CHAPTER 130: The Swords, the Signs, and the Monsters (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 130: The Swords, the Signs, and the Monsters
The witcher's combat started with the swords.
Two swords on Geralt's back. Steel and silver. The player switched them with a button. There was no draconian penalty for using the wrong sword against the wrong enemy: steel simply did less damage to monsters and silver did less damage to humans. The choice was strategic, not punitive. George wanted the player to think about which sword to use but not to die from a selection error in the middle of the chaos. The right choice gave you an advantage. The wrong one made you work harder. But both worked.
George designed the combat as a system of timing and positioning that didn't resemble anything NGS had done before. Forget the 2D combat of Castlevania with its invincibility frames. Forget the combat of Hollow Knight with its 5-frame parry. Forget the combat of Los Santos that was resolved with ranged weapons. This was third-person sword combat, hand to hand, with the camera behind Geralt and the weight of each blow visible in the animation.
Each of Geralt's attacks had wind-up frames, active frames, and recovery frames. The player who attacked at the right moment, when the enemy finished his own attack and was in recovery, did more damage and took less. The player who attacked without thinking, who spammed the attack button hoping that speed would compensate for the lack of strategy, was punished by the recovery of his own attack: Geralt was exposed during the tenths of a second the sword took to return to a guard position, and in those tenths of a second the enemy hit him.
Light attacks were fast with little damage: two hits per second, each taking 3-5% of the enemy's life. Heavy attacks were slow with a lot of damage: one hit every second and a half, each taking 10-15%. Dodge was a short lateral step with 4 frames of invincibility, enough to evade a swipe but not a charge. Roll was a long evasion that took Geralt away from danger but that left him far for a counterattack. Parry reflected the enemy's attack but required precise timing.
George calibrated the parry with the same obsession he had put into the parry of Hollow Knight: a 5-frame window. A sixth of a second. Enough for a skilled player to use it consistently but narrow enough that a casual player preferred dodge. The parry was the expert's tool. The dodge was everyone's tool. And the roll was the desperate player's tool: useful for getting out of impossible situations but that didn't help win a fight because winning required being close to the enemy, not far.
"The combat of the first original version was a glorified quicktime event," George told Elena during a calibration session in which Elena played a combat prototype against a drowner while George adjusted the numbers in real time. "The player clicked at the right rhythm and Geralt chained attacks. It was innovative in 2007 but it didn't feel like fighting. It felt like playing an instrument. Our combat has to feel like fighting: weight in the blows, consequence in the mistakes, and the sense that every victory is earned."
Elena killed the drowner on the fourth try. The first three she died because she attacked too fast and the recovery left her exposed. The fourth try, she waited. She observed the drowner's pattern: swipe, swipe, pause. In the pause, two light attacks. Dodge the next swipe. Two more. Heavy attack when the drowner staggered. Dead.
"It feels fair," Elena said, taking off the headphones with the expression of someone who has just solved a puzzle that had cost her four tries and that she didn't want to cost her three. "The drowner killed me because I made mistakes, not because the game decided to kill me. And I killed it because I learned its pattern, not because I'm stronger."
"That's the line," George said. "If the player feels the game killed him unfairly, we've failed. If the player feels he killed himself by not paying attention, we've succeeded."
* * *
The magic signs were the five tools that separated Geralt from a common swordsman.
Igni: fire. A cone of flames Geralt threw from his hand. It burned enemies, lit torches in dark caves, and could start fires in destructible environments. It was the most satisfying sign because the fire was visual and immediate: the player saw the effect instantly.
Aard: force. A telekinetic shove that knocked enemies down and destroyed obstacles. Useful against groups: a well-placed Aard threw three drowners to the ground and gave time for a heavy attack before they got up. It also opened blocked doors and revealed hidden passages.
Quen: shield. A protective bubble that absorbed a blow. The defensive sign. The player who activated Quen before a fight had a margin of error: a blow that would have killed Geralt without Quen simply broke the shield. It was the life insurance of the cautious player and the crutch of the impatient player.
Axii: mind control. The most narrative sign. Geralt could use it in combat to stun an enemy for 3 seconds, but its main use was in dialogues: Axii allowed manipulating the minds of NPCs to obtain information or avoid conflicts. But George added a condition: if the player used Axii in dialogues, the NPCs who saw it lost trust in Geralt. The sign was useful but it had a social cost. The witcher who controlled minds was the witcher the villagers started to fear.
Yrden: trap. A glyph on the ground that slowed the enemies who stepped on it. The strategist's sign: place an Yrden at an ambush point, lure the enemy toward the trap, attack while the enemy moved in slow motion. It required planning and knowledge of the terrain. It was the least-used sign by casual players and the most-used by experts.
