Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is a 2% Tier exclusive post. If you want to watch the un-edited reactions of BSG, join us in the 2%!

The Pegasus has a new commander, Starbuck is a Captain, and Apollo is now a Major (douche)...just kidding! That's for all the people who complain on YT that we hate on Lee too much 😂 This episode started out with a fun new perspective on the role of engineers in the fleet and ends with a debate about abortion rights. Thank you BSG. Looking forward to all of the totally chill and not at all triggering comments on YT from the world wide web 😮‍💨

"The Captain's Hand"
Directed by Sergio Mimica-Gezzan
Written by Jeff Vlaming

As a reminder, this is the UN-EDITED version of our reactions so you will need to have your own copy of the show to watch with us. Due to copyright rules we cannot post the full episode. You will start your version and use the timecode on our screen along with the blurred out video at the bottom to get your video as closely synced as possible.

Merch Store ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection

Full Watch-Along on YouTube: https://youtu.be/Q9AlH2B3eVI

If you can, please go and leave your comments on the public REACTION HIGHLIGHTS version when it airs Thursday @ 11:30 AM PT as it helps push the success of the show :)

Click here to give some love on YT ❤️

Youtube Reactions

Files

S2E17 "The Captain's Hand" | FULL WATCH-ALONG | Katee Sackhoff Watches BSG

The Pegasus has a new commander, Starbuck is a Captain, and Apollo is now a Major (douche)...just kidding! That's for all the people who complain that we hate on Lee too much 😂 This episode started out with a fun new perspective on the role of engineers in the fleet and ends with a debate about abortion rights. Thank you BSG. Looking forward to all of the totally chill and not at all triggering comments from the world wide web 😮‍💨 As a reminder, this is the UN-EDITED version of our reactions so you will need to have your own copy of the show to watch with us. Due to copyright rules we cannot post the full episode. You will start your version and use the timecode on our screen along with the blurred out video at the bottom to get your video as closely synced as possible. Join us on Patreon! ‣ http://patreon.com/thesackhoffshow Shop Merch ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection Watch more episodes of The Sackhoff Show: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiHvVvKZ9lt4-IZiosUjdxqB7IEQJJ6RU&si=e6pD8zR7TQeggRT4 ------------------------- Follow me and subscribe to keep updated on The Sackhoff Show, my film and television work, and my many other adventures! INSTAGRAM ‣ https://instagram.com/therealkateesackhoff/ FACEBOOK ‣ https://facebook.com/officialkateesackhoff/ TWITTER ‣ https://twitter.com/kateesackhoff YOUTUBE ‣ https://youtube.com/kateesackhoffofficial The Sackhoff Show SOCIAL: IG: https://www.instagram.com/thesackhoffshow TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@sackhoffshow

Comments

Darren Tucci

Such a great episode and quite topical (presciently) in this day and age. While I may not find this on my top 10 list of episodes it certainly sets up events and future ramifications and helped in character development for both Lee and Kara. I’m also hoping that the Starbuck ‘hot mess express’ finally pulls into that station. Is it me or did the writers have a special hate-on for the poor woman? lol

DJBluePDX

As someone who is former navy, this whole situation was absolutely correct. If you're a snipe (mechanical engineering) you're a snipe. You do the job that you're supposed to do and that you're traind to do. Not having situational or operational command experience there's no reason he should have been in charge of that battle started to begin with. QUESTION: can we get a timeline of when the writer strike happened? A writers strike happened in the middle of BSG. I would love to know where that flowed from and too.

DJBluePDX

Also, the scary thing is that Gaius could have been useful in calculating how many different bloodlines are with the group and how to not intertwine them so that they aren't getting too close to their own relations and that would build the population faster. I should probably eat something

Neoony

I really wish the music from this episode was in the soundtrack @Bear :P

David Huber

My last few years in the Air Guard, they put a weapons loader manager in charge of us specialists, just to shake things up. Specialists have to use many different books and methods to diagnose problems so we can fix them. Loaders follow a checklist that has to be 100% right, every time. Totally incompatable, and it made my last few years a nightmare. I would have made a terrible manager, but I was really good at fixing airplanes. I felt bad for the guy commanding Pegasus. I'm glad he went out with honor.

Justin E.

