CHAPTER 73: The Talk of the Invisible Player (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 73: The Talk of the Invisible Player
George received the invitation to the GDC keynote the first Monday of March 2003, in an email whose subject line was so formal it looked like a misdirected message.
The Game Developers Conference was held that year at the Moscone Center West, a ten-minute walk from the new Townsend Street office NGS had moved into that same month. The organization wanted George to take the main keynote slot on Thursday: West hall, four thousand seats, thirty minutes on stage, internal broadcast to the screens of the adjacent halls for those who couldn't get in. The keynote, above any panel or roundtable.
George read the email three times and closed it without replying.
That same afternoon Marcus came by his office with the Greenpath notebook under his arm. He saw George's face and knew, without anyone having said anything, that something had happened.
"They invited you to the GDC."
"To the keynote."
Marcus sat on the edge of the desk. He looked at the dark screen. He looked at George.
"You have to do it."
That night Claire came by Townsend Street to review a Sony invoice and found out about the email by accident. She didn't argue. She didn't make a case. She just said, with the calm of someone who had already decided for both of them: "you need to do it."
George replied to the email on Tuesday morning.
*
He spent the next two weeks writing.
Text, before slides. George wrote his talks the way he had written the marbled notebook six years earlier: by hand, in a new notebook he had bought at the stationery shop on Mission Street because he didn't want to use any of the game notebooks for this. The notebook had no title. George opened it every night after dinner, sat at the kitchen table of the apartment he shared with Lena, and wrote until the idea or the ink ran out.
He found the title on the fourth night.
Designing for the player you don't see.
The thesis was simple and, as he wrote it, George realized it was something he had been thinking for years without having said out loud: the player who finishes your game is not the audience of the game. The player is the actor. The audience is the people who watch the player finish. The brother who looks over the shoulder. The girlfriend who listens from the couch. The friend who hears the story over the phone. The girl who gets an envelope with letters from a dragon because her programmer uncle decided the world needed a little more magic.
George couldn't design for the player. The player was invisible: he was in his living room, in his bedroom, in a room George would never see, with a controller George would never touch. The only thing George could do was design for the people around the player. For the ones who would see the player cry in City of Tears and understand that something important was happening even if they didn't know what. For the ones who would hear Lena's piano from the kitchen and ask what that game was.
That was what he was going to say on stage. He had always known it. He just hadn't found the words until that night.
*
Marcus was his audience during the fourteen days of rehearsal.
They did it in the big conference room of Townsend Street after the rest of the team left. George stood at the far end, with a pointer in one hand and the notebook in the other, and Marcus sat in a chair twelve meters away, which was roughly the distance he was going to have to the nearest audience at the Moscone, and listened. Sometimes he took notes. Sometimes he said nothing. Once, at the end of the fourth rehearsal, he asked George if he was sure he wanted to mention Hannah.
Hannah was the girl from Madison, Wisconsin, who in 1999 had written to NGS asking that the dragon of the castle send her a letter. Claire had written the letter. George had signed it. Hannah had replied with a second letter addressed to the dragon. The correspondence had lasted two years and no one in the video game industry knew that story.
"Yes," George said. "Hannah is the whole point."
Marcus nodded.
*
On Thursday, March 6, at a quarter to nine in the morning, George was backstage in the West hall with his hands sweating.
The slides were minimalist. A technical assistant had compiled them from the notes George had sent him on Monday: black backgrounds, white text in a single typeface, one image for every five slides. There were no NGS logos. There were no screenshots of Castlevania or Isaac. George wanted the talk to live in his words, not in the visual nostalgia of someone who had already played his games.
He looked at the clock. He looked at his hands. He thought of Lena, who was in SF at that very moment having a café con leche in her Hayes Valley apartment, not knowing that George was staring at his fingers in a dark room with his breathing fast. He thought of Marcus, who was going to be in the front row, second seat from the center aisle, because Marcus had arrived at seven thirty in the morning to make sure of the spot.
A voice over the intercom. Thirty seconds.
George breathed. He let go of the notebook. He put it in the inside pocket of his jacket. He went up on stage.
*
He spoke for thirty-one minutes.
He started with Marcus. With the story of the artist who had come to NGS drawing with his left hand because he wanted his lines to look childlike, and who now painted watercolors of leaves that swayed in a wind that didn't exist. The audience laughed in the right places. George felt himself float.
He talked about Lena. About the composer from Sarajevo who had sent an MP3 in 2001 and who now made the rain of City of Tears sound from an upright piano in San Francisco. He mentioned September 11 without naming it, with the ellipsis he used whenever the memory stung where it shouldn't: "a week that changed everything and that taught us that music was the only thing holding time together."
And he talked about Hannah. About the letters. About the dragon that didn't exist but that wrote. About how Claire, his sister, had kept that correspondence going for two years because a girl from Madison deserved for the dragon to answer her.
"The player," George said at the end, "is invisible. I'm never going to see Hannah play Castlevania. I'm never going to know what her face looked like when she defeated the Dragon Lord. But I do know what she wrote to the dragon. And that, that letter, is what a game can produce when it's designed for someone who isn't thinking about themselves. The audience that matters is the one that fits around an envelope that arrives in the mail. Design for it."
There was a second of silence.
Then the room rose to its feet.
*
George went back backstage with his pulse in his ears. An assistant handed him a bottle of water. Tim Schafer, who had been in the front row on the left, hugged him with the cordial awkwardness of a big guy who doesn't hug strangers but who that morning had decided to make an exception.
Greg Costikyan came over in the backstage corridor and told him, with the calm of an academic, that that talk was going to be in bibliographies for ten years. Will Wright wasn't in the room because he had a commitment in Walnut Creek, but the next day he sent an email with three pages of notes that began with the sentence: "we need to talk about the invisible player as a category of design, not as an anecdote."
The transcript was posted to Gamasutra that same afternoon. By the following Monday, two professors, one from Carnegie Mellon and the other from USC, wrote to Claire asking if they could include it in the syllabus of their design courses. Claire said yes to both without consulting anyone.
*
George took a taxi back to Townsend Street around two in the afternoon.
The driver was an older man who listened to KCBS and who didn't ask him anything. George asked him to take Folsom to avoid the SoMa traffic. He looked out the window at the streets he had, in another life, walked every morning going to an office that didn't exist yet, and he saw a new version of the city: telephone poles with GDC posters, people with lanyards hanging from their necks, the Moscone emptying out toward the bars of Howard Street.
He had the notebook in his pocket. He took it out. He leafed through it to the title page.
Designing for the player you don't see.
And he thought, with the strange calm of someone who has just heard himself say things he hadn't fully thought: ‘what did I tell them that I don't know myself yet.’
He didn't have the answer. He only had the suspicion that he had spoken to himself for half an hour, with four thousand people listening over his shoulder, and that at some point in the next few years he was going to understand what he had said.
The taxi stopped at Townsend. George paid with a large bill and told the man to keep the change. He climbed the stairs of the new office, still smelling of paint, and found Marcus waiting for him at his desk with two cups of coffee and the tired smile of someone who has spent thirty-one minutes holding his breath for his friend.
"How did it go?" Marcus asked.
"Good," George said. "I think."
Marcus passed him the cup. They stayed silent. Outside it was starting to rain, the light March rain that in San Francisco gives no warning and that doesn't last. The new office had skylights. The drops sounded on the roof like soft keys.
George thought of Hannah, of Madison, of a girl who was no longer a girl but who probably still kept the dragon's letters in some drawer in her house, and he sat down to drink Marcus's coffee without saying anything more.
End of Chapter 73