Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Livestream Poll: What story should Hunter read next? (Patreon)

Published:
2026-01-15 23:24:49
Edited:
2026-01-15 23:25:01
Imported:
2026-06

Poll

Livestream Poll: What story should Hunter read next?

  • Shell-shocked veteran story 2556
  • Girlfriend has weird skin story 6211
  • Gross rat story 2785
  • Icebreakers 2408
  • 2026-01-15
  • 13960 votes
{'title': 'Livestream Poll: What story should Hunter read next?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Shell-shocked veteran story', 'votes': 2556}, {'text': 'Girlfriend has weird skin story', 'votes': 6211}, {'text': 'Gross rat story', 'votes': 2785}, {'text': 'Icebreakers', 'votes': 2408}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 1, 15, 23, 23, 23, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 13960}

Content

Comments

Derek Pyatt

Gross rat is the only option Mr. Hunter Sir

Alex Downing

Icebreakers. Not because it’d be good. But because it’d be so fucking funny.

Andrew L Green

Gross rat, and have Nick voice the rat

Zebro Chromeo

Weird skin is winning I want that rat

MK Ultra

For a moment I thought icebreakers was that horny ice hockey book 🤣😭

50cal

I need a veteran story so bad

Maeic Duncan

My girlfriend also has weird skin. Her skin is actually the creature

NazgulCookie

Icebreakers is easily the scariest story and will never be read once Isaiah gets back! This is our only chance!

Molly Farkas

Thats why i picked it too lol

Impeloqn17

And Isaiah right ☹️?

Casey Harper

Guys please Icebreakers would actually be the scariest thing they ever read

Writer_Guy

If you are not voting for Gf with Weird Skin are you really a CC fan

maddie rey

Manifesting Gross Rat wins

Graham Chapman

He would probably enjoy the rat story the most idk

Label

I don't know what Gross rat could be, but I want it

LimitlessEntertainment

I feel like the Veteran story but that seems like something directly up Isaiah's alley so maybe save that one

Monsterr Matt

Have to know what weird skin means

Pepesilivia88

Weird skin weird skin weird skin

Flynn Taggart

Icebreakers would probably get the channel deleted

HisLips.jpg

BRO PLEASE READ THAT HICKEY ROMANCE IT'S SO FUNNY

rose269

weird skin or rat easily

Pepesilivia88

Actually, you know what I take that back

Conrrado Acosta

Voted for gross skin but rat story would also go hard for papa meat

Ryley Embry

Cmon yall we have to get him to read icebreakers or pucking around

Kelcey White

As someone with severe eczema, I really need to hear the girlfriend with weird skin story 🤣

Clint

I want the rat to win

MrZelda1313

Is it not that one?? That’s ehat I voted for lol

Robert Kraft

With his reading level? Yertle the Turtle. Dead.

Nathaniel

Who doesn’t love a body horror story🤤

Crabbus

Good god I thought ice breakers was Pucking Around for a moment and I felt true darkness in my soul

FFlightRisk

people see girlfriend and see a gooning opportunity

Twegner

The goriest the better!!!🤍

Lord Rifjig

Icebreakers, not again lol, I just watched his video on it 🫠

Anthony Zadymiarz

Isn't Icebteakers literal porn? Im all for it baby

Daniel Medellin

If yall are still wanting to do any books maybe the black farm it’s the same author who did feed the pig it’s actually the world of the farm the pigs in

chabubu

Read smut.

Haley

I’m intrigued

Don Carlos

Manifesting Icebreakers

Em💕🕸️

I’m so torn between the weird skin and the gross rat, I’m also desperately waiting for yall to cover Bad Man by Dathan!! You guys are the best

FreakyP

shell shocked vet is the only acceptable answer

Austin Cole

Hunter can read? I thought he could only read the snack labels?

