NEW SCRIPT: The Game Design Genius of Magic: the Gathering’s “Joke” Cards (Patreon)
Content
April fools used to be the unofficial holiday of whoopy cushion consumers, and poorly thought through proposal pranksters. But in this age where commodities and brands permeate our everyday life, and how social media can instantaneously connect us with information, the chances of being legitimately pranked have decreased dramatically.
I mean, back in 2008 the first time I’d encounter a prank would have been mid-way through the school day, when Ash Grimes would have scared the shit out of me with a made up piece of chemistry homework I had no memory of. Nowaday though, the moment I open Twitter at 9am on April 1st I’ll be immediately reminded it’s the day of pranks by Oreo, Toyota, and Wizards of the Coats.
As such, only the most hardcore pranksters and subtle snakes are left to achieve gotcha glory on April Fools. The day had become a viral marketing campaign free for all, with every personified brand twitter account vying for the top spot of being the most outrageous, bombastic, and clickable April Fools Prank. But, as dialectical materialism teaches us (yes I’m bringing up Marxist philosophy in the first two minutes of the video bite my ass) everything is in constant motion, in constant conflict, and constantly changing.
At some point, companies realised that this day was unique in the calendar as it was and is the one day of the year where everyone buys into the plausible deniability of anything anyone says being a joke. As such, companies could use this day as a soft pilot for outrageous products to see if there was consumer demand without going through the costly process of going through research and development.
Now, as with everything in life, the material precedes the conscious and it’s impossible to say for certain which company first stumbled upon an April fools prank product that was so well received they set about making an actual version. But certainly the most significant in my eyes has to be Pokémon Go! whose concept was first pitched to the public in this April Fools Day video.
I say all this because, for whatever bizzare cultural reason, there exists a day in the calendar where presumed silliness gives companies and people an opportunity to be genuinely experimental and outlandish with ideas. Magic the Gathering has it’s own kind of April Fools day in the form of both it’s UN sets and it’s Playtest Cards and I’d like to talk about how looking towards them can tell us about the future of this game.
[Intro theme]
Hello spicy people of the internet, I’m Spice8Rack AKA. Hegel if He Got Laid and I love me a bit of a giggle, and I adore me some experimentation.
Magic’s Un-Sets have been a feature of the game since the late 90’s. Originally designed to be boosters of which you’d include two or three of in normal drafts to spice up limited gameplay. They were originally nothing more than a gag product. However, players went wild for them, these are Magic: the Gathering consumers after all, they’ll buy $50 fetchlands bent link pringles if you offer it to them.
A second set, unhinged was soon in R&Ds hands, this time with a few coherent mechanics like Ass tribal and Half Mana. Still a joke, but still greatly welcomed as an entirely comedic step away from what was then Magic’s often serious to a fault tone. Their unplayability in every format, save for kitchen table shenannigens, gave the cards a kind of cult appeal and they became collectors’ items with foil versions of cards like Richard Garfield M.D. reaching ludicrous prices for what was, in effect, a shiny bookmark.
However, it was the near inevitable third set in the Un series which saw a qualitative shift in the product. Unstable was of course a joke set, with dice rolling making a return, spells with creature keywords, and enchantments which turned your deck into a creature. But there were very noticeable differences between this set and the previous one. For one, the set was designed to be played exclusively with itself, containing actual draft archetypes, genuine bombs in to pick in draft, a complicated Contraption mechanic that was fittingly very difficult to understand.
I’m not an idiot, the system is DESIGNED to be difficult to parse, it’s flavourful STOP MAKING FUN OF ME.
The silliness of squirrel tribal and meta effects like watermarks matter spells were intertwined with a genuine focus on good quality gameplay. I mean, there were even the kind of French vanilla creatures you’d expect from any given standard set. Yes they were all silly and had a series of alternative art, but take the silver boarder away from Beast In Show and this wouldn’t look that out of place as a particularly kooky Simic card.
And this is by no means a bad thing. Unstable is my favourite joke set because you can see the effort the designers have made to create a mechanically coherent set whilst stepping so far outside of the box that you end up in random town in Wiltshire.
[FILMED BIT: Spice, outside BOX. Day.]
“Where am I?...” [Sees Sign saying “Welcome to Box”] *Screams*
(Alt)
“Thank goodness I’m away from that Vile Box.” [Sees sign and screams]
But the thing about joke sets is that we don’t just have to view them as jokes. We can very easily, and quite rightfully, see them as portents of the future. Almost everything I’ve mentioned about Unstable so far has become a reality in subsequent tournament legal Magic cards.
