Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Comments

Sparky

Star Trek problems

ValdVin

Just when Moray needs Liz's Goblin Powers they refuse to activate!

Brendan Luster

reincarnation is not a pursuit for the faint of heart

Michael

Yeah that gets a bit more into the philosophical region

Andrea Andrew

Was Liz supposed to have dialogue at panel 4?

Nikki

Moray of Thesius?

Miyaa

So in Dutch, if Apple translate is correct, it would be: «Dat is een stom ding om je zorgen over te maken en je bent stom om je er zorgen over te maken.» I presume the Swedish version would involve a lot of borks and ikea instructions.

Zig Justice

I am of the school of thought that the pattern is the individual, and if it is temporarily disrupted and then restored, that does not result in the eradication of the original and the creation of an identical but separate copy ETA: I mean, honestly it already happens a lot in a way, if you consider sleep and anesthesia

Steve DeGroof

The "transporter problem" but with considerably more goo.

Crushogre

If it's an exact copy with all of your memories does it really matter?

Andrea Andrew

Poor Moray. I was curious if Morays can return if they’re reabsorbed, andcan definitely see this as concerning and questioning if I can risk my life on the possibility that I’ll come back from reabsorption.

Ailadi

But if the micro is the macro, then she should detach her deely-bobber, get reabsorbed and glooped out, then add back the part that wasn't attached.

Mark N

The good old teleporter conundrums.

Gary Levine

Experimental Janitorial is ready for all splooge and WOOM related mishaps.

Derek Hassell

"I'm sorry Captain, the matter stream just turned purple!"

Rich Holmes

What if the Moray that splooges back out isn't this Moray, but a copy with all her memories except she remembers always being purple?

Mark N

Nice idea.

Miyaa

Or that problem where allegedly your body replaces your body parts in various stages so that maybe you have a “new” body in like five years and at that point are you the same person?

ValdVin

Isn't the "transporter problem" more like a "Mike Teavee success"?

Einy

But what if the whole Director turns purple?

Scott Haley

I wonder if she changed color because she has become an individual.

Steve DeGroof

Oh, damn. Are the "transporter problem" and "the ship of Theseus" really the same thing?

Mark N

The teleporter analogy brought up in this comment thread makes me think about the 'Akashic Records' concept which definitely would see the patern itself as the holder of the soul so it would be indestructible. But the wonder is could it be cloned such as when Riker became his own twin brother in ST:TNG.

Call me Ishmael

For a moment I thought that Jeph had forgotten Liz's word balloon, but then I realized that Liz actually thought, with empathy (!), before speaking. Panel 4 is hesitation.

FeyOne

@Jeph Jacques - I have to say, Liz in panels 4 and 5 is absolutely fantastically done. I can practically feel how she was clearly about to thoughtlessly say something in panel 4 and then stops suddenly as she really thinks about the question. Then how she is staring at her own, artificial, hand in panel 5…. It’s just such an awesome moment and really shows depth for her that she hasn’t really shown previously. And you somehow captured that in two comic panels. I really respect that and felt I had to mention it. And, as always, thank you for your fantastic work.

Drazi

I think she was able to scold Morey for being embarrassed

FeyOne

I don’t believe so. To me, panel 4 shows her catching herself just short of saying something thoughtless as she suddenly starts to really seriously think about the question Moray asked. Then this is reinforced in panel 5 with her staring at her artificial hand and, I assume, still thinking about it the question of if a copy if something could ever actually be the original thing… So unless I’m reading it wrong, or reading too much into it, I see both panels as really showing more real depth for Liz than we have seen from her so far.

voyager-ngc5195

There's also the converse issue she hasn't thought about; whether her discoloration's a sign that she *can't* be reabsorbed.

Don Whiteside

There’s a SMBC comic that addresses this, with an alien commenting to the earthling that they’re a short-lived species, only living about 16 hours. I actually find it a sort of comforting thought. We suffer these discontinuities over and over in life, why be afraid of the last one when we’re not even the same as we were, say, last year?

