Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 71: The Light, the Map, and the Dreams

Each zone of Hallownest was an inversion of the previous one. Crossroads was gray. Greenpath was green. Fungal Wastes was purple. City of Tears was blue and wet. Crystal Peak was white and blinding.

It was the most luminous zone in the game in a game built on darkness. The engine that breathed, designed to create spaces where light was scarce and darkness was the natural state, had to do the opposite: create a space where there was too much light, where the excess of visibility was as disorienting as the lack of visibility in Deepnest.

George explained the concept to Marcus with a sentence:

"I want a zone where the light is the enemy."

Marcus looked at him over the owl glasses.

"Light can't be an enemy. Light reveals. Enemies hide."

"Exactly. The light of Crystal Peak reveals so much that the player can't process what he sees. The walls glow. The crystals refract the Knight's light and multiply it. Every surface reflects. The player enters Crystal Peak after hours in the darkness and suddenly he can see everything and that's worse than seeing nothing, because his brain got used to the darkness and the light overwhelms him."

Marcus painted the Crystal Peak tiles with a palette of whites, silvers and pale light blues. The walls were rock covered in hexagonal crystals that Sam textured with surfaces that caught the engine's light and returned it amplified. In the other zones, the tiles absorbed the light of the Knight's halo: the dark colors lit up partially and the darkness persisted at the edges. In Crystal Peak, the tiles reflected the light: the crystals had a reflectivity value George implemented as a multiplier that added light to the lighting map instead of subtracting it. Where the Knight walked, the nearby crystals glowed with more intensity than the original source, creating secondary halos that overlapped the main halo and that filled the screen with a clarity that was beautiful and aggressive at the same time.

And when the Knight got too close to a large crystal, a flash. Two frames of pure white that covered the whole screen, simulating the glare of looking directly at an intense light source. The flash caused no damage but did cause disorientation: during the two frames of white, the player lost the visual reference of his position, and the enemies that were nearby could attack in that window of blindness.

The crystals that blinded were positioned on the most direct routes of each room. The player who ran in a straight line got dazzled. The one who took lateral routes, longer but away from the large crystals, advanced without blindness. Crystal Peak taught that the most obvious route wasn't always the best, that sometimes the longer path was the safer one.

*

Lena composed the Crystal Peak theme with instruments that resonated.

Tubular bells recorded in a Mission church that the priest let her use one Tuesday morning in exchange for the promise that the music would not be "satanic," a promise Lena made with the seriousness of someone who has composed the soundtrack of a game about a child who flees his mother because God told her to kill him. A glockenspiel Lena found in a toy store and that she recorded by striking the keys with a metal hammer covered in felt to soften the attack. And a reverb effect George hadn't heard before: Lena recorded the bells and the glockenspiel in the bathroom of her apartment, the smallest and most reflective space she had, and the result was a short, bright echo that sounded like the sound bouncing off crystal surfaces.

The Crystal Peak theme was the highest-pitched in the game. Where Dirtmouth was low and Greenpath was mid and City of Tears was resonant, Crystal Peak was an auditory flash: high notes that shone and faded, echoes that overlapped creating accidental harmonies, and beneath it all a low drone Lena generated with the sustain pedal of the piano held for thirty seconds, a fundamental hum that anchored the high notes to the ground like a subterranean current beneath the shining surface.

*

The enemies of Crystal Peak were workers, not natural insects.

Crystal Hunters were mining robots that had kept functioning after their operators disappeared. They fired beams of concentrated crystal in a straight line, with a warning laser that appeared 8 frames before the real shot. The player who saw the laser could dash out of the line of fire. The one who didn't see it because he was blinded by a nearby crystal took the impact without warning.

Husk Miners were dead insects that kept picking at rock with the inertia of their last act. Marcus drew them with miner's picks and broken helmets, the dim eyes of the same infected orange as the Husk Citizens of City of Tears. They attacked when the Knight approached, swinging the picks with the slowness of something that moves by habit instead of by will. They were Crystal Peak's equivalents of the city's Citizens: sad, mechanical, reduced to a single function.

Crystal Crawlers were the mechanical innovation of the zone: insects covered in crystal armor that couldn't be damaged by the nail's frontal attack. The crystal of their shell reflected the hit and pushed the Knight back with an increased double knockback. The only way to kill them was the nail bounce: attacking from above broke the dorsal crystal, which was thinner than the frontal one, and exposed the vulnerable body beneath. Three consecutive nail bounces to kill a Crystal Crawler. It was the most tedious enemy in the game and the one that most forced the player to master a specific mechanic.

*

In November, George implemented the map system.

In Castlevania, the map revealed itself automatically. The player entered a room and the room appeared on the map, colored, catalogued, permanent. It was a generous system that gave the player the security of always knowing where he had been and how much was left to explore.

In Hollow Knight, the map was a privilege that was bought.

