Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

★ Public Poll 12 ✦ Mechanics Part 1

  • 🌾 I WANT FARMING 29
  • 🌾 I DON’T WANT FARMING 2
  • 🔨 I WANT CRAFTING 28
  • 🔨 I DON’T WANT CRAFTING 4
  • 🍳 I WANT COOKING 24
  • 🗺️ I WANT SECRET AREAS THAT REQUIRE SPECIAL ABILITIES 26
  • 🧪 I WANT POTION CRAFTING / ALCHEMY 24
  • 🌱 I WANT GARDENING / GROWING PLANTS 24
  • 🪵 I WANT RESOURCE GATHERING 16
  • ⛏️ I WANT MINING 17
  • 🎣 I WANT FISHING 16
  • 🦋 I WANT CRITTER CATCHING 19
  • 🌿 I WANT FORAGING 19
  • 💎 I WANT RARE RESOURCE HUNTING 13
  • 🗝️ I WANT LOCKPICKING 18
  • 🏺 I WANT BREAKABLE OBJECTS / HIDDEN ITEMS 20
  • 🧩 I WANT ENVIRONMENTAL PUZZLES 20
  • 🪓 I WANT TOOLS THAT CAN BE UPGRADED 20
  • 🛍️ I WANT SHOPS WITH ROTATING STOCK 22
  • 🌙 I WANT ITEMS / EVENTS ONLY AVAILABLE AT CERTAIN TIMES 18
  • ❤️ I WANT CHARACTERS TO HAVE FAVORITE GIFTS 24
  • 🛡️ I WANT EQUIPMENT / GEAR 24
  • 🃏 I WANT CARD DUELS 10
  • 🏆 I WANT COLLECTION COMPLETION REWARDS 21
  • 💰 I WANT A DEEP ECONOMY WITH THINGS TO SAVE FOR 6
  • 2026-11-12
  • 464 votes
{'title': '★ Public Poll 12 ✦ Mechanics Part 1 ', 'choices': [{'text': '🌾 I WANT FARMING', 'votes': 29}, {'text': '🌾 I DON’T WANT FARMING', 'votes': 2}, {'text': '🔨 I WANT CRAFTING', 'votes': 28}, {'text': '🔨 I DON’T WANT CRAFTING', 'votes': 4}, {'text': '🍳 I WANT COOKING', 'votes': 24}, {'text': '🗺️ I WANT SECRET AREAS THAT REQUIRE SPECIAL ABILITIES', 'votes': 26}, {'text': '🧪 I WANT POTION CRAFTING / ALCHEMY', 'votes': 24}, {'text': '🌱 I WANT GARDENING / GROWING PLANTS', 'votes': 24}, {'text': '🪵 I WANT RESOURCE GATHERING', 'votes': 16}, {'text': '⛏️ I WANT MINING', 'votes': 17}, {'text': '🎣 I WANT FISHING', 'votes': 16}, {'text': '🦋 I WANT CRITTER CATCHING', 'votes': 19}, {'text': '🌿 I WANT FORAGING', 'votes': 19}, {'text': '💎 I WANT RARE RESOURCE HUNTING', 'votes': 13}, {'text': '🗝️ I WANT LOCKPICKING', 'votes': 18}, {'text': '🏺 I WANT BREAKABLE OBJECTS / HIDDEN ITEMS', 'votes': 20}, {'text': '🧩 I WANT ENVIRONMENTAL PUZZLES', 'votes': 20}, {'text': '🪓 I WANT TOOLS THAT CAN BE UPGRADED', 'votes': 20}, {'text': '🛍️ I WANT SHOPS WITH ROTATING STOCK', 'votes': 22}, {'text': '🌙 I WANT ITEMS / EVENTS ONLY AVAILABLE AT CERTAIN TIMES', 'votes': 18}, {'text': '❤️ I WANT CHARACTERS TO HAVE FAVORITE GIFTS', 'votes': 24}, {'text': '🛡️ I WANT EQUIPMENT / GEAR', 'votes': 24}, {'text': '🃏 I WANT CARD DUELS', 'votes': 10}, {'text': '🏆 I WANT COLLECTION COMPLETION REWARDS', 'votes': 21}, {'text': '💰 I WANT A DEEP ECONOMY WITH THINGS TO SAVE FOR', 'votes': 6}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 12, 16, 50, 3, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 464}

Content

OK.✨

STOP EVERYTHING.

✨FOCUS.✨

THIS IS IMPORTANT.

Like… SUUUPER important.✨

There are a bunch of mechanics and features that we could include in Bring the BEEF, and some of them I really like, some I wouldn’t mind, and some make me wonder if they would actually improve the game… or just become another annoying checklist of things you’re supposed to do every day.

So I need your feedback.

Don’t think about whether a mechanic is “normal” or expected for a cozy RPG.

Think about this:

Would this actually make BTB more fun?

Or would you eventually go:

“ugh, I have to do THIS too?”

SO.✨

Vote for as many as you want:🐒

Files

Comments

Escape the Neighborhood

Personally for almost all of these mechanics I'm fine with as long as there's a purpose, as long as there's something worthy I'm working towards. Some games will just slap in foraging or gardening just... to have it in the game but it needs to have a consistent purpose in line with the goals in the game. Am I crafting to have better gifts to give? Am I gathering/crafting to build areas that will enable certain scenes with the characters? (Like idk how far you're going with some things but just as an example, gathering materials to make leather cuffs/gear to enable some bdsm themed scenes.) Am I gathering/crafting to make accessories or clothes for my avatar or the characters? Will I craft to unlock new areas and meet new guys? Best practice in my opinion is to start with "What does the player WANT? What is the player's end goal? Romance scenes, cute clothes and accessories, sex scenes(if applicable), combat equipment, special art, unlockables, etc." and then work backwards from there on fun and rewarding ways the player can work towards those things. Also I'd ask what is the incentive for these mechanics and (very importantly) is the time spent on the mechanic worth the reward? If a player spends 5 minutes to craft enough items to unlock every scene in the game then why even bother with the crafting system? Alternatively if the player is spending 6 hours doing boring, repetitive tasks just to unlock one CG, are they going to feel satisfied with what they earned or like they wasted their time? (Like how Final Fantasy 15 put me off fishing mini games in every game ever forever. Because it was hard, tedious, and nowhere near rewarding enough to make up for the time I wasted.)