Caylan Deal

ice porn for the girlies please

Jordin Rekow

if you know hunter you’re picking shell shocked vet no doubt

Drippy Simp

People who aren’t choosing Ice breakers ain’t even actual Papa Meat fans

Daniel

I 100% excepted gross rat story to have like 80% of votes

Happy Goon

Would pay extra for this

endlessbeez

He prolly busy with the Creature and Kayla rn, he’ll be back soon

Ferbu

Icebreakers is a whole different kind of horror

louis burrows

Gross rat option of course. However, I want to put forward another idea, we’ve re-read the stairs in the woods because we felt it wasn’t given enough room last time to be told well. I went back and listened to borrasca again and large chunks of it were skipped over and you guys just said things like “and then the characters talk for a bit yada yada” I think with the way the show is now I’d love a re-read of it as it will be even better than before. Just a thought (:

Bogart Gaskill

I’ll have you all know that I’m voting purely on title alone. I’m not familiar with any of these.

Niall

Guys please my girl voted rats im scared of rats please don’t :(

Jack Bundy

Icebreakers is long overdue. He teased us on his channel, so now it's time for the real goods

Bingo Mastermind

Hunter can read Icebreakers on his own channel, Creepcast is for horror content, terrible, great, and everything in between

Master Chainsaw

Down on my hands and knees begging for Icebreakers

Kevin Fisher

I’m sad no one else shares my purely artistic pursuit to have Hunter read Icebreakers. I really think his emotional nuance would complement the totally normal novel well….

endlessbeez

Are these all the titles of the stories

Gennie

when is goon daddy coming back? i hate when my daddies are fighting 😔

craptopia

oughhh minecraft oughhhhh

corey

Crazy that ice breakers got second already... I think that deserves a lot of attention

Benjamin keyte

I think you guys forget that icebreakers is one of the most egregious books from smuttok totally worth a read from Hunter.

Kyle

Hunter should get Allison in a creepcast episode in Isiah’s absence

MK Ultra

Damn. If it is, I need to change my vote 🤣

Boobiebuddha

Someone tell me wich of these is the longest and I'll vote for that one

Smizzo

Anyone voting for icebreakers is a cancer and should be carved from the flesh as such.

Sarah Mangum

Torn between the rat and gross skin.

Ironbreaker Vincent

For a patreon episode, i suggest the splatterpunk book "playground" i believe the banter would be legendary between the two plus the voices hunter can do for the characters would be hilarious

DrPepperEnjoyer23

Whatever he reads I’ll drink a cold Dr.Pepper during #IceCold

n!ck

i totally forgot i wish i voted differently……..

cervidya

They hated Jesus because they did not understand him.

Fr1tz

Rats, rats, we are the rats

JaqueCobanyElrique III

Am i the only one who doesnt know what icebreakers is and why camt i find it anywhere

MightyMouse

I think you know what we truly want Hunter lol

cervidya

Ice breakers is like 700 pages

Xtra Small

ICE BREAKERS PLEASEEEE

Ian Brushaber

Thing in the basement pt2 button ->

Sam Persons

I highly disagree, that would be the most horrifying channel experience yet.

cervidya

Ice breaker sweep

Master Chainsaw

If I’m thinking of the right one look up Icebreaker by Hannah Grace

Boobiebuddha

With that pfp I'll do anything you say

Lance

Same dude

lasanga

It’s a smut book he talked about on papa meat

Dahcs

Ehhh idk, there's a lot of really not great content on that one that I don't think would go over well.

Samuel Emerson

Do the rat one in honor of Isaiah's friend he brought in (then you kicked out)

Onza Films

Which one has baby bones breaking?

Winter Fox

cmmonn guys let’s hear icebreakers

Kaye

THISSS

Bob Rubins

Please this could be our only chance to get a reading of Icebreakers, we have to lock in on this.

Winter Fox

Reddit will cry. idk if that’s a good idea

Marshall

ICEBREAKERS DAMN YOU

Evan Marks

Icebreakers would be so hilarious

YaBoiAloooona

Papa I beg of you school has started and I am fighting for my life I need a joyful crash out from you

Zach Towne

ICE BREAKERS PEOPLE COME ON

stephen cook

Bruh icebreakers would go crazy ☠️ he couldn’t read the whole thing tho, lmao

Wtfwhy

I think they're referring to Icebreaker. A smut book. Hunter covered a couple books like that on his Papameat channel talking about BookTok. Joking about possibly reading one in the future.

