One Night With Becky: Chapter 4 (Patreon)
Content
The hardest part wasn’t changing the settings. It was keeping my finger steady as I tapped “Save.”
Tinder’s preferences loaded back up, the gender filter now widened. My heart raced faster than I wanted to admit. There it was—just a few swipes between me and… something new…
I felt like I was one step closer to finding someone who could fill that void that Becky had opened up inside of me.
I swiped wildly that night, but the matches didn’t come. I maxed out my allowable swipes, but no new messages came in. No interested faces. Just profile after profile, most with blank bios or suspiciously filtered photos. I was used to coming across the odd AI photo on Tinder while looking for a girl, but now that I was looking at ‘trans girls’ specifically, it seemed like more than half of the options were AI, or at least modified with AI. I was starting to think that I was just setting myself up to be a catfishing victim.
I told myself it was normal: that Tinder could be slow; that I just needed to wait.
So I waited.
And waited.
Day after day, I checked the app like I was waiting for winning lottery numbers to be posted.
Morning.
Noon.
Night.
I kept the notifications turned on—even switched them to “Loud” in case I missed the buzz while walking around. Still nothing.
By the fifth day, I started wondering if something was wrong with the app. I uninstalled it. Reinstalled it. Updated it. Still no match.
Maybe something was wrong with me. Maybe trans girls are repulsed by a guy who has his settings set to only find them. Maybe that made me some sort of… pervert… some sort of fetishist. Was that what I was? This wasn’t something that I had ever wanted before—until I tried it. I wanted to think that I was doing this for all the right reasons. I wasn’t looking for quick fetish sex; I was looking for love.
By the sixth day, I told myself I was being too desperate, that real people didn’t check dating apps this much. But then I’d remember Becky’s laugh, her smile… and her big cock sliding onto my tongue—and the ache would come back, and the phone would be in my hand again, almost on its own.
Then, on the seventh day, it happened.
You’ve got a new match!
My heart skipped. I opened the app so fast I nearly dropped my phone.
Her name was Jenna. She had a cute smile, light brown eyes, and shoulder-length black hair that curled at the ends. Her makeup was a little heavy, and the lighting in her profile pictures wasn’t exactly doing her masculine traits any favours (like her broader shoulders and heavy brow line), but she looked… nice.
She wasn’t Becky…
But she was nice. She was fine.
I stared at her photo longer than I needed to, waiting for some feeling to stir. It didn’t come. Not excitement. Not longing. Not even curiosity. Just a muted buzz of… okay.
Still, I messaged her.
“Hey Jenna. I’m Richard. Thanks for matching with me!”
She replied within minutes.
“Hey! Nice to meet you, Richard. How’s your week been?”
She was polite. She was friendly… sweet… I should have been more excited than I was. We exchanged a few more messages, and I told myself the connection would come later. That chemistry on Tinder didn’t matter—chemistry in person did. Maybe she was funnier in real life. More confident… Maybe those pictures weren’t doing her much justice. I just needed to chip her walls down.
Maybe I was just projecting.
But I didn’t stop. I doubled down.
I kept talking to her, determined to find some chemistry. We talked about work, about favourite movies, music. I threw out jokes and forced myself to flirt, and she played along. She didn’t challenge me or make me feel sparks, but she was there. And for now, that was enough.
By the end of the night, we had a date set. Friday night. Coffee, at a new downtown cafe.
I stared at the message confirming it. My stomach flipped. Not in excitement. More like a sense of dread, knowing deep down that she wasn’t Becky.
I told myself this could be the start of something new, that Becky wasn’t the only person capable of making me feel alive. I told myself I could feel that again. I could recreate it. I could replace it.
*
The café was one of those trendy little downtown spots—exposed brick, mismatched furniture, indie music that nobody asked for playing a bit too loudly. I arrived ten minutes early and sat by the window. I ordered a coffee but I didn’t even sip it, worried the caffeine would just make my anxiety worse.
