CHAPTER 116: Distribution Panel (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 116: Distribution Panel
The Moscone Center in San Francisco in March 2007 was a building NGS knew. It was fifteen blocks from the Townsend Street office. George had walked through its main entrance at every GDC since 2001. The difference that year was that Claire was on one of the panels. It was the first time a member of NGS spoke on a Game Developers Conference panel.
The panel was called "Digital Distribution: The NG Store Effect" and was scheduled for Wednesday afternoon in room West 2002, with capacity for four hundred people. The moderator was Mark DeLoura, ex-Sony, now an independent consultant, author of three books on graphics programming that half of Silicon Valley had on their shelves. The panelists were four: Claire for NGS, Stewart Miller for Direct2Drive, Frances Hardy for GameTap, and Theodore Bergquist for GamersGate.
Alex Chen wasn't on the panel officially. He was in the front row as Claire's technical companion. Alex was thirty-one years old, wore a navy blue sweater his mother had sent him from Vancouver, and the restrained smile of someone who preferred to let the figures speak for him. He had been director of NG Store since the launch in January 2006. In fifteen months he had taken the platform from three hundred users on opening day to seven hundred fifty thousand active users in March 2007. The figures were his work and they were also his pride.
Claire sat at the panelists' table at three ten in the afternoon. The room was full. The four hundred chairs were occupied and there were thirty people standing at the back. George was in row seven, dressed in the same blue shirt he wore at all public appearances because he had decided five years earlier that the decision about the shirt was a decision he didn't want to make twice.
In the front row, next to Alex, several executives from Japanese and European publishers settled in silence, with notebooks on their laps.
They were faces Claire had seen at previous conferences. She lowered her eyes to her notes. The panelists' table allowed no surprises.
* * *
Mark DeLoura opened the panel with a three-minute introduction about the state of digital distribution in March 2007. NG Store had seven hundred fifty thousand users. Direct2Drive four hundred thousand. GameTap three hundred thousand. GamersGate two hundred fifty thousand. The numbers formed a clear hierarchy: NG Store at the top, in fifteen months, and a tight group below of stores that had been on the market for more years.
DeLoura opened with the easiest question. "What does the dominance of NG Store mean for the others?"
Stewart Miller of Direct2Drive answered first. He talked for four minutes about the need for differentiation, for additional services, for alternative business models. He said Direct2Drive was experimenting with subscription models. He said the future was in services more than in single downloads. He said things that sounded like answers but that didn't answer the question.
Frances Hardy of GameTap spoke second. Hardy was pragmatic. She said GameTap focused on retro games and that this was a vertical where NG Store didn't play. She said the dominance of NG Store was a fact you had to accept and work around, not confront.
Theodore Bergquist of GamersGate spoke third. Bergquist was the most combative. He said NG Store was setting a standard of 70/30 that the small stores couldn't match. He said the manual curation gave them an unfair advantage. He said the industry was going to have to organize to push for better terms.
When it was Claire's turn, there was an expectation in the room. The three previous panelists had given conventional positions. The room waited to see what the representative of the indie studio that had built the biggest digital platform on the market in fifteen months was going to say.
Claire spoke with the surgical calm she had developed over eight years of meetings with publishers.
"The competitors aren't the enemy. The previous stores did the work of educating the market: they taught that digital distribution was possible. NG Store was built knowing what those stores had tried, what had worked for them and what hadn't. We made a different decision on the split: 70/30. We did it because we want the developers who sell on NG Store to receive a percentage that lets them reinvest in their games. Digital distribution reduces costs. Those reduced costs should go back to the developer, not stay with the platform."
The room registered the figure. Seventy-thirty. No exceptions. The sentence hung in the air while DeLoura prepared the next question.
But before DeLoura continued, Stewart Miller intervened.
"A direct question, Claire, if I may. Isn't NGS taking advantage of the work the pioneering stores did for years? Direct2Drive and GameTap normalized digital distribution before you. You arrived in 2006 with a platform that wouldn't have existed without the prior work of those stores. And now you offer 70/30 as if it were an innovation. But the innovation was from those who arrived first."
