Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 120: The First 10 out of 10

Edge Magazine, the video game magazine published in Bath since 1993, had given only eighteen perfect scores of 10 out of 10 in its fourteen years of existence up to the summer of 2007. The eighteen included Zelda Ocarina of Time, Half-Life 2, Resident Evil 4, and other names the industry recognized as points of reference. Edge's editorial policy was that a 10 wasn't a score but a verdict: the explicit recognition that a game had achieved something that was going to be studied for years by the developers who came after.

The August 2007 issue of Edge reached the subscribers on Monday, July 23. The cover was black with a single word in red letters: TRANSCENDENCE. And below it, in smaller white: "Why Los Santos changes the rules."

George received his courtesy copy by courier on Tuesday, July 24, at the Townsend Street office. The magazine came in a padded envelope with a handwritten note from the editor in chief, Tony Mott, that said only: "Four pages. Page 86. T."

George opened the magazine on his desk. He turned the pages carefully until reaching page 86. The review had four pages as Tony had announced: the title, the scores by category, the main text of three pages, and at the end, in the lower right corner, enclosed in a box with a thick border, the score.

10.

George stayed looking at the number for a minute without moving. Then he closed the magazine. He opened it again to page 86. The 10 was still there. He closed the magazine a second time. He left it in the center of his desk. And he walked to Claire's office without saying a word to anyone on the way.

* * *

Claire was on the phone with a server provider when George came in without knocking. She made a "one minute" gesture with her hand and kept talking for another two about traffic rates for NG Store. When she hung up, she looked at George.

"What's going on?"

"Edge."

George put the magazine on Claire's desk. Open to page 86. The 10 visible in the corner.

Claire looked at the number. Then she looked at George. Then she looked at the number again. And then she did something George had seen Claire do only twice in thirty years of knowing her: she laughed. Not the restrained laugh of the business meetings. Not the diplomatic laugh of the press conferences. The free and unreserved laugh of a girl who discovers that something impossible has happened and that the impossibility is real.

"Ten out of ten," Claire said.

"Ten out of ten."

"From Edge."

"From Edge."

"It's the first time in history that Edge has given a 10 to an independent game from a studio that isn't Nintendo or Valve or one of the big ones."

"It's the first time in history that Edge has given a 10 to NGS."

"George."

"I know."

Claire got up from the chair. She walked to the window. She looked at Townsend Street for ten seconds. Then she turned to George.

"We're going to have problems with this."

George frowned. "Problems?"

"The expectations. Every game we make after this is going to be compared with the Edge 10. If our next game gets a 9, the forums are going to say we lost our touch. If it gets a 9.5, the forums are going to say we're in decline. Perfect scores create prisons. That's why the studios that receive them generally enter a period of three to five years where the second game after the 10 sells less than the first because the fans have convinced themselves that nothing is ever going to be as good."

George stayed quiet for a moment. Claire was right. It was a cold analysis he hadn't done in the ninety seconds since he had seen the number.

"What do we do?"

Claire went back to the chair. "We celebrate it this week. We send a press release. Janet writes a text that's grateful but not triumphalist. And then we keep working as if nothing had happened. Because that's what the employees have to see: that an Edge 10 doesn't change what NGS does. It changes what the world thinks of NGS. But it doesn't change the work. The work is still the work."

George nodded. It was exactly the right answer.

* * *

The text of the Edge review had been written by Tony Mott personally. It was unusual: Mott was editor in chief, not a reviewer. For Mott to sign a review meant the game had been important enough that the editor in chief wanted to associate himself personally with the verdict.

George read the four pages that afternoon in his office with the door closed. The review wasn't a description of mechanics or an analysis of graphics. It was a 2,800-word essay about what Los Santos represented as an evolution of the open-world genre and, more broadly, about what NGS had achieved by building it with forty-five people instead of four hundred.

Mott wrote: "Los Santos is what the open-world genre can be when an independent studio that doesn't have to justify quarterly millions of dollars decides to build something at its own pace, with its own vision, without the pressures that distort the contemporary AAAs. The result isn't just an excellent game. It's a declaration that the development model of the big publishers isn't the only path to large-scale games."

George underlined the sentence. It was exactly what he had wanted to prove since 2005 when he started building Los Santos. What mattered was what the game proved about how games could be made, not the game itself.

