Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

that does it for QC comics in 2022! Next week: BEMBO

Files

Comments

Jim Castriff

Ah, she's calmed down a bit then. Huh.

Maelwys Myrddin

Excited to see where this goes in the new year!

Tannerbot

Well, Claire just re-adjuster her world view fast. Turns out that if you witness a new being created out of a tentacle, it provides a brain reset.

Daniel S

Okay, so it’s not being run by an idiot as much as a being that doesn’t understand humanity. Or common sense.

Zak Reichle

I like that Moray-44 seems distinct from Moray x-21. I assumed that they would be a duplicate, but the personalities seem distinct and separate, at least from the limited dialogue thus far.

Andrea Andrew

So is this like a sister to the AI we’ve been following?

Nikki

I never realized how much I've wanted to be able to just extrude part of my consciousness into another being in order to communicate with people and reabsorb it afterwards so I can concentrate on other stuff until now.

salixOS

Big mood.

enchantedsleeper

Maybe she couldn't bring herself to be mad at someone who, technically, hasn't done anything yet xD

Davkas

And this is why the Director brings about Morays. She's already calmed down a bit, lol. Hope you have a great holidays, Jeph! Looking forward to more QC next year!

Absentia

That... explains why they need Claire.

Spoogle McGee

Y'all are acting like disassociating so you can deal with bulshit is weird, but if you work in retail it's how you spend 90% of your time.

Tudza

BEMBO the wonder chimp?

Likeablejerk

I think it's like how you can be mad about something with a company, but you don't want to yell at the customer service person because you know it's not their fault. Moray-44 literally didn't exist until moments ago, so she can't be held responsible for historical problems.

Bartley J Drood

Note to self: Don't use "hey, baby, want me to reabsorb you?" as a pickup line. It'll fail miserably. Note to self (additional): ...or will it?

Zak Reichle

It's also very reassuring to see Claire acknowledging the emotions and everything that has happened "big mood" sums it up nicely. I believe I was more mistaken than I realized when saying that Claire came across as a bit immature. Happy to be proven quite wrong. I still love Claire more and more, and can't wait to see where this goes in the new year. Edit* I think my own conditioning and experiences and even my biases made it harder for me to relate with Claire on certain aspects as well. Things that absolutely anyone should be bothered by that I've over time learned to accept even if I should not have. I appreciate the numerous people who have pointed out the flaws, hypocrisy, or unfairness in how I was treating this situation. I have enjoyed most of the discorse over the past several days, and it's given me some valuable things to think on further. **I have also really liked the art, and specifically Claire's look for this whole arc. She is somehow becoming even more adorable. Someone mentioned her channeling the doctor... specifically Matt Smith...and how cute she would look with a bowtie, and I could not agree more!

Byron Wright

I am now imagining the giant octopus AI saying mood at random things because they still don't quite understand how the slang works but want to feel included.

Likeablejerk

I think I've been heading down that road since I saw the movie Multiplicity.

Photon

Hmmm... the Director can extrude a new entity with human verbal and gestural skills, but can barely express itself directly? That has some fascinating implications... (here's looking at you, Yay)

Ami

Swerve: Bembo lives in Cubetown and is Alice's brother

James Redekop

Check out David Brin's "Kiln People", in which people can copy their consciousness into clay golems and send them off to do errands -- and then can chose whether to download the golems' experiences back (if, for example, they went to an important meeting) or just scrap 'em (if they just went to pick up a gallon of milk for you).

Dorian

I'm so excited for Bembo

Simon Green

Conversation is dry, like hot sand in your eye, make a Moray

Leak

Remember, kids - trepanation <b>isn't</b> "one hell of a drug", it's more of a "what a way to go"... :/

Mad Marie

Is Moray named by a mistake? I could see Moray 1 not successfully communicating with a poor local Canadian Engineer, and then when a second one is extruded, the engineer says “More, eh?”

Matt Grayson

Yay *could* have warned her...

