Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

NEXT SPICE8RACK VIDEO VOTE!

  • Innistrad 96
  • Khans 150
  • Jumpstart 51
  • Kaladesh 118
  • 2023-01-30
  • 415 votes
{'title': 'NEXT SPICE8RACK VIDEO VOTE!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Innistrad', 'votes': 96}, {'text': 'Khans', 'votes': 150}, {'text': 'Jumpstart', 'votes': 51}, {'text': 'Kaladesh', 'votes': 118}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 1, 30, 16, 21, 14, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 415}

Content

Because Mill vs Discard is taking an age to produce (I blame my staff, lazy shirker) and will most likely be out mid-February I wanted to give you all an opportunity to still interact with me and the channel. You see, I have a lot of enthusiasm for a number of topics and I'd love your help in narrowing down which one folks are most enthusiastic to see next. Thus, a poll! Ideas:

- The decline of Innistrad- The desolation of Khans/Dragons of Tarkir- The brilliance of Jumpstart- The "revolution" of Kaladesh & ConspiracyI won't bind myself to the result (if only because I may start to work on the project and realise it'll take far too long/I don't have enough to say) but I will certainly aim to make the winner of this poll my next project :D I hope this sates your appitite for Spice8Rack. Now I will disappear back into the Content Mines. Ta ra for now!

Comments

Juno Auer-Watson

Khans *please*!!! I need someone way smarter then me to prove I am correct in my hatred of Sarkhan.

Spice8Rack

Oh don't worry, I'd validate the SHIT outta that <3

Lynneiah

"Which one of these four?" Yes

Kevin Mitchell Reese

I assume we're talking about the first Jumpstart and not the watered-down successors? (Though there was that more recent one that was supposedly good but which I managed never to see/buy!)

FanOfMostEverything

Having played some, I can confirm that Jumpstart 2022 is the only other Jumpstart product worthy of the name.

StarPupil

I wasn't around for Kaladesh, so that would be most interesting from an "analyzing story" perspective, while Jumpstart seems most interesting from an actual game play perspective.

Helena Real

Innistrad, please! It's my favorite plane and I can't help but feel it has gone down so much since it's OG incarnation. The last double visit (MID & VOW) were just heartbreaking. Thanks a lot!

Sean

Jumpstart has a monkey prince with bananas

Spice8Rack

Oh yeah fully, I'd definitely talk about the other products with jumpstart branding but BOY I'd be wry!

Spice8Rack

It does! I'm adding an additional 1% onto it's voting result just for that

Morbidpanda

You know who REALLY needs attention and spotlight? Chandra. She's barely,been focused on at all by WOTC! /s Genuinely though, I think Kaladesh is just far more thematically interesting than the other two, particularly innistrad. Innistrad's setting is fun, but there's only so many times you can say "and then s*** got worse again and a lot more people died" before it gets a bit repetitive

Sean

Hooray! 💖

The Jelly Bean Warlock

Honestly, I like your positive vids, so I'd like you to do the jumpstart one.

Artos Kincaid

I had to join in on wanting the Innistrad takedown. The first version was one of the most amazing Magic sets ever printed, and it has gone massively downhill on every revisit.

GrantZeebs

I like the sounds of all four of these, but my vote is towards Jumpstart, not because it looks to be a less thematic/lore talk, but for the mechanics I loved from jumpstart. I understood enough that the fun of MtG wasn't set in only the card game during play, but to the card game at build and and re-build. and Jumpstart was one of the few sets I felt that was more direct to the player about the build before the game, rather than encouraging that through social draft or from theme dictating mechanics

ZadokShark

I'd love to see a breakdown of Khans vs Dragons of Tarkir. I started playing Magic as a teenager during BfZ, right after Khans block, so I heard a lot about the brilliance of Khans compared to Dragons from my local community, but I didn't really get it at the time, especially because seeing all the awesome dragons really helped push me to get into the game. Who doesn't like dragons, right? Now as a grown adult it would be really cool to examine why Khans succeeded so well compared to Dragons, mechanically and from a story perspective too; not to mention getting Spice's hopes for what a return to Tarkir might look like. (Tarkir's a 4 on the Rabiah Scale after all!)

Samuel Kohner

The decline of Innistrad and even the Dragons of Tarkir topics bring up mythoughts on Magic Planes/sets in recent years. Starting from Innistrad (though really Kamigawa years earlier) the planes have made in MTG have had 1 inspiration that the whole plane is hyper focused on to the detriment of creativity and making the planes feeling original. this is best scene in planes that are just near carbon copies of Mythologies (Theros, Amonkhet, and Kaldheim) to Innistrad which is just spooky gothic setting. Just makes me long for the days of creative world building and fleshing out of worlds beyond one or two concepts, like the history rich world of Dominaria, the complex (and more than 5 bloody factions) guild filled world of Ravnica, or the wonder of Lorwyn/Shadowmoor.

Samuel Kohner

Would also be good to examine the "problems" of having time travel go back and retcon a ton of shit. *cough*makingBolasthesmalleroftwinsthereforgivinghimacomplexwhenhewasalreadyanamazingvillain*cough*

Samuel Kohner

Am I one of the few people who looks at even the first Innistrad block and just feels like most of the cards art/aesthetic/story/factions/world build all just kind of blends together and doesn't stand out? I feel like the MTG switch to more hyper "realistic" looking art contributed to that. Not many different artists going outside the mold in card art these days. XD

Nos4ay2

I like werewolves and Innistard sets give me them so I like the sets cause I'm a basic bitch but I'd def be interested in hearing how it's declined from someone who not biased cause of fuzzy monsters. (I've also only gotten into magic in the last year or so, maybe I just don't have the burnout from them...)

Mathias Oberson

Would just love a Khans video, mainly because I skipped this whole block entirely and it looks like I missed a lot. (Well... I also missed Kaladesh and Conspiracy, but... anyway)

Jack F

I think Khans has the most nuance and I think it's the one i've seen people talk about the least, so i'd love to hear a Spice Dive about it. Innistrad's flanderization is pretty self-explanatory, and I feel like the professor has (lovingly) talked my ear off about the positives of jumpstart-- but khans seems like the uncharted territory of the lot!

ZadokShark

Ooh that would be interesting! I hadn't even considered that the fact it's a time travel story would create weird retcons and inconsistencies; for instant I wasn't even aware of the point you raised about Bolas!