CHAPTER 128: The Witcher, the Continent, and the Gray Decisions (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 128: The Witcher, the Continent, and the Gray Decisions
George started the design of Geralt by comparing him with the protagonists he had already created.
Geralt was the opposite of CJ. CJ was a man who came back to a place to rebuild it, a gang member with roots in a neighborhood that defined him and that he could return to every time the world got complicated. Geralt was a man with no place. Geralt walked. He always walked. From village to village, from contract to contract, killing monsters people needed him to kill and collecting the money people didn't want to pay. CJ had Grove Street. Geralt had the road.
Geralt was the opposite of Alucard. Alucard was a vampire of noble blood with supernatural powers who explored his father's castle. Alucard was mystery and elegance, a prince who moved among the shadows with the grace of someone who belonged to the darkness. Geralt was mud and blood. Geralt slept in stables when the taverns rejected him. He ate what he found. He smelled of alchemical oils and monster guts. Alucard was a prince. Geralt was a laborer.
Geralt was the opposite of the Knight. The Knight was silence: a voiceless insect the player filled with his own interpretation, an empty vessel that received whatever emotion the player projected onto it. Geralt was voice: ironic, direct, weary, with an opinion about everything that he expressed with verbal economy, because he had learned that words are like swords, better the less you use them.
And Geralt was different from the Geralt of other versions of these stories made by other people in his previous life. In the previous life, other people had made a first version in 2007 with a Geralt who had amnesia. They had decided that the way to introduce the player into Sapkowski's world was to erase Geralt's memory so that player and protagonist discovered the world together. It was a narrative trick that worked mechanically but that betrayed the character: the Geralt of the novels was a man with decades of experience, complex relationships, and a reputation that preceded him to every village. That Geralt of the first version was an amnesiac who asked "who am I?" every ten minutes.
George was going to correct that. No amnesia. Geralt complete from the first minute.
* * *
George wrote Geralt's profile in the brown notebook the way you describe a friend you haven't seen in years but remember clearly.
Geralt of Rivia. Witcher of the School of the Wolf. White hair from the mutations. Cat eyes that see in the dark. Two swords on his back: steel for humans, silver for monsters. Scars on his body like a map of every fight he survived.
Age: indefinite. Witchers age more slowly than humans. Geralt looks forty but could be eighty or a hundred twenty. He doesn't care to count it. Age is a number that stopped mattering to him when the mutations took away his certainty of how long he was going to live.
Personality: ironic. Sarcasm is cruelty disguised as humor. Irony is lucidity disguised as indifference. Geralt sees the world with the clarity of someone who has lived long enough to know that most human conflicts are stupid and that most monsters are less dangerous than the people who created them. But beneath the irony, Geralt cares. He cares about Yennefer, the sorceress who is the love of his life and who is as hard to love as she is impossible not to love. He cares about Ciri, the girl he adopted as a daughter and who carries within her a power that half the world wants to control. He cares about the innocents who die when the powerful fight. Geralt's irony is armor. Beneath the armor is a man who feels everything and who pretends to feel nothing.
George read the profile to Torres in a script meeting in the Townsend Street room that smelled of reheated coffee and the whiteboard's permanent markers. Torres listened with his eyes closed, which was his way of listening when something mattered to him: he closed his eyes so the text would enter without visual interference, like an orchestra conductor who closes his eyes during a rehearsal to hear the instruments better.
"It's a character who says one thing and feels another," Torres said when George finished. "Every line of dialogue has to work on two levels: what Geralt says and what Geralt withholds. It's the hardest thing to write."
"It's what makes him memorable. A character who says what he feels is transparent. A character who hides what he feels is human."
Torres nodded. And he started writing Geralt the way George described him: a man who responded to tragedies with dry comments and who only showed what he felt when he believed no one was looking. A man whose humor was the distance he needed from the world so as not to drown in it, and whose silence was the intimacy he reserved for the people who mattered to him enough to deserve to see what was beneath the humor.
* * *
The world of The Witcher was a semi-open world, not an open world. And the difference mattered.
