Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Okay I swear I'm working on the revolutions video. I've gotten like an hour of it recorded! Look at me go. But I was thinking about what's coming after & I decided I didn't want to make anything longer than 20 minutes. I needed a break. So, I wrote about Barney Gumble & what he represents to me, to Magic, & to capitalist cultural production as a whole.I hope you enjoy it, & please do leave any critiques, queries, or compliments in the comments on the doc!

Files

Magic & Barney Gumble - Why Capitalist Stories Reject Change

It's Thursday, November 19th, 1992. The Simpsons has been on TV for just over 5 years & season 4 has been showcasing some of the best episodes the show has to offer. Kamp Krusty, Homer the Heretic, & today: Mr. Plow. In the latest of his alternative employment pursuits, Homer has bought a snow-...

Comments

#ryanlyddall

First time reading one of your scripts (I didn’t read the last one as I wanted to experience it “properly”) but I’m amazed at how easily I read this in your voice. As someone who has no knowledge or interest in the simpsons I found this a really interesting analogy for the capitalist urge to squeeze every last drop of profit out of every franchise. I look forward to seeing this one! (And I’m tempted to read your previous script although I think I’ll try and wait)

3mix2yoo

I know you touched on the fact that the story is beholden to the game designers' (perceived) notion that the game has to whoosh from world to world with no time for deeper exploration, but it feels to me that the gameplay aspect does make the MtG situation different from the Barney situation. Tarkir was smoothly retransitioned to warring clans, but a big part of that is because three-colour factions are more interesting than two-, and that you simply can't make a working "Dragon Set" in a world with no baby Dragons. The Wolfir on Innistrad were simply retconned out of existence, but part of that is because double-sided Werewolf cards are a more interesting game piece than the Soulbond Wolfir card(s?). It's a lot more of a mixed bag when it comes to flavour which isn't gameplay-entangled. The Sultai and the Abzan are back, but the Sultai are basically a completely different culture, and the Abzan have dumb face armour but also don't have a program of janissaries. On Ravnica, the Simic have evolved from The Slime Gang to hybrid-makers with some syncreticism with the resurgent Merfolk culture. But on the other hand, Innistrad does fully regress flavour-wise, and from the brief glimpse of Lorwyn it looks like they have fully reinstated the day/night dichotomy (because the night 'encroaching' is meant to be the inciting incident). Basically, MtG is guilty of the same sin as the Simpsons and sometimes when there are no other pressures. But I think there is an element of the flavour being beholden to the game in a way which isn't just capitalistic which makes interesting design trump interesting story developments.

Spice8Rack

Fair critiques! I'll probably end up meditating on them on future drafts. Although, what I will say, is that lots of these narrative changes are either relegated to the story & kept off of card stock (most people's mediums for experiencing the narrative) & with the Sultai specifically,- & this is anecdotal- but they are clearly the most changed faction in new Tarkir and whilst lots of people appreciate that they're not just The Evil Ones anymore, a notable amount of responses to their new look have decried it, favouring the first rendition. I don't know if it is the case that the original was more compelling, or if it was more compelling because it was the original & this set a baseline that consumers didn't want to deviate from.