Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

What’s our next movie reaction? You decide!

  • The Abyss 57
  • Total Recall 101
  • Jaws 48
  • 2026-08-22
  • —2026-08-30
  • 206 votes
{'title': 'What’s our next movie reaction? You decide!', 'choices': [{'text': 'The Abyss', 'votes': 57}, {'text': 'Total Recall', 'votes': 101}, {'text': 'Jaws', 'votes': 48}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 8, 30, 21, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 8, 22, 20, 51, 43, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 206}

Content

Katee’s dad showed her three intense movies when she was little…and now we want to revisit that trauma with you guys! So please vote for which of the three movies you think we should watch next!

Comments

A.J Watson

I mean I wouldn’t say those are “highly graphic”

Stuart Henry

Another brilliant Arnie film is True Lies with Jamie Lee Curtis and Eliza Dushku.

Clark740

Jaws is suspense, not graphic (well, 3 scenes-maybe) - the Abyss was not graphic but Lindsey’s “revival” might be. Total Recall -if Arnold’s version - is much more “graphic”. I think I heard that there are 140+ acts of violence. Each one of these movies has a “special edition” with missing and extended scenes-so it boils down to suspense, Cameron’s gamble or cheesy sci-fi that requires no brain power…😊

Danny

Deep Star Six was one we kids watched on a summer vacation and scraped the crap out of us. I remember my graphic film was T2 and I “covered my eyes” when I was told too but thought it was cool and didn’t scare me.

J.D. Hollis

Given Robin’s joke on the sitrep, I think he needs to see the real Total Recall again.

Liberty Timmons

These are tough! I love the Abyss, and Jaws is a classic. But for sheer reaction content I'm going Total Recall!

Liberty Timmons

I love True Lies. The scene where Jamie Lee dances for him is the best!

Enrica Manes

Next adventure of the Sackhoff crew! Can't wait!! Thank you Katee 😎👍🏻

Caz

Any chance one day we can get a LOTR watch along? 🤣

Rowan K

DeepStar Six scarred me as a child! My parents were watching it and I snuck into the living room and secretly watched it along with them (they thought I was in bed). It was way too scary for me, I was like 6 or 7 at the time.

Dana Nourie

Abyss was soooooooo good. Great strong woman character in it too. Total Recall was really good as well. As a shark lover, Jaws makes me sad. That movie was really bad for the abuse of sharks.

StarBo

Arnold forever.

TGD66

Jaws!!! One of my top 3 movies. Saw it at the drive-in when I was 9 or 10 years old. ( let’s not judge on what my mom was thinking, typical GenX supervision). Scared the frak out of me. To this day I will not go in the water past mid shin. So imagine how terrifying it was to be in a little rubber skiff whale watching in Maui. I would do it again tho.

Darren Tucci

Isnt the Abyss a real ass-number in length?

Darren Tucci

Ass numbing effect. Sorry. lol

Mark Sonntag

THE ABYSS graphic??? Watch all three but when you watch THE ABYSS, go for the director's cut. It makes more sense.

Adam White

I chose Total Recall because it would be fun to watch the reactions, but there are no bad choices in this list.

ElectricalRadio

I liked The Abyss when I 1st saw it-- great characters and dialog. There seemed to be something missing. I saw a re-edited, scene restored director's cut version a few years later which was excellent. (Also the last long movie I saw that had an intermission!) There's a scene involving a special liquid in the story that I remember seeing in a science show as a child: a "wow" moment.

ElectricalRadio

Jaws was kind of shocking when I saw it as a teenager. The opening scene was later shown as a teaser for a pay TV channel & drew a lot of criticism in the L.A. Times' letters column.

Clark740

Yes and another Cameron Film..🤣

Alice Devilman

Okay, someone needs to say it, and since nobody has so far, I'll take the bullet for the team. The Abyss is either one of the top 5 best sci-fi movies ever made... or to be completely avoided, even if watching it would end world hunger. It's all about those two magical words that we all know and love: "Director's Cut." I'd rather watch paint dry than the theatrical release. For the love of Chuck Berry's duck walk, if The Abyss ends up winning this poll, either watch Cameron's cut or just watch whatever came in second. Seriously. That 30 minutes of footage is absolutely crucial, and act III in particular becomes about as cohesive as wet toilet paper without it.

Michelle K.

The Abyss is a favourite! The soundtrack is gorgeous.

Heather Lamer

I love the Abyss totally underrated movie but Total Recall yeah that was crazy

RAB

The abyss is fantastic but Total Recall will be fun

Daniel Cox

I re-watched Total Recall yestarday, as I forgot about it...

Eric Royer

If you do Abyss, make sure its the slightly longer director's cut

Darren Tucci

Can you imagine. By the end of the watch-along their kids will be in college and interrupting the filmingfor the car keys. lol

Terry

All of these are brilliant films and hopefully they all get the rewatch treatment. This is why I hate questions like, "What's your favorite movie?", "What's your favorite TV show?", "What's your favorite band/song?" and "What's your favorite book?". Too many factors to consider.

John

The movie the saw as a youngster that probably to intense for me was The Birds which we saw in a drive-in with my cousins. I would not say it scared me for life. I still watch i pretty regularly.

John

This is a tough choice. Jaws is a classic! Great actors, Robert Shaw is one of my faves. Great dialogue”Your gonna need a bigger boat” and John Williams’ two note Theme Total Recall sticks in mind as one of the most violent moves I’ve ever seen in the theater. It’s based on Philip K. DIck short story “ We can remember it for you wholesale. “ I’ve read the story years ago but cant remember it well enough to how accurate the movie is. I love The Abyss good drama and decent SFX. I’m leaning that way.

Darren Tucci

Just curious: would Katee allow the spuds to nominate their own movies - say with categories like ‘scariest’ or ‘just plain awful’? Now THAT would be something I’d even pay for.

The Sackhoff Show

Have you not seen it? The directors cut is almost 3 hours! We may need an intermission 😂

Darren Tucci

During my grad school days a class mate and I watched it. She and I took an hour nap for sheer necessity sake

Joe Bright

Jaws for me please. My favorite movie of all time.

Andrew S

The laughs we will get from you and Robin watching Total Recall will be top tier. I also say you should try and work in the 2 other greats of strong women in scifi. Sigourney Weaver in Aliens and Linda Hamilton in Terminator 2

Clifton Hough

I could probably still recite all the dialogue from Total Recall. And what about the full cast? A damn fine company of all-stars. Even if Robert Picardo only got to play the plastic cab driver. We won’t hold that against him. See you at the party, Richter!!

Clifton Hough

Terminator two is still the best of the series you almost don’t even need to see the first one for the set up a fine and timeless, sci-fi film, and it would make for one hell of a reactIca

Jennifer G.

I picked Jaws because it’s the 50th anniversary & I saw that National Geographic had a special about it on YouTube with Stephen Spielberg & others from that film. Also since Katee worked with Richard Dreyfuss it felt more directly connected to her podcast. Truthfully though, I’m down for all of these movies! All classics. 🔥🎬🎙️👍🏻

Robyn

I pick Logans Run even if it's not on the list

Rick Z

You mentioned Waterworld, which would be GREAT for a rewatch. Fifth Element too. Another movie in the same camp as Total Recall is Demolition Man!