Bookbeard

When being purplish Makes you fear jellyfish That's A Moray!

Sean Kinlin

And then she'd be green with a purple accessory!

Timmy

I had the same thought at first that she had missing dialogue, but I think you are correct it’s Liz growing 3 sizes of empathy that day

Shawn K. Younkin

Did you have to use the term "Splooge"? LMAO

Bookbeard

Not especially, no. Never saw the problem with transporters myself, but some people get really hung up on being made of the same molecules they were before.

BobC

I miss the tentacles on top. Purple tentacles are way cooler than green ones.

Derek Hassell

The Bobiverse books explore this problem in a way. If someone is restored from backup after the original was destroyed, it's the same person. If the original still exists, the clone is slightly different.

BobC

I miss the tentacles on top. Purple tentacles are way cooler than green ones.

Sean Kinlin

🎵 When she dreads that she'll be A copy of copy That's a Moray!

Call me Ishmael

Is it still science if you are both the observer and the subject and there's no control? I think it's just high tech Russian roulette.

LH

Grandfather's Goo Girl

Call me Ishmael

Depends on whether she splooges out green.

Samel da Camel

We don't know if Mike Teavee was killed and then perfectly reconstructed (well almost perfectly). It isn't possible to know if a teleporter kills you, because the only one who would 'know' dies during it.

Bookbeard

What was she before?

Leo Notenboom

Dutch speaker (ish): reads correct to me.

Scott Haley

A part of a bigger creature--a kind of avatar.

Captain Button

Some say yes, others say no. This is one of those philosophical questions that people will argue about endlessly. And never agree on.

Yonatan Zunger

If you really are into the story of Theseus and Ariadne, but after the shit he pulled on Naxos you were totally rooting for her to hook up with Dionysus instead, and that got you into a whole rabbit hole so soon you were waiting for him to hook up with Hymenaios... Is that still the same ship?

Steve McSheffrey

So if that copy has your memories, she's you. She should look as it as transplanting her brain into a new vessel.

MegasChara

Aww, Moray, it's okay to be a goopy Meth. Embrace the Stack.

Krista Elliott

The prospect of being quantum teleported IS rather daunting. No wonder Moray is freaked out.

Call me Ishmael

What if she's infectious, and The Director wants to quarantine her, or cauterize, or experiment? If she wasn't so ditzy, she'd be petrified in terror!

Bookbeard

Cubetown has a looser definition of science than the rest of the world.

Mark Eichin

This got mentioned a few times in these comments, but: while she 's said that she has reasonable integration with her hands, they're not actually *replacements*, unlike Clinton she never had hands in the first place (which made it more difficult to learn to use them.) So I can see them being an inspiration, but it's not really a "Liz of Theseus" situation...

Jim Fish

We are getting better and better at replication. Folk are feeding all their web history and videos into AI to make an avitar who will answer the phone and hang with their grand kids after they're dead. We've totally mapped the fruit-fly neural net, and have grown brains in petri dishes that are playing pong. Will the me who wakes up tomorrow be the one who goes to sleep tonight? Do I really give a shit?

Garrett Kunkel

I was seriously worried when this comment wasn't in the first several

Philip

We need to Checksum/ MD5 Moray. Someone get Emily.

John

When you think your fear Is that the "you" will disappear That's our Moray!

Carl Fink

I think it's cute how Liz is still wearing Marten's hoodie.

Sorastro

Well done! I don't speak Dutch but I do speak German. There is often a lot of overlap

Sammitch

Yes, but Liz is also contemplating Liz of Theseus.

Carl Fink

You were quantum teleported 14 seconds ago, Krista. Did you notice?

eddi_TBH

Principle of Parsimony. Moray in = Moray Out, minus purple coloration. Like being run through a sieve rather than a transporter.

æmbər

I had often wondered about this with AIs doing chassis transfers. Or backups. I would assume that it is, in fact, just a copy with memories.

Miyaa

Patrick, for some reason Patreon sent me your post before it was blocked. Apparently it equates an ikea diagram like it’s adult material for itself. Like the algorithm has an ikea addition. Which is hilarious.

