Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

(it was TS Eliot)

Files

Comments

Doc Gumby

Careful with that Spatula, Eugene...

Jay

Panel 4 speech bubble pointing the wrong way?

C-Cubed

I think the speech bubble in the 3rd panel is pointing towards the wrong person.

ValdVin

I feel Dora here. I can write more than acceptably whatever I think, but I can't bullshit my way through something I don't understand. Whenever people think "He's a good writer" it's because I stay in my lane until I learn something out of my lane. Chaucer was never assigned to me. I did understand Sinclair Lewis easily enough, which was my gateway drug to reading Booth Tarkington for pleasure.

Daniel S

Yeah there’s a misplaced speech bubble there

Tudza

I will show you fear in a really shitty final essay.

Holly Nelson

My advice: write the crappy thing first, then go in and edit. With a machete, if necessary.

Tannerbot

Sounds like my college expirience too. Gods I hated the English classes.

Miyaa

My best advice for science writing is actually don’t write for any longer than 30 minutes at a time and don’t research and organize your thoughts for more than 45 minutes straight. Take very frequent breaks, Liz! (I have followed a English PHD major who has a TikTok account and lives in Andorra who takes breaks and rewards herself with a shot from a glass barrel of whiskey after 6 hours of successful writing and breaks.)

Kyle Major

Its possible the speech bubble is pointed in the wrong direction in the second to last panel

Doc Gumby

I thought it might be also.

Jose Alfredo Villalobos

The road manager of the band AC/DC had a good piece of advice. “When you’re doing poorly at something, slow down. When you’re doing great, slow down.” Find your rhythm.

Carrie

The speech bubble could be Dora asking a rhetorical question for teaching the Gremlin.

awgiedawgie

Or with a Malaysian Battle Spatula.

VC

Voice throwing?! In this economy?!

alphanor

I always thought that critiquing/trying to explain literature was a total bullshit endeavor. I mean, the takeaway from reading is different for every person. If you don't match up with the teacher/professor's opinion, you're screwed!!

ValdVin

Am I the only one who wonders how Liz recognizes a "sharpened spatula"?

Miyaa

Since meteorology research is basically about reviewing archived data, I had to put in hard limits on that because it’s really easy for hours to pass by and watching the same satellite or radar loops.

alphanor

People worry too much about the speech bubbles. Figure it out.

Adam

Is Liz supposed to be the one talking in the 4th panel?

Diptych

Lately, when I've struggled to write something, I've thought of a line from Dorothy L. Sayers' Gaudy Night. The protagonist, struggling to write a letter about a sensitive issue, asks herself 'Why can’t I write a straightforward piece of English on a set subject?'. Recognising that - that writing can be simply a matter of recognising what point you're trying to communicate and doing so as effectively as possible - unblocks her.

Joseph Bonnar

As a certified Gremlin, Gremlizabeth has been trained to recognize all weapons she is able to wield: A penknife, a punknife, a tire iron, and all forms of battle spatulas.

Steve McSheffrey

The worst was how subjective it could be. I did the type of story structure the assignment called for but set it in a fantasy world. Professor refused to read it.

alphanor

When I saw Dora whapping Marten, I wondered the same thing. It 's big, but it doesn't look sharp.

Diptych

Also, per the caption, how are we generally feeling about T. S. Eliot? I rather like his work and have enjoyed writing about it in the past, personally.

Chas Simmons

Since people are giving writing advice, I'll add my two-bits worth. Concentrate on the reader's convenience. Remember that you know what you intend to say (I hope), but the reader doesn't yet know, or why is he reading it? In particular, your reader should never have to use the semantics (the meaning) to parse your sentences; what word applies to what thing should be a matter of syntax only. For example, unless you are writing riddles, the reader should never have to figure out what a pronoun refers to.

Diptych

Maybe she was honing it off-screen?