Oracaidum

Hunter I am begging you to read the story from the creepcast subreddit about gas station d*ck pills. Easily the funniest story written by someone in the community and hearing you read it in a southern trucker voice would make my year

Madoka Vaughn

Putting Ice Breakers on there made this choice REAL hard

Smizzo

L comparison coming from someone who doesnt realize this is a horror content podcast.

Smizzo

Then go champion for it on the papa meat channel you degenerate

Flaky Fan

Having Hunter struggle reading Icebreakers would be awesome.

baphel

Glad were all on the same page

Christian Downey

*So does anyone think Hunter and Isaiah are fighting?*

Jt Azevedo

The Bible, front to back

Samuel Sal

Please oh please let it be ice breakers

Shovan

I don't know any of these so I picked the skin one. Sorry.

Wtfwhy

I could see it doing okay as a patreon exclusive if they treat it for how insane and over the top it is. Just treat it like a shitpost honestly

Smizzo

Yeah, I second this

Tom Chivvis

THE THING IN THE BASEMENT IS GETTING BETTER AT MIMICKING PEOPLE, GIVE THE PEOPLE THE CRASHOUT WE DESERVE

HEAP ASS

Children of Men

Ryan Fifield

Idk any of these stories lol

2 _generation

He should read a creep cast fanfic

VictoriaQ

yall better pick icebreakers

Samuel Sal

Icebreakers is the smut talk that hunter has grown proficient in, it would rob the talent from the poor man to not let him spread his wings and fly like the smutterfly he is.

Dtplus2

Swamps of dagobah would go hard too

Allen

Pick icebreakers I swear to god

Squig

Let’s justr say… my peanits

huh.

It would be criminal to not read this in the voice

Bailey Walker

If they could get permission on “how to survive camping” by Bonnie Quinn…. Just read the first book and it’s great

Odell Tucker

Erm that weird, I don’t see the horror from the vault on this list?!?!?!

Anthony Stamps

Funny enough, Hunter is the reason why I decided to read icebreakers, and it might be because I have a low IQ, but I kinda liked it.

Froog

Dude I really liked it, I hope it gets picked

Smizzo

Wild that this isnt the papameat channel.

n!ck

its been done.

Leah Clayton

GROSS RAT STORY PLEASS i am crying and shitting please

Neàgér Quãck

The title alone of "The Gross Rat Story" seems like something Hunter himself would have written.

Red Rocket

Who are your freaks using bots to vote for things other than rat story

Papa Meats little Meat Baby

I think Hunter would looooove Den of Vipers. It would give him and Nick some bedroom ideas

Riley McConnell

why are you people not voting icebreakers

MeatyMadness1408

Papa is an amazing voice actor the shell shocked veteran would be great I think personally the Russian accent was on the nose!

Orion Not Ryan

RATS!!! RATS!!! RATS!!!! 🐀🐀🐀

Orion Not Ryan

No. Hunter said that Isaiah is having some family stuff going on. Let's just hope that it's nothing crazy and his family is ok :)

Crumk

I tried, mate

gloomara

pretty sure he had a kid

Sharkitty Tiddycrumbs

The one I like the least is winning and im scrunched about it. Gross rat story please, Father Flesh

gloomara

Hey, thats my story!

Lilpiizzahut

Howww are we not voting for ice breakers

Christian Downey

Hunter made a meme about people commenting this. I'm hoping all is well on Isaiah's end as well.

BonghornLeghorn

Would love to see some Western based horror if there's any chance of that.

MercuryMars

You all suck, Icebreaker would be peak. Prudes, the lot of you.

P2K-itty

Any chance for a part three of I'm not human game you guys played?

