Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Turns out quite a few people were having trouble following the original version of this strip, so I thought it might make more sense with an actual flashback. Hope that's a little clearer!

Files

Comments

Bookbeard

Much clearer with the flashback, thanks Jeph!

aetherspoon

That flashback is ADORABLE.

rhekke

The flashback is quite handy indeed.

Doc Brown

...but she has no hands in the flashback

Jp

I agree with team now I can visualize this better. Thank you. Though the manservant gag was hilarious in the original.

Eric Sieck

Oh wow today I learned that she lost her arms way earlier than I thought (did I miss an earlier reference?)

Jason Scott

god as my witness I thought I had a stroke

Tannerbot

This is cute, but somehow makes it worse.

Stephen Wells

All of you people who can't handle information entirely in plain text, what are you doing in this, er. Graphic. Medium. ... I'll see myself out.

Bookbeard

So far there has not been any indication of when, how or even IF she lost her arms. She may simply have been born without them.

LtDan

Is a cat. Cat has right not to be pet if it doesn't want to be.

Sean Kinlin

Adorable infected wound! 😉

SquigglyComics

That does make a lot more sense, I didn't get how a robot hand could get infected so I assumed she was drunk rambling, I get it more now

Eric Sieck

The way she phrased it makes me think the last one is the case.

Elberik

How'd her hand get infected if it was synthetic?

Bookbeard

Something seems punny about that comment, but I just can't put my finger on it.

Bookbeard

It's those big sad gremlin eyes.

Jay

The illustration shows she wasn't wearing her prosthetics, it's her arm that got infected.

Adrian Bartoli

It was clear to me the first time. It is a fine line compromising the art to explain to the audience.

Bookbeard

That's what the flashback panel is there to clarify, she didn't have her synthetic hands at that point.

Sean Kinlin

The flashback does make things clearer, though it also raises more questions in my mind. Jeph does not need to answer this, of course, but I'm wondering if Liz had lower tech prosthetics at that age, and if so, why she wasn't wearing them (or at least one - presumably she would take one off to feel Platina's fur).

Egos

Oooooo so it's not that Liz had her arms removed, she might have had some genetic condition where they didn't grow properly

Josh Dick

I was initially confused by there being a different person named Hannelore!

Bookbeard

If you're telling a story and something you thought was obvious turns out to be ambiguous, clarifying it is hardly compromising the art. This is precisely what beta readers are for.

Weston Clowney

It does clear things up a bit, but the original just made you empathize with Clinton.

Timothy Roller

Yeah, I totally thought she had chosen to have her arms removed. Also, arm sausage for kitty.

Nathan Walton

Well, I confess I was confused, anyway. Poor Liz.

Josh Dick

Thanks for this, apparently my memory is terrible!

Veronica Jane

When every comment on the original is about how people don't understand what's happening it isn't a compromise to fix it

carmanut

Deeeeeefinitely didn't think she went to pet the cat with her stumps. Is that the right word? Is that insensitive? Damn, I legit have no idea.

GigglingGoblin

I've seen someone say they really don't like that word. I*think* "partial arm" was what they used?

enchantedsleeper

So many questions about cat care, like why was this cat left completely unattended in a classroom over lunch? Where was the manservant at? And will we ever clap eyes on the infamous Hannelore von Schwartzpunkt, nemesis of nemeses?

carmanut

When I was googling it, I saw "residual limb" which didn't sound that much better...

Emily Jane

Ohhhhhhhhh I thought I got it before but I didn’t realize you meant her nubbin until this clarification.

Dalmeir

Oh shit yeah, I totally thought it was her prosthetic that got infected, and I was like "Sure, why not, bacteria can live anywhere I guess" I thought it might be leading up to Clinton mentioning that the first computer bugs were literal bugs inside the computer haha

Bookbeard

Not sure about the sensitivity, but "the remaining portion of a missing limb" is in fact the original meaning of that word. Even the tree-related definition didn't show up until quite a bit later.

carmanut

Oh good lord, just found a recent reddit thread with doctors in residency calling them things like "limbn't"

alphanor

Grade school aged Liz is very cute.

Dalmeir

The fact that this has happened twice, and you were able to remember and locate exactly where, is both impressive and a little frightening.

Rob McBobson

Okay, now I feel like a genius for getting it right from the start.

Miyaa

Liz will now be the heroine for every differently armed people. Especially the ones who are testing out high tech robot arms right now.

Jeff Norman

I just hope we don't get into a tedious "right to bear arms" discussion...

Sean Kinlin

Leaving the cat alone is just another despicable entry in the long red ledger of Hannelore von Schwartzpunkt.

Sean Kinlin

@Dalmeir: This is BookBeard's superpower.

Will

How does a robotic hand become infected?

Paracog Steadham

Do robotic hands dream of petting electric kitties?

Mad Pooka

Thank you, that makes more sense now, I didn't say anything, but I was having trouble following it

Foam0Fett

Do we actually know how she lost her arms? Or if she was just born w/o them?

Bookbeard

As yet unconfirmed, but the "born without them" theory seems increasingly likely.