Jenea Ylinen Fredrickson

This is similar to how we test students where I am. We break it up and take absolutely no longer than 30 mins.

alphanor

But you can usually figure it out without much effort.

Diptych

Disagree. It's about how skilfully you construct and support your interpretations. A good teacher will recognise a well-made argument, even if they personally disagree with it, and vice versa.

DodgerEmerson

"Write drunk; edit sober" (Hemingway)

bunnitos

I came to the comments to point this out as well. Pretty sure that's the case.

Rob Vary

Yeah you can, but it's still distracting and something that any creator would want to correct.

Ash

Prufrock was my fucking jam. Also the Hollow Men. And I think the speech bubble in the second to last panel should probably be pointing at Liz. (From experience, the best advice for getting over writers block is never to listen to anyone’s advice on how to get over writers block and try to write silly stuff every day until your brain-toilet flushes itself)

Tannerbot

Well, for me, I was too immature to be away from home for school. Once I grew up, it went better.

Diptych

Sure - there are lots of things we can generally figure out - but we still try to communicate clearly and without errors. It's part of providing a smooth reading experience without unwanted distractions. Unless Jeph is aiming to create a kind of Brechtian Verfremdungseffekt, he'll probably fix the tail.

Diptych

Write in haste; edit at leisure.

Joe Bocanegra

How does this writing advice fit into my slashfic of toaster ovens and a certain ex-cop? Asking for Pintsize. #nonsequitur

alphanor

There are not that many good teachers out there who will put that much effort into it, as cynical as that sounds. Certainly at the college level, where much of the reading and evaluation of classwork is done by teaching assistants.

Ben R

They moved after Jeph finished.

alphanor

Still it's not worth complaining about, although from the number of likes to the comments made here, not too many people agree.

ValdVin

Huh. When I saw Dora whapping Marten I was wondering what role that implement may have played in interpersonal relations.

Ben R

Last college final I took was in a film class I took for fun and then had fun doing other things...so I had to write an essay comparing 2 films for 1/3 of the final, and of which I'd only seen 1. At that point I said to myself "Self, this is the culmination of all you have learned at college; go get it".So I studied the question, wrote mostly about the film I'd seen and made vague references to the other. Got a C and was very self-congratulatory. Really wasted money the way I went to school.

Adam

I talk like that sometimes, and refer to myself in the third person and then answer my own question, but the context suggested it wasn't that.

Diptych

This is the way the word ends This is the way the word ends This is the way the word ends Not with an interrobang but with a tilde nya~

Bookbeard

It's not complaining, it's helping. Whether you realize it or not, we are all paying to be beta readers.

Luke

The best writing advice I've ever heard applies to any type of work: 'sit in the chair'.

Dev

There's a difference between it not being done well in educational contexts and it being a bullshit endeavor. Exploring what literature has to say on a deeper level than just what the words are directly communicating is an important skill.

Jay

Liz' mouth is open and Dora's isn't.

Diptych

Depends on the university and the class, I daresay - I've had a lot of classes where the coursework was assessed by the courserunner/s, not the tutors (if any).

William Cole

Prufrock through Waste-Land are great. I was never really able to get into the later poetry or the plays. The less said about Practical Cats, the better.

Pejo

Jeph reads the comments & often fixes stuff like this between Patreon & the live site. He did so just yesterday. It's worth mentioning, & it's not worth going after people who do.

Diptych

Yeah - it's proofreading, not complaining. There's zero malice or ill-feeling in it. We all know everyone makes little mistakes here and there.

William Cole

So, we finally get to SEE the famed spatula! A momentous day in QC history.

Bookbeard

I was thinking the same thing actually. I know it's probably wrong, but there's definitely a way to read it that makes it work.

Jay

I'm not worried about it, it's an easy mistake to overlook and I don't think Jeph would want to leave it there if he was aware of it. These things happen and he's fixed them before. No big deal.

Simon

Was Liz supposed to say that in panel 3? Cause it feels like Dora's just making her point worse

Bookbeard

I mean, maybe not *any* type of work. Electric chair executioner springs to mind.

