FMK Date Night: Chapter 4 (Patreon)
Content
DATE NIGHT
CHAPTER 4
I slipped back into the house. Erin was at the counter. Water was boiling on the stove and she was digging around, looking for the hot chocolate mix. She smiled at me and I returned the smile, even though there was a coldness tingling in my spine.
I looked out the window, at Cass’s house. The window was still glowing red. She apparently didn’t do much sleeping at night… but what was she doing?
“I’m just going to poke my head in and check on Brit,” I said.
“Okay,” Erin smiled, so I slipped away. I made sure that Brit was still sleeping, and she was. Then, I noticed the open basement door. Erin was still busy at the counter, now humming a gentle pop song. I took the opportunity to creep into the basement, down the creaky stairs. It was an unfinished basement, and it was almost entirely empty. There were a few boxes next to the large steel posts holding the old house up—but that was about it. I saw the blinking router in the corner, though there were no signs of anything falling over. In fact, there was nothing there to fall over. There was a carboard box about twenty feet from the router, but that was it. There was no blood, no signs that anyone had spent hours blacked out on that old, dusty floor. But there was an opened window, letting in a cool breeze. I walked over to that window. It looked out into the backyard.
Was Erin lying about being knocked unconscious? Was she really lying about being Brit’s babysitter? If she was lying, then who was she, and what was she up to?
I looked up, to see if there were some loose floorboards or beams—anything that could have knocked that young woman unconscious. But there was nothing.
So I went back up the stairs. Now, Erin was pouring the boiling water into mugs, still humming that pop song. “How’s your head feeling?” I asked quietly.
She looked back at me, almost looking confused for a moment before widening her eyes. “Oh, fine,” she said. “Like I said, it’s just a little headache and a cut.”
I wasn’t a doctor. I’d never gone to medical school, or even read a medical journal… but I was pretty sure that being knocked out for hours was not something common with head injuries outside of bad made-for-TV movies. In fact, I’m pretty sure a person would suffer brain damage after being knocked out for hours.
So why was she lying? I slipped out my phone. Now, it was dead. Mindy didn’t have a house phone. I wanted to politely leave, but I accepted that romp and now I felt like I had to live up to my end of the deal, even though this all seemed fishy… and somehow illegal.
“I’m just going to look around really quickly,” I said.
“For what?” she asked.
“A phone charger. I think Mindy had the same phone as me. She probably has a charger kicking around here somewhere.”
“Mindy will probably be home in a few hours. I would just not worry about it,” said Erin.
“I know,” I smiled. “But I hate being without a phone. I’m just going to poke around a little bit.”
Erin watched me closely as I left the room. Now, I was starting to get freaky vibes. Was she some sort of serial killer? Why was she so tense? Why was she watching me so closely? Why was my heart pounding so hard?
I went into Mindy’s bedroom. It was messy: bed unmade, clothes on the ground, dresser covered in makeup supplies. I looked around and spotted a phone charger plugged in behind her bed; the cord was tucked under her mattress, poking out next to her nightstand. I plugged in my phone, but the screen stayed black. I wasn’t sure if it was a dead outlet, or if my phone was just super-dead, and needed a few minutes before it would even turn on again.
“Hey, Willie?” Erin called out from the other room.
Then, before I could even react, she was in the doorway, staring at me. She was a silhouette against the light of the living room. “You coming?”
“Yeah,” I said. “I just thought I would give my phone a minute. I want to try calling Mindy again.”
She sighed. “I don’t know how to tell you any other way, Willie—she’s not going to pick up. I’ve been through this over and over. The first time she disappeared, I was nervous like you are now. But I got used to it. C’mon—come watch a movie with me. Do you want a horror movie or an action movie?”
“Maybe an action movie,” I said softly. “But I really want to make this call first. It will give me a little peace of mind.” And maybe I really wanted to call the police. I was starting to think that there was more going on here. Maybe there was nothing illegal happening, but the police could at least take a look around, and maybe they could figure out how to reach Mindy.
“Does that charger even work?” she asked, watching me paw at my phone, trying to make it turn on.
“I don’t know,” I said. “I might just swing by the neighbor’s house and borrow her phone. I know she has Mindy’s number. I’ll just be a few minutes.”
