Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 92: The E3 That Wasn't

The E3 of May 2005 was the last E3 George was going to attend without having something to sell. He didn't know it yet. He was going to know it a year later. But that first morning at the Los Angeles Convention Center, with the press pass hanging from his neck over a shirt that had wrinkled in the suitcase, George walked through the main entrance like a spectator among spectators and no one in the video game world knew who he was.

Marcus and Daniel walked behind him. The three of them had press passes Claire had gotten after three weeks of calls, two formal emails to the ESA's public relations department, and a useful lie about the editorial coverage of NG Update, the internal NGS newsletter that had four hundred subscribers and that technically, if you squinted, could pass for a publication with its own identity.

"I can't believe this worked," Daniel said, looking at the pass as if expecting it to disintegrate.

"It worked because Claire is Claire," George said.

"It worked because no one cares who we are," Marcus said.

The three of them entered the main hangar and the sentence got filed in George's head as one of the truths of the week.

*

Sony presented the PlayStation 3 that afternoon in a room with the capacity of a medium-sized stadium that filled two hours before the start. George, Marcus and Daniel found seats in the thirty-second row, to the left of the stage, behind a Spanish journalist who smelled of cigarette and next to a Korean journalist who took notes in a graph-paper notebook with handwriting that looked like an algorithm.

Ken Kutaragi came out on stage with the serene confidence of a man who had made Sony win two generations in a row and who assumed, without needing to prove it, that he was going to make it win a third. He spoke in English with a Japanese accent, without notes, without hesitations. He talked about the Cell. About the four SPUs. About the seven coprocessors. About the architecture that was going to allow so-called "4D gaming," a term Kutaragi pronounced with the same seriousness with which a cardiologist pronounces a diagnosis. The slides behind him showed graphs of FLOPS and architecture diagrams that eighty percent of the audience didn't understand and that the twenty percent who did understand were too intimidated to dispute.

George took notes in a small notebook. Not of the numbers, which he would forget. He took notes of Kutaragi's posture. Of the way he pronounced the word "Cell." Of the pause he made before each figure. Of the thin smile he gave at the end of each slide, as if he knew something the audience didn't know and that sooner or later they were going to know.

Microsoft had revealed the Xbox 360 the day before at a separate event at the Shrine Auditorium. George had watched the broadcast at the hotel. The show had been bigger, louder, with lights and cameras and a stage that cost more than the entire budget of Castlevania. Bill Gates hadn't appeared, but Robbie Bach had done his best impression of a visionary. The message had been the same: more powerful hardware, more impressive graphics, the future around the corner.

George closed the notebook when Kutaragi finished. The audience applauded. The Korean journalist beside him noted something. The Spanish journalist lit another cigarette, he couldn't, but he tried. George leaned toward Marcus.

"Spec sheet wars," he said.

"What?"

"It's what they're fighting. A war of specs. Who has more SPUs. Who has more FLOPS. Who has a better floating-point unit."

"And us?"

"We can't fight that war. We don't have a hundred million dollars to build a Cell."

Marcus nodded. With curiosity. He had the curiosity of an anthropologist watching a tribe perform a ritual whose purpose wasn't obvious but whose structure deserved study.

*

They left the Sony room and entered the main showroom and the main showroom was a cathedral of marketing.

Electronic Arts had a three-story stand with stairs and railings and LED screens that took up entire walls. In front of the entrance to the stand they had installed an inflatable pool three meters by three meters, with real blue water, with bubbles and submerged lights. Four models in bikinis walked around the pool offering promotional T-shirts of Madden 06 to the attendees who had the decency not to stare too hard. A professional photographer took photos of the models. Another photographer took photos of the photographer taking photos of the models.

Marcus stood three meters before reaching the stand, observing the whole thing, his head tilted as if trying to decipher the semiotic code of a civilization that had evolved in parallel to his own.

"This has nothing to do with football," Marcus said.

"No," George said.

"I mean, technically yes. But conceptually no."

"It's advertising."

"It's something stranger than advertising. It's advertising that doesn't know it's advertising. Or knows but pretends it isn't."

Daniel stood next to Marcus looking at the pool with the neutral expression of a man who had grown up in Berkeley with two lesbian activist mothers and for whom the models in bikinis next to an inflatable pool in a convention center under fluorescent lights constituted a phenomenon of a strangeness his upbringing hadn't prepared him to process.