Buck Caldwell

What ever became of Wil, anyway?

Jeph Jacques

thanks for the heads up! after spending a couple hours drawing I just don't see these things anymore

Not that Patrick Foltz

By the shape of the head, and it appears to be drawn with an angled head too. Specially spatulas can be sharp. It could be a recognisable type in QCVERSE

Finvaara

I would have assumed Dora was talking in the 3rd person as an example in that 3rd panel, if not for her facial expression in the 4th.

Not that Patrick Foltz

Spatulas are typically thin steel and could be easily sharpened without looking sharp. It is quite sharp regardless of it's edge

Skyger

Is the speech bubble in panel five supposed to point to Liz or Dora?

Matthew Delahaye

Hey, do you know how much you can sell artisanal thrown voices for? It's the perfect side hustle!

Cole Blackblood

Write the garbage, edit it into something pretty later. At least you'll have started at all, and have something to work with.

Matthew Fuchs

I think you've got the speech bubble in panel 4 pointing the wrong way.

Carl Fink

Sincere compliment: nice to know you're a grownup. Not everyone is grateful for that stuff.

Graydon Armstrong

Write the crappy thing first, then be too fed up with it to edit. But at least it's done.

Bookbeard

Or you'll just end up writing something else, but it's still better to write garbage you'll never use than to write nothing at all. Every brilliant writer has a folder full of crap they'll never show anyone, it's part of the process.

Dean Reilly

Liz spent years training under the legendary Battle Spatula Masters.

Carrie

Yes! Something to revisit, other times to burn. 😏😅

Yenni Desroches

Not sure if this link will show up, but I found great help from the leveling up abilities aspect of this comic. It's so easy to see yourself as doing horribly but that's just you realizing you have more to learn from where you are at. Improvement comes from when you learn to advance past what you saw as inadequacies. Graph from DeviantArt user "Shattered-earth" titled "Art Cycle" It shows the ability improvement over time with highlights of periods of 'perceived lack of skill' vs 'perceived skill' against a second line of 'skill at seeing or evaluating art' https://www.deviantart.com/shattered-earth/art/Art-Cycle-329593292

Josh

Huh. My ability to evaluate art was always much higher than my ability to create it, and any attempts to improve the latter also improved the former just as much. I think that's why I was never able to be an artist: I I could never enjoy the process of creation or practice, because I never liked the output, and I never perceived meaningful improvement. The one exception is cooking. I'm a talented, creative, improvisational cook. I suppose it's because I always need to eat, so I had to cook, and as long as I was cooking, I might as well try to make it as good as I could. There was always a reason to try again, and even an aesthetic failure was at least a nutritional success.

Holly Nelson

Yay! Another Sayers fan. -waves-

Holly Nelson

Was it Twain, or Thurber, or Strunk … can’t remember, but one of them said "Your reader may be trying to follow your essay, but could be derailed by poor punctuation or word choice … if you think they might have trouble following you, you need to throw them a line and help them out."

Nulgar

Dora, that's highly unsanitary, you don't know where Marten has sat before! Pull down his pants first.

Darius Jenai

Is the "Okay, but how do I get past that?" supposed to be Liz? It makes more sense that way, I think

LH

excellent, i'll follow your advice by not following your advice

Miyaa

So how soon before Hanners meets a sexy female firefighter/EMT?

Yelling Bird

Writing is one of the things I do well. I should, I spent 7 years getting a BA in English with a minor in Creative Writing. And no, that wasn't meant to be a flex. Seven years, seven majors.

Bookbeard

Thank you! I knew we had seen it before but I couldn't find it yesterday.

Diptych

Hello! She's fantastic, isn't she?

Todd Ellner

The poet William Stafford had the best advice. "Lower your standards and keep writing."

William Cole

BookBeard couldn't find a strip? That's an even MORE momentous day in QC history.