“I think you’re getting worked up over nothing,” Erin said.
“Maybe,” I smiled. “Better to be safe than sorry, right?”
There was a long and terribly awkward silence. “I guess so,” she said. “Just try to be quick.” She stared in my eyes as I brushed by her. Then she grabbed my wrist before I was too far away, sending my heart up into my throat. I spun around quickly to face her, half-expecting to get a knife to the face.
“What is it?” I asked, jaw almost trembling.
“I was just going to ask you how you’re feeling,” she said, glaring into my eyes.
“Fine. I’m fine,” I said.
“Good to go again?” she asked with a grin. And it took a moment to realize that she was talking about sex. “I promise I’ll make it feel so, so good.”
“O—Okay,” I said. “Maybe. That could be fun. I’m honestly pretty tired. It’s been a long night.” I laughed nervously. Her long eyelashes fluttered and that smile remained on her face. And now I was starting to think that I was living in a horror movie.
She watched me as I went to the door, and she kept watching me until I was gone. I rushed over to the neighbor’s house. The light was still on inside, glowing red. Once I was at the door, I could hear the thumping of her subwoofer. She was listening to loud music, so it wasn’t a surprise when she didn’t answer the door after I rang the bell. She didn’t answer the door after I knocked either.
I looked over at Mindy’s house. The windows were dark now, but there was a faint glow—the glow of the television—in the living room. I couldn’t see Erin, but I had a good feeling that she was watching me from one of those darkened windows. Then I looked back at my car. I felt my keys in my pocket. I was tempted to make a run for it. I could get into my car and get away. I would be leaving my phone behind, but I could always get a new one. That phone wasn’t worth my life…
But what if there was something terrible happening behind the scenes? What if Erin did murder Mindy? If I left, would I be leaving behind the evidence that I was there? Would the police suspect me as the murderer? Erin had all the time in the world to clean up her own tracks…
No, I was being paranoid. I was tired and getting carried away. Erin probably was the babysitter, and Cass was just mistaken. Surely this was all just a big misunderstanding.
I knocked again, this time louder, hoping Cass would hear. Again, I felt that gaze watching me from the window. I grabbed the door handle and gave it a twist. It opened. So I leaned my head in. “Hey Cass!” I called out gently. “It’s just Willie, the, uh, guy from next door—Mindy’s friend. You in here?”
But her music was loud. I didn’t want to yell over it and have Erin hear me yelling, so I slipped inside. My heart raced, but it felt like I was running out of time. I had to get to her. I had to get to a phone, and I needed to know if she was telling me the truth: was Erin really a stranger, and not the babysitter?
“Hey Cass?” I called out. I could see the red glow coming from an open doorway. I didn’t want to invade her privacy; I knew that I was probably going to shock her by appearing suddenly. I knew that she was probably going to think that I was some huge creep… But figuring out this conundrum seemed like a higher priority than respecting some stranger’s privacy. I needed to use a phone. I needed to figure out whether Cass was being genuine when she said that Erin wasn’t Brit’s babysitter—and I had to do it fast, because Erin was alone in the house with Brit now. What if she was some sort of deranged kidnapper? What if she killed Mindy and now, she was trying to steal Mindy’s daughter away for some sort of underground child sex trafficking ring?
Maybe I was just getting increasingly paranoid, but I wasn’t going to take any risks.
I stepped to the side, looking into Cass’s bedroom. Then, I froze, shocked by what I was seeing.
Cass was up on her bed, on her knees, posing in front of a camera mounted in the middle of a ring light. That nightrobe was on the floor next to the bed. Now, she was naked, unless you count the choker around her throat or the lace stockings on her legs. She was clutching her right breast with her left hand, squeezing it and moaning while she stroked her big cock with her right hand…
I had to blink a few times before looking again: she really was stroking a cock.
And she was stroking it fast, squeezing it firmly. Her tip was red and she was beating off with fury. “Oh God,” she moaned softly. She pushed her pelvis forward. The muscles in her butt clenched. She was completely unaware of my presence, and I was unable to move, unable to look away. My lips were parted, but I wasn’t breathing.