The question made sense. It had rhetoric. It had the trap of asking Claire to defend NGS without offending the previous stores, or to acknowledge their work without weakening NG Store's position. It was a question designed to make Claire lose on either of the two sides.
Claire didn't lose on either.
"Direct2Drive didn't invent the 70/30. We didn't invent it either. Both are refinements of the model that one day we're going to call the App Store model and that at this moment doesn't exist but that is going to exist. Digital distribution is a category that's going to have five or six big players in the next ten years. The previous stores did the work of educating the market. NG Store arrived later with a different model. A third, a fourth, and a fifth are going to come. When the six are competing, the winner is going to be the one who understood sooner that the right split is the one that keeps the chain of developers alive, not the one who arrived first. That's going to be our bet. The pie is going to grow enough for everyone to eat."
In the front row, the publisher executives took notes.
In row seven, George looked at his sister with the admiration he felt every time he saw her operate under pressure. The sentence about the App Store model was a sentence he had slipped to her at a dinner a month earlier, with no context, as if it were an intuition about the future of the industry. Claire had kept it. She had used it when she needed it. And she had used it well.
* * *
DeLoura passed the floor to Alex from the front row. The participation wasn't formally scheduled, but DeLoura had facilitated it because he knew the NG Store figures were what the room wanted to hear.
Alex stood. He had a paper with the numbers. He didn't look at it. He knew them by heart.
"Seven hundred fifty thousand active users as of March 2007. Twenty-two percent month-over-month growth in the last quarter. A conversion rate of thirteen percent, the visitors who come to NG Store and buy something. For comparison: the typical conversion rate of physical retail is two percent. The digital stores report between five and seven percent. The catalog has two hundred games. Three are ours. The other one hundred ninety-seven are from fifty-two third-party publishers. The third-quarter commissions project eight hundred thousand dollars of revenue for NGS in distribution margins alone, not counting the sales of our own games."
The room processed. The numbers were numbers NGS hadn't made public before. The thirteen percent conversion rate was a figure that was above any known benchmark in digital distribution. Stewart Miller looked at Alex with the expression of someone calculating what his boss was going to say when Miller reported the figure to him that night.
Frances Hardy asked the obvious question. "How do you achieve a thirteen percent conversion rate?"
Alex answered without a pause. "Because most NG Store visitors aren't casual visitors. They're players who bought one of our games and discovered that NG Store has other games. The barrier to entry is already crossed. They have the account. They have the payment method. They have trust in the platform. The conversion is high because the friction is low. If Direct2Drive had started as an appendix of its own game, its conversion rate would also be higher. But those stores started as pure stores. We started as an appendix. That was the strategic difference."
DeLoura interrupted. "Is the strategy replicable?"
"Only if you have a game people want to buy and that sells enough to pull the platform. Los Santos did the work in 2007. But Los Santos only exists because NGS built it. The trick is having something the platform can distribute."
The room nodded. It was an honest answer. It was an answer that showed the limits of the model itself. And it was an answer a competitor couldn't use because it required having a game like Los Santos first.
* * *
The panel ended at four thirty in the afternoon with the room still full. DeLoura closed with an observation that was going to appear the next day on GamesIndustry.biz and that was going to circulate in emails for weeks.
"Claire Hightower and Alex Chen are building the next generation of digital distribution. They can do it quietly or loudly. Today they chose loudly. And we're going to remember this day as the day the market understood that NG Store is a strategy, not an experiment."
Applause. Claire got up from the panelists' table. She greeted the other three. She came down from the stage. She walked to where George was in row seven. She gave him a quick kiss on the cheek, the gesture of siblings who recognized each other when one had done the other's job well.
Behind Claire, in the room that was emptying, six publishers came over in a line to talk with her. Two were from a Japanese catalog. One was from a German publisher. Three were from a medium North American catalog that hadn't signed with NG Store yet. Claire gave each one five minutes. She noted names. She promised emails. She didn't promise contracts. Claire didn't promise contracts in hallways.
