Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 725243812.mp4

Downloads

Content

This is the AD- FREE and EARLY ACCESS version of the REACTION HIGHLIGHTS!

"Black Market" is allegedly the worst episode of Battlestar Galactica across all 4 seasons, according to the internet. Katee and Robin have thoughts on this, as well as one major overarching question...Why the hell isn't Kara Thrace in this episode!?

"Black Market"
Directed by James Head
Written by Mark Verheiden

Shop Merch ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection

If you can, please go and leave your comments on the public version when it airs Thursday @ 11:30 AM PT as it helps push the success of the show :)

Click here to give some love on YT ❤️

Youtube Reactions

Files

Comments

Jess

The lack of Starbuck also was IN ITSELF a factor in how badly it was received among my circle, let me tell you! Like Starbuck in it wouldn't necessarily have made it a good episode (not sure what anyone could have done to save that script) but maybe it would have been a bit less cringey and out of context with the rest of the season. Also I wish I'd had the word "cringey" in 2006 to describe this.

Enrica Manes

I think the point isn't whether Starbuck was/is there or not; it's rather that Lee Is completely out of place as the main character driving an investigation in this context. It doesn't suited for him. At the same time, we see him with this woman, and it's never mentioned either before or after this, and also introducing this flashback of his past where he left his girlfriend on Caprica before the Cylon attack is a nonsense there. Lee never talked about this, so it makes no sense why author's thought to construct his backstory this way. In fact, he has unresolved issues with Kara and Dualla, yet here we see him with Shevon... at the very least, you end up asking yourself why...or not?

Enrica Manes

he's not the right person, he cannot make clear-cut decisions outside of the command bridge, he is in a deep crisis with himself, to the point where he sometimes thinks he isn't completely cut out to be a pilot or a soldier, which leads him to start considering a career as a lawyer. Here, instead, he is immersed in a film noir scenario, playing the role of what is supposed to be a DEA or ATF agent, and it just doesn't fit his character. someone with such a clean-cut face and fragile soul like his is highly unbelievable in that role

Enrica Manes

And the worst part is that everything ends up resulting in nothing, without any follow-up in the subsequent episodes, in the name of a dirty yet necessary balance.

Enrica Manes

Agree Katee, totally, Is an episode completely out of context. We talked about it in these days on discord

Enrica Manes

I totally agree Katee, It is completely out of context as we talked about in these days on discord

Robyn

Katee and Robin, the two of you look good together and the banter back and forth is insanely fun. Thanks for sharing Battlestar Reacta. I can't believe season 2 is almost over. Where has the time gone? Can't wait for next week, "Scar" is one of my favorites ❤️

Enrica Manes

Scar Is One my favourites too! Can't wait to talk about It together! And thank so much to Katee and Robin!

Brad

The thumbnails are off by one. I think that fighting picture is from SCAR. If you look at the thumbnail for Epiphanies, it's Lee confronting the black market.

Jess

Mystified as to why comments get hidden half the time on here... TLDR, you are right, it is all of the above as well. Bad pacing, implausible filler storyline, two vanishing and undeveloped female characters who exist only to try (and fail) to expand a male lead's backstory, cartoonish villain in a series that's otherwise filled with complex, morally complicated characters (that plus the episode being so all-around gack after a solid first half of the season, the long mid-season break back when it aired, and some of the best episodes of the whole series). But Starbuck not being in the episode was salt in the wound.

Jess

Unrelatedly, I am approximately Katee's age and it brings me so much joy when she busts out the 80s and 90s song lyrics from pattern-matching random conversation snippets. I do the same thing all the time and it drives my family and friends nuts. (In fact the very first time she said "it's all coming back to me now" in last season's reactions, I actually started humming the Celine Dion song before she did.) I've learned it's also a common ADHD thing, FWIW.

Simply.Beyond

Yeah, I usually skip this episode on re-watches. 😅

Steven Pagnucco

I was looking forward to this one; this is definitely by far my least favourite episode in the series so… cant wait to watch with yall!

Dana Nourie

I 100% agree with Katee and Robin on this episode. I also felt that there is so much going on in the current story arcs, that this episode felt like to much extra and stuff that doesn't matter. The women with Lee was just confusing. I get him going to a prostitute, but the other woman in his past wasn't necessary. I agree it should have been past memories with Starbuck.

Steven McCormack

This isn’t the worst episode. There’s a couple of doozies that are bottle episodes in season 3.

TaraGel

You should come over to the Discord and chat with us, Jess!

Ranyen

I think Robin hit the nail on the head why most people don’t like this episode. This isn’t a bad episode per se it’s just one of the worst on an amazing series that set the bar so high.

Enrica Manes

You know that this aspect struck me right away too? and besides being a fantastic actress, she also sings very well! he drives me crazy with her 80s-90s references (I was born in 1982); once she even quoted Jem and the Holograms and I burst out laughing! It's incredible how she manages to feel so close to us in such genuine way!

Enrica Manes

I agree too about some past memories with Kara, some academy flashback to focus on training anecdote, focus on their friendship, their bond... It Is a lack of temporary and narrative arc

Joe Bright

This episode is a strange one and was a bit of a letdown after the high from the episodes right before it. Maybe it could have worked if it was tied into some of the other storylines like how Cylon Gina escaped from the Pegasus after shooting Cain. They could have showed how Rosilyn permitted an underground black market to exist just to keep some kind of commerce active in the fleet. It just shows that even a great series like this will have a few misfires along the way. Still, it was well acted and shot so it was a solid effort but just fell short from a story concept.

Alice Devilman

This is FAR from the worst episode of the series. In fact, I think it's probably one of the most important episodes in terms of telling the story of the fleet, and the survivors in it. This episode hangs a huge, glowing neon sign on what this entire BSG series story (not plot, to be very clear) is about, and makes a blunt statement that can't be ignored any longer, even if you've somehow managed to do so up to this point as a viewer. And that statement is: "This is an examination and exploration of pragmatism versus principle in a society. We're going to show you the pros and cons of each, why you can't lean fully into one or the other, that you have to accept that they must exist symbiotically to sustain a society, and that the ultimate success or failure of a society is determined by the ability (or inability) of both the governance and the individual citizens to balance the two appropriately and responsibly." That's really the whole show, from the miniseries right on to Daybreak. It's the backbone of the series as a whole, and every single individual episode is a micro examination of it. Everything is driven by showing you why characters make the decisions they do (sometimes principled, sometimes pragmatic), and then showing you the fallout and ramifications of those decisions as they play out, both positive and negative. This is the first episode to really put a spotlight directly on it, but it's certainly not the last. There are future episodes that retroactively provide missing context and information, that a viewer doesn't have at this point, that totally reframe context and highlight the pragmatism Vs. principle struggle in spectacular fashion, and make it impossible to not see the entire series as an ongoing string of exploring each character's internal debates of "do I do what I know is right, or do I do what I know is necessary?" That's drama 101, ah cha cha!

Kev Cavalry

Ah, someone has seen “Hero” and “The Woman King”

James Hubbard

I forgot how boring this episode is