Patreon Status Part 1: Problems (Patreon)
Content
So, It’s been a while and I have to finally just face the music on this as I haven’t been able to get any other way to fix it. This is to address the lack of completed rewards from tiers as well as a lot of the other problems happening around the patreon that have been making things harder.
This is the first of two postings on this. This one will explain pretty much the entire history of the why as well as note all the other problems have have been going on to give full context, while a second, smaller and slightly more direct post will be the ‘solutions’ that I have for it. Neither posting will be all that great, sadly. However it’s not, like, OVER. So don’t worry, the patreon isn’t going anywhere. Even if the word pile might make it feel that way. ^^;
To begin with, a summary of why the patreon exists. About two years ago, I decided to try and start a patreon to lower the ‘requirements’ for my job, one that is overtly demanding and highly damaging to me and especially my hands. I wanted to do something I liked while also making the job take up less of my time.
I didn’t start the patreon two years ago, though. The first year was entirely dedicated to just drawing and getting good enough to think I could successfully do one. So for almost that entire year, I would make things every single day. When I thought I was good enough, that's when I started the patreon, I set a fairly low baseline for what I thought would be that threshold for when I could lower the job hours comfortably and pay the loss with the patreon income. I had a friend that was running a patreon for a while say that baseline should be easy to do, likely even hit that within the first month, so I went for it.
The patreon had, at start, two tiers, the base tier, support tier, the most basic tier that all others get access to the ‘rewards’ from, where I would make things every second day and post them as 30 day patreon exclusives, and a draw tier, where the reward was a single simple sketch for that month, at 3$ and 10$ respectively. In Canadian $’s since I’m Canadian. :)
The balance was, every day an exclusive wasn’t being done, I’d have ‘off’, do the rewards and whatever else and post old exclusives that finished their exclusive time to the public.
So, it’s been almost a full year since the patreon started, and while exclusives have been, for the most part, fairly on time and every second day as meant to be, for the last while something has been missing. Tier Draw Rewards. Unfortunately there has been a constant, endless pile of problems that have been blocking my ability to do them and with how bad it’s gotten, I had to finally just explain what exactly is going on and more over, what kind of ‘solutions’ I have for it.
There is a lot to cover, so I’ll try my best to stay mostly in chronological order to get as much covered as I can remember to. I feel the context is important.
So, after starting the patreon, I had a very slow start. Even after trying to hype things up, having had multiple people be interested in it just not show up, the patreon was very empty and for the first month, barely even interacted with. I was basically posting things in an empty void, no way to know what was liked or not because no one would say anything or even like the posts. To make matters worse, since it was the start, I was making new stuff EVERY day, there were no exclusives to post to pub and I didn’t want it to just instantly go dead for a month, so I kept it all going.
After the first month ended, I instantly got hit with a massive problem, my bank account was stolen from, money was getting charged from it. At the time, it was a very real possibility that money was gone. A very substantial amount. So, I had a nervous breakdown over that. I didn’t SAY I did at the time, and tried to play things off and keep things together, but I was completely fucked up from it.
It was eventually cleared and thankfully it had been refunded and seemingly whatever idiot hole the bank had that let them just snatch money out of accounts was patched up.
At this point, I had not made the base amount per month needed to even consider the patreon really 'started' either, so I went ahead and pushed out some new tiers. Second Draw tier and Three draw tier, as well as Commission tiers, though they have been disabled. We’ll get to that. <_<;
So after this, things are still slow, but a few people hop on and about a month later, it finally hits the baseline for what I consider it actually started. And then pixiv randomly killed my pixiv account. They didn’t tell me explicitly what posting or why, but the general listing was external links.
Pixiv does not have a sane way to handle things at all, this was one of the TWO warnings they give and then the account is DELETED FOREVER. To add insult to injury, because of the reason why, I had to not only remove every link from my entire pixiv on every single piece I had ever made, which means ALL patreon old exclusives were now unlabeled and had no output to the patreon, but also any and all possible avenues of advertisement or even announcements for the patreon had to be completely removed, since they were related to an external site. Pixiv was effectively ONE THIRD of my possible income for patrons.
I didn’t want to abandon it entirely, so I spent a long ass time getting everything cleaned up, removed anything that ever mentioned the patreon and even had to remove all links to my DA. Pixiv was a complete deadzone, and post there could not even mention patreon at all or risk getting an extremely old account deleted.
