FMK #2: New Faces, New Hard Choices (Patreon)
Content
HERE'S HOW THE GAME WORKS!
In the comments, pick who you would FUCK, who you would MARRY, and who you would KILL. I will tally the results and eliminate one girl (KILL), write a sex scene for one girl (FUCK), and the final girl (MARRY) will go on to compete in future contests.
18 girls
9 dead bodies
8 hot fucks
1 ring on one finger
YESTERDAY'S RESULTS
The community chose to take Piper into the next round.
Lori was chosen to be killed in a close race with Andi (7 votes to 6).
You chose to fuck Andi.
TODAY'S CONTESTANTS
Meet Terri, Kris, and Anna. Choose who you will fuck, who you might marry, and who you will kill.
FUCK, MARRY, KILL
CHAPTER ONE
GONE TOO SOON
It’s not how I wanted to be returning to my hometown. I’d never actually been to a funeral before, unless you count my grandpa’s funeral, when I was four years old. The only thing I remember from that funeral is when my brother tried to climb up to see my grandpa in the casket, and then the whole thing fell down. My brother broke his ankle under the weight of my dead grandfather, and the dead body landed on top of him, traumatizing a number of people in that room… And I remember that it was raining outside.
Now, I was on my way home to watch them bury Lori. I had to buy a suit just for the occasion, even though I didn’t really know Lori that well. I thought I would wear the suit once and then it would be a decade or two before I had to wear it again. Boy, was I wrong… That suit was about to get a lot of use.
Lori was Arnold’s older sister, and Arnold was my best friend growing up. Lori was twelve years older than us and we never really saw her much. She moved out when me and Arnold were little eight-year-olds, and then she would be gone for days, partying, doing drugs, getting drunk—the same stuff that every eighteen-year-old city girl does.
Lori and Arnold’s mom died after Arnold was born, leaving them with just their dad. But Lori was there to fill the gap, and she did a pretty good job when she wasn’t out partying. In fact, when we were really young, I thought that Lori was Arnold’s mom—and Arnold thought the same thing; at five years old, he was too young to realize that a seventeen-year-old probably wasn’t his mother. He called her ‘Mommy’ and she never corrected him—at least not while I was around. And he was too young to remember when Lori started transitioning—because she was born a boy.
I didn’t know that she had been born a boy until I turned eighteen and I ran into Lori at a bar in Vancouver. “What are you doing here?” I asked her. I was in Vancouver for college. She told me that she in town for a big party: her thirtieth birthday. She invited me, and I accepted the invite. The party was at a huge downtown club. It was busy, and all of Lori’s friends were there. Lori kept buying me drinks. Then, when she noticed that I was getting drunk, she started bringing me waters. She even ordered me some food, sat me down, and made sure I ate everything on my plate.
I remember laughing and saying, “You’re like my mom.”
“You can call me mommy,” she said with a grin. And I was too drunk at the time to consider how weird the comment was, especially since her hand was on my thigh. Then, her hand started sliding up my thigh, towards my crotch. In that moment, I forgot that she was trans. I reached over and put my hand on her bare thigh. I looked into her eyes and she looked into mine. I started sliding my own hand up once she had her fingers clutched around the girth of my bulge. She started massaging. I pushed my fingers up to her panties, under her dress. She let out a slight moan. I pushed my fingers under that thin cotton fabric, and then my hand grabbed onto a half-erect penis.
It was huge and completely unexpected. My face turned while and my heart skipped a beat. I stared into her eyes, trying to think of a way to let go without offending her. She was now stroking my cock under that club table. People were buzzing all around us, but nobody seemed to care that we were getting handsy under the table (it had a glass top, so it’s not like we were being too secretive).
“I’m sorry,” I said. “You—You’re my friend’s mom.”
“I’m Arnold’s sister,” she said with a laugh. “Not his mom.”
“But—But you were like his mom,” I said. Then I let go. A wave of relief washed over me. But even though I wasn’t holding that cock anymore, I felt like I could still feel it: that throbbing warmth as it stretched out, becoming erect in my palm. It wasn’t right, but I couldn’t stop thinking about it.
“You’ll like it,” she said, almost whispering with a grin on her face.
“Like it? Like what?” I said, still white all over.