PixelThis

I think the arrow in panel 4 is going the wrong way...

Todd Ellner

Dora should not do that without both Marten and Claire's permission

SpookyPenguin

process is the operative word, if you never do anything you don't have a process

SpookyPenguin

I think the biggest stumbling block to any artistic process is valuing what you have to say, sometimes its a hard road to find that because self-belief is difficult to sustain. As is mixing metaphors :P

KiTA

Came to say the same thing

Clifton Royston

That's how I read it the first time, and then on a second look decided it would make more sense for Liz.

Clifton Royston

Oh I love Dorothy Sayers' mysteries and I've read them since my teens; I adore how well she paints Harriet Vane, and 'Gaudy Night' is one of her best. And I also really liked Prufrock once it clicked for me, and that carried over to the Wasteland and the Hollow Men. Practical Cats is just fine IMO, it's silly fun and never meant to be taken seriously.

ellafine

I'm intrigued by the look on Marten's face in the first panel and curious to see if there are repercussions from this

09Klr650

Is the wrong character asking how to get past it? And she needs to be careful spanking him, someone else reserves that kink now :)

Mad Marie

You know you're in trouble when the material looks like Chaucerian English and it's actually just EB White.

Digi

Which is why it's incredibly difficult to proofread your own work.

Ash

“How fleeting are all human passions compared with the massive continuity of ducks”

mike stone

“If it’s worth doing, it’s worth doing badly.”. The problem is wanting to move forward in unreasonably large steps. Taking three steps is more exercise than getting depressed over not being able to run a marathon. Scatching out a barely coherent half sentence is more writing than deciding you have writer’s block because you can’t crank out award winning work as a first draft. Write something that sucks, then write something that sucks less. Each pass solves a problem with a previous one, and clears space for you to discover the next problem. Solving those problems is where all the creativity happens, but the whole freakin’ world wants to tell us it’s a waste of time and only the final product matters.

Charles Hirst

I always had troubles with essays! I can write technical manuals and poetry, but when I was asked to write a report, they used mine as the Executive Summary and a sales-being then wrote the preceding xx pages of waffle.

Carl Cravens

Which is why writing college papers can be so hard.

NWN Mechanic

is the speech bubble in panel #3 pointing at the wrong character?

Marc Zuckerman

I think you meant panel #4? First panel, bottom row, yeah? And yes, I think you're correct.

allanfranta

@diptych - I thought the phrase was "marry in haste repent at leisure", which was fun translating into Spanish for some ladies in Antofagasta, Chile.

allanfranta

When I was 18, I would argue with the teachers (Screw the grade, I'm RIGHT, dammit!). By the time I went back to school 2 decades later, I realized that for some of the teachers it was better to just write from their perspective, get the grade, THEN argue if it was really worth it, and it generally wasn't. (I'm not sure if it's telling but my history and calculus profs was more amenable to this than the business English teacher, she had an agenda.)

allanfranta

I think we need to attribute this one to Holly Nelson, good job!

allanfranta

If someone wants to destroy a budding author, they just read and critique the aspiring authors private notebooks. Once that writing has been violated, it's really hard to get back to it. Remove anyone in your life who disrespects you like that.

allanfranta

The best part of "Cooking as Art One Shares" is you can eat the good results and toss the bad and make pizza. If you screw up the pizza, fold it and half and have a calzone.

allanfranta

minor correction, should it be "worth doing poorly"?

allanfranta

Do some people not read the comments before commenting?

mike stone

The version I first heard used ‘badly’. ‘Poorly’ can turn abusive. It’s ‘running a marathon but your time is 3x the average’ territory. That’s how you decide the most you can do won’t even be disappointing. ‘Badly’ replaces ‘is it any good?’ with ‘is it more than nothing?’. It answers all negative self-talk with, “yep.. still worth it” leaving you nothing to do but take the next not-good-enough step.

Leak

Yes. Why?