Damon Hart-Davis

Two AIs passing by, cast a pattern in your eye, that's a Moiré

Paul Veselovsky

This Moray reminds me of a book, Kiln People by David Brin. The principal (you) can make copies of yourself to deal with other things you either don't want or have time to do. At the end of their usefulness they get re-absorbed and then the original get the memories of what they experienced that day. Great book.

Chris Gropp

I accept this headcanon.

Clifton Royston

Dissociating to deal with bullshit is probably the only reason I'm alive now. For some values of bullshit.

Mad Marie

^that’s a lovely compliment! Thank you. You are of course welcome to use this or twist it a bit. :-)

Miyaa

@Damon Hart-Davis • Great, now I’m dying from laughter. Take your like. You will be hearing from my spirit!

PixelThis

When she said far down at the other end of the spectrum my brain went to "Oh a jellyfish, then"

Zak Reichle

@Spoogle McGee: I don't know that it ever occurred to me to think of it that way... 🧐 Very good point.

K C

And now back to the real star of QC ... Bembo!

Autographedcat

I loved the premise of "Kiln People", and really enjoyed exploring the world of it. I think it falls apart a little when he figured out he had to *end* it somehow, but it's still a fun read.

Zak Reichle

Have we ever seen Claire in a hat? Seems like her hair might win against a Fez. If nothing else I'm not sure how well a crimson Fez would stand out given her hair color. Maybe she could borrow the little hats from Hanners and Marigold?

Andrew

Kinda want to see a series of Moray’s decreasing in size and Jellyfish-like-ness that then have to translate back and forth with inevitable mistakes. “Big mood” becomes “large cow noise” etc.

Bill Silvia

I wish I could make a Moray when I need to meet with people and my brain is galaxies away.

awgiedawgie

Nailed it. They get re-absorbed when their job is done.

awgiedawgie

I'd like to make a Moray when I need to meet with people and my brain is right there in the room.

Devinity

I'm waiting for Jeph to drop the "that's a Moray" pun. I can tell he's got it all planned out

Anna Lisa

Thank you for making my 2022 lighter and more joyous! Happy Holidays and Happy New Year!

Zak Reichle

Moray x-21 seems to have been persistent for long enough that I don't think that is the only way, or reason, for the knowledge from a "facilitator" to be uploaded. That's assuming the designation for each Moray is not reused though. Or perhaps Moray-44 is the first of the type that transmits/uploads experiences back upon job completion and reabsorption? That could explain the difference in appearance and naming convention.

Jeffrey Anderson

Have a wonderful holiday, Jeph. And thanks for another year of Questionable Content, my favorite web comic.

MisterVimes

True. What it doesn't explain is why Claire needs Them. That's the real challenge here.

MisterVimes

Props for listening to the feedback. Lots of us have shitty experiences and/or legitimate trauma, whether from abuse, past work issues, etc. that lots of therapy and hard work have led us to really appreciate clear boundaries. I'm just coming out of some of my own, and slowly learning what is/is not a deal-breaker in the workplace. It's taken a long time to get there and I'm still slow on the uptake. So I have a lot of respect for Claire knowing what the challenges are and wanting clear answers, and demanding them at the outset. She could show a little more tact about it - but she does need to be this forceful with them, and would need to continue to be so in order to maintain any sense of work/life boundary here. Personal example: Right now I'm a temple director, which is about as much of a hot mess and personal space invasion as Cubetown sounds, but without the hilarity, technical competence, or for me, the interesting challenges (and people). It took me over a year to realize that some of my issues were really straightforward and related to utter lack of predictability and general lack of clear boundaries and chains of communication. I've been working on improving some of that, and have enforced as many boundaries as are reasonable, but some is related to my supervisors/supervisory structure and some is just the nature of the beast. While I'm proud of the improvements I've made (place was really suffering when I started 18 months ago), I also wish I had some awareness of the problems before I took the job. It would have dramatically shaped how I bargained, etc. and whether I chose to take an offer.