In Los Santos, the player could go anywhere from the first minute. The city existed complete and the player decided what to explore. The story was a guide, not an obligation. In The Witcher, the story was the reason to explore. Without the story, the Continent was a pretty map with villages and forests. With the story, it was a world where each village had a secret, each forest had a monster with a reason to exist, and each player decision changed who lived and who died.
George designed the Continent as four regions that unlocked with the narrative progression, each one with its own visual personality, its own music, and its own narrative problems. They were societies, not levels.
Vizima was the capital. The biggest city in the game: cobblestone streets, markets with merchants shouting prices, a palace on the hill where power concentrated like the heat at a point of a lens, and slums by the river where the elves lived in the misery the humans had assigned them. Vizima was Downtown Los Santos but in the fourteenth century: power concentrated in one space, with the inequalities written in the architecture. The stone houses for the rich, the wooden houses for the merchants, the mud huts for the non-humans. The player who walked from the hill to the river crossed three centuries of oppression in five hundred meters.
Velen was the swamps. The biggest region and the most desolate: villages separated by kilometers of hostile terrain, battlefields where the armies had left corpses no one buried, and a fog the weather system of NGN 2.0 generated as a white wall that moved with the wind and that reduced visibility to 30 meters. Velen was poverty as a landscape, a place where the war had passed and what remained was the silence of the things war destroys and that no one rebuilds because rebuilding requires hope and hope had emigrated from Velen years earlier.
Oxenfurt was the university. A city smaller than Vizima but more alive: students arguing in the taverns, professors quoting books that probably didn't exist, intellectual debates Torres wrote as dialogues where the player could participate with opinions that affected Geralt's reputation. Oxenfurt was the cultural elite that looked down on the rest of the world, convinced that understanding a problem was the same as solving it.
And Skellige. The islands. Fjords that cut the coast like wounds in the rock, snow-covered mountains, and a sea NGN 2.0 rendered with the water shader inherited from Los Santos but with bigger waves and a colder color: blue-gray instead of blue-turquoise. Skellige was Viking. Clans that fought for honor and for territory, jarls who ruled by the law of the sword, and a culture of honor Geralt respected because the Skelligers treated witchers as warriors instead of as pariahs. It was the breath of the game: a place where the rules were simple and where the player could catch his breath after the ambiguity of Velen and the intrigue of Vizima.
Each region had its own color palette Marcus defined in the art direction document with the meticulousness of a painter who mixes pigments on a palette before touching the canvas. Vizima: grays of stone with touches of red and gold of power. Velen: muted browns and greens with the white fog as the dominant. Oxenfurt: warm tones of wood and parchment with the blue of the river. Skellige: whites of snow, grays of rock, blues of the sea.
"Four regions, four worlds," Marcus said in the art meeting where he presented the palettes to the team. "In Los Santos the districts were differentiated by social class. In The Witcher they're differentiated by culture. Vizima is politics. Velen is war. Oxenfurt is knowledge. Skellige is honor. Geralt walks among the four and belongs to none."
* * *
George designed each region as a space and also as a lesson.
Vizima taught politics. The Vizima missions involved court intrigues, assassinations, broken alliances. The player learned that in the Continent power was won with information before swords, and that Geralt, a man with two swords who didn't care about politics, was paradoxically the most dangerous person in a court because he had no alliances and therefore had no political weaknesses.
Velen taught consequences. The Velen missions were the most morally ambiguous: each village had a problem with no clean solution. The baron who looked for his wife and who turned out to be a monster worse than the monsters Geralt hunted. The swamp witch who helped the orphans but who fed on them. The Velen decisions pursued the player throughout the game, appearing at moments the player didn't expect, reminding him that the choices he made in a swamp had weight in a palace.
Oxenfurt taught perspective. The Oxenfurt missions were intellectual: solving mysteries, deciphering texts, debating philosophy with professors who questioned the player's decisions with arguments that had no easy answer. Oxenfurt was where the game asked the player: what you did in Velen, was it right? And the player couldn't answer with certainty.
