CHAPTER 129: The Sorceresses, the Daughter, and the Three Loves (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 129: The Sorceresses, the Daughter, and the Three Loves
Torres was afraid to write Yennefer.
He didn't say it in those words. Torres didn't admit fear. What he said was: "Yennefer is the hardest character in the script and I need more time than I have to do her well." He said it one Tuesday in September in the Townsend Street script room, sitting in front of George's brown notebook that was open to the page where George had written Yennefer's profile in three paragraphs Torres had read six times and that each time seemed more intimidating to him.
George understood why. Yennefer of Vengerberg was much more than a love interest. She was more than the princess the hero rescues, more than the companion who gives him strength, more than the woman who waits at home while the man goes out to kill monsters. Yennefer was a force of nature in the form of a woman. In Sapkowski's novels, she was a sorceress of unbreakable will who manipulated kings, defied other sorceresses, and loved Geralt with the ferocity of someone who knows that love is weakness and chooses to be weak anyway. She was brilliant, cruel when she needed to be, tender when no one saw her, and capable of filling a room with her presence the way a storm fills a sky: by instinct, because that's what storms do.
Writing her badly was turning her into a stereotype: the difficult woman the hero tames. Writing her badly was reducing her to a test Geralt passed with patience until Yennefer "softened" and became the domesticated version of herself the player considered acceptable. It was what the RPGs of 2008 did with the female characters: they made them difficult at the start and accessible at the end, as if the difficulty were an obstacle and not the essence.
Writing her well was creating someone the player respected, feared, and loved at the same time. Someone who spoke with Geralt as an equal and not as a subordinate. Someone whose decisions had as much narrative importance as the protagonist's. Someone the player couldn't tame because taming Yennefer meant destroying what made her Yennefer, and destroying what made her Yennefer was destroying the reason Geralt loved her.
George gave Torres a simple instruction:
"Yennefer is never wrong. Even when she's wrong, her reasons are solid. If the player chooses to go against Yennefer's opinion, the player has to feel he's betting against someone smarter than him."
* * *
Torres wrote Yennefer's dialogues as verbal fencing.
Every conversation between Geralt and Yennefer was a duel where both said one thing and meant another, where the insults were compliments and the silences were declarations of love that neither of them was going to articulate because articulating love was giving power to the other and neither Geralt nor Yennefer ceded power willingly. Torres worked for three weeks on the first ten exchanges. Three weeks for ten conversations. It was the slowest pace of writing in his whole career at NGS, and Torres knew it, and George knew it, and neither of them pushed because both understood that Yennefer couldn't be rushed.
The first exchange Torres presented in the script meeting:
"I missed you, Yen."
"Don't call me Yen. And you didn't miss me. You missed the idea of me. The idea is more comfortable than the person."
"The person has her moments too."
"Few. And I waste them on you."
Torres read the exchange aloud in the voice he used for script readings: neutral, without acting, letting the words do the work without the voice pushing them. George smiled. It was exactly the tone he remembered from other versions of these stories made by other people in his previous life: two people who loved each other the way adults who have been hurt before love each other, with caution and without surrender. The love of adults who know the net doesn't exist and who throw themselves anyway because not throwing themselves would be worse than falling.
Elena, who was in the meeting because Yennefer's missions required specific level design, said: "If I were a player and Geralt talked to me like that, I'd punch him."
"That's exactly the right reaction," George said. "Yennefer isn't likable. Yennefer is necessary. And the difference between a likable character and a necessary character is the difference between a character you like and a character you can't forget."
Torres kept writing. Every Yennefer line passed through what he called "the double-bottom test": if the line only said one thing, Torres rewrote it until it said two. What Yennefer pronounced and what Yennefer withheld had to coexist in every sentence, and the player who listened carefully could detect the second level beneath the first, like an underground river you only see if you know where to look.
* * *
Triss Merigold was Yennefer's counterpoint.
Where Yennefer was ice, Triss was fire. Where Yennefer defied, Triss invited. Where Yennefer told Geralt what was wrong with him, Triss told him what was right. Triss was the comfortable option. The option that required no emotional work. The option that made Geralt feel good about himself instead of challenging him to be better.
George designed her as the most elegant trap in the game.
Because Triss was genuinely good: a brave, loyal, intelligent, and affectionate sorceress who truly loved Geralt and who treated him with a tenderness Yennefer never showed. There was in her no covert villain or manipulator who revealed her true face in the third act. The player who chose Triss was choosing something real and good and genuine.
But he was choosing against the story. Against what Geralt and Yennefer had built over decades of a stormy and deep relationship. Choosing comfort over complexity. And George wanted the player to feel the weight of that choice as the awareness that sometimes choosing the easy thing meant giving up the deep thing. That comfort had a price, and the price was the intensity that only exists when two people love each other without protection.
Torres wrote Triss with deliberate warmth. Every scene with Triss was pleasant. Every dialogue was kind. Every moment was a breath from the harshness of the world and the harshness of Yennefer. And that was what made her dangerous narratively: in a game where everything was hard, the monsters, the decisions, the swamps of Velen, Triss was easy. And the easy was addictive.