Daniel S

Oh totally. This is a shitshow and I can’t imagine why she’d want to stay unless the paycheck is obscene. Sure, a creature completely incapable of relating to normal people is your standard executive, but that doesn’t mean it’s a good idea!

MisterVimes

On the Moray vs. Moray-x thing - I assume the X stands for experimental or extended operation or both. Probably extruding an extended life body requires additional or different "portions" of Director's consciousness/subprotocols/codebase. And there is likely experiential value in giving them distinct personalities to learn new modes of existing upon reabsorption. The whole theme here, I suspect, is exploring possible modes of living and the AIs likely all have something unique related to that. Some of the people might, too. It wouldn't surprise me if Director had also extruded non-Moray bodies to experience different modes of being. Seems a great way to learn - really takes advantage of parallel processing and such.

DP23

I love this comic so much. You rock Jeph! Have a great Holiday break

ValdVin

I wish I had a Moray to find slang, argot, or lingo before it's turned uncool. Then again, a lot of people depend on me as the bellwether of passe-ness.

Matthew Foweraker

As Nero Wolfe would often observe “ Good slang.”

Joseph Bonnar

And now -I- can't unimagine that. :P

Mad Marie

Perhaps something like the little cats from ‘The Cat in the Hat Comes Back’?

Joseph Bonnar

BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO BEMBO!

Sean Kinlin

I'm not sure he needs to - the readers have been doing a bang-up job of it during this whole storyline. :)

Andrew

Jeph could write children’s books!

Emma Humphries

Oh great, I'm going to stare at the ceiling all the rest of the year every night with the brain weasels wondering "is there still a Moray after the Director reabsorbs them" to go with "does the transporter make a copy of you and kill you".

Amanda Smith

Bet, no cap 👀 (One of the best parts of teaching high school is coming home and teaching my nerdy, late-30s, engineer husband new slang, then watching him use it all wrong)

Zak Reichle

I can't tell if it's just the lighting of the past few panels or if Moray-44 is more blue than Moray x-21, who appears more green to me. I believe you're probably spot on about the significance of the X. Cubetown seems like it would be a safe location (relative term) for Yay's apartment/townhouse that we've caught glimpses of a few times. I could see them choosing to live above a fancy hat shop.

Some Ed

@Russell Altizer: which is a really good trick, and possibly why Moray All-parent opted to use it here. Though, there's also the fact that this particular trick is pretty good at conveying, "The stuff you thought you knew? Stuff is more complicated than that." Knowing stuff is not just more complicated than I understand but more complicated than I can understand feels to me like something that's good at helping me calm down. I understand it doesn't work that way for everyone. Some people I know get very anxious when presented with a detail like that. Past me was like that. But that doesn't mean that everyone can get over that just with exposure. It's, um, more complicated than that.

Some Ed

Another reason to possibly stay is the pay is good enough, and it turns out Director Moray prime is better at understanding normal people than your standard executive, once things are explained properly. To be clear, I didn't say *good at*. Just better. It doesn't take much to meet that particular benchmark. If this comment feels off to you, chances are good you either haven't talked with a lot of executives or you haven't talked with a lot of non-executives. Or maybe you have talked with a lot of non-executives just haven't really cared enough about them to think long enough to read to the end of this comment. But I guess any such executives have already left by now.

Dan Curtis

This has Rick and Morty butter passing robot vibes

Zak Reichle

@Stephen Wells: yeah, I believe you are correct here, and I feel silly to have not drawn the same conclusion myself as it seems rather obvious now... Though as pointed out by another.. the -x could also be denoting her previously mentioned "experimental" status. Makes sense to me either way and could possibly be a combination of the two.