Mott continued: "The modularity of NGN, the engine New Game Studios developed over three years under the direction of George Hightower, suggests an architecture that is going to sustain future NGS projects with a flexibility that the proprietary engines of the big studios haven't achieved. If NGS builds on this base, the next five years of its catalog could be one of the most interesting periods in the industry."

George marked the sentence with a dot in the margin. It was a prediction. And it was exactly what he himself had been thinking since he finished NGN in November 2005: that the engine was the base on which the next ten years of NGS were going to be built.

The review ended with a paragraph George had to read twice before fully understanding it:

"There are moments in the history of a medium where an individual work clarifies what the medium can be. The Godfather did that for cinema. Citizen Kane did it forty years earlier. Symphony of the Night did it for 2D games in 1999. And Los Santos, in this summer of 2007, does it for open worlds. Not because it invented the genre but because it demonstrates that the genre can contain something more than the repetition of a formula. For the first time in years, an open-world game feels like literature: ambitious, formal, self-aware, and deeply human in its thematic concerns. This isn't just another game. It's a point of reference."

George read the paragraph three times. Then he closed the magazine. He put it in the top drawer of his desk because leaving it out where someone could read it over his shoulder seemed vulgar to him.

* * *

The reviews from the rest of the industry came in the week following Edge's.

IGN published the final review on Friday, July 27: 9.8 out of 10. The review described Los Santos as "the best open world of the generation." IGN highlighted the technical quality of NGN, Elena's mission design, Marcus's art direction, and the twelve thousand dialogues produced by the voice team that the reviewer didn't know had worked in Koreatown the previous summer.

GameSpot published on Monday, July 30: 9.5. The review was more reserved than IGN's and Edge's. The reviewer noted some technical limitations in the PS2 version (compressed textures, closer distance fog) that the next-gen versions didn't have. But it concluded that Los Santos was "one of the definitive launches of the generation."

Eurogamer published on Tuesday: 10 out of 10. The second perfect score. Tom Bramwell wrote: "This is the easiest review I've written in five years at Eurogamer. Los Santos is a game that explains itself. The only thing I have to do is ratify what anyone who has played it for ten hours already knows: this is one of those games that define a decade."

Kotaku published on Wednesday: 9.7 out of 10. Brian Crecente's review was the longest of the package, 4,500 words, and focused less on the game itself and more on the cultural context: what it meant that an independent American studio had produced the most ambitious game of the year in an industry dominated by Japanese and British publishers.

Edge, IGN, GameSpot, Eurogamer, Kotaku. The five reviews Metacritic aggregated with the highest weights. The Metascore of Los Santos at the close of the week: 96.

It was the second-highest Metascore of the year 2007 up to that point, behind only a Nintendo game whose reviews had closed at 97. It was the highest Metascore an independent game had achieved in the history of Metacritic.

* * *

Janet Park printed the reviews and stuck them on the back wall of the office next to the mural. The wall filled up: five reviews of five pages each, with the scores underlined in yellow marker and with the most memorable quotes marked with colored post-its. Every NGS employee passed by that wall several times a day. And every employee, without anyone having told them anything explicit, read the reviews at least once in full during that week.

Marcus stopped in front of the Edge review one Thursday at eleven in the morning. Tony Mott had dedicated a whole column to the art direction. Marcus read it twice. Then he went to his desk. He took from the drawer the sketchbook he had taken to LA in April 2006 when he and Priya had spent six days photographing South Central. He opened it to the first page. The page had a quick sketch of the Grove Street houses Marcus had drawn in the Hyatt Regency room in LA on the night of the first day of the trip. The houses in the drawing weren't very different from the ones that had ended up in the game: a pencil sketch that had become four thousand five hundred 3D models over fifteen months of production.

Marcus closed the notebook. He put it in the drawer. He didn't tell anyone what he had done. It was the kind of private moment he preferred not to share because sharing it would have forced him to explain emotions he didn't know how to articulate.

