Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

He's supposed to have a light orb hovering over his left shoulder when it gets colored, so we'll see how it turns out. I think it looks appropriately awesome! It wasn't exactly what I pictured in my mind for the Rootbound Depths, but dangit, the artist's interpretation looks really, really good. Hope you like it.

Jon

Files

Comments

Caiban

I like it, just the weapon of choice is bad... A spear... still so boring... 😅 So.. bland

Caiban

Spear = worst weapon Not in the "Its a bad weapon" way... just in the.. i mean its a pointy stick Nothing more I can go outside right now grab a stick and have a spear... yey. Yes ofc i know that its a "good" weapon in tearms of usefullniss and all that. But at the end its a pointy stick. Swords are also much used true, every mc that dosnt have a spear has a sword... but a sword has more elegance, it has variations it has speed and strength. I know i rant about such things a lot, i think like 1/5 of my royal road comments are just rants sbout that xD But its just such a... bland thing. Even more with his skillset... going spear is such a waste

Adam N.

Well he has Savant of the Body and a storage ring so for him, he can learn multiple weapons and use them at will depending on the situation, so I think it's great. Maybe one day he'll get access to a morph-type weapon so his skills can really shine :)

Caiban

He can yes... but he dosnt rly do it... i havent read much of book 2 yet because i want to save up chapters but in book 1 he only used other weapons here and there. Mostly the pointy stick... Hmm a moroh type weapon sounds great yeah ^^ Maybe even two, for dual daggers or sword and shield..and combining them could give pointy sticks or battle axes or so

Street Cat Restoration Project

Looks great! Also Spears are one of the most badass and most utilized weapon in history, Caiban is a nutter.

BlastYoBoots

Very good setting for the challenges he faces in Book 2! (Forgive me for posting this next writing-centric part both here and in Ch164's comments section though, I wasn't sure where it'd be more visible, I swear I won't make a habit of double-posting...) I have some possible revision advice before the newest in-progress Book (it's 3, right?) reaches Book-form... I've been re-reading the chapters on Royal Road with Cal's rise to E-tier and afterwards, and reading a bunch of the Royal Road comments, and there's an inconsistency I would agree could use at least a *paragraph* or few of clarification somewhere important, needed for reader-understanding even in published non-episodic form. Because Cal's choices and actions in the current Book after hitting E-tier make perfect sense to me, but only because I think I've read between the lines, and to a significant portion of the readership those actions seem FAR too reckless to match his earlier psychological resolution and commitment to "patience". People see him reaching that grieving conclusion during the meditation up to E-Tier, and promising patience to Selara as well, and then they immediately see him taking even crazier risks than he ever had with spell experimentation (trying the dangerous Portal for the first time, etc) and rushing to save Jakob arguably half-prepared and the like. I'll quote how I put it to a couple people in the comments there: <"[The way Cal only reached E-Tier because of this last favor from Selara, rather than from his own hard work...] It’s meant as a slap in the face to the idea that he could have EVER survived to do this under his own power.  The world he’s entered is FAR too unfair, FAR too unequal, and those with real wealth and power have a transcendent advantage.  While if you’re from the dirt, no matter how hard you work yourself up, you’ll still be ground under heel [unless you refuse to ever stand out at all, and maybe even then].  What just happened is the harsh truth of this world, distilled:  If he hadn’t been gifted Sovereign E-Tier by a wealthy patron, he never, EVER could have survived to reach it the “honest” way.  There WAS no honest way.  It was a lie. Now that he’s had that lesson bled out of him and those he cares about, he’s going to have to change his approach dramatically.  He’s not going to “win” against this world by playing by its own rigged rules or coloring just a little outside the lines [like trying to eke a little more out by selling to Jakob]."> But I added that up myself (assuming I'm even right); it wasn't spelled out like his other lessons, even though it seems to be crucial in shaping most of his subsequent actions. That's why you might need to add a couple paragraphs of clarification somewhere crucial, to justify Cal's shift in attitude to readers who didn't internalize that implied message. I'm sure from Cal's subsequent actions that he learned that crucial lesson RIGHT alongside the Patience lesson, and it's an incredibly weird and challenging line Cal was taught he has to walk, now: Cal HAS to slow down and work more long-term in a vast number of ways, or he'll die; the story showed him realizing this. However, the cruel inequality of this world he'd just witnessed DEMANDS that he can't follow its unfair rules either and needs to find ways to step FAR outside what could be considered possible for him, in secret, or anyone higher up who catches sight of his talent rising will snuff him out before he can become a threat. The story DIDN'T explain Cal coming to this conclusion, only the first one. The result over on Royal Road -- and somewhat unusually, I DO believe they're entirely justified, this time -- has been that a number of people saw his commitment to be patient as a lie, rather than a quiet and paradoxical compromise with an even *more* intimidating urgent recklessness he wouldn't have dared to before this Book. To the average reader, seeing Cal's excellent psychological reckoning during the meditation to E-Tier followed by a series of desperate risks, prioritizing saving and making up to the friends he wronged (which was its own kind of urgent priority for Cal) but not exclusively so, FEELS kind of jarring to read. We got a clear window into one side of his reasoning but not the other, and when that unspoken side takes SO much of the lead, it can be a little difficult to understand. I wasn't as jarred at the time because I added up the thematic lesson I quoted, but when so much of the "patience" half of his psychological reckoning was finally spelled out, I don't feel it's fair to expect most readers to add up the rationale behind the more reckless side of the lesson on their own. Even just a paragraph or two early in this Book could fix it-- having Cal spell out the lesson he learned in his head, and *acknowledging* how conflicting and strange it's going to be to balance patience and rule-breaking to survive, would preempt questions that are confusing a lot of people and making it seem like he's undermining that massive, satisfying meditation-reckoning. I don't know exactly when or where you would work it in, but I feel like it's pretty important, and you'd definitely do a better job explaining it than I would.

BlastYoBoots

Spears are underrepresented as hero weapons given their universal historical utility and superiority, yeah.