Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 147: Stamina, the Weapons, and the Man of Two Words

The combat of Dark Souls rested on a green bar the player learned to respect or died without understanding why.

Stamina. Every action the character performed consumed stamina: attacking, dodging, blocking, running, rolling on the ground to avoid a blow. The bar emptied with each action and refilled when the character stayed still, standing in place with the shield down and the sword at rest, waiting. The player who attacked without measuring, three blows, four, five, chasing the enemy and confusing speed with strategy, ran out of stamina and was defenseless during the two seconds the bar took to regenerate. Two seconds was an eternity in Dark Souls. Two seconds was the time a black knight needed to raise his sword and bring it down on a player who couldn't dodge or block or run because the green bar was empty.

George calibrated stamina as the most important resource in the game, above health and above souls. Health was recovered with estus flasks. Souls were recovered by killing enemies. Stamina was recovered only with patience. And patience was what Dark Souls wanted to teach: that combat was won by attacking at the right moment and resting at the right moment, alternating aggression and caution with the rhythm of someone who knows the fight ends when the last enemy falls, not when the first blow lands.

The weapon system amplified the importance of stamina. Each weapon in the game had a complete moveset: light attacks, heavy attacks, lunging attacks, falling attacks, and the special move each weapon executed with both hands. A straight sword was fast and consumed little stamina but did little damage. A greatsword was slow and consumed a lot of stamina but did enough damage to kill a hollow in a single blow. A spear had reach but required space and left the player exposed in narrow hallways.

A bow allowed attacking at a distance but left the player immobile during the shot. Magic consumed a different bar but required the player to stay still during the casting, which meant that a mage in Dark Souls was powerful at a distance and fragile up close, a crystal that could destroy mountains but that broke if someone touched it.

George wanted each weapon to feel different not only in the numbers but in the body. A player who used a greatsword for ten hours and then switched to a straight sword had to feel the change in his fingers: the straight sword responded faster, the attacks came out sooner, the character moved with a lightness the greatsword didn't allow. A player who used a spear had to feel the distance as an advantage and the closeness as a danger. Each weapon was a way of playing, not just a way of dealing damage, and the decision of which weapon to use was a decision of identity: the player who chose the greatsword became a different kind of warrior than the one who chose the straight sword, with different rhythms, different distances, different risks.

George calibrated each weapon frame by frame with the same obsession he had put into the parry of Hollow Knight. Each swing had an exact number of anticipation frames before the blow, of active frames where the blow connected, and of recovery frames where the player couldn't do anything. The anticipation frames were the signal the enemy read to dodge. The active frames were the window where the damage occurred. The recovery frames were the punishment for attacking: the price the player paid for each attempt to deal damage.

A greatsword had 12 anticipation frames, 6 active, and 18 recovery. A straight sword had 5, 4, and 10. The difference was invisible to the casual player but decisive for the expert player, because the expert player counted the frames unconsciously, felt them in the rhythm of his thumbs on the buttons, and the difference between 10 recovery frames and 18 was the difference between being able to dodge the enemy's counterattack and not being able to.

Elena tested the weapons for weeks, playing each one against each type of enemy, documenting the matchups that worked and the ones that didn't, identifying the combinations where the player was at an unfair disadvantage and the combinations where he was at an excessive advantage. The balance was delicate: George wanted each weapon to be viable for completing the entire game, no weapon to be objectively better than another, the choice to be one of preference and not of optimization. A greatsword player and a straight-sword player who completed the same boss should have had different experiences, the greatsword with spaced blows and calculated dodges, the straight sword with fast bursts and constant movement, but with the same perceived difficulty. Different difficulty was injustice. Equal difficulty with a different experience was design.

* * *

Kenji shaped Team Souls with the same patience with which a river shapes a stone: without hurry, without apparent force, with the certainty that time would do the work that urgency couldn't do.

He had been the daily director of Team Souls for nine months and the team of 30 people had changed in a way hard to identify if you looked day to day but evident if you compared the team of June 2009 with that of March 2010. The people were the same. The same 30 people with the same skills and the same personalities. What had changed was their internal standard: the point at which each person on the team considered their work finished had moved, imperceptibly, a little higher each week.