Jenna walked in, right on time.
She looked better in person, I had to admit. Her hair was glossy and well-kept, and her eyes lit up when she saw me. There was a softness to her smile that made her seem warm—and above all, feminine. But as she sat down and took off her coat, I couldn’t help noticing what the filtered profile pictures hadn’t fully revealed.
Her jawline was stronger than I expected. Her shoulders a bit broad. Her voice, when she greeted me, just a touch lower than I’d prepared myself mentally for. Not jarringly so—but noticeable. More noticeable than Becky.
And that’s where my mind kept going: back to Becky. Comparing. Measuring. Becky was like a barometer: a bar set unrealistically high. But didn’t I deserve to be with someone like her? Someone ideal?
I hated myself for having those thoughts.
“So,” Jenna said, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear, “do you come here a lot?”
It was the kind of question someone asks when they don’t know what else to say—setting the stage for that entire conversation. I smiled politely. “Sometimes. It’s close to work.”
She nodded, sipping her latte. “I like the vibe. It’s... different.”
“Yeah,” I said. “Kinda artsy.”
“Are you artsy?” she asked.
“Not really. You?”
“Not really.”
The conversation stumbled along. She told me about her job—data entry at some logistics firm (whatever that even meant)—and how she was trying to teach herself guitar from watching YouTube videos (she hadn’t actually learned a whole song yet). I nodded and chuckled when it seemed appropriate, but her words didn’t seem to stick. Neither did mine. I was too busy forcing myself to feel something.
But there was nothing.
No spark. No pulse-racing excitement. No butterflies.
I tried harder. I leaned in more, smiled more, cracked more jokes (not good ones). She laughed—more out of politeness than amusement—but it all felt hollow, like we were both just trying to keep something afloat that had no business floating.
I asked about her past relationships. She hesitated, then she shrugged.
“I haven’t really… dated much,” she admitted. “A few guys here and there—Tinder dates… First dates, mostly. Some ghosted me. Some got weird when they found out I’m trans. Others just wanted…” She trailed off and gave a sheepish smile. “Well, you know.”
“Yeah,” I said. I nodded for a while… too long, maybe wondering if I fit into that last category.
I had no idea what I was doing.
And still, I couldn’t bring myself to end the date. I didn’t want to walk away empty-handed. I didn’t want to feel like this whole thing—the search, the match, the effort—was all for nothing.
So I made a move that betrayed my own morals.
“You wanna come back to my place?” I asked, as casually as I could manage.
She blinked, surprised. “Oh. Uh, sure. Yeah. That’d be nice.” She looked totally shocked—as if she thought the date was going just as badly as me… But I could just sense that she was desperate. I could tell that she hadn’t been beyond many first dates.
But even still, I hadn’t expected her to say yes. Not so quickly. Not so easily.
But then I saw it—that flicker in her eyes. The way her fingers tightened slightly around her cup. The way her voice faltered. She wasn’t sure of herself. Not really. She was shy, maybe a little awkward, not quite at ease in her own skin. Her self-esteem was below sea level. She was pretty in her own way, but not the kind of pretty people stop and stare at. Chubby in a soft, endearing kind of way maybe… or maybe not.
I could see it in her eyes: Don’t blow it. Just take what you can get.
We walked the few blocks back to my apartment mostly in silence. The city was loud around us—cars, horns, sidewalk chatter—but between us, it was quiet. Neither of us reached for the other’s hand. Neither of us laughed. There wasn’t that same playful energy that was between me and Becky.
But that playful energy had never been real—at least not for both of us.
When we arrived, I unlocked the door and let her in first. She stepped inside slowly, looking around like she wasn’t quite sure she belonged.
I closed the door behind us.
Whatever this was, it was happening now. And I wasn’t sure if I was hoping for magic… or just trying to pretend it might still show up.
Files
Previews only