Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

After being classified into erotica for the fourth time in a row, I reached out to Amazon. It took a while, but I got an answer from a rep. Apparently they've started scanning manuscripts for keywords like 'cock' and 'cunt' and 'pussy', etc. They weigh the number of erotic words to the total number of words, and use an algorithm to decide if the book is 'erotica' or not. 

I will go broke if my books keep going into erotica, so I may have to tone down my language for Amazon. I also may try to censor my next release, changing words like 'cock' into 'c--k'. Would this censorship ruin the experience for you as a reader? Please be honest! 

Comments

DJay

I've noticed that people start using other words and now I understand why there's been an explosive use of the word "honey pot" instead of "pussy" or "meat stick" instead of "cock" in certain stories that I read. I would still read your works...Hell I just read "Couples Night" and would have read that if it were censored. I just love your works....Side note. I stopped commenting on the works because they hide my reviews on books like yours on Amazon to "protect" me.

88nikkig

I believe placing a * +, or your own character on pus⁵y, c@ck, di÷k,

Patrick Carey

I think I prefer substituted words to dashes. It's an opportunity to get creative with descriptions and substitutions, anyway. Interesting, my reviews don't get hidden, maybe I'm beyond saving. The story's the thing, so I'm not that attached to "dirty" words. Maybe if you talk about hardness, velvety depths, and back passages, they'll think it's romantic.

A.E. Cockman

C__k, won’t bother me. I also submit “meat stick” “cave of desire”, “sweet nectar” as other possibilities. Keep up the good work, I love your stories!

Dave McAllister

You know, I don't even notice those words. Like when reading russian novels, for some reason my mind blips them out. I say going to illusionary wording will be fine (heck I'm looking to see how creative you can be

Anonymous

Nikki, love your stories. C__K is ok. DICK is fine. Snatch or snach.

Michael Kopacz

I would have no problem with that as long as it is easy to infer the word by its context in the sentence.

Sam Ebert

Either way works for me!!!! Just as long as you're able to still write and post to Amazon and make a living!!!! Love your work and would deal with whatever you need to do just to be able to read your tales!!!!!!!!

Fluffy Cloud

just so long as 'throbber' doesn't need censoring, i've come to attach that word with your writing. :P

Fluffy Cloud

also, what category are you trying to fit in? because i'd personally categorize most of it as erotica...

Anonymous

Giving into censorship and allowing others to control your freedom of expression is a leap into the arms of repression of thought.

Ray

Speaking for myself, it probably wouldn't matter, however for someone that doesn't know your logic or reasoning for the censorship (someone that, for example, just stumbles into your books while surfing kindle) it would , I feel, appear to them that you either aren't confident enough to write what you are trying to say, are more of an embarrassed amateur, or are trying to clean up your content to entice either (a:) younger or (b:) more prudent readers simply to boost sales (which is, I understand the end goal, but the censorship reads more like you as an author feeling uncomfortable with what you want to say). Just my humble opinion. Ray

Fluffy Cloud

another way around a filter that checks the ratio of explitives:otherwords is to increase the count of other words.... your current is erotica. often it's 3 sexy scenes and then put a 'the end' sign up... i personally would prefer another few chapters of non-sexy stuff that solidified the emotional/romantic aspect of a story.

Patrick Carey

Is all erotica targeted or are the tg stories being singled out? I recall romance novels getting rather explicit, I wonder if they're just avoiding the naughty words to get by.

nikkicrescent

I'm not too sure to be honest!! Most of the people I knew who weren't writing TG either stopped writing over the past couple of years, or they moved onto more tame romance novels (sci fi, fantasy, etc).

nikkicrescent

It's a hard balance to find, as I have many readers who (and it's everyone's right to read however they want to read) only read the sex scenes. I get many emails from people who say they just skim to the sex and that's it. Amazon pays per pages read, so financially it makes sense to have a higher ratio of sex. It's always a struggle for me, feeling like books are ending abruptly, but knowing that if I spend another day writing an extended ending, many people won't read it... It's really just a weird balance at the end of the day!

nikkicrescent

I like humble opinions, and this is exactly how I feel. Just for the sake of experimenting, my next 2-3 releases will probably be censored. Amazon doesn't reveal how it judges new releases in the publication queue, so us authors have to experiment to figure it out. At least if I can understand what the trigger words are, I can start to come up with a solution -- maybe like another person pointed out: more non-sexy words to lower the ratio of sexy words.

nikkicrescent

Trans romance! And yes, most of my books are certainly erotic (and maybe lots of even 'erotica'), but the problem is that the erotica audience doesn't look in the erotica category, mostly because it's hidden from most users unless they turn off specific settings that they have to know exist in the first place. It's been a tough battle for years, writing in a genre that mixes romance with erotica. If you scan through the 'transgender erotica' top 100 chart on Amazon, you'll see what people who are searching the erotica charts are looking for: lots of taboo, very short works (less than a quarter the length of what I write), and mostly sex (more than half the content is sex). So being in the erotica category, that becomes the competition, which leaves me with the options: get back into romance (most romance these days has lots of sex) or adapt to compete on the erotica charts. Most new readers scroll those charts to buy new books.

nikkicrescent

I've adapted many times before when Amazon has flipped things on its head. So I'm sure I'll survive this too!

Anonymous

I love your stories! I usually search writers name to find the stories I want to read.