An animator who in June would have delivered an attack animation with 24 frames and considered it finished, in March delivered it with 22 frames because he had discovered that the two extra frames were an excess of anticipation that made the blow feel a millisecond soft. Kenji hadn't told him: he had returned the original animation with an "again" and the animator had found the two frames himself, and the act of finding them had recalibrated his perception of what "finished" meant.

A texture artist who in June would have delivered a stone wall with a resolution that was "good enough" for the distance at which the camera showed it, in March delivered it with a level of detail that exceeded what the camera needed, because the artist had internalized that "good enough" wasn't a standard but an excuse, and that the difference between "good enough" and "right" was the difference between a game the player forgot and a game the player remembered.

Kenji didn't give speeches about quality. He didn't send motivational emails. He didn't organize meetings where they talked about the vision and excellence and the team's values. Kenji worked. He worked more hours than anyone on the team, arriving before eight and leaving after ten, sitting in front of his monitor with the concentration of someone who considers every pixel of the game his personal responsibility. And the team watched how Kenji worked and understood that the standard was what Kenji did, not what Kenji said. That words were cheap and that the hours in front of the monitor were the real currency of someone who believed the work deserved everything you could give it.

George visited Team Souls on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Tuesdays to review the general progress, sitting with Kenji for an hour to see the new builds and discuss the problems that had come up during the week. Thursdays to play: George sat in front of a monitor on the upper floor and played the latest Dark Souls build as a player, with no director's privileges, dying to the same enemies that were going to kill the final player, getting frustrated with the same traps, traveling the same shortcuts with the satisfaction of someone who remembered where they were from his earlier life. The surprise was feigned, but the satisfaction was real.

Each Tuesday the game was better. Better through the accumulation of small corrections Kenji drew out of the team, one by one. A texture with a little more detail. An animation with one less frame of transition. A light effect that was 5% warmer in Firelink and 3% colder in Blighttown. Each correction was invisible on its own. The sum of the corrections was visible like the change of season: you don't see the day the trees change, but one day you look and they're different.

George asked Kenji every Tuesday how it was going. Kenji answered every Tuesday with the same word: "Better." Without explaining how much better or in what. Just "better." And George had learned that "better" said by Kenji was the most complete answer he was going to get, because Kenji didn't elaborate on what could already be seen and because what could be seen was that the game improved with the constancy of something that grows in the right direction without anyone having to explain to it which direction was right.

* * *

There was a moment in the Thursday visits George kept for himself.

After playing the build for two hours, after dying and improving and discovering a new detail Kenji and the team had added during the week, George took off the headphones and walked through the upper floor watching the team work. He set the monitors aside and looked at the faces.

He looked at the animator who was adjusting Sif's collapse when the wolf reached 20% of his health, searching for the exact number of frames that made the limp look like pain without looking pathetic. He looked at the environment artist who was painting the cracks of a wall of Anor Londo with the dedication of someone painting a picture that would hang in a museum, though the picture was a virtual wall in a game and the museum was the screen of millions of people who were going to run past the wall without stopping to look at it, except one in a thousand who would stop and see the cracks and think that someone had put care into a wall no one was going to look at, and that one in a thousand was the person the artist painted for.

He looked at Kenji sitting in front of his monitor at eight at night with the same posture he had at eight in the morning, because Kenji didn't tire the way people who work out of obligation tire. Kenji tired the way people who work out of conviction tire: the body wore out but the attention stayed intact, the eyes kept seeing what they needed to see, the hands kept correcting what they needed to correct.

George thought in those moments that Kenji had done something George wouldn't have been able to do: turn 30 people into an organism that pursued perfection without anyone using the word perfection, because the word was unnecessary when the standard was embodied in a person who worked twelve hours a day and who said only two words: "again" when something wasn't right, and "better" when something approached what it had to be.

Two words. All of Dark Souls was being built on two words a silent man pronounced with the economy of someone who knew that words, like the swords of the game he was building, were better the less you used them.

End of Chapter 147

Comments

No comments found for this post.