Lena read the Eurogamer review on Friday afternoon. Bramwell dedicated two full paragraphs to the audio design: the conversation between the car's engine and the radio that was the heart of the driving experience, the Santa Monica waves recorded at five in the morning, the silence of the Industrial District that was broken only by the sound of the port's water. Bramwell ended the section about audio with a sentence: "The audio of Los Santos is one of the few cases where listening to the game with headphones is a different and superior experience to listening to it with speakers. Lena Kovac understands something about sound that most video game composers are still trying to learn."

Lena read the sentence three times. Then she went to the office studio where she had the audio mixing system. She sat in front of the console. She closed her eyes. And she stayed that way for ten minutes doing nothing, listening to the sounds of the office on the other side of the wall: Daniel's typing, Janet's voice on the phone, the coffee pot someone had just turned on. It was the silence of someone who had spent years trying to make the world hear something she had heard first and that now, finally, someone else had heard and had said out loud in a magazine in Bath, England.

* * *

On Saturday, August 4, 2007, George drove to Oakland to his parents' house with the Edge magazine under his arm.

Margaret opened the door. She was in a kitchen apron because it was five in the afternoon and she had cooked chili on Saturdays since 1976 and saw no reason to change the custom in 2007.

"You brought something," Margaret said, looking at the magazine.

"A magazine from England."

"About the game?"

"About the game."

"Did they give it a good grade?"

George laughed. "They gave it the best grade."

Margaret nodded. She let George in. Richard was in the living room watching a baseball game on the television. Margaret announced that their son had brought an important magazine. Richard turned off the television without protesting, which was a fact about the importance he attributed to the event: Richard never turned off a baseball game except for dinner or for emergencies.

George put the magazine on the dining room table. Margaret and Richard sat on the other side. George opened the magazine to page 86. He explained to them what Edge was. He explained to them what a 10 out of 10 meant in the context of the video game industry.

Richard looked at the number for a minute in silence. Then he looked at George.

"Ten out of ten."

"Ten out of ten."

"From the English."

"From the English."

Richard laughed. It was a deep and full laugh Margaret didn't hear often. Then he got up from the chair. He walked to the living room shelf where there was a photo of him with George in 1984 when George was seven years old and Richard thirty-two. He took the photo. He came back to the table. He put it next to the magazine.

"This kid," Richard said, pointing at the seven-year-old in the photo, "is the same one who's in that magazine from England. And no one in 1984 could have said that was going to happen. I couldn't have said it. Your mother couldn't have said it. You least of all."

Margaret took Richard's hand on the table. George felt something in his chest he had been controlling with difficulty for two weeks and that now, in his parents' living room at five in the afternoon on a Saturday in August, he let out without fighting. He cried without shame. Margaret cried with him. Richard didn't cry but he squeezed Margaret's hand with the strength of someone who holds back emotions he wasn't taught to let go of.

They had chili for dinner. George stayed until eleven at night. When he left, Richard hugged him at the door for ten seconds without saying anything. It was one of the longest hugs he had given him since the university graduation in 1998. And like all of Richard's important hugs, it needed no words: the hug said what Richard didn't know how to say and what George didn't need to hear said to understand.

* * *

George drove back to his Mission Street apartment with the radio tuned to KFOG and with the Edge magazine on the passenger seat. At eleven thirty at night, he stopped the car at a corner of Folsom Street to wait for a traffic light. A young couple crossed the street in front of the car. They were holding hands. The boy wore a black T-shirt with a white logo George recognized the second his eyes landed on it: it was the NGS logo, the simple square Marcus had designed in 2003, printed on a T-shirt the couple must have bought at some online unofficial merchandise store.

George didn't know that unofficial NGS merchandise existed. It was the first time he saw someone wearing a T-shirt with his logo in the street without that person being an NGS employee.

The light changed. The couple finished crossing. George moved the car forward. And while he drove the next six blocks to his apartment, he had the awareness of a man who had just witnessed tangible evidence that the work of a studio of forty-five people in a Townsend Street office had left the office and started to live in the world, on people's T-shirts, on internet forums, in the reviews of English magazines that gave 10 out of 10 to something that two and a half years earlier had been just a black notebook with an idea.

He got to the apartment. He went up the stairs. He opened the door. He left the magazine on the kitchen table. And he fell asleep at twelve thirty with the awareness that the first 10 out of 10 had arrived and that probably, if NGS did its job well over the next few years, it wasn't going to be the last.

End of Chapter 120

Comments

No comments found for this post.