Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is a 2% Tier exclusive post. If you want to watch the un-edited reactions of BSG with me, join us in the 2%!

"Black Market" is allegedly the worst episode of Battlestar Galactica across all 4 seasons, according to the internet. Katee and Robin have thoughts on this, as well as one major overarching question...Why the hell isn't Kara Thrace in this episode!?

"Black Market"
Directed by James Head
Written by Mark Verheiden

As a reminder, this is the UN-EDITED version of our reactions so you will need to have your own copy of the show to watch with us. Due to copyright rules we cannot post the full episode. You will start your version and use the timecode on our screen along with the blurred out video at the bottom to get your video as closely synced as possible.

Merch Store ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection

Full Watch-Along on YouTube: https://youtu.be/p9fAkH93zZw

If you can, please go and leave your comments on the public REACTION HIGHLIGHTS version when it airs Thursday @ 11:30 AM PT as it helps push the success of the show :)

Click here to give some love on YT ❤️

Youtube Reactions

Files

S2E14 "BLACK MARKET" | FULL WATCH-ALONG | Katee Sackhoff Watches BSG

"Black Market" is allegedly the worst episode of Battlestar Galactica across all 4 seasons, according to the internet. Katee and Robin have thoughts on this, as well as one major overarching question...Why the hell isn't Kara Thrace in this episode!? As a reminder, this is the UN-EDITED version of our reactions so you will need to have your own copy of the show to watch with us. Due to copyright rules we cannot post the full episode. You will start your version and use the timecode on our screen along with the blurred out video at the bottom to get your video as closely synced as possible. Join us on Patreon! ‣ http://patreon.com/thesackhoffshow Shop Merch ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection Watch more episodes of The Sackhoff Show: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiHvVvKZ9lt4-IZiosUjdxqB7IEQJJ6RU&si=e6pD8zR7TQeggRT4 ------------------------- Follow me and subscribe to keep updated on The Sackhoff Show, my film and television work, and my many other adventures! INSTAGRAM ‣ https://instagram.com/therealkateesackhoff/ FACEBOOK ‣ https://facebook.com/officialkateesackhoff/ TWITTER ‣ https://twitter.com/kateesackhoff YOUTUBE ‣ https://youtube.com/kateesackhoffofficial The Sackhoff Show SOCIAL: IG: https://www.instagram.com/thesackhoffshow TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@sackhoffshow

Comments

Joe Scheid

Let’s goooooo!!!!!!

Adrienne Leffler

This is the only episode my husband and I skip.

Aaron Scofield

I’m waiting till next week to watch so I have a good episode to enjoy right afterwards…this one is such a weird one. Also, I’m so bummed I can’t get out of work for the watch along live…frakking tragic

Luiz Filipe Santos

Not the best episode, but I really think this episode makes a lot of sense. It's one of those episodes that shows there is a lot going on 'outside' the military context.

Joe W

This is actually my least favourite episode, but I tell ya.. my least favourite episode of BSG is TEN TIMES BETTER then the slop we get on TV today - *cough* Lanterns *cough*

Mike S

My recollection is that Moore said Lee was a test pilot before the attack, perhaps on the verge of getting out of the service?

Zhaikadom

Just noticed on Prime Video that some thumbnails are incorrect. - Thumbnail for Resurrection Ship Pt 2 is from Epiphanies - Thumbnail for Epiphanies is from Black Market Is the thumbnail for Black Market from Scar? (EDIT: Yes) Oh, and thumbnail for Scar is *not* from Scar.

DJBluePDX

I'm so excited for Rose City comic Con! I think I'll actually go this year. I'm skipping PAX so... This sounds like fun. And I'm a 5-minute drive away 🤣

Vicky Humphrey

Its nice to get some Lee back story. Although it seems thrown at us. Seeing the dark seedy underbelly of the society is also interesting. Reminded me of the Star Trek Holodeck and Lee was using it to figure out his personal problems/demons.

