Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

FUCK, MARRY, KILL has come to a close! You voted 10 times, choosing between 18 unique girls. In the end, you chose to marry a girl you previously chose to kill but brought back in a special resurrection vote. 

I had a ton of fun writing all 9 pieces of the story: 76,119 words in total (Making FMK one of the longest stories I've ever written). I also had a great time writing the 3 (and counting) Patreon-Exclusive FMK bonus pieces: Cora's Cucumber, Lori's Las Fuck, and Petra's Frisky Photoshoot. 

The big question is: is this something you would like to see again? 

Next, I'll be writing the winning story from the Pitch Contest, and then I have one other book to write before I will start a new FMK, with a new storyline and a new batch of girls--assuming it was entertaining for you. 

In the comments, feel free to discuss the results of the game. Tell me your honest feedback: What did you like? What did you not care so much for? Were you able to keep up with the story as it was published? Or was it published too slowly to hold your interest? What do you want more of in the future? 

I already have some ideas for future games. My goal is to increase engagement. We have over 150 people in this community, but we were only getting ~20 votes each round. I know we have a lot of weekenders here, and I have some ideas to make them feel more included too. 

One idea that I have is to give everyone a special skill that they can use once in the game. For example, a double-power vote you can use once, or a 'protection spell' that you could use to keep a girl safe from being eliminated. Perhaps there could be better 'skills' that are available to readers who have participated in past rounds. Let me know what you think about this... too complicated? 

Overall, I hope everyone had fun! I hope you got turned on by at least a few of the sex scenes. I hope that this can be something we can build on, so we can all have something to look forward to each month. 

Files

Previews only

Comments

Davinder

I enjoyed everything. I can see how much hard work you have done for it but there are couple of suggestions i like to make likke selected to marry doesn't get anything except some vanilla flirting even though she won that poll for example pipper died virgin even though se won first poll and my second suggestion is we don't to kill kill character we also forget them by giving them less screen time like tv series do with side characters.....

nikkicrescent

I get what you're saying. But I think that makes each vote more consequential. If every 'marry' also got fucked, it would diminish the point of the 'fuck' vote. Choosing to marry a girl is like taking a big risk -- you risk bringing her to the end, but you're also risking taking her to another vote where she could be lost before we get to have fun with her. In the end, the winning girl got a sex scene (Petra, on the plane). For your second suggestion, are you saying that we should talk less about them after they've been killed?

guardian__J

I thought it was great, tons of fun and some real surprises in the direction everyone was going. Couple suggestive comments: 1. Too slow? No way, almost too fast. Some of the voting felt like it came before I got to read the previous story. Maybe not necessarily slower posting, but maybe more refined time for how long until the voting cuts off. Or maybe having the voting posts not directly on the new story's post. Might make the gap between when you are needing to write the story and our voting flow differently? 2. Which is the second suggestion, I've seen other Patreons that have actual voting options in the post and then the comments are just every one talking about how they voted or want it to go. Then it has a cut off to show that it is done. Maybe have a first post with picking the Marry that voting is open for two days, then cut off and post the remaining two in a kill vote for two days? Or what ever order makes your writing easier. Should make counting easier too.

JeffJ

I absolutely had a lot of fun with it. I actually joined your Patreon when I saw the FMK game because of the type of interaction with others that it could create. I do wish there was more conversation about why people voted the way they did. I looked at all of the posts when voting was done specifically looking for why people voted different than I did. I think that would create more community. I'll throw another idea out for future versions of the game. Would it be possible to add other user's that have voted and included feedback into the stories? It would be amazing to see others added to the stories that I may have a conversation with through the voting. Just an option for making it even more interactive for users.

