CHAPTER 84: Six Years and Change (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 84: Six Years and Change
Edge magazine published the October 2004 issue with a twenty-page article titled "NGS at 6 years."
It was a critical retrospective signed only "Edge," as was the custom of the British magazine, and it was structured as an analysis of each of NGS's three games read as a sequence and as a system. It wasn't an interview or a profile. It was serious criticism with Edge's typical severity: that tone that managed to praise and challenge in the same sentence and that for small studios was at once a consecration and an exam.
George bought the magazine at the Castro Street newsstand one Saturday afternoon, put it in his backpack without reading it, and took it home.
*
He read it on Sunday on the couch.
It was October. Hayes Valley was in one of those warm autumn weekends in SF when the fog stays in the west and the sun comes through the east windows as if it were May. Lena was at the piano transcribing an idea she had noted down in the early morning. George sat on the couch with the magazine, with a coffee and a blanket over his legs because they hadn't turned on the heating yet.
The article identified a pattern.
Three games. Three reviews. One formula.
The harshest paragraph of the article appeared on page sixteen:
"NGS is in danger of becoming its own cliché. Three games in a row with the same creative formula: identify the familiar and redefine it. This stance has worked three times, but the curve of diminishing returns exists in genre criticism too. For NGS's fourth project not to be a Hollow Knight 2 disguised as something new, the studio has to abandon the critical position and assume the affirmative position. To avoid the cliché, NGS needs to make something that criticizes nothing. Something affirmative."
*
That night he had dinner with Lena in the kitchen of the apartment.
Lena, who had read the article over George's shoulder midafternoon, didn't comment on anything until they sat down at the table. Then, cutting a piece of bread, she said:
"They're right."
"In what part?"
"The part about the cliché."
George nodded. He didn't argue. When Lena said "they're right" about something of NGS, she was usually correct: her criteria were those of someone who listened to the studio from outside, without being committed to its internal mythology.
"What would you say?" George asked.
Lena thought about it. She chewed. She swallowed.
"I'd say you no longer need to prove you're clever. You proved you're clever in Castlevania. That you're rigorous in Isaac. That you're sensitive in Hollow Knight. The next one has to be something you don't have to prove. Something you just build."
George stayed looking at her. Then he kept eating.
*
On Monday morning George put the magazine in the center of the table of the big room of Townsend Street.
It was a round table, of wood, that Marcus had chosen when they moved to Townsend because he had seen it at a flea market in Berkeley and because he thought round tables forced meetings to have less hierarchy. It had eleven chairs around it. That morning six sat down: George, Marcus, Claire, Daniel, Lena, and Priya, who had joined the meeting because she knew Marcus was going to need someone beside him afterward.
Marcus read the magazine first. He read it all in silence for forty minutes. When he finished he closed it, set it on the table, and said: "it's fair."
Claire picked it up next. She turned the pages faster, stopping at the paragraphs George had underlined. When she finished, she said: "they're right."
Daniel picked it up third. He read it without underlining anything. When he finished, he said: "they're not right."
George looked at him.
"Why not?"
"Because the criticism of a genre isn't a cliché if each time it criticizes something different. Castlevania criticizes one thing, Isaac another, Hollow Knight another. The formula isn't in criticizing. It's in the honesty with which each game faces a concrete question. If the fourth question is new, the fourth game is new, even if the method is the same."
Lena, from the other end of the table: "but the method is what wears out. A new question with an old method feels old."
Daniel nodded. He didn't argue. It was one of those arguments he found hard to admit but that he admitted when he heard them.
Priya, without having opened the magazine, said: "what matters isn't whether the reviewer is right. What matters is whether you believe it."
*
The meeting lasted another two hours.
George posed a direct question: could the fourth game really be different?
Daniel answered first: "it has to be 3D."
Marcus, nodding: "it has to be a place, not a sequence."
Lena: "it has to sound like a city, not a castle."
Claire: "it has to be sellable on console and PC without compromises. If we go 3D we need the publishers of both."
Each one had said a sentence. Each sentence was a constraint and at the same time an invitation. George wrote them down on a loose sheet. He looked at them. He folded it. He put it away.
*
Before leaving the office that afternoon, George went up to the room where the notebooks were.
Marbled: Castlevania. Blue: Isaac. Green: Hollow Knight. Three closed volumes on a wooden shelf against the wall, each with its finished world inside and with the thickness of the corresponding effort.
He took out the new notebook, the black one, which he had bought two months earlier at the Castro stationery shop and that had been empty until then. He opened it to the first page. He took a marker from his pocket. And he wrote, in the small handwriting he used when he wrote for himself:
No more criticism of the genre. This time we create one.
He closed the notebook. He put it next to the green one on the shelf.
He went down to the studio and told Marcus he was leaving early.
*
The page stayed alone with that sentence for three months.
George wrote nothing more in the black notebook until January of the following year. Not a sketch. Not a diagram. Not a mechanics note. The sentence rested alone on the first page like a statement the rest of the project wasn't ready to answer yet.
Marcus came by the room once a day and looked at the closed notebook without opening it. Daniel asked twice whether George had anything yet. George said no. Claire, in her biweekly budget review meetings, stopped including a slot for the fourth project, because George had asked her not to until January.
The green notebook, on the other hand, was completed in those three months. The last notes of Hollow Knight, the corrections of the minor DLC NGS was considering for 2005, the notes on post-launch support. Every time George closed the green notebook he put it on the shelf next to the black one, and the contrast between the two was an image the team had started to notice without mentioning: a worn, complete notebook next to a virgin notebook with a single sentence.
That image didn't weigh on George.
It was, he thought, the only honest way to start a fourth project after three ascending ones: without the noise of inertia, without the shortcut of the formula, without the safety net of the genre you already knew. A blank page with a single sentence. An order to himself, in private, in an empty room, after reading an anonymous British critic who had seen, before NGS itself, the risk of spending the same thing twice.
Edge was right. So was Daniel. So was Lena. The two things were simultaneously true and NGS was going to have to choose which one was honored with the fourth game.
George had already chosen.
This time we create one.
Three words on an empty page for three months. And then, in January, the first idea was going to appear as a city, before as a mechanic or character or map, a city George already saw in his head with the sun falling from the west the way the sun falls over Los Angeles when there's smog and the air yellows and any asphalt looks hand-painted.
But that was January. October was still the sentence.
End of Chapter 84