The species isn't worth compromising certain principals. Whether you are talking about this, or other awful things humans do to justify the greater good, it's not worth it. If you can't hold to the values that give the human race value, then the human race no longer has value. Obviously people who are pro life won't agree with this characterization, but the point of the episode is to ask whether you should hold to your values in tough circumstances where you can argue the ends justify the means. Forget that the topic in this case is abortion. My answer is no. If I have to do something horrible to allegedly ensure the survival of my species, I choose not to do it. Let the species die. If you don't draw the line somewhere and lead by example then there isn't anything worth saving. We have to be worth saving.

Darren Tucci

Although didnt Lee state during the charge against the first base star to invert and then (as assurance) have starbucks viper group to protect the upper hull from cylon ships?

Neoony

I guess protecting the upper hull would not necessarily mean she also has to land on the upper deck afterward. Actually, I just found the episode commentary where Ron talks about that exact shot: https://en.battlestarwiki.org/Podcast%3AThe_Captain%27s_Hand "Okay, there they go. Upside-down into the lower bay of Pegasus, which is something that I had been pressing to do for a long time. I― from the get-go when Gary was first designing the Pegasus with flight decks I said, "Let's do one of the flight decks upside-down." He said, "Why?" I said, "'Cause it'll be cool!" And it's still one of the cool things I like. I just― I don't know. It's just one of those― it's the geek in me still loves the notion that there's these upside-down flight decks and so when we were editing it I wanted Kara's fighter to come in upside-down and I flipped the shot of Kara in the cockpit to be upside-down for no reason at all except that I thought it was cool and hey― if you can't do things that you think are cool in a television show, why be a showrunner? " Cool :P

J.D. Hollis

This is a genuine Star Trek episode in all the best ways.

Joe Bright

Is that the Dad from Home Alone put in command of the Pegasus. Also, the name of this episode is my early vote for most sexual for season 2.

Joe Bright

Hot mess express is a great description of Starbuck in this point of the series.

Joe Bright

That is the whole point of the series. What it means to be human and how far are people willing to go for survival.

The Sackhoff Show

Home Alone! That’s right! And I forgot about the most sexual name comp 😂 it’s gotta be between this and Valley of Darkness…

streaky

There are a lot of nepo hires in this fleet. I do find it amusing how Katee gets offended on behalf of Starbuck, makes me chuckle every time.

TJ

Very solid episode as we head into the trifecta at the end of Season 2... I also agree with Roslin's position, as Admiral Adama said it best: "That number doesn't go up that often." It was a great bridge back to the pilot where Roslin said "we need to start having babies".

ElectricalRadio

A thriller with human drama, great effects & camera work! This is my 1st time watching the whole series since the early 2000's, so I always watch the episode myself before the Patreon rewatch, so I don't mind if you ramble on. I had the DVDs, which include a commentary with Ron, Grace & Tamoh on 1 episode. (Tamoh was in fine spirits & Grace was swearing like a fighter pilot.) BTW, Jeffrey Vlaming wrote one of my all time favorite lines for an episode of Northern Exposure. "Curiosity is the fire under the ass of human experience." -- Chris in the Morning

ElectricalRadio

Although both explore complex issues, Galactica is more visceral & hits harder than Star Trek-- like garage rock vs. Steely Dan!

Enrica Manes

No worries at all, Katee ❤️it's totally fine! It’s been such a long time and I understand that you might not remember if you guys discussed such heavy topics when you were on set - especially because It was heavy tough time, so involving for you on psychological side, so it’s completely fine if those backstage memories faded.😉 Thanks for trying and thank you Always for kind attention! loving the rewatch: it's still so awesome watching the episodes together!❤️

Enrica Manes

These episodes highlight themes that have proven to be prophetic twenty years later, and today they are widely debated and highly relevant. You were put to the test on set because the characters are already precisely constructed with great psychological depth; furthermore, as actors, you were brought face-to-face with absolutely real-world issues. The writers did a great job, advancing both the themes and the growth of the characters, who—like Lee and Kara—reach a major turning point in their lives during these episodes. Katee being hypercritical of her alter ego, Starbuck, is fantastic because it mirrors the exact process we all go through with ourselves: analyzing mistakes, missteps, weaknesses, and strengths that others sometimes fail to recognize in us, or simply cannot read and interpret at that moment. These Reactica sessions are multifaceted because they help us see many different perspectives.