“We’ll go to the bathroom and I’ll fuck you. I promise you’ll like it,” she said. “I’ll make you come without touching your cock. Have you ever come from being penetrated before? It’s amazing.”
I shook my head quickly. “I have school tomorrow,” I said in a panic. Then I jumped away from that table and rushed away from Lori. And that was the last time I ever saw her alive.
On my way out of the club, I ran into another old friend: Andi. I hadn’t seen Andi since we were in junior high, but I knew that she lived in Vancouver. I’d actually been meaning to reach out to her, but I never really had a reason. Now, she was staring into my eyes. I recognized her face, but not her body, which was now littered with colorful tattoos. “Where are you going, Ricky?” she said. “It’s so early. You’re leaving already?”
“I’ve got school in the morning,” I said. I looked over her shoulder to make sure Lori wasn’t coming. I still couldn’t stop thinking about the feeling of that cock in my hand. It was just so warm—and it felt so strangely… nice. There was something feminine about it, even though that made absolutely no sense. A cock shouldn’t be feminine. Cocks belong on men… don’t they?
“Are you okay?” Andi asked, narrowing her eyes. “You’re all zoned out.”
“Just tired,” I said.
“Well, I know you’ve got school in the morning, but you should stay for one more drink. We should catch up,” she said with a smile. It was a bit hard to focus on her words as she spoke to me. She wasn’t wearing clothes... not really. She was wearing leather booty shorts over a crimson lacy teddy: lingerie. I could see the contour of her breasts and her nipples, as if she was completely topless, and she didn’t even seem to care. I could see the thin scars from where she had her implants put it—because she was also trans, like Lori.
That’s how she became friends with Lori. She was twelve when she started transitioning at school. The kids in my class all made fun of her—I stayed out of it, not wanting to hurt anybody’s feelings, even though I thought it was weird at the time. Arnold told Andi to call his sister, and she did. Then, like the ‘mommy’ she was, Lori took Andi under her wing, and they’d been great friends ever since.
“I really can’t stay,” I said, looking around again to make sure Lori wasn’t coming for me. I don’t know what I was so scared of. I knew she wasn’t going to grab me and drag me against my will into a bathroom to fuck me. I think I was afraid that if I saw her, looking all hot and dolled up on her thirtieth birthday, I might convince myself to give it a try. I was afraid that I would like it. I was afraid that Lori was going to completely change me. I didn’t want to lose my virginity by taking a cock in the ass. And I knew that Arnold wouldn’t approve of me having sex with his sister.
“We should catch up some time,” Andi said. She looked down at my crotch, and it was a moment before I realized that I was still half-erect from being rubbed by Lori. I blushed all over and bit down on my tongue.
“Another time,” I said with a forced smile, and then I didn’t see her again for almost a decade.
I was sitting down on the plane, a late-night redeye, wearing my new black funeral suit, when I noticed a sleeve of tattoos next to me. I looked up that arm, and saw that the girl was wearing lingerie, as if lingerie was an acceptable form of clothing in public. The sight of her breasts through the thin lace made me remember Andi, and then I looked up at the girl’s face and saw that it was her. “Andi?” I said.
She looked up at me and her eyes became wide. “What are the chances!?” she said, lighting up. She reached out her arms and we hugged on that plane. I felt her soft lace and her squishy breasts. She smelled nice.
Finally, we had our chance to catch up. She was on her way to Lori’s funeral as well. She started crying as she spoke about Lori and all of her nice memories. I consoled her with a tight hug. I basked in the smell of that amazing perfume. Then, Andi had the brilliant idea of ordering drinks. It wasn’t the longest flight: only two hours. But somehow, we managed to get through four drinks each. We laughed as we caught up. And it wasn’t long before we started talking about our exes. Andi was quick to get into intimate details. “I had to leave my last boyfriend because he wouldn’t pull my hair,” she said.
“What do you mean, pull your hair?” I asked, sounding totally naïve.
“When he was fucking me. He wouldn’t pull my hair. I begged him to do it for months, and he said he wasn’t comfortable doing it. He just wouldn’t pull my hair.”