I had a lot more to say about this, but this isn’t really the time for them. Just going to say, if someone is suffering because someone else did something to attack them, don’t insinuate the victim of the attack is to blame...
…ahem, anyways. <_<;
After this, I got things back on track once again and decided to finally try and claim the money from the patreon. Up till this point I was holding off to keep it in the patreon ‘pile’ in case I needed to refund things. But feeling secure enough with it, I tried to do a payout. If you don’t know what that is, it’s when the patreon actually pays the person running the page. Up till payout, the money is just pooled in a pile they hold onto, so you don’t ever actually directly pay the person you are subbing to, you pay to patreon who then pays out to them.
So anyways this led to absolute hell. Patreon sent the money out to the people that were meant to get me the money and then the money just went missing for several months. I had to spend months CONSTANTLY contacting every possible place and location every single day to get that money and had to keep putting up the pressure to make sure no one just shoved it all into their pocket and stole it. This was not a small amount, there’s no option to take it in parts, this was basically half a year of patreon. It was ALL of it.
Between this horrible experience I still kept things running as well as I could on the patreon, but this is the point in which the constant problems completely removed my ability to do rewards, since on top of just needing to fight endlessly for the money I also had my own life to deal with as well as my job still being completely unmitigated. At this point, I disabled the commission tiers knowing that with how things were, a full on commission was not going to be possible and I didn’t want to ‘trap’ anyone with the option, planning on bringing them back when things calmed down. They didn’t.
By the end of 2025 I had finally rescued the money. But it didn’t even go to me, it was just returned back into the patreon pile. So in order to get it, I would have to attempt another payout. Which meant if I didn’t get everything perfectly straightened out and slammed every greedy paw that would snatch at it, it would happen AGAIN. So I had to wait on even getting paid.
I did eventually get it all working and made that first, extremely stressful, payout months later. A payout that had now consisted of almost double the money too, so… YEAH. It sucked to have to wait to see if that ever made it through. I didn’t mention this on the patreon since things were still having problems, so adding even more stress, even if it worked out, was not a great idea.
I also had two hard drives get nuked, one of which was so bad it almost bricked my PC. So there is that too. To add to that, one of the HD’s had some stuff on it that I made sure to have been properly backed up, but ended up not getting backed up at all so it’s just gone for reasons I have no idea. Wooo.
There’s even more problems that happened as well, between these as well as after, mostly related to the job I work. Since I couldn’t do anything to lower the time I had to spend at work, I ended up stuck working more instead. Which cut into my time as well as my me. I’ve gotten hurt a lot, hand, wrist, arm even. On top of that, I had to start using time between exclusive days just to make stuff for other exclusive days, since half my week was work days and they gave me almost no time to do anything between them anymore. Which brings me to the final, biggest ‘problem’.
I got good at drawing. Uh. That sounds like bragging but let me explain. :)
During all these problems I was still keeping at the base level of the patreon, the exclusives. Other then a short week or two worth of days off, I kept going at it, making new things every second day, learning new stuff, trying new stuff and as a result getting better. And getting better meant more people would see the quality and join up, so I kept at it. The problem is, this quality costs time. Even with optimisations and such, it takes longer to make things then ever before.
The base costs for the patreon tiers was not intended to stay as is. My original expectation was I would set them low, effectively a ‘loss’, to get people in the door, and then when things started to pick up, bring them up a bit more to be in line. This needed the patreon to be fully functional and make enough to afford the losses, but at the start I figured I’d hit that eventually. The problem is, it has never hit that value.
My patreon only has a single gallery attached that can help generate revenue. The base cost to sub for the patreon is extremely low, so low patreon has told me I made very little from it. I also make things every second day, which is apparently a lot? But even then, at the low cost, no one is really joining. So making it more expensive just means having even less people join and likely more people leave.
No one really shares my stuff outside DA or patreon either, so there’s no spread. I could try reposting/advertising instead, but on top of having some very bad social anxieties and having such a horrible experience even when I tried to stick my neck out for it, it’s also just a bad idea to have even more people join on tiers higher than support, since I can’t even do any of the requests.
Here we hit the main problems. I don’t have time to do rewards between days, the cost of running the patreon is a lot of time and very little paid for it which means my job has not been mitigated, and instead said job has gotten worse to deal with.
So whats the plan?
That is in post two, since this one is already quite big and chances are too tl;dr to contain it.