My Best Friend's Wedding Chapter 6 (Patreon)
Content
All characters engaged in sexual activity are 18 or older.
The bar is one of those narrow, dim places downtown that never seems crowded even when it is. Dark wood, low lights, the kind of quiet that lets you hear the ice in someone’s glass two tables over. I get there first and take a booth in the back. Wren walks in ten minutes later looking like he hasn’t slept any better than I have.
He slides into the seat across from me. For a moment neither of us speaks. Then he says, “Thanks for coming.”
“Yeah.”
We order drinks even though I'm not in the mood. The silence stretches until he breaks it.
“I’ve been thinking about college a lot,” he says. “Sophomore year, when you started seeing that guy from your legislative branch class. I used to make excuses to stay at the library late so I wouldn’t have to hear you through the wall. I told myself it was just because the walls were thin and wanted to give you privacy, but that wasn’t it. I hated the idea of someone else touching you.”
I wrap both hands around my glass and stay quiet. He keeps going.
“Junior year, the night you got really sick with the flu and I stayed up taking care of you. I remember sitting on the edge of your bed watching you sleep and thinking I would do anything to keep you safe. Anything. And then senior year, when you were deciding between law schools and I quietly hoped you’d pick the one that kept you in the city. I always found a way to put your happiness first, even when it meant ignoring what I was feeling. It was easier than looking at it directly.”
His voice is steady but low. I can see the effort it costs him.
“I prioritized you over every relationship I had,” he continues. “Even with Camila at the beginning. Little things. Canceling plans because you needed help moving. Taking your side in arguments with mutual friends without thinking. I told myself that’s just what best friends do. But it was more than that. I just never let myself say it.”
The honesty sits between us like something alive and dangerous. I meet his eyes.
“And now?”
“Now I can’t stop saying it.” He looks down at his hands. “I don’t know what that makes me. I just know it’s true.”
We leave the bar without finishing the drinks. Outside the air is cold and damp. Neither of us suggests going separate ways. We end up on the subway uptown, standing close enough that our shoulders brush with every sway of the car. At his stop we get off together since Camila is at a work conference in Boston until Sunday. The apartment feels too quiet when he unlocks the door.
The second it closes behind us the careful distance collapses.
We kiss like we’ve been holding our breath for days. Hands under shirts, mouths open and hungry. I get his jacket off, then his sweater. He does the same to me. We make it to the bedroom in a trail of discarded clothes. When we’re both down to nothing he pulls me onto the bed and then does something that stops my heart for a second—he rolls onto his back and looks up at me, eyes dark and uncertain.
“I want you to fuck me,” he says.
The words land hard. I search his face. “Are you sure?”
“Yeah. I’ve been thinking about it. I trust you.” His voice is quiet but steady. “I want to feel you.”
Fierce tenderness rises in my chest so fast it almost hurts. I kiss him slowly, deeply, while my hand slides down his stomach. He’s already hard. I take my time opening him up—one slick finger, then two, working him carefully while he breathes through the stretch and his cock leaks against his abdomen. He's tight and hot and shaking by the time I add a third. The sounds he makes—soft, surprised, almost overwhelmed—make my own cock throb.
When I finally push inside him the world narrows to the tight heat of his body and the look on his face. His eyes are open, locked on mine, and there is something raw and trusting there that makes my throat tight. I go slow, giving him time to adjust, watching every flicker of sensation cross his features. The ache of knowing this still might end sits right beside the fierce protectiveness flooding through me. I want to take care of him. I want to ruin him for anyone else. I want to keep him.
“Okay?” I ask, voice rough.
“Yeah.” He sounds wrecked already. “Fuck, Col—move.”
I do. Deep, steady strokes that make his breath hitch. I wrap a hand around his cock and stroke him in time with my thrusts. The dual sensation has him arching under me, one hand fisted in the sheets, the other gripping my forearm hard enough to bruise. I lean down and kiss him through it—open-mouthed, messy, pouring every unsaid thing into the contact. Pleasure builds hot and thick at the base of my spine, but I hold it back, focused on the way his body clenches around me, the broken sounds he makes when I angle just right.
“You feel perfect,” I tell him, because it’s true and because I need him to know. “So fucking perfect.”
He comes first with a low, punched-out cry, spilling over my fist and his own stomach while his hole flutters tightly around my cock. The sight of it pulls me under. I bury myself deep and follow, pulsing inside him in long, hard waves while his name leaves my mouth like a prayer.
We stay joined for a long time afterward, breathing hard. Eventually I pull out carefully and clean us both up with a damp cloth from his bathroom. Then we collapse into a tangle of limbs under the sheets, his head on my chest, my fingers tracing idle patterns on his shoulder.
“I keep trying to imagine a future where this makes sense,” he says quietly into the dark. “One where I’m not engaged to someone else. One where I get to keep you. And every version feels impossible right now.”
I press a kiss to his hair. “I know.”
“I’ve started questioning everything,” he continues. “Who I thought I was. What I thought I wanted. The whole foundation feels like it’s cracking and I don’t know what’s underneath yet. I just know I don’t want to lose this. I don’t want to lose you.”
The words settle into the quiet of the room. We don’t try to solve anything. We just hold on.
Morning arrives too soon. Sunlight cuts across the bed. My phone starts buzzing first—a group text from the wedding party about final tux fittings. Then Wren’s phone lights up with emails from the venue and a reminder about the cake tasting Camila scheduled for next week. The ticking clock is suddenly loud again.
We get dressed in silence. At the door he pulls me in for a long, desperate kiss that tastes like goodbye even though neither of us says the word.
“I’ll text you,” he says.
“Okay.”
I leave with the feeling of him still on my skin and the knowledge that we are no closer to an answer than we were last night—only more tangled, more needy, and running out of time.