Enrica Manes

I totally agree Katee, It is completely out of context as we talked about in these days on discord

Paul Mix

"Fisk… he's really gonna be a staple now…" Yeah, about that…

Enrica Manes

with Black Market the serie steps into a gritty, film-noir space to examine how human society decomposes under extreme resource and sometimes liberties and rights scarcity, while the episode weaves a murder mystery together with an exploration of Lee mental state coming into a spiral, with Lee attempts to play the heroic protector to compensate for his own feelings of uselessness and death wish following his near-death experience in space...but Lee in this episode is not the right person, he cannot make clear-cut decisions outside of the bridge, he is in a deep crisis with himself, to the point where he sometimes thinks he isn't completely cut out to be a pilot or a soldier, which leads him to start considering a career as a lawyer. Here, instead, he is immersed in a film noir scenario, playing the role of what is supposed to be a DEA or ATF agent, and it just doesn't fit his character. someone with such a clean-cut face and fragile soul like his is highly unbelievable in that role

Enrica Manes

Lee's relationship with Shevon is not a romance but a transactional surrogate dynamic driven by his psychological collapse. In that moment staying in that time with Shevon allows Lee physical and emotional intimacy without the risk of actual emotional vulnerability; he doesn't have to be open about his depression or face real commitment. Then this relations is quite a surrogate of redemption, helping Shevon and her young daughter, Paya, sounds like a sort of stand-ins for Gianne and his lost unborn child and for Lee a chance to quiet his own conscience.

Rowan K

It really is the weakest episode of the whole series, but still enjoyable with Katee and Robin's yapping.

Stuart

I don't think it was terrible, Bill Duke is a legend and fit so well, his henchmen barely said anything they were just nameless, faceless henchmen which is sad. The story should have played out over longer or at least had the characters show up again and explored this part of Lee's emotional back story.

Matt Bornemann

I strongly disagree with the hate this episode gets. It's good – not fine; good! – and it has an excellent guest star. Commenting before doing the watch-along.

Jo

On the subject of Lee not letting Kara achieve her potential, I think/hope you’ll change your mind on that as the show progresses! Lee’s random backstory love interest is pretty jarring, but for me I take it as a huge source of guilt for him that was all brought to the surface by the events of Pegasus/Resurrection Ship, as opposed to pining after a long lost love. The moral compass of the fleet was called into question for Lee over the last few episodes, which at the same time forced Lee to come to terms with his own guilty conscience that he needed to work through.

Jess

lol yeah, a few episodes back they were talking about the Pegasus command and I am sitting there thinking, oh sweet summer child...

David V.

Syncing the two videos is pure satisfaction. I am so happy when I get it to the millisecond.

Jeren

Paddlestar Reactica, let's goooo

BoobsweatLeadsToPearlNecklaces

So, I'm probably one of the few people who do not like this episode, but not for the most obvious reason. The child involvement totally disgusts me. A family member had that happen to them. But it's much deeper than that for me. I understood exactly how Lee felt. I saw this episode probably about a year and a half after my divorce and it was like looking in a mirror. And I saw how shitty of a person I was because of how things with my ex-wife occurred.

David V.

I actually like this episode. It's Scar that I usually skip.

David Huber

It wasn't one of my favorite episodes, either, but it was fun watching you two react to it. Looking forward to Scar now. I'll have to think up a question, if I can find the right forum to ask it in.

ElectricalRadio

The black market exists because people have *wants* that exceed their needs. The gov't gives citizens enough rations to feed their family so nobody will starve. After living with the stress of a war & the sadness of loss (friends, family, home planet), how can people not want some special things in their lives? A box of candy, fine liquor, cosmetics; items the gov't would not feel obligated to provide & for which legitimate merchants charge high prices. I appreciate the episode's realistic approach: It's crime that can't be eliminated, only managed (especially during wartime).