Patrick Carey

I had a lot of fun, it was quite exciting, and the sex scenes were as well. I think that maybe not everyone could keep up, perhaps that's why there weren't as many votes? The raise dead vote is a good example of a special skill that can make it more interesting, though our choice didn't work out quite like I thought. The idea reminds me of the show "Survivor", which has introduced some game changing idol twists over the years. There are a lot of possibilities, it would be a complication mostly for you to keep track of. Immunity, double vote, steal a vote, resurrection, there could be others depending on the type of story. You said other stories wouldn't necessarily be literally killing girls, so you might change the special powers accordingly. This was, by the way, an interesting little mystery, something you might use for a regular story, an erotic thriller. It also fits the choose your own adventure genre, where each choice you make leads to a different outcome. There's several of those out there if you want to see what it might look like if you wanted to publish one. It would be challenging writing out all possible outcomes, but fun for those who want to see what would have happened, and try to get the ending they like. Games like this are a lot of fun, and I'd definitely like more. To draw in those who don't always check in daily, perhaps announce what the next FMK will be ahead of time, offering a vote on some aspect of it, and come back in a week to kick it off, so more people will have had time to see it. You might make the daily vote on some smaller aspect of the girls' appearance or the setting, and make the FMK vote happen on a set day afterwards, like with the story choice vote, to give less frequent fans a chance to play. Something like, your girl wants you to dress up: do you choose naughty schoolgirl, glamour gal, or slutty call girl? Do you want to do it at her place, your place, or right there in club/gym/whatever? Daily fans still get more gameplay for checking in, but the others can be part of the overall game. This would stretch it out a bit more, but would maybe encourage more casual fans to join in. This would also work if it wasn't exactly FMK, but still a vote how the story goes, like how a character gets feminized.

Jason Thomas

I definitely want to see more of this kind of content. I felt that the pacing was just fine for me, but definitely no faster than that. If it were slower to help more people enjoy it, I would not have a problem with that either. I agree that a character that wins the Marry vote shouldn't also get fucked that round, but how about a solo scene? I really liked the bringing one person back at the end. It didn't turn out how I wanted the vote to go (poor Piper!) but I like the way it was done. Definitely keep including an occasional biologically female character. I like the idea of it being a poll. If my math is right, there are 6 options in FMK. That is short enough to list all of the options for a poll.

Bridgette

I also liked the FMK series. I'd suggest dragging it out a little longer unless you're flush with lots and lots of characters.

Thom

Loved it first time I got involved. Super job…Nice

guardian__J

Special powers sounds cool, but that also seems complicated to keep track of if it's for specific people, and it's still pretty awesome anyways. The Raise Dead option that the whole group got to vote and use the special power is an excellent way to add more flavor.

guardian__J

It could work with 6 options, only problem with that is split votes for the second-third choices can split the first choice. For example: Choice 1: F Girl 1, M Girl 2, K Girl 3 = 3 Votes Choice 2: F Girl 1, M Girl 3, K Girl 2 = 3 Votes Choice 3: F Girl 3, M Girl 2, K Girl 1 = 4 Votes (...etc...) Technically Girl 1 got 6 Votes to Fuck, but Choice 3 wins the votes so Girl 1 gets Killed. Seems like harsh margin for splitting the votes on the secondary options. If we choose who to F first, then Nikki can start writing the scene for that while we vote who gets to Marry from the last two options.

Will

Very well done. I have a couple of suggestions but they may not be great ideas. What if at the beginning, you show all 18 girls and give them all a brief little bio. If you want one of them to be a killer then, also give each something suspicious so they would have a motive. For a setting this is almost perfect for a Survivor or Bachelor like show. You could also do a ranking system if you showed all the options at the beginning and let the fans vote on who they like best vs least. You then rank them 1-18 and have it be like a basketball tournament. So fir example 1 would be paired with 18 and 12. 2 with 17 and 11. 3 with 16 and 10 and so forth.

nikkicrescent

I could totally make polls if that system would be better for everyone, though breaking it up into two polls to stretch over two days would slow things down for sure. Maybe that would be fine. But it wouldn't necessarily work with the idea I had of having special powers, like a double-strength vote you can use once, etc.

nikkicrescent

Glad you had fun, Jeff :) I'm not entirely sure what you mean by adding other users that have voted. Could you clarify a little bit for me?