Dice rolling was in Adventures in the Forgotten Realms, and expanded upon in its commander product. Super Duper Death Laser and Flame Spill are functionally the same card. Squirrel tribal was pushed as a genuine modern and commander archetype in Modern Horrizons 2. Animate Library was turned into an actually realistic magic card with Strixhaven’s Body of Research. I’d even make the argument that the whole “multiple versions of the same card with different art” we can see on cards like Beast in Show became a feature of contemporary sets with extended art planeswalkers, and that weird thing M21 did where Teferi had 16 almost entirely identical alternative arts that cost different amounts for some bizarre reason.
Ah yes, Teferi with pale blue rings should cost €14 and deep blue teferi should cost €8. This makes sense and anyone who disagrees is literally Stalin.
But much like April Fools day, these “joke” sets have become a space for trialling out truly experimental gameplay ideas, with the plausible deniability of it all just being a big gag should cards not be received well, and without the fear of it ruining a standard season, if not an entire legacy format, should it go wrong.
But it’s not just unsets which include highly experimental cards. Firstly there were the Future Sight cards, which coincidentally first use the contraption mechanic that would go onto be fleshed out exactly a decade later. Some cards printed with the future sight border, symbolic of the card’s experimental nature and it’s distinction from the rest of the set, have ended up being essential cards for a variety of decks. Street Wraith, Daybreak Coronet, Narcomeba and Tarmogoyf were all highly successful experiments in the future sight border.
But both of these venues for experimentation come with their own issues. As iconic as the future sight cards are, however, being legal to play game pieces with massively limited availability, had a negative impact, for many years after their release. The buy-in price for anyone who wanted to play a high level deck in a format like Modern, where these cards were important pieces, was extremely high. It’s taken over 10 years of reprints and meta changes for a futuresight Tarmogoyf to stabilise at around $60.
Yet, with a set like Unstable, your experimental cards will only realistically be played in combination with either other experimental cards, or actual joke cards, thus not really giving you accurate feedback on whether or not these pieces would break a normal format. Plus, as popular as Unsets are, their silver border discourages a lot of potential players from picking the product up. After all, why pay £200 for a booster box of cards you’ll not be allowed to play in any other forma- wait £200?? Jesus Christ no wonder Jeff Bezoas thanked Amazon customers for paying for his spaceflight. Magic Players alone could send this guy to the moon (and hopefully leave him there).
But there are a series of experimental Joke cards which exist in a format and which fixes both of these issues beautifully: I’m of course talking about Magic’s Playtest cards and the Mystery Boosters they came in.
For those who don’t know, mystery boosters were these amazing things that like 200 people got to play with before we all locked ourselves inside our homes for a year and a half. It was touted as a pre-packaged chaos draft, with over 1,600 cards from throughout Magic’s history that, when drafted, would produce a truly chaotic limited format.
No archetypes, no strategy, just vibes. The exact contents of the mystery boosters were also kept a secret, meaning that the 80 people who ever got their hands on them (Bastards, lucky lucky bastards) didn’t even have an idea about the card pool they were drafting from, so when someone at an event opened a booster and there was a Mana Crypt inside, everyone watching that draft discovered that Mana Crypt was in the card pool and made plans to play a Mystery Draft at Magic Fest Toronto which was happening in March of next year AHAHAHAHA HOW FOOLISH OF ME.
Within each mystery booster, however, there weren’t just random prexisting Magic cards. There were entirely new ones. Or, more specifically, wildly experimental playtest cards which walked a fine line between the kind of utter joke you may find in an Un-set [One with Death] to cards which, with a lot of reformatting, wouldn’t seem too out of place in a standard set [Louvaq, the Aberrant].
These test cards placements within a format of completely normal Magic cards not only solves the Unstable issue of experimental cards not seeing play against real cards. But it also solves the Future Sight Issue where experimental cards are immediately legal to play game pieces and become in high demand with purposefully little supply.
Looking at these kind of cards, be them ostensive jokes, or flavourful glimpses into the future, we can see some cool ideas that Magic’s designers are toying with for future black bordered sets. Growth Charm, for example, was a precursor to the Flavour Keywords used in Adventures in the Forgotten Realms, and the way Time Sidewalk creates copies of a specific spell that get shuffled into your deck isn’t too dissimilar to the effect found on Garth One Eye, who taps to cast one of a series of named spells.
Personally I’d love to see the Instant Creatures like Visitor from Planet Q explored in a hyper-arcane or art themed set. I love the pseudo counterspell effect of Transcantation and I’d love to see that kind of design space explored more. I think the Modified mechcanic on Loyvaq would be a really fun set mechanic for a plane brimming with rapid mutation, and I could absolutely see Noxious Bayou being printed in the inevitable return to New Phyrexia.
Joke cards can act as a window into the future of the game, whilst still being tangible game pieces that can make us reconsider exactly what can possibly exist within the realistic boundaries of Magic the Gathering. What are your favourite joke cards, or a card you'd love to see a "realistic" black border printing of? Let me know in the comments below, and as always stay spicy!