Darren Tucci

First, the cartoon was an homage to John Carpenter's The Thing. Secondly, and I know this will fly in the face of the shade many are throwing at this episode, it is FAR from the worst episode but a logical extension in the moral ambiguity/moral relativism which informs the entire series and every character of this damn fine series. What I've gathered from the series (having seen it in full and renewed with the watch-along) Lee is trying to establish himself as a self-sustained entity not overshadowed by his father's legacy. As we will see (no spoilers here, honest!) Lee has a different path that he must tread, where his true (or dare I say altruistic) destiny lay. In contrast to many who have claimed that Lee couldn't carry the crux of the episodes fixation, I heartily but respectfully disagree. What we are seeing, amidst the moral degradation of humanity trying to save itself from doom but inevitably rotting away from the inside out, is Lee becoming who he was supposed to become. A flawed hero. Morally relative to his version of right or wrong. Finding his place amidst the entropy that is human race's survival. I think this was a magnificent stepping stone into further episodes and a must watch for those of us who want to see Lee grow up and be his own man. Nuff said, True believer!

Rick Z

That thumbnail of Starbuck and Helo boxing is from S03E09, "Unfinished Business"

The Sackhoff Show

I think that’s true for many people, but they reference medicine a few times in the episode. It was implied that the little girl might die without meds. Definitely a need!

Michelle

It's from the next episode 2x15: Scar.

Darren Tucci

This exactly is what I felt. Lee is working through his issues and finding his place in this ‘new normal’ while still trying to uphold his beliefs albeit in a questionable manner.

Mike Todd

This is NOT the worst episode of the show. That honor goes to (I’m so sorry to Tamoh who is amazing still) The Woman King! That episode sticks out as painfully bad and total filler. I think it makes Black Market look like a masterpiece! 😂 And hey, this at least has some fun rock from Bear and most of the Oingo Boingo boys! I actually enjoy the gritty and dark storyline of this episode. I do think a black market would exist no matter what, but I don’t understand how it got so insanely out of control that fast with the military running things.

Alex Konkel

I'm surprised that Patreon let you put the link over Katee's boobs 😂

Caz

Discord is on fire. Yeah it is lots of fun

Eboe Thrasher

Lanterns is wonderful. Unbelievable that people are out here maligning it.

Eboe Thrasher

Every thumbnail at some point got one behind, the one from this episode appears on 2X13. So the one on 2X15 Scar has to actually be from 2X16.

Eboe Thrasher

Constructive suggestion - watch with subtitles so that when you're discussing things, you can see if something important is being discussed on the screen via the subtitles. When Lee was paying her earlier, right before he started paying her, she said "That'll be an extra 100 because you stayed over", and if you had subs on, you would have seen that while you were having a discussion. Just a recommendation for y'all. Love the reactions, just an idea based on some observations of things like that. I don't think this is a bad episode, just a different episode. I mean the entire plot is that Lee was with a woman who had a child (Shavone), and that either made him think about the woman back on Caprica, or thoughts of the woman back on Caprica drove him into the arms of Shavone. I don't see Kara out there trying to have kids at this point, nor even in the past, so in order for this storyline to stick and make sense, they had to have a different love interest. And Shavone had to be employed by the guy running the black market so he could have that on Lee. Always useful to have tabs on powerful people. He could have extorted Tigh as well, I would wager. And the bet on Lee paid off for him.

Eboe Thrasher

OOH, Scar's such a great episode, the context of the Raider that gets smarter is so fascinating.

Jim

Great episode, I like these “non-timeline” episodes every once in a while. What do people think about the prostitute role? Seems like a reversal of the Cassiopeia role in the original series, where she turned all sweet and did live on Galactica, even becoming part of the crew…

Jim

I thought it was funny to see the dog, now he really is a sack off🤣🤣. Get it!

Jim

Oh totally

Stuart Henry

I agree, even if one or two scenes about the black market appeared in previous episodes would've helped it gel better within the series. And Bill Duke always knows how to play the scary intimidating guy. He'd put the shits up me in real life. Ha

Stuart Henry

Looks like Katee had a week off. And I love how Adama misses nothing. lol

Stuart Henry

If I remember right Zach introduced you to each other in a flashback. And I dont think a Black Market is needed but I do think there is always someone who will always find away to take advantage of others for some kind of profit.