Thisguy

No, it shows that the fear is not stupid, and that Moray’s feelings about it are valid.

Michael Steamweed

I love their interaction! (you could say i ship[of theseus] it)

Verteiron

Is Moray's AI "substrate" actually contained within her... goo? I can't recall whether that came up. I sort of assumed the Morays were all remote avatars of processes contained within the Director already.

Candace Griffin-Campbell

Well, considering the Patreon censorship, we have to get our joy somewhere. 🤣

Candace Griffin-Campbell

I think she is kind of scared. It's why she's avoiding the Director. (That, and the nagging about never visiting.)

Candace Griffin-Campbell

This instance of Moray has chosen not to be reabsorbed in order to remain an individual.

Reso

No, I hugged one yesterday, and today I was reincarnated in my current form. 0/10, do not recommend.

Paul

What if it's the transporter problem where a person was split into two separate people with different personalities? We could have purple Moray who seems pretty normal, and then somewhere else there is a green Moray who looks normal but has a really bad attitude.

SilverbackRon

I don't know. I was always rather fond of the Asari

SilverbackRon

Yeah, it looks like they just upload their consciousness into a new chassis. There is no hardware transfer. And if they are okay with that, then they shouldn't have Transporter worry. Then again, Moray is an experimental AI. She doesn't have the normal kind of framework

Bookbeard

Refusing to goblin when somebody needs you to goblin is the most goblin thing you can do. Liz has unlocked her ultimate technique.

Bookbeard

"Delicious! 10/10 would recommend." - the Owlbear

Stephen Wells

We were told early on that the Director had had an idea linking fluid dynamics with paperclip sorting, which made the Morays possible, and removing her "hair" means she can't do maths; so it seems her processing is local.

Mark Eichin

I got the impression that once the decline reabsorption, they mostly keep in touch via traditional group chat. And given that ( https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=5308 ) her skills are physically distributed within her goo and partitionable (and she doesn't have access to them when they're not attached!) that she doesn't really have any remote capabilities beyond "normal AI" well-integrated cellphone...

Dana Banaan

Yes, this is correct ☺️

Myriad Rose

Okay, new theory, Emily put some kind of chemical or supplement that's good for Moray's plankton in her tank (Since she wanted to be in charge of taking care of Moray) and forgot to tell her. Bonus points if this turns out to be something she should have been doing all along. Side effect: Purple.

Cley Faye

Just replace each blobs one by one, so we get a Moray of Theseus.

Darnel D Cooper

Okay. THAT is a legitimate concern/fear. Each Moray is a one shot distinct individual. While I'm still waiting for two of them to merge outside their parent, I feel that going back into the director is a death sentence as far as personality.

kupo

Encountering unexpected existential horror in a webcomic was not on my bingo card for tonight, but thanks I guess? Now Moray and I will both have problems sleeping. Lol...

Miyaa

Kind of until the slab that hums shows up.

Miyaa

Pretty sure Russian roulette is one of Zlata’s expertise along with making drones and no till crop rotation. (Alas, I know too much about no till crop rotation.)

Kattandra

this this this, the way she looks at her artificial hand, it really is the embodiment of a picture saying more than 1000 words.

David Paul

It would be interesting to see either way, really. Like, what would it actually mean for her if she is no longer able to be reabsorbed back into The Director? Could this also be passed on to other Moray units?

John Clary

I have died and come back several times, but is it the same "me" that comes back? Hades and sometimes Persephone said it is but I still wonder...

John

So can Thomas Riker...

CaseyAEC

I knew it...

CaseyAEC

This isn't a Transporter problem, this is a BORG problem. Reabsorption means re-dissolving into the collective conscious of the Director and all the other diffuse Morays within. The director and Morarys appear, grossely, as bags of fluid, without compartments for isolation. It becomes a violation of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. You can't UNMIX a dissolved fluid. Rather, you can't do it by 'stirring'.

