Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

mmm spaghettification

Files

Comments

Doc Gumby

Plausible cunnilingus is the best kind.

Andrew

I cannot WAIT for her first fic

Inflim

Wait until it's revealed it was written by another former classmate

Miyaa

No. Just no.

Miyaa

Doctor Who isn’t that much better, Liz.

Rob McBobson

That always interested me: Why is some fake science so much more acceptable than other fake science? IfLuke Skywalker starts flapping his arms, no faster than a real person can, and it lets him fly, we'd call that unrealistic. But if laser beams from laser guns are much slower than actual light speed, we accept that.

Michael

Smart move gremlin

Amelia Lewis

Is that what "pleasurable" sounds like when it's mumbled?

Alex Mullenix

This has to be setting up a new career path for Liz as science smut writer, right?

Darkstand

While I tend to agree with her - plot holes in books and movies bother me more than other people it seems - I will make this observation: as the level of scientific knowledge of the reader goes up, so does the definition of 'bare minimum of scientific plausibility'. In addition to lazy/hack writers, you can also run into similar issues in science fiction written long enough ago, since the baseline scientific knowledge shifted.

Asthmatic Space Gimp

Hey, I made sure the people affected by the solar laser explosion in my Alien Lesbian Pirate Fanfic FELT the shockwave before they heard it! I have Standards™!

Daryl Sawyer

In my experience, the phrase "plot hole" means "I don't understand what happened there, therefore there is nothing to understand."

Daryl Sawyer

Liz, getting out of a black hole by going really fast is the least I've heard. I once saw a starship escape a black hole through "a crack in the event horizon".

Populuxe

The scientific method • Make an observation. • Ask a question. • Form a hypothesis, or testable explanation. • Make a prediction based on the hypothesis. • Test the prediction. • Iterate: use the results to make new hypotheses or predictions. In other words, who’s going down on Liz first?

BobC

If the bad science in my fanfic is canon, IT STAYS!

Amelia Lewis

Movie physics? Because we expect everything, regardless of environment and technology, to work like known things. So distance weapons work like guns, or like long sticks; melee weapons are like swords and staves, vehicles are cars or airplanes or sometimes (rarely more like helicopters or boats, depending). But airplanes behave more like wwii fighters than modern jets, and boats often behave in very unboatlike ways (especially if they're driven by wind or muscle). For that matter, if it's a fantasy and there are animals, they'e more likely to behave like modern style vehicles (park your horse), or maybe like pets. To connect it has to be an analog of something current, maybe?

Darkstand

I used it here in the 'contradiction in lore/events' way, but I think your response mosly sums up the issue. Most people just go 'eh, whatever' and move on.

Viktor

The more familiar we are with the thing in question, the harder it is to ignore problems with it. Most people have a lot of experience with arms, more than even laser scientists will have with lasers(except for really bad laser scientists), which makes something weird with arms stand out more than something weird with lasers. There’s also the question of how something was established. We see laser guns early in Star Wars, we learn the rules. When something changes those rules(Vader catching Han’s lasers in ESB), it’s treated as a big deal. The Star Wars movies therefore have laser guns, and people can understand them. We’ve never seen someone fly by flapping their arms, in fact we often DONT see people doing that in the setting despite situations where it would be useful. Therefore Luke doing that would be a significant change to people’s understanding of the setting, and will make people think about the movie in a way that often prevents enjoying it.

William Cole

Or, who does she go down on first?

TIPDucky

I've got to know where you saw this.

dcy665 .

Did you take a picture?

David Durant

This feels like an attempt to summon a Weinersmith or perhaps Randal Munroe character cameo to science-up said document!

dcy665 .

I would suggest that is part of the situation but is not the defining limiting it. Fringe, a fringe Sci Fi series had either time travel or multidimensional travel. Things going places they have no right to be there. It was, however, very credible. It was delivered with complete commitment to the show's belief being valid. It was also, pretty damned enjoyable. So, depends on the audience, and to some extent, how far out past the edge the writer/creators are willing to go. I enjoyed Space Balls, but the mere thought of a series of sequels would cause me to squeal in pain.

Darkstand

I'll take a crack at that one - breaks from reality that are more fantastical (and less falsifiable) sit better. The reader does not understand the inner workings of the laser gun, but most children know flapping your arms wont let you fly. The same works for magic - you dont have magic, so who are you to say? As long as the stated rules stay consistant, it all works out.

Adam

Only if we get to read it! Maybe Jeph is wanting to exercise his other creative muscles under her name as a pseudonym.

Bookbeard

So you're saying we need a way to get characters from other comics into this universe? Perhaps we should try flying really fast at the event horizon.

Robin

They should NOT have sent a poet!

Darnel D Cooper

LOL, I need to read about what she actually knows about sex vice science.

Ricardo Bittencourt

She would like read Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality.

Jennifer Doyle

Thank you for this. I shall remain occupied for...a while.

Bookbeard

One of the only fanfics I've ever actually read. I've never been particularly interested in fan fiction but it came recommended by a friend. I liked the idea of it more than the execution though, it drags on a bit.

Joe

yeah, but have you watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate??