Activision had a stand with a stage where a live band played covers of the Guitar Hero songs, the game had just come out and wasn't yet the phenomenon it was going to be six months later. Ubisoft had gigantic screens with trailers of Assassin's Creed that already promised what it was going to deliver two years later. Each stand was a universe in itself. Each universe cost more than NGS had spent in the last five years combined.

George walked through the aisles of the showroom with a feeling he had learned to recognize: that of being a visitor on a planet whose gravity was different. Not less. Not more. Different.

*

The Maxis stand was in the Electronic Arts section but set off in a corner, with fewer screens and no models. In the center of the stand was a modest desk with a PC and a chair, and in the chair sat Will Wright explaining something to a small group of journalists.

George came closer. Wright was forty-five years old, with the disheveled hair of someone who had more important things to think about, and the low voice of someone used to people leaning in to listen. On the PC screen was a single-celled organism swimming in a blue liquid. Wright moved it with the mouse. The organism ate particles. The organism grew. The organism divided.

"This is the first phase," Wright was saying. "Cell. The player starts as a single cell in an ocean. It eats. It grows. It evolves. And the evolution isn't prescribed: it depends on what the player does. If it eats meat, it becomes carnivorous. If it eats plants, it becomes herbivorous. And the body of the organism changes accordingly."

George listened with the notebook closed. He didn't want to take notes in front of Wright. He didn't want it to look like he was copying. But he was registering, mentally, the idea of a system that simulated itself without the designer having to decide every detail.

"Is it a simulation?" a journalist asked.

"It's a system," Wright said. "The difference matters. A simulation tries to copy reality. A system produces its own reality from simple rules. The cell follows rules. The rules produce the creature. The creature, afterward, is going to produce a tribe. The tribe is going to produce a civilization. The civilization is going to produce a spaceship. Each phase emerges from the previous one. The designer doesn't build the creature. He builds the rules. The creature builds itself."

George closed his eyes for a second. Rules that produce creatures. Systems that produce worlds. The idea wasn't new, he had read it in books on artificial life in the nineties, but seeing it applied to a commercial video game by a designer with Wright's pedigree gave it another density.

When the group dispersed, Wright was left alone in front of the PC. George came over.

"I'm George Hightower. New Game Studios."

Wright looked at him. Something lit up behind his eyes. "Hollow Knight."

"Yes."

"I finished it last summer. My son recommended it to me. Good game."

"Thank you."

"What are you doing now?"

George hesitated for a second. The honest answer was "a 3D open world that's a lie about Los Angeles." The press release answer was "an ambitious project in a new direction." The answer he gave was in between.

"Something in 3D. A city. We're building the engine."

Wright nodded. "The hardest thing about cities is that they have to look like they don't have a designer. If the player feels the designer's hand at every corner, the city dies."

"And how do you keep them from feeling it?"

"Rules," Wright said. "You put rules. You let the rules make the corners. The designer builds the system. The system builds the city."

George noted the sentence in his head. He was going to transcribe it that night in the black notebook he had in the hotel suitcase.

*

They had dinner at a restaurant in West Hollywood Marcus had chosen because he had read a review in LA Weekly and because he wanted to try the ceviche. The restaurant had exposed brick walls and tables of reclaimed wood and waiters who recited the menu as if it were poetry. They ordered three plates to share. George ate little. Marcus ate for two. Daniel ordered a hamburger because Daniel always ordered a hamburger.

"What are you thinking about?" Marcus asked at some point between the ceviche and the second plate.

George looked at his glass. He looked at Marcus. He looked at Daniel.

"That we're not going to compete with them."

"With whom?"

"With Sony. With Microsoft. With EA. With the specs. With the 4D gaming. We're not going to get into that fight."

"We weren't planning to get into it."

"No. But the temptation is going to be there. When we start talking about Los Santos in public, people are going to want to compare. Polygons. FLOPS. Textures. Resolution. And if we get into that conversation, we lose. Because we can't win with specs. We don't have a hundred million dollars or four hundred people."

"So what?" Daniel asked.

George took a drink. He took a while to answer.

"We're going to give them something they can't do. Different in category. A city that breathes. Something that can't be reduced to a spec sheet. Because when something can't be reduced to a sheet, it stops competing with the sheets."

