Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

As many of you know, I exclusively publish on Amazon. There are a few reasons for this, but mainly: it's a requirement in order to be in Kindle Unlimited. I make about half of my income from Kindle Unlimited 'borrows', and being in KU makes my books show up higher in search results. 

But recently, myself and a number of other authors (DL Savage, Barbara Deloto, etc) have run into an issue with Amazon. No matter how much we tame down our covers/descriptions/meta data, Amazon is putting our books into Erotica instead of Romance. Why is this a problem? Erotica titles don't appear in everyone's search results. Barb told me this morning that she's had a 4-5x decrease in sales :( I haven't had the same decrease (yet), mostly thanks to loyal fans like yourself (thank you so much). But the sting will come soon. Erotica titles tend to drop off the charts much, much faster than romance titles, and my last 4 releases all went into erotica. It's only a matter of time before the change is reflected in my sales. 

So what does this mean?

We're trying to get to the bottom of the issue, trying to figure out if there is a particular keyword responsible for the recent eroticapocolypse. If we can figure that out, then nothing will change. If our books are doomed to be in Amazon's mostly-hidden erotica dungeon, then there will be change. 

It might mean more Patreon-exclusive stories. Patreon seems stable, so slowly bringing my audience here might be the best solution! However, because Patreon doesn't pay out per number of pages read by readers (like KU), it will mean shorter stories. 

It will also mean dirtier stories, as there are no restrictions here. 

If Amazon keeps putting my stories into erotica, I will probably start writing them as erotica, so to not upset the buyers who search those categories. So that means less story and more sex. For some of you, this is a bonus, but I know that some of you will be upset with this change. But if I can't reach the people who casually search romance on Amazon (they account for more than half of my income) then I will have to cater to the erotica audience. 

I spent the weekend researching erotic authors who make their living outside of Amazon, and it seems that the vast majority of them write 2,000-5,000 word stories on Patreon. My average story runs about 20,000 words. Their tier systems are much different than mine, which might mean some rejigging. 

But the big downside to this might mean that I need to diversify my writing, and publish more traditional romance novellas (with my alternate pen name, Cordelia Blanc). I love writing trans tales, so I would never abandon my Nikki Crescent brand, but if this truly is an eroticapocolypse, then I may have to fight to avoid a one-way trip to my local trade school. 

But I plan on spending the next few months experimenting with my releases! So change won't come too soon. I have 22 books written that have yet to be published, and I will keep writing they way I've been writing until I figure out the best next step!

Comments

DJay

I know a lot of people have issues with Amazon. MSE got kicked off KU because according to the court files, his readers read too many books through KU and didn't buy enough, so they booted him off Amazon and told him to sell his books elsewhere. And on TOP of that, he had to fight to get the rights to sell his ol books back from Amazon and ended up losing a book deal to a publisher. All in all, be careful. Might want to look at Smashwords to sell your spicier stuff and Amazon for your more tame stuff.

Patrick Carey

So much stress. Let us know what we can do, if anything, to help. If borrowing titles on kindle unlimited boosts your numbers, would borrowing more help you or your fellow authors? I already borrow a lot, but if revisiting titles would help, I'm there.

88nikkig

Instead of using erotica, would it make sense to be fantasy? Several fantasy books with elves and witches can easily go into the extra erotica genre but it appears like the publisher insists that it's a fantasy transformation, fantasy experience, fantasy romance, etc...

nikkicrescent

It doesn't matter what category I choose, Amazon has been overriding my choice, putting everything into erotica. I tried putting my last release into Coming of Age, but it went straight into Erotica.

Sam Ebert

I'm so sorry to read you're still having this issue!!!! Amazon is where i do all my reading!!! They lose you as an author and I'll cancel my unlimited account!!!! Why pay extra money every month off they chase away my favorite author?

nikkicrescent

Thanks Sam! But I won't be leaving Amazon -- I might just end up posting much more here, and less there (or maybe shorter works there). I have another release tomorrow and I plan to experiment a little bit more with meta data and whatnot. We'll see what happens!

Patrick Carey

We're with you, whatever you do.