George designed an NPC named Cornifer: an obsessive cartographer who roamed Hallownest drawing maps of each zone. The player found Cornifer somewhere in each zone, always in a non-obvious corner, and bought the map of that zone for a price in coins. Without the map, the player explored blind: no reference, no orientation, no knowing whether the corridor on the left led to the boss or to a dead end.

Cornifer wasn't easy to find. But he had a trait that gave him away: he hummed. A melody Lena composed as an eight-bar loop, cheerful and incongruous with the melancholy of the rest of the game, that sounded louder the closer the player was. The humming was the clue: if the player heard the melody, Cornifer was near. If he didn't hear it, he was far or didn't exist in that zone.

George implemented the humming with a positional audio system: the volume of the loop was calculated according to the distance between the Knight and Cornifer's position, with a maximum range of 200 pixels. At 200 pixels, the humming was barely audible. At 50, it was clear. At 0, the player was in front of Cornifer and could buy the map.

The system rewarded the players who explored with attention, who listened to the sounds of the world, who treated audio as information instead of as background. A player with headphones who paid attention to the humming found Cornifer faster. A player without headphones or who played with the television at low volume might take longer or never find him.

Tomás tested the system and reported something George didn't expect: the players grew fond of Cornifer. The NPC was a round insect with glasses, surrounded by papers and ink, sitting in the most inhospitable places of Hallownest drawing maps with the concentration of someone who has found his purpose. In a world of death and decay, Cornifer was cheerfully productive. His humming was the only happy sound in the game. The players sought him out not only for the map but for the company: finding Cornifer in Deepnest or in Crystal Peak was finding a friend in a hostile place.

Marcus drew Cornifer with the same philosophy he had applied to all the NPCs of HK: big eyes, expressive body, personality communicated by the silhouette. Cornifer leaned over his papers with the curved posture of a scholar, the pen moving with a 6-frame animation Priya designed, and the glasses reflecting the Knight's light when he approached, as if Cornifer's glasses were looking at the player with the curiosity of a cartographer who sees a traveler and thinks: where do you come from and how far do you intend to go?

*

The most controversial decision of the map system was what happened before buying the map: nothing.

Without a map, the player had no reference at all. There was no mini-map in the HUD. There was no compass. There was no direction indicator. The player entered a new zone and had to orient himself by memory, by the visual landmarks Marcus and Sam had placed in each zone, by the intuition that the corridor on the left looked more important than the one on the right because the tiles were more elaborate.

Elena was the first to question the decision.

"George, there are players who are going to get lost. Completely. They're going to walk in circles for twenty minutes without finding Cornifer and they're going to get frustrated."

"Yes."

"And that's what you want?"

"I want them to get lost. Getting lost is part of the experience. Hallownest is a world that wasn't designed for the player. It has no signage. It has no tour guides. It has a crazy cartographer who hums in a corner and who sells you information in exchange for coins. If the player wants to orient himself, he has to earn it. And if he gets lost before earning it, he discovers things he wouldn't have discovered if he'd had the map from the beginning."

"Discovers what?"

"The world. Without a map, the player looks at the world. With a map, he looks at the map. I want him to look at the world first."

Elena thought about it. Then she nodded with the reluctance of a designer who understands the argument but who knows the forums are going to be full of players complaining that they got lost.

"The forums are going to hate you for this," Elena said.

"The forums hate me for everything. Then they love it. It's the cycle."

*

In December, George built the smallest and most important zone of Hallownest.

Resting Grounds was a cemetery. Five rooms connected by narrow corridors, with tombs in the walls, gravestones on the ground, and a stillness that was different from the stillness of Dirtmouth. Dirtmouth was the silence of an abandoned town. Resting Grounds was the silence of a place where people came to rest and where the rest was permanent.

Marcus painted the tiles with the most sober palette in the game: neutral grays without the blue of City of Tears or the green of Greenpath. Simple stone, without ornaments, without vegetation, without bioluminescence. The only light sources were candles someone had lit beside the tombs and that kept burning with the same persistence as the lanterns of the city. Sam painted the background as a black void with no depth: there was no horizon in Resting Grounds. Just darkness behind the tombs, as if the cemetery existed at the edge of nothingness.

For Resting Grounds, Lena composed a silence. A silence with texture: the sound of air that doesn't move, recorded in an empty room of her apartment at four in the morning with the window closed and the traffic stopped. It was a barely perceptible room tone that filled the auditory space with the presence of absence, as if the cemetery were holding its breath.

*

In the center of Resting Grounds, the Knight found the Dream Nail.

George designed the Dream Nail as the game's narrative tool. A tool to read the thoughts of the dead, that could also be used as a combat weapon.

Mechanically, the Dream Nail was simple. The player approached a sleeping NPC, a corpse, or a tomb, and pressed the Dream Nail button. A 30-frame animation showed the Knight extending a translucent weapon and touching the target with it. And on the screen a text appeared: the last thought of the being touched.