Bookbeard

I can't help it, it's just what my brain does instead of remembering useless things like names or faces or deadlines. 😅

Rob McBobson

It's a pity that we lost the line "Wait, hold up- a manservant? As in, a man? Who serves?"

Rentapulous

What if: Liz and Schwatrzpunkt were not enemies She was kept away from the cat for safety reasons because she had health issues related to her arms The cat bit her and caused a bad infection Her parents were furious; sued and won for a considerable sum The Von Schwatzpunkt family decided to keep Liz away from their daughter for fear of more mishaps and lawsuits Liz, being a child at the time, made the whole story about her and her nemesis because that's how children see the world

Eva Grimm

Much clearer, thank you!

Uniquitous

Poor anti-virus protection?

Comics Ladybird

I must admit I had to go back and forth a few times between the 4th and 5th panels of the originally proposed update before I could reconstitute the chronology; there are clearly too many retroactively-applying chronological pieces of information being communicated here for it not to come with some sort of illustration… (everyone can now resume commenting on the events of the strip)

SpookyPenguin

I still don't unnerstand why that naughty cat bit ower Liz. She's perfectly 'armless.

Bookbeard

It's possible she simply didn't have one at that point. Providing properly fitted prosthetics for children is notoriously difficult because they are expensive and children keep outgrowing them (although growth spurts have clearly not been a huge issue for Liz).

Kurt Larson

I did have to think about it for a few seconds, but I got it. Didn't really take me out of the narrative... But the new drawings are well worth the correction. *Seeing* Liz as a child with no prosthetics really helps fill out her backstory.

Lucanid Landman

As someone who works in healthcare, we usually say 'residual limb'.

Rob McBobson

No, "cat" isn't insensitive, but "fluffball" and "litte cuddlypants" are the preferred terms.

Matt

I like it. Breaks up the talking heads and is frankly, super cute.

Ahmed Tedjini

Honestly I prefer v1 but I guess I'm in the minority lol

allanfranta

@BookBeard: Use these powers only for good!

Finvaara

I understood the first one, but I like this one better

Bryentt Engelhardt

Thanks, I re-read it a few times before I came to that conclusion. Glad it was clarified

Captain Button

She will be why Hannelore E-C Releases the Virus.

Doc Gumby

It does flow better this way I think, thanks Jeph!

David Durant

In shock news, not everyone is you.

Diptych

Please have a closer look at panel 4.

David Durant

All I can think about is how few more years Liz has in a normal grade school environment at that point before she's off to university for the double-Phd timeline to work.

alphanor

I tend to agree at this point.

awgiedawgie

My best friend's oldest brother graduated from high school at 14, and graduated from medical school at 18. With Liz's level of genius, I can see her pulling it off a year younger.

Wild Card

How does an artificial hand become infected from a cat bite? Broken (wires cut, etc) I can see, but it is not biological so it shouldn't get infected.

Diptych

Have another look at panel 4.

Sean Kinlin

I just realized that the flashback uses the Bembo color scheme. ETA: well, the colors that were used one or two years, anyway. The last couple rounds were all grayscale.

Jared

Seeing it like this makes me think the doctor was joking about the amputation since she was already armless, possibly also to scare her into not hiding injuries. Admittedly I was under the impression she received surgery for this event from the previous version.

Michael

It was probably stressed out like crazy. Cats don't like unfamiliar places or people.

Law the Fox

😭😭😭 NO I WANT TO HUG AND COMFORT LITTLE GREMLIN

Law the Fox

That doesn't change that I want to give them, only if she will accept them. If she doesn't, I will be sad.

will davison

Ty. I’m the one person who needed clarification. It was just me.

Zak Reichle

I choose to believe Bembo is also dutch.

Thisguy

Well, while I understood the first one well enough, this does make it clear that she didn’t have hands at that point, just stumps, which then became infected. … While cats don’t need an excuse to bite, I can imagine that this cat may not have liked someone waving big thick sausages in its face.

JCfromNC

Yes, this does make it a lot clearer. Thanks for changing it, I appreciate the extra work you did.

JCfromNC

That was quite the ride.

Clifton Royston

Or a really really bad accident at a very early age; it can happen. A FOAF's small daughter had an accident where she lost both legs below the knee.

David Paul

While I followed the flow of the conversation in the original, I do like this version with the flashback better. Thank you, Jeph 😊

Pete

This is still not a meaningful thing for a doctor to say, unless the doctor was an asshole failing at dark humour.

Comics Ladybird

Three moons (and two chapters), from wherever that beach was to the doors of Freëhya, on the back of a pteroncle? I have to agree it is quite the ride.

Sydney J Freedberg

Flashback panel is helpful but now I'm wondering how Liz did any schoolwork without some kind of prosthetics.... maybe whatever she used in grade school had crappy haptic feedback so she took them off to pet the cat ?

Josh

I’m only now realizing that Gremlin didn’t say the cat bit her in the hand, like I assumed. Awesome clarification, Jeph!

Josh

Check panel 4–this was pre-prosthesis!

Wild Card

Thank you, I missed that it was before she got her artificial arms.

Sparky

Flashback makes it sadder