CaseyAEC

I think there may be a physical transfer, the substrate. When Roko was crushed, they noted her substrate was fine because of police-grade hardening or some such. But I suppose that could have just meant, 'your old hard drive wasn't damaged, so we can pull a copy off it no problem!"

CaseyAEC

As I've said in other threads - More of a BORG problem. She's not getting transported, but reabsorbed into a master/collective consciousness.

Phil_M

Presumably, when AIs transfer, they end up running on mathematically identical processor architectures. Yes, it’s a copy of the old memories in a different brain and body, but there is no possible behavioural way of distinguishing the old and new versions, so they don’t sweat it. Unless they have Roko’s sort of sense of identity, of course. But Moray is different. The new “brain” that’s basing its behaviour on those copied memories might be subtly but crucially different to the old one, leading to different behaviour. So Moray may not be entirely irrational here.

CaseyAEC

So can Locutus of Borg

Phil_M

Zlata and May and Pintsize might raise an ironic eyebrow or two at this worry, though Roko might sympathise. But Moray isn’t really an AI like they are…

CaseyAEC

Everybody now: *They got the mustard out!*

Phil_M

Incidentally, Moray could always do some reading in medieval Christian theology. Apparently the idea of the resurrection of the body led them into pretty well exactly thus worry.

Alias Fakename

When existential dread Gets all up in your head That's a Moray!

awgiedawgie

The Swedish version can't possibly include Ikea instructions, because there would be no words at all.

Mark Eichin

Hmm, actually Yay might know enough about The Director's internals/architecture at this point that they might have relevant advice (though this wasn't their primary concern at the time and they were working on communicating *directly* with The Director and might not have picked up as much about the avatars in the process.)

Joe

Steven Wright: Last night somebody broke into my apartment and replaced everything with exact duplicates... When I pointed it out to my roommate, he said, ‘Do I know you?’

Joe

@Sammitch 🤯

Joe

@Derek "so fix it Scotty!" "Captain, I canna change the laws of colour combination!"

Bookbeard

Why is Moray purple? I've got a theory. It could be bunnies.

eddi_TBH

Seven of Nine came out her old self. (mostly, sort of A lifetime as a Borg did influence her)

eddi_TBH

She'd be a perfect match for Liz.

Stephen Wells

There was at one point serious debate about what happens to your poop during the resurrection.

Mark Eichin

Heh, and two comics later (270) Faye, Marten, and Pintsize have *literally this debate* about memory and continuity. (Fortunately, they defuse it with toilet humour, so they're not *still* having that discussion fifty five hundred comics later :-)

Peter Shaw

If you consider it from the perspective of pragmatist philosophy, it’s a non-question. If what pops out is an identical copy with the identical memories, in what way is it *not* the original? Or is there even such a thing as an “original“? “The difference that makes no difference is no difference.” in other words, don’t waste your time on questions that have no practical meaning.

Zig Justice

Yes that is a take. I feel it glazes over the (most likely insoluble) question of subjective experience though. But also, I feel it's just a phrasing issue; it's basically making the same claim as I am, except not disregarding the possibility of multiple copies. Also, you can't tell me how to waste my time! You're not my mom!

Peter Shaw

This also makes me think of the classic anime “Ghost in the Shell“. How much of you can be replaced, and it’s still *you*? One of the reasons why I love anime is that it isn’t afraid to ask the big questions. I love QC for the same reason; I would much prefer to be living in Jeph’s universe than in this one… Especially these days.

Stephen Wells

They get to the Director's lair and there are a hundred differently coloured Morays having a disco in the Director's multicoloured light show.

legobil

Also the Director is now neon pink.

legobil

Did Jeph forget to upload…? 🥹🥺🥹🥺

legobil

Also, think of how absorbing Moray would change The Director. The multitude of experiences to process and all that.

enchantedsleeper

An interesting theory, though it would suggest that Moray changing her base appearance (i.e. hairstyle) was the catalyst for her becoming an individual and not anything that came before it. You could argue that it was the decision to try something new, mind you, which would be a more engaging idea from a psychological perspective. But still, why now?