The Hot Stranger I Met on Halloween | E6 (Patreon)
Content
All characters in this story are over 18 years of age.
Previous part here
Now He Wanted Us to Be His Dessert
James stood in front of us naked, calm, and satisfied, as if he knew exactly what he was going to do with the silence that followed his words.
"I guess I'll have to find out what you two taste like now."
That sentence hung between us more heavily than all the earlier joking about dessert.
Just moments ago, John and I had been kneeling by the couch, licking whipped cream from his ass, pretending this was still just some Halloween game. But after what he'd just said, there was no pretending anymore. We all knew exactly what he meant.
I felt myself getting hot.
Only moments earlier, I'd had my face between James's cheeks. I'd felt his skin, tasted the whipped cream, and felt the way his body reacted to my tongue. And now that same man was looking at me like he wanted to do exactly the same thing to me.
John was the first to glance at me.
He looked surprised, but not scared. More like someone who had just heard an offer so good that, for a second, he wasn't sure whether he should accept right away.
"You want..." I started, but my voice came out a little weaker than I'd intended. "You want to taste our asses?"
James smiled slowly.
"Since you two tasted mine, it seems fair."
John swallowed.
"I don't mind."
I looked at him, then back at James.
"Neither do I."
James picked up the can of whipped cream from the couch and turned it in his hand as if he were holding the most important prop of the night.
"Then come to the bedroom," he said. "You'll be more comfortable there."
My heart beat harder.
The living room was where everything had started as a joke. Trick or treat. A lollipop. Dessert. Laughter.
But the bedroom sounded different.
More private.
More real.
James went first, and John and I followed him, naked, hard, and quiet, as if we both understood that we were walking into something neither of us would want to back out of.
The bedroom changed everything immediately.
In the living room, we could still pretend this was some absurd Halloween joke that had gotten out of control. It had started there with a knock on the door, no candy, and one shameless smile from James.
In here, it was quieter.
Warmer.
More intimate.
The bed was large, covered in dark, slightly rumpled sheets. A small lamp on the nightstand cast a soft light over the room. James set the can of whipped cream beside the bed, then turned toward us.
"Lie down," he said calmly. "Next to each other. On your stomachs."
John and I looked at each other.
It was stupid, because only moments earlier we'd been naked in the living room doing things I couldn't even have imagined the day before. And yet this moment embarrassed me more. Maybe because this time, we were the ones who had to lie down in front of him. Expose ourselves. Let him look.
James noticed our hesitation.
"No pressure," he said. "If either of you changes your mind, say so."
That only made me want it more.
"I want to," I said.
John immediately added, "Me too."
We climbed onto the bed and lay down next to each other on our stomachs. Our shoulders almost touched. I could hear his breathing, slightly uneven, just as nervous as mine. We were both hard, overheated, and far too turned on to pretend we were relaxed.
James stood behind us.
For a moment, he didn't do anything.
He just looked.
I could feel his eyes on my back, my hips, my ass. Then I heard him move closer to the bed. One of his hands settled on my hip, the other on John's.
"You look even better than I expected," he said.
John let out a nervous laugh.
"I'm not sure that's supposed to make me feel better."
James laughed quietly.
"It doesn't have to."
His hand moved along my back, then lower, onto my ass.
"Matt first," he said.
I tightened my fingers in the sheets.
I knew I was about to feel his mouth somewhere no one had ever touched me like that before.
James started with his hand.
He placed it on my lower back and slowly moved it toward my hip, as if he wanted to calm me down before doing anything more. That simple touch made my whole body tense immediately. I lay on my stomach with my face turned slightly toward John, feeling his presence right beside me.
"Breathe," James said softly.
I tried.
It didn't go very well.
James laughed under his breath, but not mockingly. Then his hands spread my cheeks, and that was when I really froze. Not because I didn't want it. I wanted it too much. It was just the awareness that he was looking at me like that, that John was lying right beside me and could see it too, that hit me harder than I'd expected.
I heard the soft hiss of the whipped cream.
The cold cream touched my skin first, spreading across one cheek, then closer to the center. I sucked in a breath as the cold cream met the warmth of James's hand.
"Easy," he murmured. "It'll feel better in a second."
Then I felt his tongue.
Broad at first, slow, gathering the cream from my skin. He moved without rushing, almost like he was actually tasting dessert. The warmth of his mouth was so different from the cold cream that my fingers tightened in the sheets on their own.
John was lying beside me, watching.
I could feel it.
That only made it worse.
James moved lower, closer to the place I was trying to relax, even though my body kept reacting by tensing up. Then he placed a hand on my thigh and started circling his tongue more slowly, more precisely, until my breathing changed on its own.
I hadn't known it could feel that good.
Not like this. Not in this way.
"Now I understand," James said quietly, pulling away only for a moment. "Why you were looking at me like that earlier."
I wanted to answer, but I couldn't.
When his tongue returned, firmer and more confident, my whole body softened beneath him. The embarrassment mixed with arousal, and then all that remained was the warm, slow movement of his mouth and the awareness that James was really tasting me.
After a while, he slowly pulled away.
"You taste good," he said.
I didn't answer.
I couldn't.
James moved over to John.
I felt him move over to John more than I saw it. His weight disappeared from behind me, the mattress dipped slightly beside me, and John's whole body immediately tensed as if he were waiting for the first touch while also being afraid of how strongly he would react to it.
I lay beside him, still overheated, my face pressed into the sheets, my breathing impossible to calm.
Now it was my turn to watch.
James placed his hands on John's hips.
I heard the hiss of whipped cream, and John immediately sucked in a breath. James applied it slowly, first more broadly, then closer to the center, exactly the way he had with me. John tried to make a joke, but the laugh caught in his throat when James spread him with his hands.
Then he leaned down and started licking.
John reacted louder than I had.
His back tensed, his fingers clenched in the sheets, and a short, muffled moan escaped his mouth. James noticed immediately. He didn't speed up. Just the opposite. He slowed down, as if he wanted to show John there was nowhere to hide from the sensation.
"Breathe," he said. "It'll feel better."
John tried, but when James moved his tongue closer to the center again, his breath broke all over again.
I watched and felt my body reacting again. I could see John's face, his closed eyes, tense shoulders, the way he was trying to pretend he was still in control even though James was slowly taking him apart one movement of his tongue at a time.
It was almost as intense as when he'd done it to me.
After a while, James pulled away and sat between us on the bed.
John and I were still lying on our stomachs, hot, relaxed, and still hard.
James looked at us with satisfaction.
"Come by tomorrow," he said.
I lifted my head.
"What for?"
He smiled slowly.
"I've got an idea."
John turned his face toward him.
"What kind?"
James looked at our asses, then back at us.
"The kind where whipped cream alone won't be enough."
For a moment, neither of us said anything.
But I knew we'd be back tomorrow.