Zak Reichle

A snippet from SMBC comes to mind, "It's complicated! Everything's complicated! "

Some Ed

@Zak Reichle: She is absolutely more blue, despite being much more green. At least, I think she's much more green. Though, having said that, I've realized for all know, they maintain stable personalities, consciouses, and names when they're re-absorbed, and maybe Morray-44 has an overall larger amount of experience dealing with people. That doesn't seem likely, but it could be. To be clear, as far as the color goes, Moray X-21 was more of a 78ad97, while Moray-44 is more of a 88d5da. So I guess she's not just more blue, but also brighter and a bit more green and even slightly more red, despite being so much more blue. (To be clear, I just took one color sample from each, but from one of their more brightly lit portions).

Zak Reichle

@Some Ed, thank you for the hex colors! I didn't have a way to sample them myself, so it's much appreciated. I'm not always great with green and red. I think the use of reabsorption was my only reason to think that each.. instance.. iteration.. not sure... Would not persist after they had uploaded their experiences. I can see pros and cons for both the persistent and non-persistent so I'm very curious for more detail and lore about Moray(all) and the director, I hope Jeph plans to elaborate on this. Edit* I also totally missed your word play at first 😳 @Sean Morgan: I had initially floated a similar hypothesis about each additional instance(?) Requiring more resources and possibly reducing the available processing power for each every time another is spun up. I believe I used that to try and explain some of Moray x-21s "quirks" but I think I prefer your explanation. 👍 Also, taking into account all the different view points and opinions of all the people who have commented on and talked at length with myself and others seemed the only reasonable thing to do. It's part of the reason I particularly like this community, and why I try to remain open to having my mind/opinion changed or to people pointing out aspects I may not have even considered or been aware of.

Some Ed

I've realized how useful it could be before, but then I've also wondered if this wasn't all a simulation I was doing to try to understand people better. Though, if it is, I'm not sure it's working, because there's just so much I don't understand about everything and everyone. Though, without being fully aware of my starting point, maybe that's some remarkable improvement over the complete lack of understanding I had before.

Daniel S

Director Jelly already seems more capable, considering there’s a recognized deficiency and steps are being taken to remedy that.

Some Ed

Except what base counting are we doing? I could see the Director having either a different name, or a non-numerated name, and the Morays start at 1 or even 0.

Some Ed

I think Yay thought they did warn her. It's just, Yay isn't *that* much better at communicating than Morays are. To be fair, they're significantly better at communicating than the Director is.

Some Ed

It's my expectation that will be Claire's line every so often after she takes the job.

James Dominguez

God damn it, this is a major plot point in the novel I'm currently writing. Curse you Jacques!

Some Ed

No problem. I mean, apart from the insanity that is picking out colors. I feel like it should be a lot easier than it is. Unfortunately, gpick does not work like I expect nor a way I can apparently understand, so I need something heavy like gimp or blender to do the heavy lifting. To be honest, my initial thought was the instances wouldn't persist after absorption either. Then I thought about the number 44 and the length of time that's passed since the thing the AIs have been building just off of Hallifax. Unless it's something like base 36, 44 is *way* too low. I mean, Director Jelly seems sufficiently bad at communicating with the humanoids on their own that it feels like they'd have needed more than 43 just to get this place built. And then there's all of Cubetown that we've seen and all of Cubetown that we haven't seen. Of course, it *could* be base 36 or base 69 or some other odd thing and just *happen* to be entirely digits that are represented with the shapes we are comfortable with. But there's other strategies that could be in use as well. Additionally, there's a possibility that to my surprise, Director Jelly's a natural at construction, so it was only the hiring of researchers that required Morays. It could just be a number based on how many were currently out right at that time. Another option would be distinct personalities and enumerations that get associated, but the consciousness does not. Given that option, even if Moray-44 has been used a hundred times, for her, this really is the first few moments, because it's just the personality and name that were recycled. Maybe the enumerations get reused, while the personalities and consciousnesses don't. Yet another option would be the "We don't bother with the digits over 99 when talking with other people." There are so entirely many ways to do this, and I've spent *way* too much time thinking about this, because it happens to have veered close enough to stuff I've thought about for story characters far too much. That is, specifically, story characters whose perceptions are sufficiently different from people as we understand them to present substantial communication issues. And then working out that communication. I'm not sure how long I've been thinking in that space exactly, but I believe it's on the order of decades.