The texts were short. Never more than two lines. Fragments of consciousness George wrote in the green notebook for every NPC and every corpse in the game:

A Husk Sentry in City of Tears: "My post... I must not abandon my post..."

A Husk Citizen: "Where is everyone? Why am I alone?"

A Mosskin in Greenpath: "The light... the light calls me... I must not follow it..."

A tomb in Resting Grounds: "I will return when the bells ring. The bells have not rung."

Each text revealed a fragment of the story of Hallownest without telling it directly. The Sentry stayed at his post because the infection had frozen him in his last function. The Citizen searched for the others because the infection had erased his memory of the evacuation. The Mosskin resisted the call of the Radiance. And the dead one in the tomb waited for an event that was never going to happen.

The Dream Nail turned every dead enemy and every sleeping NPC into a source of lore. The player who wanted to understand Hallownest could roam the whole world using the Dream Nail on every being he found, collecting fragments that assembled like a puzzle. The player who didn't care about the lore could ignore the Dream Nail completely and use it only to access the Dream Bosses, which were harder versions of defeated bosses.

George wrote more than two hundred Dream Nail texts in the green notebook. Each one two lines or less. Each one with a different voice: the Sentry spoke with the rigidity of a soldier, the Citizen with the confusion of a civilian, the Mosskin with the resistance of a warrior, the dead one with the patience of someone who is no longer in a hurry.

It was the hardest writing George had done for a game. Not because the texts were complicated but because they had to communicate a whole life in two lines. Each text was the last thought of a being. The distillation of an existence into a sentence. And each sentence had to be specific enough to reveal something about the character and ambiguous enough for the player to imagine the rest.

*

Marcus drew the tombs of Resting Grounds with more care than any other tile in the game.

Because they were personal, more than because of technical complexity.

Each tomb had a different shape. Some were vertical gravestones with inscriptions the player couldn't read because they were in a language that didn't exist. Others were stone sarcophagi with sealed lids. Others were mounds of earth with a withered flower on top. Marcus designed thirty-two different tombs for five rooms, which meant that no tomb repeated. Each one was individual. Each one was the tomb of someone specific.

"That's a lot of tombs for five rooms," George said when he saw the sprites.

"It's few tombs for a kingdom," Marcus said.

George didn't respond because Marcus was right. Hallownest had had thousands of inhabitants. Resting Grounds had only thirty-two tombs. The cemetery was incomplete. Most of Hallownest's dead had no tomb. They had died in the streets, in the caves, in their homes, and no one had buried them. The thirty-two tombs of Resting Grounds were the fortunate ones: the ones someone remembered enough to give them a place to rest.

Marcus had thought about this without George telling him. He had thought about it because he was an artist who understood that every sprite communicated something and that thirty-two tombs in a cemetery communicated not only the presence of the dead but the absence of all those who weren't there.

*

By the end of December 2002, George had seven complete zones: Dirtmouth, Forgotten Crossroads, Greenpath, Fungal Wastes with the Mantis Village, City of Tears, Crystal Peak, and Resting Grounds. Almost half of Hallownest.

The team went off on Christmas vacation with the satisfaction of a productive year. Claire presented the closing numbers: the sales of Castlevania and Isaac had exceeded the projections by 12%, which meant that the year with no launch had generated more than expected. The 2003 budget was secured. The hires of Elena, Ryan and Sam had been the right ones. The office needed more space but Claire already had three options to move into in February.

George had lunch with his parents on December 25. Margaret made turkey. Richard helped her this time and the result was less dry than the year before, which Richard celebrated as if he had won a championship. Lena came with a bottle of rakija her mother had sent her from Sarajevo and that Richard tried with the approval of a veteran: "Strong but honest. Like last year."

Claire brought David. David brought wine. Margaret handed out the twelve grapes at midnight on December 31, even though New Year's was a week away, because Margaret had decided that the grapes were for Christmas as well as New Year's Eve and no one argued.

George looked at his family gathered at Oakland table. Lena sitting between Claire and Margaret, eating turkey with the voracity of someone who weighs less than she should. Richard with the new shirt he still couldn't fasten on his own. David nodding at everything. And Claire, who looked at George with an expression that said: another year. Another half-made game. Another full table. We're all right.

They were all right. Seven zones of fifteen. Less than half the game but more than half the soul. City of Tears existed. The Dream Nail worked. Cornifer hummed. And somewhere in Hallownest, behind the door the Mantis guarded, Deepnest waited.

George ate turkey. He set Deepnest aside and thought about his father's hands cutting the meat with the precision of a mechanic, about Lena's voice arguing rakija recipes with Richard, about Claire explaining to David what a Charm was without David understanding. He thought about eighteen people who were going to come back in January to build the rest of a subterranean world. And he thought, without saying it, that Marcus's thirty-two tombs were thirty-two reminders that what you have doesn't last forever and that every Christmas with the people you love is one tomb fewer that someone will have to draw.

End of Chapter 71

Comments

No comments found for this post.