John Spaghetti

Hooked on Phonics Reading Comprehension: 1st Grade

MercuryMars

At least someone gets it

Dakoda

im a fanfic reader so i know if i opened that book, i'd finish it in a night, i live for corny books (but i only watch horror ? rom coms are not for me)

Donovan Crain

My freaky deaky ahh chick’s skin got bumps n shi

Floor Lamp

please read diary of a wimpy kid: dog days

Donovan Crain

She be leavin her skin on da couch. Had a whole ass argument bout why she wasn’t talking thout she was mad smh it was just her epidermis

Sulem Chavez

Icebreakers is smut if you need the reminder! Please vote

dangerxbadger

His wife is 39 weeks pregnant. That baby girl is coming any day now. I don't blame him for not wanting to be committed to a 3-5hr recording session that might have to get scrapped in the middle anyway bc baby time happens while it's going on. 😂

Donovan Crain

This nasty bih got bumps all over. Lookin like a freshly plucked chicken

starmamma🤍

Surprised not many chose ice breakers lol

Stephanie Ortiz

Can we go down the list? Like read the winner first but definitely read the others in future episodes 🙏🙏

Variant 5

Tbh I think he'd like abandoned by Disney but I don't think it'd be that fun without Mr Isiah

Sebarino

Honestly I think the skin story would be perfect for hunter to read solo. But My Father Finally Told me What Happened That Day would be perfect for them both. :)

bzerko

Thanks for going the extra mile Hunter, we appreciate you ❤️

SnowFawn

Idk man I don’t understand why icebreakers isn’t first 🤣 it’s honestly a tragedy

Melon Momma

It’s not on the list but I finished Brother by Ania Aalborn and it feels like something with a bit of everything of both papa and goon is the idea of reading full books a thing still?

High_Rat_King_Benis

Cmon now, gross rat story sounds like the best story ever

babyhole

anyone not voting Icebreakers is a fake fan and should be shunned

Oracaidum

That story lives rent free in my head. Genuinely one of the greatest stories ever written, thank you!

Erick

Voted icebreaker but would like to hear them read 28 Strange Happenings in Russian Wildlife

jayjay24

whatever would be the most funy

Lukas Chaushoff

So is it common knowledge that Isaiah is going to be a dad

Billy the Git

You are all WEAAAAK! Embrace true Horror. Embrace Icebreakers 🧊⛸️🥒

Soulairus

Anything with Ice has to be read by the Iceberg Boy himself but we know how you get about girlfriends in stories Hunter. Lets see how fast he gets pissed off at this one

Dimmy Jeams

Need Hunter to read the entirety of Icebreaker in one stream

tedkaczynski99

Gotta save icebreakers for the goon man

Blobz

Icebreakers????? It would be like 11 hours long

Andrew Ridge

I dont want icebreakers man its a horror story podcast not smut cast ppl

Andrew Ridge

Id like the shell shocked veteran or the skin story idk about the rat one but definitely don't want ice breakers

Big Tim

I don’t have a clue what gross rats is about but if you didn’t choose it your a rat bastard

TaquitosMama

literally had no idea until they announced it 😭

TaquitosMama

i don’t want to vote simply because i don’t want to be blamed for choosing a bad story LMAO

Amoxie

Ice breakers like the hockey smut story?? A new type of fear

Alex Lamb

No smut???? 🍅 👋

Pippa's Beatten Meat

I've been praying for Isiah and Hunter to read a smut story. Please patreon, vote for what you know in your hearts to be a golden crash out episode.

Abraham North

I don't think those voting against Icebreakers understand the pure horror and comedy Hunter reading it would be.

Lawnknee

Hockey smut would be absolutely metal😭

Cloudeyes

Mods can we get pucking around in there too

midnight

i would love to hear a smut reading, but i think it would be way better if both of them read it, itd just be a depressing one sided crashout if its just hunter... all of that said, yall please vote for icebreaker lol

Chanze

this is a good point actually we need Isaiah so he can cringe over the unhinged shit Hunters gonna say

Sweetz

The fact that "girlfriend with weird skin" is at 44% great minds think alike

Carissa Willard

I am glad that I am among friends with my creepy mind.

Carissa Willard

Agreed, it's only fun when Isaiah sounds like he's about to throw up.