Cass was a transgender cam whore, and now she was jerking off in front of her fans. I could see her fans: little usernames filling up her laptop screen. Small hearts were popping up and floating to the top of her screen. Small ka-ching sounds were letting Cass know that she was being tipped well for her performance. And she was giving them a good show, massaging her breasts while violently pumping her cock, leaning forward to get her long shaft closer to her camera.
“I’m going to fucking come!” she gasped. She walked forward on her knees. She moaned amazingly. Then she erupted. Long streaks of cum blasted across her bedroom. The second shot was a money-shot, right on the lens of her camera. The rest soaked her rug and her bed—until she put her hand in front of her tip to catch a blast, which she rubbed all over her breasts, pleasing her fans immensely (the ka-ching sounds were now chiming off by the second).
The show was over. Cass was now panting, looking down at her erect cock, which was oozing one final drop of thick, white cream.
I backed away before I was caught, finally gathering the sensibilities I needed to not embarrass myself too much. I went all the way back to her front door and stepped back onto her front step, just as she was turning off her loud music. I carefully closed the door, waited ten seconds, and then I knocked, pretending like I hadn’t been inside of her house. There was a delay, and then I heard her call out, “Coming!”
When she answered the door, now in her satin nightrobe, I smiled. I felt my whole face turning red, and I looked down for a second to notice the bulge between her legs: a subtle bulge that was still slumping. I cleared my throat.
“What is it?” she asked.
I looked over at Mindy’s house, knowing that Erin was inside, waiting for me to return. Maybe she was even watching me. “Um, can I come in really quickly?”
“Why?” she asked.
I let myself slip by her, not feeling like having a whole pre-discussion of why it was such an urgent situation. The houses were close together; there was a chance that Erin was close enough to listen to us.
“What is it?” she asked, rushing in and blocking my view of her bedroom with her body. She was still totally oblivious to the fact I’d already been in her house. As shocking as her little show was to see, it wasn’t important. Now, there was a serious matter involving a child that needed to be figured out quickly.
“Can I use your phone?” I said. “I need to call the police.”
“What?! The police!?” she said. “Look—if this is because of the music, I can turn it down. It just helps me work, and, uh, I work nights.” She turned red all over. “I’ll turn off the music. Let’s not call the police.”
“It’s not that,” I said, shaking my head quickly. “You said that Erin wasn’t Brit’s babysitter.”
“Erin is Brit’s babysitter,” Cass said, now crossing her arms over her chest to cover her breasts.
“Oh,” I said. “You said in the yard that Erin wasn’t the babysitter.”
“No, I said that the girl with you in the backyard wasn’t the babysitter—because that wasn’t Erin. Erin lived a few houses down from here. She’s fourteen, with black hair. She’s a bit of a tomboy. That girl wasn’t Erin.”
“Then who is she?” I asked.
“I don’t know. I’ve never seen her. Who did she say she was?”
“She said she was Erin, the babysitter!” I snapped, feeling like I was starting to go crazy. A few hours earlier, I thought that I was meeting a nice girl in her mid-twenties for drinks at a bar. Now, I was all wrapped up in what was seeming more and more like a murder mystery by the minute.
“Well maybe her name is Erin, and maybe she’s also a babysitter…” Cass said. “I don’t know. Lots of people name their kids Erin, and I’m sure lots of girls named Erin go into babysitting. Maybe it’s just a coincidence. Maybe the usual Erin wasn’t available tonight.” And I will admit that my mind drifted from the matter at hand for a moment. Cass’s voice was remarkably feminine considering she wasn’t born a woman. In fact, there weren’t many hints at all aside from that bulge, which was almost totally gone now. Her shoulders were narrow and her hips were wide. She’d obviously been taking hormones—no man can naturally pull off a look like—
“What are you looking at?” she asked. I quickly looked up, feeling the blood rushing into my cheeks.
“Nothing,” I said.
“I was just trying these on,” she said nervously, looking down at her white lace stockings. “They’re part of my, uh, Halloween outfit.”
“Right,” I said, playing dumb, playing along with her little fib. “They look good on you.”
“Thanks,” she blushed.
Then I cleared my throat again. “So what are you saying? Are you saying I shouldn’t call the cops? Mindy has been missing for hours. Erin—or whatever her real name is—told me that Mindy does this sometimes. I don’t know what to believe, but it’s all weird as hell, and I’m starting to get freaked out.” I did my best not to look down at her legs, which made absolutely no sense. Only a natural woman could have long, smooth, curvy legs like she had. What kind of pill could give a dude legs like hers?