Bookbeard

I don't know if anyone's ever mentioned this, but I think some people don't read the comments before commenting.

Bookbeard

I would hazard a guess that Marten does his best not to associate spanking with sexy times, because of what his mother does for a living.

allanfranta

I should have taken that sociology class...

Hugh Eckert

I'm a big fan of Four Quartets...

Ash

It’s the gleam of danger along the sharpened side…

Someonelse

I'm fascinated by this exchange. No matter how many times I read them in my head, I don't pick up any difference in meaning between "worth doing poorly" and "worth doing badly". I guess there's some culture-specific connotations at play. I think I would have reached for "badly" just because "poorly" sounds very slightly old-fashioned to me - like saying "dear" for "expensive", but not quite as marked.

Joe

you might wanna lay off the shibby

Graeme Lewis

See, this is why I loaded the comments before adding my 2¢. I figured someone else might've noticed what I did and said something, so I looked before I leapt.

ValdVin

Tangent: "Every artist has 100,000 bad drawings inside them. The sooner you complete them the sooner you get better." (--Chuck Jones, paraphrased)

awgiedawgie

When you develop a kitchen tool deadly enough to be used in battle, you can name it whatever you want.

awgiedawgie

The first rule of writing is to write. It could be utter nonsense, but it gets the mind working. If you refuse to write because you can't think of anything "good", you will stagnate. And then you will *never* think of anything "good" to write.

Miyaa

Marie hasn’t been the same since Pintsize got his current body.

Miyaa

I spent 10 years and going to three colleges to try to get a BS in meteorology. Then I spent another 4 years getting a Masters. If it has to take a long time, so be it.

Miyaa

Yes, but those were sexy male firefighters/EMTs. There still is hope for Hannelore.

enchantedsleeper

Looks like Jeph has fixed it even in the Patreon version, possibly to stop us all asking XD

enchantedsleeper

Is the writing part Liz's problem? I thought the real problem was that she didn't know what to *research*. Surely writing it up is several steps down the line from there...

Miyaa

I wonder if students from other countries hate their native language’s class? Do students in France complain, «Dieux, je déteste mon cours de Français ?» (🍎 Translate so I’m sure it could be better translated.)

Tannerbot

All those Russian kids complaining about how Dostoyevsky is a pretentious fuck.

Miyaa

I’m surprised Wil & Penelope haven’t eloped and spent their honeymoon taking care of Hemingway’s polydactyl cats in Key West.

mike stone

English is full of synonyms with slightly different meanings. You find the differences by swapping them in different contexts, like the old joke: "I'm sorry" and "forgive me" mean the same thing unless you're telling someone their Grandma just died. Try "badly" versus "poorly" in settings where you don't want to offend someone.

Charles Hirst

In my case, it's lots of incomplete text files on the hard drives of dead PCs - they convert to chunky USB drives if you have an adaptor.

Charles Hirst

I've had occasions when I've just hit reply only to find another reply beating me to it.

allanfranta

I hear you, Charles. It gets hot and heavy in here!

Someonelse

Oh, I absolutely agree that words are rarely completely synonymous, but in this particular case, I'm genuinely struggling to pick up why one would be more offensive. If somebody told me I'd done something "badly" *or* "poorly", I'd take that as a pretty strong criticism. Is it that you read "poorly" as inherently "less good" than "badly"? Or that one is about effort, and the other about results? For context, I'm a millennial from southern England; no idea if that is a different background to you, and might explain some dialectal difference?

mike stone

I read ‘bad’ as a base concept word: I can’t think of a simpler, more general, or less ambiguous word to replace it. It offers the least freedom to say, “I didn’t mean to be harsh.” I read ‘poor’ as a hedge word: one with a negative meaning, but less direct than ‘bad’. To me it indicates a lesser degree of failure and accepts more possibility of partial success than ‘bad’.

Russell or Russ

TS Eliot being an unbearable subject is not on you. There's only so much you can do with that twat waffle.