Skellige taught respect. The Skellige missions were direct: a jarl asked for something, Geralt did it or didn't do it, and the consequences were immediate and clear. Without the ambiguity of Velen or the intrigue of Vizima. Skellige was the breath of the game: a place where the rules were simple and where Geralt was treated as an equal.
"The four regions are the four faces of a world," George wrote in the brown notebook at eleven at night on a Thursday in July, with the office empty and the light of the lamp falling on the pages like a spotlight illuminating a stage that didn't have actors yet. "The player who completes the four understands the Continent as a society and not as a map. And a society where witchers are necessary and despised at the same time resembles the real one too much to be only fantasy."
* * *
The moral decision system was what turned The Witcher into something no RPG of 2008 was.
George had designed it in January, in the first thirty pages of the brown notebook, but in August he refined it with Torres and Elena until every branch worked as a mechanic and as an emotional experience. The central idea hadn't changed: there's no good or bad option. There are only options with consequences. But the consequences now had an architecture George drew on the conference room whiteboard like a diagram that looked like a nervous system: lines that branched, that crossed, that converged at unexpected points.
Each player decision activated a variable. The variables accumulated. And at specific moments in the game, sometimes hours after the original decision, the combined variables produced a result the player couldn't have anticipated. Saving an NPC in Act 1 could mean that NPC betrayed someone in Act 2. Killing a monster in Velen could mean a village in Oxenfurt prospered because the monster controlled a plague that now spread out of control.
"The player can't calculate the consequences," George said in the design meeting with Torres and Elena. "And that's the idea. In real life you don't calculate the consequences of your decisions. You act with the information you have and live with what happens after. The Witcher does the same: it gives you incomplete information, forces you to decide, and shows you the consequences when you can no longer change them."
Torres had a legitimate concern that he raised in the measured voice of a writer who has thought a lot about a problem and who knows the solution is harder than the problem:
"If the consequences are unpredictable, the player is going to feel that the game is arbitrary. That it doesn't matter what he chooses because he can't control the result."
"No," George said. "The consequences are logical, not random. If the player thinks about what he did, he can trace the chain of cause and effect. What he can't do is predict it before acting. It's the difference between arbitrary and unpredictable: the arbitrary has no logic, the unpredictable has a logic you only see afterward."
Elena added the level design layer that completed the system. The missions that activated the most important variables weren't marked. There was no sign that said "this decision matters." The player didn't know which of his decisions were going to have consequences and which weren't. Some secondary missions that seemed trivial activated variables that changed Act 3. Some main missions that seemed crucial activated nothing. The uncertainty was part of the design: the player treated every decision as important because he didn't know which ones were important. And treating every decision as important was exactly what George wanted: a player who thought before acting, who weighed every option, who felt the weight of choosing.
"We're designing anxiety," Elena said with a half-smile that suggested that anxiety seemed to her a perfectly valid design objective.
"We're designing responsibility," George corrected. "The anxiety is the byproduct. The responsibility is the objective. We want the player to feel that his actions have weight. And weight doesn't exist without the possibility of being wrong."
Torres looked at the branch diagram on the whiteboard. The lines that crossed. The points where the decisions converged into results no one could predict. And he said something George kept:
"This is a representation of how life works, not a decision system. You do what you can with what you know and you live with what you didn't know."
George looked at Torres. Torres was looking at the whiteboard. And George thought that Torres had just described the decision system of the Witcher and also the entire life of George Hightower: a man who did what he could with what he remembered and who lived with the consequences of the memories that weren't perfect. The 65% sharpness of the Witcher meant that the remaining 35% was invention, improvisation, decisions made without the certainty that they were right. George designed games with incomplete memories the same way Geralt hunted monsters with incomplete information: the best you could do with what you had, and the hope that the best would be enough.
George closed the brown notebook at the end of August with the design of Geralt, the Continent, and the decision system complete. Sixty pages. It was still a promise more than a game. A promise, written in a brown leather notebook.
Now the people who gave life to the world were missing: the sorceresses, the daughter who didn't appear, and the swords Geralt carried on his back.
End of Chapter 128