“I don’t know,” she said. “I almost called the cops after I heard that sound.”
“Right,” I said. “The sound! What did it sound like? That’s how all of this started.”
“It was like a scream—but it was really fast… but loud. Like someone started screaming and then quickly got muffled. Or maybe it was just… I don’t know… someone’s lawnmower starting up for the first time in a year. I don’t know—it happened so fast, and I was in the middle of a session—I mean, a meeting. It was a meeting with, uh, some clients—a work meeting…”
I shook my head quickly. “Look,” I said. “I know that you’re doing webcam stuff. It’s not a big deal. It’s the least of my concerns right now.”
And then her face suddenly turned dark red. “It’s how I make my living,” she said firmly, tilting her chin up slightly.
“It’s fine,” I said. “I don’t care.”
“It’s empowering,” she said. “I make my money how I want to make it, with my own hours, and I don’t have to answer to anybody.” It almost seemed like she was trying to convince me that it wasn’t embarrassing—or maybe she was trying to convince herself.
“Right. I don’t care—like I said.”
“How did you know?” she asked suddenly, narrowing her eyes and looking angry.
And now I was the one with the red face. “That’s really not important,” I said. “Brit’s with that woman right now, and—”
“—Just tell me how you knew,” she said, cutting me off. “Do I look like a whore to you?”
“No, not at all,” I said.
“Have you seen my work? Do you recognize me?” Then her eyes became wide. “Wait! Are you D-Man69? I did that private chat with you a few weeks back, didn’t I?”
“I don’t know what that means—and no.”
“Are you sure? You wanted me to put that ball in my hole and push it out, and you made me do it like six times.”
“That wasn’t me!” I said suddenly.
“Oh,” she said. “Actually, you’re right, that wasn’t you.” And now her face was white. “But you look a lot alike.” Now, her voice was soft, hardly a whimper as she was overwhelmed with humiliation.
There was a sudden silence in the room. I won’t lie: the image of her pushing some sort of golf ball into her asshole was in my mind, along with the image of her big, veiny, erect cock. I tried to push the image away, but it just kept coming back. Now, I was forgetting why I was at her house in the first place.
She cleared her throat and tried to veer the subject back on track. “So you’re worried the girl over there is a killer?” she said. “And you think she killed Mindy?”
“I don’t know,” I said. “She’s definitely up to something. She told me that she hit her head in the basement, but there’s nothing in the basement—no blood or anything, but she has this big cut on the side of her head. I just don’t know—it’s all just… spooky.”
“Are you going to go back over there?” she asked.
“I don’t know. I guess so—after I call the cops.”
“What are the cops going to do?”
“Look for Mindy. Maybe question this Erin girl, or whatever her real name is. I don’t know! Maybe I just need to go home. I shouldn’t be here anyway. This is quickly turning out the be the worst date I’ve ever gone on.”
“So it was a date,” she said.
I felt my muscles tensing up. I felt the strangest urge to take it back, worried that I somehow just blew all my chances with her. Though I wasn’t sure why I cared—especially under the circumstances. There were far bigger things happening, and she wasn’t even a biological female. “It was a blind date, basically. It lasted all of ten minutes, and there won’t be a second date.”
“You don’t like Mindy?” she asked.
“She’s not my type.”
“What’s your type?”
“Why are we talking about this right now?” I sighed and walked over to her window, looking at Mindy’s house, which was so quiet and innocent—but I knew there was a real threat inside. “So can I use your phone to call the cops or not?”
“You can,” she said. “I don’t know if this is a ‘call the cops’ kind of situation, personally, but they aren’t going to arrest you if it’s a false alarm. And, like you said, you’re not going to go on another date with Mindy, so it’s not like you have to worry about what she’s going to think about you.”
“Right,” I said. “Okay, I’ll make the call then. Mind grabbing your phone for me?”
Just then, the power went out. The inside of the house became black and Cass let out a little yelp, looking around suddenly. “Did the power just go out?” she asked.
“I guess so,” I said. “Does that happen a lot?”
“No,” she said.
“Where’s the breaker?”