RaZielimLXIX

just throwing in my 2 cents and trying to keep it short. re:economy-there's no such thing as a utopia. it'd be nice if the 'government' could get everybody everything they need, but who's to decide that? people are all different. should only the military get coffee because they need it to stay alert because they're protecting the colony? sure, you could argue that but they'd have to pry my coffee can from my cold dead hands. the government is obviously not the appropriate ones to decide what people need, and especially control the flow of it. i can attest to this first hand. i live in arizona. and recently our 'government' has decided that arizona/nevada and california need to reduce/limit their water usage even lower, which will just increase the cost of our cost of water, while also not making the other states 'upriver' who are blocking and hording the water keep and use all the water they want with no restrictions. isn't water something that we, as human beings and who live in the desert, need for life? should our government decide that someone else should be allowed to keep all the water while we just get left to fight over the scraps between our 3 states? currently nevada is filing a lawsuit against the 'government' while we here in arizona are facing record water restrictions. point being, the flow of trade goods and services should be allowed to flow and not be 'controlled' by the government. i'd have to side with lee, 'we'll keep an eye on it' and step in if necessary.

TJ

Definitely in the bottom five of BSG episodes. I'm not questioning the existence of a black market, and I sort of get what the writers were trying to do, but in the end this was simply a poorly told story. It drags on in many places, and they overdid Lee's flashbacks of his ex girlfriend. Just seems like the plot was filled with a lot of convenient contrivances... I agree with Katee, this was a very out of character bottle episode that was dark and downright disturbing. The only part I enjoyed was Lee shooting that sick POS.

Christopher Daniels

While not the strongest episode in the series, saying its the worst somehow implies to me that its bad, which I personally don't feel that it is. I can see how other folks might think that it is though. I do find Lee's flashbacks a little jarring, referencing a deeply important love interest that has never been mentioned until now. Either way, while it doesn't strictly advance the main plot, I do kinda like the detour to talk about other aspects of fleet life that add depth to the situation.

Travis Allen

This episode was very dark, so it's odd to say that I enjoyed it, but I did. It explores the fleet and what people are doing to survive The Lee back story was interesting, he's definitely working through some issues. Roslin and Gauis are headed for a showdown and Zarek eliminated the competition. RIP RICHARD HATCH

Travis Allen

I don't know why thumbnails get flip flopped, but I see it everywhere.

Bryan Davis

Was enjoying the reactica right up to the point where Katie decided to inject her politics with her asinine “billionaires shouldn’t be allowed comment”. 🙄 Anyway, while I respect it’s your channel and you can say whatever you want, I don’t have to pay you to alienate half of your audience in the process. It’s a shame because when you guys just talk about the show it’s great. I get enough progressive liberal propaganda everywhere else I don’t need it from you as well. Take care.

Paul Bame

Good on y'all for talking beyond the (contested!) politico/economic words, about concrete things like how to feed people because that's where people can still actually have a conversation. Communism, for example, has toxically different common-US definitions vs lefty/progressive/non-US definitions, often erupting instantly into arguments based on unstated assumptions that the other person has the same, which is the "only", definition. Seems like BSG decided to regulate the informal market economy, which is a familiar idea. It feels like a blind spot that they omitted how economic decisions are made and implemented in "normal" AdamaRosaland. Good grist for a post-apocalyptic parallel story.

LordM8rshal

I spent a long time thinking about where to post my first comment and "Black Market" is the one that finally prompted me to do so. For me personally, Season 2, Episode 14 is not part of *Battlestar Galactica*. The episode is so poorly written and executed, and bears so little resemblance to the show's feel, atmosphere, and mood, that I never watched it again after the first time and I never will. Perhaps this episode might have worked in a different series, but not in *Battlestar Galactica*. To this day, I still don't understand what the producers and writers were thinking. As far as I'm concerned, this episode simply doesn't exist. I’ve deleted it from my collection and will never watch it again.

Michael Ducharme

I think you missed the line she said just before he paid her, something like "you owe me an extra (whatever amount of money) since you spent the night"