Thom

I like Will’s ideas👆

nikkicrescent

I really like the idea, but my only concern with doing it that way is that people will choose who they want to win from the start and then challenges between other characters would become somewhat inconsequential. Also, wouldn't the pre-ranking almost certainly determine who will be killed and who will be married?

Thom

I liked first idea better than second

Thom

Yep maybe leave 1 or 2 mystery for you…

Thom

For me the second Anna was shown she was my girl though temptation was cool think Iris and Quinn… so why not see 16 incomplete bios and leave 2 for you

nikkicrescent

I'm not saying no to the idea. It would require quite a bit of additional planning and preparation. I tweaked around later girls based on the results of the first few rounds.

Will

Okay another spitball idea, what if we know 8-9 or so of them but we only know a fact or two. Then as the story progresses, you build in facts in the story and their bios then get updated. So like we would know hair color approximate age but personality quirks we don’t know and are slowly revealed The mc could know the first say six or so but after that they are getting information during the first part of the story.

Will

I don’t know if that makes sense but I would imagine it like they have some close contacts which could be the first few rounds but gets introduced to the others in like parties or get togethers or something like that so they start off as a vague person to th mc and the readers and then they get fleshed out as the story continues

Thom

I think the special vote/skill is ok but with lots of participants might be very hard to administer what ever you think is best

Pepe

I really, really liked the series but I definitely regret my last vote since I was a loyal Olya fan all the way. It was a very immersive and addictive experience, and its all thanks to your hard work, nikki. I think you've definitely grown your community with this series. I think we can improve this series by introducing polling instead of comments as it may help in solidifying someone's decision and you may also get some rest while you're at it. Also, there won't remain the issue of patrons being unable to cast a vote in time. Secondly, it would be great if you could implement a more reasonable solution for overlapping decisions. If a girl wins both the marry and fuck poll, the solution is obvious (as with Olya), one of the others will be killed and the other can be done away with using a quick scene or something instead of moving forward. If a girl "wins" both the fuck/marry and kill votes, then she should be chosen as the winner of the fuck/marry vote, if the margin of win (fuck/marry) is greater than the margin of loss (kill).

nikkicrescent

Totally! I'll have to really think hard about how to properly implement something like that without things getting off the rails.

Felicia Jones

I did enjoy this but it seems like my notifications that something new was up came late. Once I got the notification the poll was available at the same time the results were being posted. Only other problem I had was trying to keep up with the story. Probably a combination of the weird notifications, not having time right then to read a story and just life getting in the way made following the story a little tough at times. Need to make sure I pulled down everything and go back through it with most of the material done. Might be useful to have the one graphic of all the girls without the fuck, marry kill graphics on it to reminds us of who is who. Might also recommend if you do put out more stories with the girls give a suggestion on when to read this in the larger FMK story for first time readers, if appropriate.

Felicia Jones

Only recommendation I would make in the format is slowing it down a hair next time. Maybe 3 polls a week with stories on other days. I loved FMK (even if some of the decisions were REALLY hard) and what I have read of the story is great. However I prefer to set some time aside to really enjoy the stories you write. I think I missed some of the stories in all the rush to get the polls responded to in a timely manner. Don't feel like I enjoyed the story.

nikkicrescent

Absolutely! I think 3 polls per week will be just right. That will also give me more time to complete bonus stories for the exclusive tier. 5 votes per week was crazy. I think I wrote 50,000 words in one week, which is insane. I'll slow it down a touch next time, and make sure the bigger votes happen over weekends, giving everyone time to really catch up. Also, if you aren't caught up, don't be afraid to vote just based on the character descriptions! You may end up regretting your vote later, but the gamble might also make it fun in its own right :)

Fluffy Cloud

I loved the game, and thought it was a lot of fun. i thought it was a trifle too fast paced, and it was half over before i caught on. it was very engaging though!