“In my room,” she said.
There was a loud thump from her bedroom—the door blowing shut—and then Cass jumped into my arms, pressing her body against me and squeezing me tightly—digging her manicured fingernails into my skin.
“It was just the wind blowing your door shut,” I said. “There must be a storm rolling in.” Though I wasn’t believing my own words. It was a spooky set of coincidences.
“But my window was closed,” she said, still clinging onto me. And I will admit that I didn’t mind having her pressed against me like that. I could feel her soft breasts against me, and her hard nipples. I could feel the nice bulge of her cock, and her warm thighs. She kept holding me, now turning to look into my eyes. “I—I’m sorry,” she said suddenly.
“It’s okay. Do you want me to go in?”
“My phone’s in there, so one of us needs to.”
“I don’t mind,” I said, but I was lying. I was actually terrified to go into that room. I knew that her window was closed; I’d looked over at it multiple times throughout that night. There hadn’t been a single point that it had been opened.
“If you don’t mind,” she said. Then she bit her lip and looked away from me. “Just don’t judge me for, uh, what you see in there. It’s just work.”
“It’s fine. I don’t care about any of that.” I stepped away from her. My skin was tingling. I took a deep breath and reached for the handle. I was half-expecting Erin to lunge at me with a knife, Psycho style. I pushed the door open and braced, but the room was empty. The window was now open and the curtains were flapping in the breeze.
The walls were indeed red, and so were the bedsheets, which were still streaked with cum. I pretended not to notice—though it was harder to ignore the dildos being displayed on the little side table: sex toys of various shapes and sizes. There was even a ‘horse cock’ dildo, about the size of my arm, and almost just as thick too. I turned as red as the walls as I looked away from it.
There were vibrators, and a rack of outfits. There were leather cuffs and other pieces of bondage. There were whips and there was one toy in particular that made me gasp: a double cock, like some sort of alien dildo with two shafts, complete with two big tips. She only had one hole that I was aware of… so were they both supposed to go into the same hole?
Now, Cass was at the door behind me, clutching the doorframe and looking around. “Is it safe?” she whispered.
“There’s nothing here,” I said. I went and closed her window for her. It didn’t have a lock.
She rushed over to her nightstand and looked around. “My phone is gone!” she gasped.
“Actually?” I said.
“Oh God,” she said. “I think I left it unlocked. There are pictures on that phone that can’t—I mean… oh no, all of my contacts…”
“Are you sure that’s where you left it?”
She nodded her head. “I’m positive. That’s where I always leave it when I do shows.”
“Right,” I said.
“Someone took it. This is crazy. I’m actually freaking out right now.”
“It’s fine.” I looked out the window, at Mindy’s house. The TV was still glowing inside. “Maybe you can come next door with me and we can use Mindy’s laptop to contact the police.”
I closed my eyes and took a deep breath. Then I leaned back and planted my hand down to support myself. I was tired. It had been a long night, and there didn’t seem to be an end in sight. That night just kept going and going.
Then I realized my hand was on top of something: something long and thick and phallic. I looked down and saw that I was holding a big, black dildo. I gasped and pulled my hand away.
“It’s clean!” she said. “I haven’t used that one in days.”
“I don’t want to know. Let’s just… Let’s go get to the bottom of this—and let’s make sure Brit’s okay.”
She nodded her head. She followed me through her dark house to the front door. She stayed close to me, keeping her beautiful perfume wafting up into my nostrils. As we stepped out, she even clutched my arm and pushed herself against my body. I really didn’t mind. She had a nice, soft body.
We crossed the lawn and tiptoed up to Mindy’s front door. I pushed the door open and poked my head in. “Hey Erin?” I called out.
But there was no answer. I looked around, seeing the glowing TV screen. “Erin, you in here?” I called out.
Cass stuck to me like glue, clutching my arm, occasionally grazing me with the bulge of her cock. I don’t think she’d had a moment to slip her flaccid member back into her lacy panties since I interrupted her broadcast.
“Let’s go check on Brit,” I said, dating across the living room. Cass stuck with me, watching my back in the dark house.
I pushed open Brit’s bedroom door, and then my heart fell down into the pit of my stomach.
Brit was gone.
TO BE CONTINUED...
Files
Previews only