Graceee

plz weird skin w nik as cohost

CrizzlyBear

Creepcast lost episode from the reddit :)

Malakai

But gross rat boy voice guys BIG GROSS RAT BOY BIG GROSS RAT BOY

RylantheReee

He can finally commit stolen valor with the veteran one

Ozmataz Buckshank

I wanna thank papa meat for continuing to post while wendigoon is gone. Things are shit in Minnesota right now like anywhere else and creeping my cast is one of the few things I can look forward to lately.

Tresses

Ive been hoping for the shell shock story from them forever, yall dont know peak

Beef

Beef

Cream

Cream ranking

Queen_Of_Empion

GROSS RAT! GROSS RAT! GROSS RAT! 🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀

Serenity

We need more on here !!

Serenity

We crave more content

Garf

Girlfriend has weird skin? I see people still have no taste here.

kkatsios

Not related but is there any specialized playlist for pure patreon exclusives? Would be nice to not have to scroll past all the ad-free versions.

D L

The veteran one has so many themes to play off of its gonna have a better chance of being a quality story, but on the other hand gf having weird skin would be funny.

Crabbus

Based #IceCold

kelloshot

Do them all lol 😂 I really enjoyed the last livestream, though Hunter did great, I liked how he blurted out his intrusive thoughts lol 😂

Monique

Team rat.

pinheadlarry

It would be scary (I didn't vote for it)

gloomara

Absolutely! Happy to help :)

Allison Small

I’m in the twin cities too and agree with this sentiment. ❤️

babyhole

i don’t think it’s that deep stephen

childeminaj

Icebreakers mid we need pucking around

DREACH

Brother they put it up there as an option get a grip

Jordan

my brother in rice; its a meme vote, people are having fun memeing, calm down <3

Hunter R.

should read the rest of the point pine series on the main page

Milky BB

I hope I can actually be at this live 😭🙏

Annie Almonde

I know I can never have it but the shitshow that would be caused by reading the playground would be so funny

Seth Cains

You guys should do a creep tv for Vita Carnis. Hunter would love it

Maybe Baby

Read mother horse eyes all by himself

Smizzo

That would be S tier content

Seth Cains

I know right. It would be so good

Smizzo

Its just 11.5 hours of fairy queen, lmao

coürt

We need some more romance, long live turk brownie

CJ

RELEASE THE RATS!!!!!!! 🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀

TacticalChef

this and Weird Birds but for the exact opposite reason

Probot

If your looking at the comments to pick a vote everyone else voted ice breakers

corey

Hey guys, I think you would really like the Novel Tender Is The Flesh by Augustina Bazterrica. It's not very long and since yall have been doing longer vids, maybe it may fit in. It's a crazy read and I think you'd like it. I read it when looking for more authors of color. I will keep commenting this everywhere until you acknowledge it!

Glar

What’s ice breakers?

Glar

Can you link the story? I would quite like to read it

lamexdame

Even if the rat doesn’t win the popular vote, go with the RAT

SkinWanker

Snuff video where wendigoon dies

Hulku

Wtf is the weird skin story

UrMom

I’m currently reading and was thinking the same thing!! And they could even break it into parts or do a patreon special episode

corey

Agreed! It's right up their alley!

Lennon

YOO YESYES!!! great book omg

Jake

No idea, but I voted for it because I’d love to have a solo hunter do a story about weird skin. It seems right up his alley

Avo Mustashio

I can't believe people picked a gross skin girl over a gross rat story... you monsters...

DImmy

VOTE ICEBREAKER just imagine wendy reading Snuff LOL

Fishtherapist

"My Girlfriend Has Weird Skin. " Chapter 1: We Broke Up The End

Tyler Hall

This is just Hunter reading it like the last story

Ducky

Lmao not us having the same hair

Ducky

From mn as well and this is my only distraction ❤️ deleted social media everything is shit

Hulku

Hey very accurate i agree

Farquad

only difference between Isaiah not being there is that hunter has nobody to make fun of, and that now we get to hear hunter crash out over his dyslexia lol

Farquad

It would take a month with how many times he rereads sections then he would just start cracking so many jokes during the part were the girl is in the vr sex simulation

Fishtherapist

I gotta disagree with you, buddy. The balance between Isaiah and Hunter is lightening in a bottle. They are much, much stronger together.

endlessbeez

Someone didn’t get to watch Heated Rivalry 💀💀💀

charles dwyer

If you fellas ever do another creepcast grab bag y'all should check out Football 17776!!! It's a great sci-fi vignette about immortality and of course, good ole american football

Fr1tz

Tripled

Ozmataz Buckshank

I hope y'all are staying safe if you're out there today.