Some Ed

I frequently feel like I'm the least cool of all of my friends. And then I go to stuff like the company Christmas party and find I need to explain all the lingo I use. Sigh.

Some Ed

I don't know the answer to the first yet, but the answer to the second is definitely

Carl Fink

And the green ones are considered low-quality and especially temporary.

Carl Fink

In US Air Force designations, "X" is an experimental aircraft, FWIW.

Carl Fink

Does the Director strike anyone else as possibly a spinoff of whatever project created Yay (or vice versa)? It/they (??) has/have multiple instances that communicate, but asynchronously, where Yay's bodies communicate in realtime. It would explain why Yay was apparently contemptuous of Cubetown but also positive Claire going there--sibling rivalry?

Zak Reichle

My mind, she is blown 🤯 I didn't expect many people would have thought about characters that were different in terms of how well they can communicate, or that perceive things in a very different way than what would be considered "normal", and how they would interact with others as well as their environment. This is something that for a number of reasons hits fairly close to home for me personally, and I am very pleasantly surprised to find I was again mistaken, and that there has been *far* more thought put into this type of situation than I expected/anticipated. Thank you for going into such detail. Also, base 69... Nice

Chelsea

Much of this feels Yay-adjacent, yes. I'm also strongly reminded of Alice Grove, the sci-fi comic Jeph did a few years ago

Zak Reichle

I knew that was the case with the x-planes from the 50s & 60s. I did not know if that was still used by the Air force, Space force, or NASA.

Etienne M.J. Dubourg

This definitely has a very Alice Grove feeling, at least since it's getting more and more sci-fi...

Bagge

This raises profound questions about identity

Aaron Schulz

Yeah I am guessing the director and Yay have similar origins and its why Yay thought it was so funny for claire to go visit.

Fart Captor

The director is made out of slime girls 🥰

Nulgar

See, you can just tell people things, you don't have to be reabsorbed.

Zak Reichle

Now I'm curious as to how much Yay knows of their own origins.

Finvaara

"The Director is a Slime Harem' is filmed before a live studio audience."

Photon

And the slime girls are made of Director

Shane Wegner

When spend your time thinking in nonlinear five dimensional mathematics, it’s easier to spawn off a child process when you need to communicate with a subject-predicate English user. And I’m a little iffy on the implications that Moray-44’s unique sentient experience will come to and end as soon as she’s reabsorbed. But somehow I just know she cheerfully consents to this end of her existence, for the greater good.

Shane Wegner

Clinton is going to lose his mind when he hears Claire got to see this whole thing firsthand and he didn’t.

Captain Button

And one category of things you don't want to do is jobs that are too dangerous or involved toxic chemicals or radiation.

Clifton Royston

That is pretty close to why some multiple systems have a "front" personality or a "hyper-functional" personality, specifically to deal with communicating with norms when nobody else feels up to it or would do a good job. (Not all systems, certainly; there's no standard pattern.)

Miyaa

Bembo?

Zak Reichle

That was a very deep rabbit hole to fall down on Wikipedia, extremely interesting even though I don't know how well I understood it all. TIL about 5 dimensional mathematics, polytopes and was reminded that I briefly touched on the physics aspect in a college course many years ago. I love to learn 👍 FOR THE GREATER GOOD. always makes me think of Hot Fuzz

Sarah Buisson

I had this first feeling time we learn about cube town but... could it be the place where Yay is originate from?

Stephen Wells

I think it's more like some of the Director gets extruded as a Moray, does its thing, and returns to the pool, in much the same way that a person might leave the house, run an errand and return to the welcoming bosom of their family :) i.e. Moray has no more trouble being resorbed than they did being extruded...