Bookbeard

Yeah, but the beauty of Doctor Who is that they're clearly not trying to be consistent about the science of that universe. The rules of time travel are whatever the narrative requires and they've never made any attempt to hide it. I respect that.

Jeff Gedney

Now is when our favorite squishy portal shows up and develops a healthy fixation on fanfic… just watch

Jeff Gedney

I always headcanoned Star Wars blasters and light sabers as plasma weapons and they are using magnetic fields to carry packets of plasma which is why they move slower than light, emit light along their path, and bounce off magnetically sealed trash compactor doors.

Jeff Gedney

Where I finally lost me was starkiller base sucking up an entire fucking Star to power the ray. Lazy ass writing, that. The energies involved, the sheer masses involved, the very nature of stars… all easily looked up with a google search

Brooks Moses

Didn't we also have an espresso dinosaur jump forward in time from the very counter across the room from Liz, or am I misremembering? I am probably misremembering.

Miyaa

In a not so surprising twist, it will be Hannelore Von Swartzpunkt. You know enemies to frienemies to friends to friends with benefits.

Brooks Moses

True enough, but it definitely did something that seems incompatible with everything dreamt of in Liz's cosmology. (Also, it did happen again as https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2309 for some inexplicable reason, which confused me when I started reading forward from there to figure out when it came back. Thank you for the proper links!)

Carl Fink

OK, @Jeph: we need the espresso-pooping dinosaur to appear in Coffee of Doom behind Liz's back, so she is never aware of it, then phase out again (back to comic 1978) before she turns around.

Daryl Sawyer

Star Trek: Voyager, S1E3 "Parallax"

Miyaa

This threads reminds of a video I saw from a podcast that roasted Star Wars for being so far removed from science fiction that they started by saying, “Star Wars is so bad they justified ships going at the speed of light by saying ‘go to light speed.’”

Doug DeJulio

That... is a really fair point. ...and now I'm wondering if "the alphabet trick" works with mathematical equations. I usually use Tengwar and try to spell out the ring inscription or crap like that.

JD

and now we’ve seen a glimpse into Liz’s future: writing wildly popular scientifically accurate smut

Bookbeard

That's because Star Wars isn't science fiction, it's space fantasy. You can call them jedi and lightsabers all you want, but that doesn't make them not wizards and swords.

Charles Hirst

I can handle improbable/impossible science in SF as long as there is no attempt to explain it! Magic is unexplained technology and vice versa. Artificial gravity and "beam me up" are no problem, but I gave up on an Andre Norton book where the description of an airship engine implied a perpetual motion device - however the airships of Barzoom were fine.

Bookbeard

And when it appears Emily is riding on its back dressed in full Doc Brown cosplay for reasons that will never be explained.

Graydon Armstrong

I dunno, implausible opens up a lot more fun options.

Graydon Armstrong

He'd better have already snapped up an account for her before one of us degenerates does.

Graydon Armstrong

Fellatio is “rocket” science. The science part may or may not need quotes.

Joseph Bonnar

Regarding the word Cantilever: I remember Dora using it to abort some attack by (I think) station. NOW I gotta see if I can find that comic...

Graydon Armstrong

Hey, it didn't come back with an espresso! What gives?!

Joseph Bonnar

OOOHHH, I beat BookBeard. Check the time stamps! :)

Brian

That is one of the best and funniest things I’ve ever read.

Graydon Armstrong

Sorry to say, I'm showing BookBeard beat you by 2 minutes...

SpookyPenguin

Oh Liz you're going to be *so* disappointed by HP fanfic.

Bookbeard

That's only because Emily gave me a quick ride back in her time machi-I MEAN... NOTHING! YOU HEARD NOTHING!

SilverbackRon

The sad truth about the state of affairs in modern fan-fic.

Adam

What a sentence!

Shane Wegner

No see Dr, in Mass Effect, they discovered "Eezo", Element-0, an atom with zero protons and zero electrons. If you run a high current through it, it reduces the apparent mass of other atoms (of your spaceship) to zero, allowing you to comply with relativity and go faster than light. It also interacts with some organic beings, giving them telekinetic powers and making their booties extra firm and thicc. This is know as the "Ass Effect".

Yelling Bird

I've been working on a piece that takes place in the near future. I've had to learn a LOT of shit to even try to keep it realistic.

Clifton Royston

I suddenly realize there are generations of people now who didn't start with Usenet and therefore *haven't* heard of Elf Sternberg as a legend.

Onyx

..........................a justified opinion

David Paul

@Stephen Wells that would actually suit her. She'll do the calculations on the three-body problem, while the author is writing up a "three-body problem"...

David Paul

Drunken shenanigans aside... not really, no.

Mark

Tailsteak's latest comic https://forwardcomic.com/firstpage.html (which assuming that he finishes at around #1000 as he has his previous two is about 1/3 done, although it feels to me as if it has barely started) bears a resemblance in some aspects (e.g. economically) to that in-universe fiction, but is obviously not the same.