Smizzo

💀💀💀 oh wow, what a sick comment about major league homohockey. 💀💀💀

David Bern

Y'all are tripping for not wanting him to read smut. I'm tryna hear big boy moan in my ear and talk about the sheer girth and tonage

kuni

is the stream at 10AM CST again? i'll probably have to miss it which sucks

ItsJustFitz

Any story that requires them to read about female characters is a plus because I know Jacoby will make an appearance

Louie Luke

Love this sort of content. Prefer both hosts but since Wendi is busy with life I’m completely for Hunter soloing it. Please post the live stream so people who can’t make it (likely myself) can enjoy the content as well.

Meena

All.

Alikade

OMG ICEBREAKERS LIKE THE BOOKTOK BOOK????

Alikade

WAIT WAIT

Alikade

Gf has weird skin Whyd i think of Mikayla from ur slomw season2 recap 😭🖤💚

Overhead_cam

He would love the gross rat story

Robin Lewis

There's actually a creepy pasta cemented in my memory called 'shellshock'. I listened to the narration and it's pretty short but also a slam dunk for me. I'm waiting for the next grab bag style episode or author highlight for shorter stories

snuzz

I THOUGHT THAT TOO LMFAO

Farquad

I agree all jokes ofc it’s mainly just cope on my end

KyndalTheMeister

Diarrhea from Hell story. Just any one, real or not.

Phoob

Hate gross stories

KEEFZILLA

I love the top two comments I see are "I love gross stories" and "Hate gross stories"

Carlen Gordon

I love a good shell shock story, Jacob's Ladder had a huge impact on me as a vet

Libertarian Joker

Can’t believe we have so few votes for Icebreaker. This community is full of vapid freaks who don’t know real literature when it’s staring them in the face

KyndalTheMeister

Maybe a story with a song or something Hunter can sing? Since he enjoys that and with Isaiah gone he doesn't have to worry about him getting annoyed. Maybe there is a creepypasta out there that's just a song? I remember reading/listening to creepypastas that were extremely short in length, like 30 seconds to under five minutes, so I think there might be some out there. The Alvin Schwartz Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark trilogy had some songs in it, they were so cute. There was The Hearse Song, and the rhyme, The Man Who Lived In Leeds, Ba-Rooom!, and The Slithery-Dee.

Frank slow

Oh god I’ve read Icebreakers please don’t!

Valento Dub

The fact that one of the options is "girlfriend has weird skin" as a title is already enough for me to vote for it lol can't wait to hear Hunter read that

Björn

True!! Of course they vote for the title made by a 12 year old.

Björn

You're a freak

David Bern

Or I guess you might say..... A creep?

David Bern

Perchance casting my creepiness in the comment section?

Abba

Please play Reanimal on stream!!

CalebyJacky

I would love to watch hunter play no, i'm not human

Heem Jeffe

Penismonkey story when?

HomunculusFreak

Of course you people pick a story about women's skin

Charisma

I wanted to hear Hunter talk about a gross rat 😞

Cy Overstreet

I know Hunter isn't as keen on SCP stuff, but I've been reading a fantastic novel adapted from an SCP story called "There is No Antimemetics Division". It has a lot to do with the fear of forgetting and "antimemes" which are monsters that melt your mind and make you forget that they even existed or make others forget that you existed. Definitely too long for a creep cast episode but it's a very good story. Just thought I'd recommend (just don't watch the fan films).

John Roache

Gotta read Icebreakers with Isaiah now

Savannah Rayfield

I’m devastated he didn’t get to read more in the stream

MacNCheese

that sounds sick, adding that to my tbr rn

JimPlatinum

Sorry for necro posting but it looks like we got the gross rat episode!

Yikes Brook

Why is no one picking ice breakers