I laughed. “Well I would pull your hair for you, Andi,” I said jokingly. Then, we had a moment. Her eyes met mine and there was a silence. I started thinking about that moment with Lori, almost ten years earlier, when I had my fingers curled around that throbbing cock. I’d thought about that moment a lot. For years, I thought about what I’d missed out on. I wondered if I would have liked it. I’d watched porn featuring trans porn stars. I’d thought a lot about penetrating myself with dildos. I even bought a dildo, but I was too afraid to go through with using it; it never made it into my asshole.
Now, I had a tingling in my heart. After nearly ten years, I had another chance.
“We’ll be landing in fifteen minutes,” the pilot said.
“I really have to use the bathroom,” Andi said, still looking into my eyes.
“Me too,” I said. “You go first.”
We went together to the back of the plane. The plane was mostly empty, and the few passengers on the flight were asleep. Andi opened the bathroom door to go in. Then she paused and turned to me. Our eyes met again. She reached out her hand and I took it. We went into the bathroom together. A moment later, our drunken lips were locked together. My hands were on her sides, sliding up her shirt. I looked down and saw more tattoos than I could count. There was more ink than bare skin—by a large margin.
I pulled her shirt off and squeezed her breasts. She wrapped her leg around me and gently grinded herself against my body. I could feel her bulge, and it was big, making my heart race. I had no idea what I was getting myself into. I was terrified that I would regret it. I’d never been with a trans girl before. I’d never touched another cock, except for Lori’s, and that was by accident.
But I had to try it. I had to know what it felt like. I reached down into her tight shorts, pushing my fingers down along her lacy lingerie. I felt her enormous bulge and I squeezed it. I massaged and fondled it while she moaned. Then, I unbuttoned those shorts and slid them down to her thighs. My heart was racing fast now. My hands were trembling. I took her lacy lingerie and pulled it to the side, letting her meat fall out. I gasped, freezing at the sight of her cock. I couldn’t believe how big it was. I slowly dropped to my knees. I reached out to grab it. My fingers curled around it, and I felt like I’d been transported back to 2011, in that club with Lori. I lifted it up—and it was heavy—and I brought it to my lips.
Then, Andi grabbed her cock and pulled it away from me. “What are you doing?” she said. “I don’t want that.”
“You don’t? I—I’m sorry,” I said.
“Stand up,” she said. So I stood up. Then she dropped to her knees. She unzipped my fly and pulled my cock out. I couldn’t help but notice her free hand stuffing her cock back into her lingerie. I had no idea how her ten-inch monster stayed inside that tiny garment. She pulled out my throbbing erection and started sucking it. She moaned out a sigh of relief. She sucked me until I was rock hard. My head was spinning with confusion now. Why didn’t she want me sucking her cock? Why did I want to suck her cock? Maybe that moment with Lori did end up changing me, even though I didn’t go through with Lori’s offer.
Andi spat out my cock. She stood up and turned around in that small airplane bathroom. She pressed her hands against the wall. “Fuck me quickly. The plane will land soon,” she said.
I was slow to move in, slow to put my hands on her tattooed sides. I caressed her soft body and felt her squishy tits. I pulled on her nipples and then I took my cock and pushed it into her asshole. She groaned as I pushed in. She was tight. She had a tattoo on her left butt cheek that said, ‘PULL MY HAIR’. So I grabbed onto her pink hair, squeezed tight, and pulled her head back. She groaned loudly. “Harder!” she said. So I pulled harder. “Harder! Pull fucking harder!” I yanked on her head, scared I was going to break her neck—but she liked it. She moaned and her butthole clenched my cock over and over.
I pumped her hard, pulling her hair. She moaned and trembled as we both broke a good sweat in that poorly ventilated space. I reached around to grab onto her giant erection, but she swatted my hand away. “I don’t want that right now,” she said, almost as if I’d ruined the mood. So I didn’t try to touch her again. Her cock was off limits, and that made me feel a bit strange and uncomfortable—and very embarrassed. I felt like I was being rejected, even though my cock was in her ass and she was moaning loudly.
I pumped harder and pulled her hair as hard as I could. As her body trembled, her ass cheeks jiggled. Her skin turned dark red. She lifted one foot up and placed it down on the small sink. Now, I was fucking her at a peculiar angle, but I liked it. I used both of my hands to spread out her butt cheeks, so I could watch my cock sliding in and out.