Mark

It sticks the landing, though.

panpolypuff

More like a *cumsultant*, amirite?

allanfranta

my neighbor was reading that last summer...

allanfranta

Opus, I think she was expressing a preference for the act, but not the actor. And she has demonstrated in the past that she likes the big ones...

allanfranta

Bookbeard, make sure you aim for the crack! In the event horizon!

allanfranta

Research material received. Awaiting grant money.

Hawkeye

This is why I prefer my smut to be science-free. So I can get down to the dirty details without getting hung up on the technical details.

allanfranta

That reminded me of the tootsie pop commercials, "How many licks...". on an unrelated note, how many people have sprained their tongues?

Doug DeJulio

Eleven. The number of people who have sprained their tongues is exactly eleven. I counted.

Robert Wrigley

so...I see hard-science fan-fiction writing in Liz's future. "hard" is a double entendre here...

Doc Gumby

Niven, Simak, Bear...

Bagge

In the future, someone will have a REALLY hard time to please Liz

Miyaa

I see someone had a great time with the significant other last night.

Miyaa

We are not worthy!

Ben R

It's like looking for realism...or a hidden message...in a Hallmark movie.

MisterVimes

A really *hard* time you say?

Photon

Don't forget Sturgeon! Hard Science with a warm heart...

Photon

Rule of Cool, right?

Maurice Kessler

Hooboy. And now I'm hearing dozens of angry-Trek-nerd voices, arguing about "lack of plausibility in detached engine nacelles". SMH

Clifton Royston

But the important question is do they have an accurate depiction of Aer Lingus?

Stephen Wells

@Opus we know she's very into Evan in particular and large-breasted ladies in general. And she's currently reading a lesbian-themed fanfic. There seems to be no indication of heterosexuality about her :)

Stephen Wells

You're THE Elf Sternberg?!! We are truly not worthy!

OldGoat

Does Liz have a Fetlife account?

ValdVin

"In episode 2F09, when Itchy plays Scratchy's skeleton like a xylophone, he strikes that same rib twice in succession yet he produces two clearly different tones. I mean, what are we, to believe that this is some sort of a, a magic xylophone or something?"

Graydon Armstrong

PUT ME IN YOUR CLEAVAGE, I'LL RIDE YOU LIKE A POWER LOADER

Gible Fog

mmm spaghettifiction

Some Ed

Because Star Wars doesn't call them laser guns, they call them blasters. We're not given any technobabble about how they work, so it's hard to say they don't. They simply named them and showed us how they worked, and it was some of the fans who decided that they were laser guns rather than plasma guns or whatever. What I find interesting is that blasters are not only slower than light, they're slower than bullets. But the world of Star Wars doesn't have bullets, the closest they have to them seem to be the flechette rounds that the cloners use. Well, at least, as far as I know. I've only seen 7 of the movies and one of those just once.

Some Ed

@TIPDucky: I've *got* to know where *I* saw this. I mean, it's written down in my dream journal as something that happened while I was sleeping. If I've accidentally plagiarized something in my dream journal, I want to know. To be clear, I do recognize that the term is simple enough that there could be two entirely independent works that feature the same thing, while otherwise bearing virtually no resemblance to one another. But I won't be comfortable thinking that was what happened until I see how different this other thing was.

Some Ed

Or one could take a short cut and go from frienemies to frienemies with benefits.

Some Ed

@ValdVin: damn you, now I have another comic to read. Sigh. Also thanks.

Some Ed

You should feel so dang seen. Just saying, so you know. To be clear, I'm not complaining. Different people are different so do different things, and it's how the world functions. If everyone was CEO material, we'd all starve to death. To be clear, I'm not a CEO, I'm a computer programmer. And if we were all computer programmers, then none of us could be because we couldn't build one.

BigKumaDM

See this is why I like 40k. If space magic, soul magic, and weird boy magic are all possible explanations then whats possible and plausible suddenly opens up....

Ack

I vibe with Liz on this stance more than I'm actually comfortable with. A couple of years ago, I read a romance novel with the name Adventures in Time, which had as the story hook regular time travel between the 18th century and 20th century, where the protagonists went forward in time (using their steampunk time machine, built into a steampunk submarine) to gather plant life that was all but extinct in the 18th century. Plus, there was fuckin'. But what really threw me out of the story was that in the 18th century, everyone with any money had flying beetle-like steampunk cars and there were steampunk automata in law enforcement, and it was really cool. In the 20th century ... Landrovers. Some time in the 2 century gap, all that amazing tech just vanished, and THE AUTHOR NEVER EXPLAINS WHY. It still bugs me today. Great story premise, medium good writing, cool steampunk descriptions, terrible plot consistency.

Ross

Didn't they merge with Continental Airlines, naming the merged company Contilingus?

Ross

I'd guess that the steampunk time travel submarine was really a sideways-in-time traveller.

Ack

And it would've been great if they'd even IMPLIED that. But nope, it was all presented as straight-up time travel, whee.

Graydon Armstrong

That was incredible. Thank you! But now I've read it all and need more! By the way, is the PayPal link busted? It keeps saying there's a problem when I try to use it, but maybe it doesn't like me because I'm in NZ? Also, I think pendor_date.js has a bug I'd be happy to patch...