"The player is going to choose Triss," Torres said when he finished the first dialogues of both sorceresses and put them side by side on the table of the script room, like a lawyer who presents two contracts and asks the client to choose.
"60% are going to choose Triss," George said. He knew the number because in his previous life, the polls of the players of other versions of these stories had shown exactly that: most chose Triss in the first playthrough. "And then they're going to play again and they're going to choose Yennefer and they're going to understand why the difficult option was the true option. And they're going to play a third time without knowing whom to choose. That's a good love triangle: one where the three playthroughs are different and none is wrong."
Torres looked at the dialogues on the table. Yennefer's: sharp, dense, requiring attention. Triss's: warm, clear, requiring surrender. And he said:
"We're making the player choose between being challenged and being comforted. It's the most personal decision in the game because it has to do with what kind of love the player wants, not with monsters or politics."
George nodded. That was exactly it. And that was exactly what made The Witcher different from any RPG of 2008: a game where the hardest decision was who to love before who to kill.
* * *
Ciri didn't appear in the first game.
George made that decision deliberately, and he knew it was one of the riskiest design decisions of the whole project. Ciri was, in Sapkowski's novels, the most important character in the universe after Geralt. The witcher's adopted daughter. A princess with powers of travel between dimensions that half the world wanted to control and that the other half wanted to kill. She was the emotional heart of the saga: everything Geralt did, he did for her. Everything Yennefer sacrificed, she sacrificed for her. Ciri was the reason both of them existed, and George was saving her for the second game.
But he planted her in the first. Ciri existed in The Witcher as an absence that filled every conversation.
Geralt mentioned Ciri when he talked with Yennefer: "If Ciri were here, she'd know what to do." Yennefer mentioned Ciri when she argued with Geralt: "Everything I do is to find her." The NPCs mentioned a young woman with ashen hair and a scar on her face who had passed through their villages weeks earlier, always moving, always fleeing. The wanted posters the player found in the taverns had a portrait of a girl who matched the description. The rumors in the markets spoke of a young woman who did impossible things, disappeared in one place and appeared in another, and whom the witch hunters pursued relentlessly.
The player never saw her. Never spoke to her. He only heard her name repeated by every important character in the game like an echo with no visible origin. Torres wrote the mentions of Ciri with the discipline of a composer who uses a leitmotif: each mention added a new detail. In Act 1, the player knew Ciri existed. In Act 2, he knew what she could do. In Act 3, he knew why half the world pursued her. By the time the first game ended, the player was going to know Ciri better than many characters who did appear, because the absence was more powerful than the presence when handled with care.
"You're building anticipation for a character who doesn't appear," Elena said when she heard the strategy in a design meeting.
"I'm building a ghost," George answered. "When Ciri finally appears in the second game, the player already knows her. Already loves her. Already wants to protect her. Because he's spent 40 hours listening to Geralt talk about her with the voice of a father."
Elena processed the idea. She turned it over in her head the way she turned over the levels she designed: looking for angles, looking for problems, looking for the piece that didn't fit. She found none. The strategy was solid because it rested on something that couldn't fail: the player's imagination. The Ciri the player built in his head from the mentions was more powerful than any Ciri NGS could render on screen, because the imagination has no limits of polygons or animation budget. The imagined Ciri was perfect because the player filled her with what he wanted her to be. And when the real Ciri appeared in the second game, there was going to be a fascinating tension between the imagined Ciri and the real Ciri that Torres was going to be able to exploit narratively.
"It's absence as a narrative tool," Torres said, who had been quiet during the whole discussion and who now spoke in the slow voice of someone who has just understood something that changed how he thought about writing. "Hitchcock did it with fear: what you don't see is scarier than what you see. We're doing the same with affection: what you love through others weighs more than what you know directly."
George looked at Torres. Torres was looking at the brown notebook where Ciri's profile took up half a page: a few lines that described a girl the player was never going to see in this game and who was going to be the reason the player bought the second game on the day of its launch.
Half a page for the most important character in the universe. Because sometimes less was everything.
* * *
George closed the brown notebook at the end of September with the three profiles complete.
Yennefer: the ice that burned. Triss: the fire that comforted. Ciri: the ghost that was missing.
Three women who defined Geralt as much as Geralt defined himself. Because a protagonist doesn't exist in a vacuum. A protagonist exists in relation to the people around him, and the people around Geralt were three women who represented three types of love the player had to navigate: the hard love that challenged, the easy love that comforted, and the paternal love that protected without asking anything in return.
Torres had 200 pages of dialogue written for the three. Yennefer's lines were the shortest and the densest: every word measured, every silence calculated. Triss's were the longest and the warmest: conversations that flowed with the naturalness of someone who has nothing to hide. Ciri's were mentions more than dialogues: phrases said by other characters that built a portrait made of fragments, like a mosaic where each piece was placed by someone different and the result was only seen when you stepped back far enough.
George put the notebook on the shelf. Now The Witcher had a protagonist, a world, a decision system, and three women who gave heart to a game that until that moment had been architecture and philosophy. The swords Geralt carried on his back and the monsters he used them against were missing.
But the swords and the monsters were mechanics; the people were what mattered.
End of Chapter 129