I couldn’t hold on. I came inside of her, making her gasp. I filled her tight asshole with thick, warm cum. As I pulled out, she reached back, plugging her hold with her middle finger. I watched for a moment as she pulled her finger out of her hole. I had no idea what was happening.
As she pulled her finger out, cum came out. She let it pool into her hand. “What are you doing?” I asked.
“Stand there and watch. Don’t talk,” she said. She turned to face me. She dug her erection out from her lingerie. It stood tall, throbbing, and thick. She spread my cum along her big shaft and she began to pump herself.
She just wanted me to watch her jerk off. I had no idea what to do. I was scared but also mesmerized. I couldn’t stop watching as she squeezed and pulled, making my cum gush between her fingers. My white cream was getting under her foreskin, and into her pink-dyed pubic hair. She didn’t seem to care. She stared into my eyes while she jerked herself. Was this her fetish? I liked it, but I knew I wasn’t supposed to be liking it. I knew it wasn’t normal.
She squeezed hard and moaned. Then, she froze, with her fist clenched around her tip. Suddenly, cum began spewing into the air. It flew up about two feet before falling to the ground with a heavy splat. Her whole body trembled—almost convulsing. She drained herself on that bathroom floor, and then she slipped her cock away, stuffing it back into that lingerie.
She took a deep breath, stared into my eyes for another long, intimidating moment, and then she turned to the sink to rinse off her hand. “That was cool,” she said.
“Y—Yeah,” I said.
“You should go back to your seat before they find us in here,” she said.
So I went back to my seat. She came out two minutes later, five minutes before the plane landed. We didn’t speak much after that. Once we stepped off the plane, she said, “I have to go exchange some money, so I’ll see you at the funeral.”
“Okay,” I said, still dumbfounded. I was completely confused. I had no idea what had just happened. I liked it, but I was left feeling unsatisfied, and terrified that I was about to be feeling a whole lot of regret. I could remember when Andi was Andy. I remembered when he was just a shaggy-haired boy, like the rest of us. That was fifteen years ago, but the memory was still fresh.
I went to the baggage claim. Now, it was 3:30 AM. The airport was silent save for the hum of the floor cleaner, and the squeeze footsteps of the janitor pushing it. I stood and waited for fifteen long minutes while the luggage made its way from the plane to the carousel. Finally, I saw my bag come down. I grabbed it quickly, wanting to get to my parents’ house, so I could get into bed. I knew that my dad was waiting outside, in the car, and he was probably wanting to get some sleep too. He was an older man, after all.
So I rushed out and hopped into the passenger seat. I didn’t even give my dad a hug. We sped off.
“It’s great to see you,” he said. “We’ll catch up in the morning.” Then he yawned and rubbed his eyes.
“Thanks for picking me up,” I said.
“It’s too bad that you come home for the first time in nearly ten years because of a funeral. You should really visit more often,” he said.
“I know. I’ve been meaning to,” I said, looking out the window at the city lights. That city had changed a lot since I left. It was so much bigger and so much newer. I hardly even recognized the place until we pulled into our neighborhood—then, it suddenly felt like I’d never left. And a part of me felt like I’d never left. A part of me was worried that I was just waking up from a long dream, and now, I was still living with my parents in my hometown: no college degree, no career, still a virgin… Well, I could still smell Andi’s perfume on me, so I knew I wasn’t still a virgin.
“So how did she die?” my dad asked.
“She was hit by a bus while crossing the road,” I said.
“Terrible way to go,” he said.
“Couldn’t have happened to a nicer lady,” I said.
We pulled into the driveway. My dad helped to get my suitcase out of the trunk, even though I insisted I could do it. Then he insisted on carrying it up to my old childhood room. “Goodnight, son,” he said.
“Goodnight, dad,” I said with a smile. He went off to sleep, and then I got undressed. The sheets smelled old, like they hadn’t been washed since I last visited. So I decided to put on some sweat pants to sleep in. I unzipped my suitcase and flipped it open. Then, I paused, staring down at a suitcase full of dresses, bras, and panties. I stared for a long moment before flipping the top back over and looking at the tag.
Apparently, I had grabbed the wrong bag. It was identical, aside from the tag. This bag belonged to someone named Piper Murphy.
TO BE CONTINUED...
Files
Previews only