Informed Consent - your favorite version (Patreon)

Having published two different versions of the caption, I'd love to get your feedback on which version of the story you prefer. I've outlined both options and am trying to decide between them.

Here's version 1, and version 2 for comparison. Which do you like better? I'll only be running this poll this week so I can start writing, so please respond quickly if you have an opinion. Results will be weighted based on your subscription tier.