Stewart Miller stayed at the back of the room. He didn't come over. He closed his folder when the last publisher finished talking with Claire. He got up from the chair. He walked toward the exit. He passed by George without looking at him. He left the room.
George watched him leave. He didn't know whether Miller didn't come over because he considered NG Store a competitor that didn't deserve conversation or because he considered NG Store a competitor with whom any public conversation was going to be interpreted. Either of the two readings was possible. Either of the two mattered.
* * *
That night George and Claire came back to SF from the Oakland regional airport, where they had had to land because of an itinerary change, because Claire had promised David she would pick up David's father's car before dinner, and George had joined the trip because he liked the logistical trick of the short flights as an excuse to talk in peace.
They were in the boarding area when Claire opened the laptop. Calculator. George looked at her.
"What are you calculating?"
"Production capacity."
"Capacity for what."
"If NG Store keeps growing at twenty-two percent month over month for two more years, we have three million users by the end of 2008. At a thirteen percent conversion rate and an ARPU of fifty dollars a year, that's twenty million annually in commissions alone. Plus our own sales. Enough to finance five simultaneous AAA projects."
George looked at her. He closed his eyes for a second. He opened them.
"Five?"
"It's math, George. If we have the financing for five, we can make five. If we can make five, we can cover the genres we're not covering. An RPG. A cyberpunk. A Hollow Knight sequel. Something new in 2D. Something we haven't even imagined."
George knew that look in his sister. The look she had when a financial plan showed her a future that was theoretically possible and that she was going to start making literally possible the following week. It was a roadmap, not a hypothesis.
"It's too early to talk about five projects," George said.
"It's too early to talk about three. But I'm going to be talking to you about five within a year."
"Claire."
"George. You brought me this far. Don't complain now if I show you where we can keep going."
George didn't answer. He closed his eyes. He was going to fall asleep during the trip. The last thought before falling asleep was that Claire had found the financial model that was going to make Witcher and Night City possible without his having to take the two notebooks out of the filing cabinet yet. The speed was a step ahead of his own. It was the right place for her to be.
* * *
The email from Andrew Reiner arrived Friday morning. It was a summary of the panel for a short section Game Informer was going to publish in the May issue. Reiner had listened to the recording. He had taken notes. He had decided to close the summary with DeLoura's quote, the quote about Claire Hightower and Alex Chen building the next generation of digital distribution.
George read the email twice. He printed the quote. He cut it with scissors. He took it to the black Los Santos notebook.
He opened the notebook to the "post-launch" section, the section he had started to fill after the previous year's E3, where he noted ideas for what NGS was going to do after launching Los Santos. Patches. Downloadable content. A version for PSP. A mod kit. The expanded radio.
He pasted the quote on the first page of that section. Above the technical ideas. Above the operational plans. Above everything he had already noted.
"Claire Hightower and Alex Chen are building the next generation of digital distribution."
And beneath it he wrote, in pencil: "Los Santos is the rock. NG Store is the ripples. The post-launch is what the game allows us to do."
He closed the notebook. He left it on the desk. He went out to get coffee.
In the coffee area of the Townsend Street office, Marcus was pouring himself an Americano. George came over. Marcus asked him how the panel had gone.
"They're going to remember it," George said.
"Well or badly?"
"They're going to remember it. That's what matters."
Marcus nodded. He passed George the coffee pot. He went back to his desk. George poured the coffee and stayed a minute alone in the kitchen looking out the window at Townsend Street.
He thought: ‘Claire has just changed the calendar of the next five years of NGS and she still doesn't realize it’. Or she does realize it. With Claire it was hard to tell.
He took the coffee. He went back to the back office. There was a decision to make about the spatial audio sound of the Ballas in a mission in the Idlewood neighborhood and Lena was waiting for his answer.
The rest could wait.
End of Chapter 116