job.”
“I’m not rubbing your feet.”
I rubbed his feet. He groaned like I was doing something insane to him. My shoulders came down from around my ears for the first time all week. That was his trick. He never told you to relax. He just took up so much space the panic had nowhere to sit.
My phone buzzed on the arm of the couch.
Zach: Drove past your place earlier. That Colt’s truck?
My stomach did one small, cold flip. Then Colton’s foot nudged me, and I typed the first thing that was true enough.
Me: He’s dragging me to the gym. Pray for me.
Zach: Since when do you go to the gym
Me: Since today apparently
Zach: Huh.
That was all. I flipped the phone face down. Colton was looking at me.
“Who’s that?”
“Zach.”
“What’s he want?”
“Nothing. Being Zach.”
He nodded. Then he sat up, swung his feet off my lap and stood, stretching until my t-shirt rode up over his stomach.
“Get your shoes.”
“Why?”
“It’s Saturday. Let me show you how hard I work to keep these muscles you like so much.”
“I didn’t say I like them.”
“Sure, princess. And I thought you liked me for my personality.”
“I don’t like you for either,” I said. “You just keep showing up naked.”
He grinned down at me. “And you keep opening the door.”
────୨ৎ────
His gym on a Saturday evening was nothing like the late nights I knew. Lights on. A woman on the rower in headphones. A guy doing curls in the corner who nodded at Colton like he was a minor god. Otherwise it was us, the mirrors, and rubber and chalk.
Colton was back in his own clothes, black tank and grey shorts, and looked like the poster on the wall instead of a man who had eaten my ice cream out of the carton an hour ago.
He benched first. I stood at the head of the bench, supposedly spotting.
“If that bar falls,” I said, “I’m calling Taylor.”
“You’re not spotting. You’re watching me.”
“Same thing.”
He lowered the bar to his chest. His pecs swelled up around it, so full the tank lost the fight. He pressed. Veins jumped up his forearms. Rep after rep, breath in short hard pushes, sweat darkening a line down his sternum. From where I stood I could see every muscle in his chest working, and I could see him watching me watch.
He racked it. Sat up. Wiped his face with the bottom of the tank and gave me all of his stomach on purpose.
“You good?” he asked.
“You’re showing off.”
“I’m training.” He stood. “Your turn.”
“No.”
“Legs.” He was already loading a bar on the squat rack. Light. Insultingly light. “You walk around with an ass like that and you’ve never squatted. That’s a crime against the gym.”
“I squat. I sit on chairs.”
“Get under the bar.”
I got under the bar. He stepped behind me.
His hands found my hips. Coaching. Completely professional, as far as the curl guy knew. He fixed my feet with the side of his shoe. He pushed my knees out with two fingers.
“Chest up. Sit back. Like there’s a chair behind you.”
I sat back. My ass went down and back, and his hands followed it.
“Good. Again.”
I did it again. In the mirror I could see him behind me in the tank, arms out, quads like cut stone under those grey shorts. His eyes were not on my form. They were lower. They were exactly where the chair was supposed to be.
“Slower,” he said. His voice came out tighter than it had been on the bench. “Control it.”
I controlled it. All the way down. Hold. All the way up. I was twenty-eight years old and blushing in a squat rack, and I didn’t stop.
“Again.”
On the fourth rep I watched the mirror instead of the floor, and I saw it. The front of his grey shorts. Right there. Not subtle. Grey shorts never are.
He saw me see it. His fingers tightened on my hips.
“Eyes forward, princess.”
“You told me to watch my form.”
“I said forward.”
My phone buzzed in the cubby by the rack. The screen lit up and a preview slid across it.
Zach: I’ll swing by tmrw morning. Bringing coffee. Got something to show y—
“Eyes up,” Colton said. “Last one.”
I reached over, flipped the phone face down without finishing it, and got back under the bar. I didn’t think about it again. I was busy working out.
The last one I did slower than all the others. Down. Hold. He stepped in close to spot it, hands on my hips, and at the bottom my ass met the front of his shorts. The hard line of his cock pressed right into me, hot through two layers of cotton, and stayed there for one long second while the curl guy counted his own reps ten feet away.
I stood up slowly. Behind me, Colton breathed out through his nose like a man counting to ten.
He racked the bar, picked up his bag and his keys and said, “We’re done.”
“I thought you were going to show me how hard you work.”
“You saw enough.”
“Are we showering here?”
“No.” He was already walking. “Your place.”
“Why?”
“Water pressure.”
“You’ve used it once.”
“Once was enough.”
────୨ৎ────
The truck smelled like the gym on both of us. He drove with one hand on the wheel and the other on my thigh, high, his thumb moving in slow lines over my shorts like he’d forgotten it was there. He hadn’t. Every red light, the thumb went higher.
Neither of us said anything for six blocks. It was the loudest drive of my life.
Upstairs, he dropped his bag by the couch in the same spot as last night. Like it lived there.
I didn’t stop in the living room. My thighs had turned to wet sand, and if I stood still near him I was going to make a decision my ass hadn’t signed off on.
“I’m showering,” I said from the hallway. “Alone.”
“Sure, princess.”
I shut the bathroom door. I didn’t lock it. I told myself it was because the lock stuck.
The water came hot. I stood under it with my palms on the tile, legs still shaking from the squats, steam fogging the glass. I closed my eyes, and there it was again, the thing he had spent all day walking around. His hand on my neck. His mouth on mine. Not a thumb this time. A kiss.
He had cooked me eggs and lied to his girlfriend in the same five minutes. He had held my hips in front of a stranger and called it form. He had not said one word about last night, and he had not let go of me once all day.
The bathroom door clicked open.
Cool air cut through the steam. Through the fogged glass, I could see the shape of him. Big. Bare. Coming closer.
The shower door slid open.
Colton stood there naked, sweat still drying on his chest, his cock already hard and heavy between his thighs, looking at me like I had been teasing him for twelve straight hours.
He stepped in.
“Move over, princess. Your asshole’s had all day to recover.”
────୨ৎ────