George calibrated them for weeks with Elena, testing each sign against each type of enemy, adjusting the stamina costs, the recharge times, the ranges of effect. Each sign had to be useful without being indispensable: the player who ignored the signs could complete the game with swords alone, more slowly and with more risk. The player who mastered them felt he had an arsenal that multiplied his options without trivializing the challenge.
* * *
The potions were the preparation that turned Geralt into what a witcher was supposed to be: a hunter who studied his prey before facing it.
George designed the alchemy system with one central rule: power had a price. Each potion Geralt drank gave him an advantage, night vision, health regeneration, poison resistance, increased damage, but each potion also increased his toxicity. The toxicity bar was a green line below the health bar. With low toxicity, Geralt was fine. With medium toxicity, the screen started to distort slightly: the edges got blurry, the colors saturated, the audio acquired a metallic echo that suggested reality was bending. With high toxicity, Geralt started to lose health. The potions that made him stronger were killing him at the same time.
"A witcher who fights without preparing is a dead witcher," George wrote in the brown notebook. "But a witcher who prepares too much is also dead."
The player had to decide how many potions to drink before each fight. A Cat potion to see in the dark and a Swallow to regenerate health: low toxicity, moderate benefits. Three potions for a boss fight: medium toxicity, high benefits, risk that the toxicity would kill Geralt before the monster. Five potions for a desperate situation: Geralt became a killing machine for 60 seconds but then the toxicity left him on the brink of death.
The oils for the swords complemented the potions. Specter oil for ghosts. Insectoid oil for insects. Vampire oil for vampires. Each oil increased the damage against a specific type of enemy. The player who arrived at a monster contract without the right oil could complete it, but he took twice as long and spent twice the potions. The player who prepared, who read the bestiary, identified the monster, applied the right oil, drank the appropriate potions, completed it with the lethal efficiency of a professional who knows exactly what he's doing.
"The preparation is the real combat," George said in the design meeting where he presented the complete alchemy system. "The moment of the sword is just the conclusion."
* * *
The monsters of the Continent existed because the world created them.
George designed the bestiary with Sapkowski's philosophy: each monster had an origin, a reason to exist, and a narrative context that connected it to the human world. The monsters were the consequences of the cruelty, the negligence, and the superstition of a society that produced horror and then hired a witcher to clean it up. They weren't generic enemies that appeared on the map for the player to kill.
The strigas were cursed women. A princess her father didn't want, a mother who died in childbirth, a wife who was betrayed. The curse transformed them into beasts that hunted at night with claws and teeth that had been hands and mouth. To kill a striga was easy. To lift the curse was hard and required a whole night of survival next to the creature without killing it, waiting for the dawn to transform it back. The player who chose to lift the curse had to survive 7 minutes of defensive combat without attacking. It was the most tense mission in the game because the difficulty was in not killing rather than in killing.
The drowners were the drowned who returned. People who had died in the water, fishermen, suicides, victims of floods, and who came back as amphibious creatures that dragged the living to the bottom. They appeared near rivers and swamps, always in groups, always at night. They were the most common enemies of Velen and the saddest: the player who read their entries in the bestiary discovered that each drowner had been a person with a name.
The griffins were territorial. They attacked by instinct and not by malice: they protected their nests. A griffin that lived in the mountain over a village attacked the travelers who passed too close to the nest. The griffin contract gave the player the option to kill it or to relocate the nest with the Axii sign, which required more work but left the griffin alive. The player who killed the griffin discovered weeks later that the rodents the griffin controlled had invaded the village and destroyed the crops. Consequences.
Marcus designed each monster with a philosophy he had developed over ten years of drawing creatures for NGS: "A monster that's scary from afar and pitiful up close is a well-designed monster." The concept arts showed the creatures in two versions: the combat version (fierce, terrifying, with teeth and claws and eyes that glowed in the dark) and the context version (the striga before the curse, the drowner when it was a fisherman, the griffin feeding its young). The team's artists used both versions to model: the combat version for the game, the context version for the bestiary illustrations the player unlocked when he killed or studied each creature.
Forty monsters in the initial bestiary. Forty creatures with forty stories. Forty reasons for the player to ask himself, after killing each one, whether killing had been the right answer.
George looked at the complete bestiary on the wall of the art room where Marcus had pasted the forty concept arts in an eight-by-five grid. The creatures looked at him from the wall with the eyes Marcus had given them: eyes that had hunger and pain and something that, if the player stopped long enough to look, resembled human sadness too much to be only monstrosity.
"Are they monsters or are they people?" Elena asked, who was looking at the grid with her head slightly tilted.
"They're both," George said. "And that's the question the player has to ask himself every time he draws the sword."
End of Chapter 130