Marcus put down the fork. "A city that breathes."

"Yes."

"I like it."

Daniel looked at his hamburger. "I'm going to have to write a lot of code."

"Yes," George said. "You're going to have to write a lot of code."

*

After dinner they went out to walk along Hollywood Boulevard. It was almost midnight. The lights of the theaters were still on. The Chinese Theatre. The Dolby. The marquees. The bronze stars on the sidewalk with names half the tourists didn't recognize. And among the lights, the rest.

The broken tiles on the sidewalks. The cracks in the cement. The flickering neon signs. The tourists with cameras and backpacks and folded maps. The street vendors of fake handbags. The men in superhero costumes offering photos for five dollars. The prostitutes on the corners, waiting with professional patience. The police cars passing slowly. The smell of marijuana mixed with the smell of fast food mixed with the smell of the sewer.

George walked in silence. Marcus walked beside him taking everything in with his eyes. Daniel walked behind, his hands in his pockets, registering the atmosphere without meaning to.

They passed a hotel whose marquee said VACANCIES in red letters with the C burned out. They passed an evangelical church with a yellow banner that promised salvation in capital letters. They passed a bar whose door opened for an instant and let out a riff of distorted guitar and the shout of someone celebrating something or suffering something, it was hard to tell.

George stopped at a corner. He looked around. The street extended in both directions with its layers: the superficial glamour, the immediate decay beneath it, the tourists who didn't want to see the decay, the people who lived in the decay and whom the tourists didn't want to see. Four layers on one sidewalk. Four worlds superimposed three meters apart.

"This," George said. "This is Los Santos."

Marcus stopped beside him. He looked at what George was looking at. He processed it.

"It isn't Los Angeles," Marcus said.

"No."

"It's the lie of Los Angeles. The version people believe is the city. The one the tourists come looking for. The one the movies film. The one that exists in the imagination before it exists on the map."

"Exactly."

"And we're going to make that one."

"We're going to make that one."

Marcus sat on the curb. He took from the inner pocket of his jacket the sketchbook he carried everywhere, a Moleskine with the corners folded from years of use, and opened a blank page. He took out a mechanical pencil. He started to draw.

He drew the hotel marquee with the C burned out. He drew the church banner. He drew the silhouette of a palm tree against the yellow light of a lamppost. He drew a woman standing on a corner with a shiny handbag. He drew the crack in the cement between two tiles. He drew the four layers of the sidewalk with the visual economy of a man who had learned to see the essential and to register only that.

George watched him draw. Daniel sat next to Marcus and watched too. Twenty minutes passed without any of them speaking. Marcus filled three pages of the Moleskine before closing the notebook and putting it back in his jacket.

"Tomorrow I do more," Marcus said.

"Tomorrow we see more," George said.

They walked back to the hotel. They passed the Walk of Fame with its stars that named dead people and living people, famous people and forgotten people, in an order that seemed random because it was random. George looked at the stars beneath his feet and thought that a city that puts the names of its celebrities on the sidewalk for the tourists to step on was a city that understood something profound about the nature of worship and of indignity.

He was going to put that idea into Los Santos. He didn't know how yet. But he was going to do it.

At the hotel, in the room he shared with Marcus, George took the black Los Santos notebook out of the suitcase. It was the first notebook. It was almost empty. There were notes from the first weeks at Townsend Street, loose ideas about the engine, lists of film references that were going to influence the tone. But the pages were mostly blank.

George opened to the first empty page. He wrote, in the small handwriting he used when he wanted something important to be recorded without ostentation:

A city that breathes. Don't compete on specs. Rules that produce corners. The lie people believe. Four layers on one sidewalk. The names beneath the feet.

He closed the notebook. He turned off the light. Marcus was already asleep in the next bed, with the Moleskine on his chest and the mechanical pencil still in his hand.

The E3 was over for George. He hadn't announced anything. He had no stand. No one in the showroom knew he had been there. The industry was going to remember May 2005 as the month Sony revealed the Cell and Microsoft revealed the Xbox 360 and EA put a pool with bikini models next to Madden 06.

George was going to remember it as the month he saw Hollywood Boulevard at midnight.

End of Chapter 92

Comments

No comments found for this post.