Peter Jensen

A slime girl is extruded from the director. Is the director made of slime girls or is she made of director? She screams for she does not know.

Matt Pedone

Given their reaction to Claire interviewing there, I think they came from someplace else. It could be that Yay and The Director are from the same lab, though. Or, perhaps competing labs.

Daniel Drazen

If I'm Claire and I still need a job, I want to change the subject and ask to tour the library or wherever I'll be working.

legobil

I imagine The Director just hovering behind them in the background already watching and hearing. I mean, look at that glow. He already knows “Big mood” when Moray 44 gets reabsorbed.

William Cole

I never reabsorb on the first date!

Daniel Drazen

"Extruding a whole new person" is the new definition of "delegating."

William Cole

Stephen Wells above mentioned the extruded Morays "returning to the pool" and I immediately thought of Shub-Niggurath, the Black Goat of the Wood with a Thousand Young. So now y'all have to think about that too.

Stephen Wells

The DIrector already got distracted and is thinking about five-dimensional squid. Again.

Mad Marie

Elon Musk is currently trying to extrude a new CEO…

Clarence the Liar

@Shane Wegner: Could be a Star Trek DS9 changeling sort of affair; "the ocean becomes the drop; the drop becomes the ocean" kind of thing.

legobil

That makes absolute sense. It would explain why/how/where Cubetown… is…

Todd Ellner

You would be excused from recognizing it as a turd with a stylized "T" logo

Todd Ellner

That would be "Abhoth Source of Uncleanness" Courtesy of Clark Ashton Smith " ...[H]e described a sort of pool with a margin of mud that was marled with obscene offal; and in the pool a grayish, horrid mass that nearly choked it from rim to rim... Here, it seemed, was the ultimate source of all miscreation and abomination. For the gray mass quobbed and quivered, and swelled perpetually; and from it, in manifold fission, were spawned the anatomies that crept away on every side through the grotto. There were things like bodiless legs or arms that flailed in the slime, or heads that rolled, or floundering bellies with fishes' fins; and all manner of things malformed and monstrous, that grew in size as they departed from the neighborhood of Abhoth. And those that swam not swiftly ashore when they fell into the pool from Abhoth, were devoured by mouths that gaped in the parent bulk."

Andrew

I mean, the result would be a generation of robosexuals, but…

Ursus Ridens

I do _not_ want to watch that. (And I won't , 'cause I'm not on social media -- only on antisocial media. )

Ursus Ridens

I've been saying that all this is how QC segues into Alice Grove, but will anybody believe me? Nooooooooooooo...

Ursus Ridens

It's true, you can think of yourself as having been extruded by your family, but your mom would probably prefer that you step around that thought instead.

Ursus Ridens

I love all the deep speculations about the origin and makeup of the Director, but all the while I've been thinking something like "Huzzah! Bembo! More barbarian-heroing silliness!"

panpolypuff

Well since his injury, doesn’t Clinton see everything secondhand anyway?

Carl Fink

I seem to remember Jeph denying that this storyline leads to Alice Grove, so you can add him to the list of unbelievers. :-)

Daniel S

Of course Jeph also denied that Claire and Marten were going to be a couple - or at least that he was teasing it at the time - so…

J Corkey Custer

Thanks for all the great comics. I open even one with anticipation, which is justified at an astonishingly high rate. May your days be merry and bright.

Stephen Wells

Bembo is the way a Conan story would go if you did at at a D&D table :) One of my parties includes a barbarian who adopted a wolf in session 1. It's called Fluffy :)

doorbender

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!!!

Darnel D Cooper

Just sad Moray isn't a perm. She is a data-packet, a waldo,.... sigh.

Solomon Garland

See, Claire is totally fine once you get some answers in her!

Stephen Wells

Moray-44 is temporary but Moray-X-22 is persistent :) X for eXtended lifetime presumably...

Ace

HOLY SHIT