Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

When you come up with a new project idea or hear an idea proposed by someone else, how should you judge whether it is a good idea or not?

Have you ever had the experience that, at the moment an interesting idea comes to mind while thinking about a project, concrete settings related to it come to you in succession? For example, “If the basic idea is like this, then let’s make the screen layout like this,” or “If the button operation is like this, it will allow play that makes better use of the idea.”

This is not something limited to game creators, but I think it is something that comes out as a chain reaction from the ideas that are stimulated by the experience of work you have repeated daily. What is considered a good idea often has instantaneous power based on such experience.

If you do not leave this chain of ideas that occurs in your head as only abstract images, but always keep clear standards, systematize them, and organize your thoughts so that you can judge instantly, it is effective when planning and deciding the quality of other ideas.

To explain concretely, convert the quality of the chaining ideas into distance, and draw lines radiating from the original idea at the center. For example, if “screen layout” is a setting chained from the idea, and you instantly come up with concrete images such as the positions of characters and the way of displaying text, then the radiating line is long. Conversely, if it is vague and abstract, then draw the line short.

What this represents is the level of the instantaneous idea. Long radiating lines mean that chained ideas have concretely appeared, and short ones mean that not many chained ideas have come up.

For example, if I take the Famicom game “COCORON” that I planned as an example, the first idea was a 2D side-scrolling action game where the player can create a character by assembling the parts like head and body. The settings that instantly came to mind from this plan included the following:

▼ “Player Status”

Since there are designs with various features, give each part an individual status, and make the player’s movement differ depending on the combination.

▼ “Stage Settings”

Besides clearing the game, add the setting of “stage capture” as another play element to enjoy “character creation.” Specifically, instead of one-way stages, all stages circulate and can be advanced from either forward or return direction. This way, depending on the way of creating the player character, the difficulty changes even in the same stage.

▼ “Story”

As a story to match the special setting of “character creation,” set it as “an adventure in a mysterious world inside a dream.”

If you illustrate these, it looks like this.

As an impression, if the settings spread out like a big blooming flower, it is a good idea, and if they remain like a bud, it is not very good. Let’s call this kind of figure “Idea Scale.”Ideas do not always come in order from the beginning according to the setting. However, whether the idea that came up can be used later or not is extremely important.

Features of Idea Scale:

(1) You can instantly judge the evaluation of the base project (idea) by the image of the figure.

Even though it is a figure drawn in your head, at the moment you hear someone else’s idea or think of one yourself, you can see the drawn Idea Scale according to the types, levels, and concreteness of the accompanying ideas, and know the overall good or bad of the plan.

(2) Even if the chaining ideas are not related to each other and inconsistent, you can evaluate purely. 

You can evaluate individual settings of ideas separated from story or visual image. If you construct around story from the beginning, you may throw away ideas when contradictions occur. In the conception stage, fun play should be separated from the image.

(3) Regardless of genre such as sound, picture, action settings, you can evaluate individually, yet judge comprehensively the overall image of the game. 

A game is play. Even if the settings associated from one idea are disorderly, by lining them up, the whole impression of the game becomes visible. At that time, whether you feel “I want to play it” is an important sense.

Until you get used to it, it may be easier to understand if you actually draw it on paper and diagram it, but basically, this is something to draw in your head and judge the instant you hear the idea. 

I always draw this in my head and judge whether it seems it will be interesting. I also use this to judge ideas I hear from people or ideas I suddenly think of. There were projects that I thought were good ideas, but since no chained ideas came to mind, I kept them pending or threw them away.

By doing this, for the projects finally decided, once begun, there is almost no big change or remake on the way. Even if you worry about individual settings, if the direction is decided, you just proceed toward it.

And what is even more important is to correctly evaluate other people’s ideas. In positions where you have to make such judgments, judging and expressing opinions on ideas is a very difficult job that carries responsibility.

In a past episode I talked about Satoshi Tajiri of the game company Game Freak. At that time, when he asked me for my opinion about the “Pocket Monsters” then in development, I listened while imagining the Idea Scale in my head. To my surprise, at that moment, an enormously large flower bloomed in my head. 

I spoke my impression as it was, but I wonder how it was for him. Did it sound exaggerated, or like flattery? He just happily listened to my story. Of course, afterward, the game in question was released and became a worldwide hit.

This Idea Scale may seem like an intuitive judgment, but since each related matter has concrete reasons, it is actually a very logical method of judgment. However, the speed at which the various chained ideas come to mind is instantaneous. Therefore, when explaining it to others, it is important to be more concrete, to take time, and to do it carefully. Otherwise, there is the risk that people will think your instantaneous opinion was a careless judgment.

(Automatic translation by AI)

Files

Comments

Sheacu

The longer line helps decide which ideas can be better defined and what should be imaged around on. I always have these ideas and I never knew where to start around. Thank you for sharing this.

AK’s Blueprints

It’s hard to put what’s in my head into words... I’m glad you understand.