Kirsten

Katee; "I before E, except after C..." Kirsten; "< > the shark mouth wants to eat the bigger number..." EVERY TIME!!!

Michelle

Was this episode way more blurry than usual? I had a hard time syncing my episode to what you were watching because I couldn't even work out what you were watching 🤣 I'm guessing you had to do that because the Paramount copyright gods were coming for you.

Enrica Manes

this question "are we ok?" sounds like a forlorn cry into the void...💔 as I wrote before, Kara tries to turn with irony, desperately trying to send messages to Lee that he does not seem to understand. he continues to keep pointing out that Kara even gets on his nerves... and before to reporting for duty on the Pegasus, and before the shaking hands Lee rubs salt in the wound by reminding Kara that she shot him...💔 Kara ' s eyes while they embrace...

Jo

It’s been really interesting watching your reactions to this last stretch of episodes and commenting on Starbuck being a mess. I suppose it never really bothered me because even when Starbuck is f*cked up personally, she still gets it done and is smarter than everyone else in the room (this episode: case in point!). It was also really nice to see Lee/Kara air their shit out and actually talk things through - they ARE capable of it when they’re willing to be vulnerable with each other, which is hard for both of them. And Kara’s face and look of relief when she sinks into that hug…🥹

Enrica Manes

💯 agree! Kara ' s eyes while embrace Lee...💔

Enrica Manes

I believe there's a strong, subconscious bond between BSG protagonists and people, and it’s no coincidence but is a positive identification that helps us overcome obstacles and understand ourselves on a deeper level. We don't need to be perfect: rediscovering that we share the same doubts and fears, same faults and sorrow allows us to mirror ourselves in people we can trust to, turning every perceived weakness into a new strength. Each of us can relate to it, and it's no coincidence, because every character/actor and Katee/Starbuck in particular Is a truly sensitive person who has gone through intense life experiences: is a profound step, and every one of us is called to do our part being able to overcome both the challenges that life imposes on us

Travis Allen

Damn!!! I think this episode was mislabeled. Roslin and then Baltar had the best hand

Travis Allen

So I get to enjoy the show and the reaction commentary I watch the show twice. I get to enjoy the story, CGI, music, etc and then the reaction with the volume down

Paul Bame

BSG chose a simple anti-abortion stick -- could there be carrots? If a bunch of fleet-humans supported growing the population, how could they step up to encourage population growth enough that anti-abortion edicts would be unnecessary? Maybe make the fleet into a fracking great place (Cloud 9?) for kids to grow up? And for families/parents/caregivers and "the village" to raise them? Maybe support and honor carrying babies whether or not pregnancies were planned, and even where the birth mom might not become a parent, tipping mom's choices toward the choice to carry? Navigating the inevitable Geminese opposition to both out-of-wedlock children and less-isolated/rigid child-rearing structures, would be a tricky job which Rosalyn could probably pull off with a combination of religious exceptions and being the "reasonable" voice to Baltar's proposals for radical (and hugely threatening to Geminese) structures like the Fifth Sacred Thing or Woman on the Edge of Time. End of episode.

The Sackhoff Show

It is actually. Literally nothing gets by you Michelle 😂 for some unknown and stupid reason, YouTube has blocked the last two episodes for copyright even though we did the same amount of blur as always and we leave the watchalongs demonetized and unlisted. So we had to reupload a bunch of times and keep blurring more and more. Maybe NBCUniversal has it out for us idk. We’ll see what happens on the next one.

zenzero

Another amazing episode! Btw, the guy with the Star Trek haircut is Lieutenant Hoshi. You’ll learn more about him in the Season 4 webisodes!

TaraGel

How dare you! The Kara's Hand is clearly the superior hand AND title. 😂

Sarah Chia-Pet

I actually don’t think it would be 50% men and 50% women to repopulate considering a large portion of the population in BSG is military. I’m just looking on Google which says currently about 17.9% of the USA military is women, and from the looks of it from BSG a lot of the military is men there as well. Even if it’s more like 30% women military in BSG, it’s going to be less women than men total in the whole population.