Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I honesly have no idea if I'll do anything with this, but this has been on my mind since March of the Machine and a bunch of extra frustrations I have with the idea of "unlikely allies" as both a media trope and ideal of political organising kinda flowed out into this. let me know if this has legs! It'd be a short video if I did make it!

Files

The liberal fable of the unlikely teamup

The liberal fable of the unlikely teamup "If only we could set aside our differences," may as well be the warcry of the liberal pseudo-revolutionary. You see it all the time in both calls to political action, and in entertainment media. If only we could unite despite race, gender, or culture di...

Comments

George Lee

Definitely had legs; feet even. The perfect amount of cynicism

Paula G.

I usually prefer your longer videos but I think this script being short and to the gut makes it very brilliant. 10/10 gave me chills. I expect some of the general public might have trouble understanding how this video is about Magic the Gathering but honestly I don't think that matters much.

Kaye Sandham

Really striking concept! I think it’s got potential!

Lars Flyger

This whole trope seems to be a really common thing in the sort of "crisis events" that DC Comics pioneered, it's a fantastic way to get a bunch of characters together for a really big spectacle but it does sorta inherently end up cheapening the conflicts that existed within the setting prior to said spectacle. Part of the reason why I disliked War of the Spark so much (and why it made me more-or-less permanently lose interest in Magic's story) is that it presented some grand unified vision of Ravnica when MtG spent close to a decade establishing the fact that all of the guilds* fucking suck and are constantly at each other's throats. Overall, great essay. The only real complaint I have is that I disagree with how it uses the word "liberal" but I think that's more of a difference in our overall political perspectives than anything. *Except the Izzet because they're funny

Squidpeanut

Seems good but I see some issue with how the script compares fictional narratives and real life events. It treats the two as if they are parallel when in fact the forces acting upon a work of fiction and a real world event are very different. Maybe structure it so it goes, people have a narrative craving for unlikely team ups, this craving bleeds into them desiring similar narratives in real life regardless of how unrealistic or foolish they might be, even when you get things that look like unlikely team ups in real life they can easily be ephemeral or exaggerated. In fact not even fiction is willing to commit to this kind of a resolution, how often does an unlikely alliance last in any meaningful way. What’s important is to recognize how desires can turn to cravings and create myths that hold more power over us then they should (or something like that) Hope what I’m suggesting makes sense

Jonathan Horn

This is precisely the kind of content that I love you for. Be it long-form or not. Our love of magic brings us here, yes, yes, but what it makes you think of and your commitment to justice always seem to take you further than your peers...of course I tend to agree with you even if i didn't know I would at the outset...maybe because you make great arguments...but yes....make as many videos as you possibly fuckin can...This one definitely has legs.