Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Little Carolyn weighed almost nothing in his arms as he walked across Mirathra. Cal took quieter streets along the way, with fewer runelight lamps and storefronts closed by the start of second dusk. Thomas kept so close to his hip that their legs tangled twice. Each time the boy mumbled something like an apology but didn't space himself out any further. A cart pulled by a pair of garrons rolled by, and one of them snorted in their direction. Thomas stiffened and clutched at Cal's sheath, while Carolyn made a small sound and tucked herself harder against his shoulder.

"It's okay, guys," Cal said, intentionally louder than he needed to be. "They're just big draft animals. Those critters won't hurt you. The smell, on the other hand, is something to watch out for." He looked down at Thomas with a wink, but his attempt at levity failed to console the boy.

The kids had apparently never been to the city, and after what they'd recently experienced, the entire situation was overwhelming.

Cinder hung low over the yellow-tiled buildings, staining the white stones a mottled red. The sorting after the rescue had taken the Legion under an hour: clerks with slates and chalked lines drawn through one of the fort's inner courtyards, with the freed slaves over here, the Mycari oppressors over there, names taken and numbers assigned.

"There is a department for them," Cardea had stated, standing beside him as they watched. "The Chancellery's civil division will find homes for the displaced. Tenement housing, simple labor—that sort of thing. Your freed folks will be on the rolls by midday the day after tomorrow."

"That sounds… promising?" he'd replied.

She had looked out at the ongoing process for a while, before snorting derisively.

"On the street they call it The Mill. It is underfunded, understaffed, and the safeguards are a polite fiction. Gangs run most of the intake clerks. Many go in and are simply never heard from again."

An older man in an apron banged out of a side door ahead with a bundle under his arms, and Thomas flinched hard enough that he almost tripped Cal.

"Deep breaths, buddy. We're almost there."

Cardea had elaborated further, explaining how most youths that survived The Mill long enough to Awaken showed up for the mandated youth training and didn't want to leave. The steady meals and roof over their heads were worth the soldier's life. She offered to take Thomas and Carolyn on as wards of the garrison and use them as runners and support staff, but he couldn't help suspecting ulterior motives.

"No thank you, Commander," Cal had said. "I've got somewhere in mind that will take better care of them. No offense."

She'd nodded and wisely chosen to let it go. He'd had enough of the world and its hardships for one day, and that included dodging pressure from this woman. He confirmed his willingness to help them on portal commissions a final time and left it at that, telling her where she could leave a message for him. Then he'd collected the kids and made like a tree.

Four more days until Corinne's month is up, he thought, shifting the little girl's weight and turning onto a broad street. I wonder what she's been doing?

The original Hearthsong Inn rose five stories around the next corner. A doorman in dark green livery straightened as they came up the steps and did a double take when he saw Cal.

"M-Master Valorn!"

"Hey Tobias, it's good to see you. I'm glad you're on shift tonight."

"Good to see you too, sir. Seems I missed all the excitement the other day." The man pulled the door wide, calling over his shoulder, "Wait right here, don't—just wait," and vanished inside at a near run.

Cal chuckled to himself as he watched the big fella sprint off like a man half his size. It was unsurprising after his last visit.

The common room rose up three stories in ringed galleries, a hundred-odd patrons at the tables, clamoring with talk and cutlery that made Thomas shrink into his leg. Two men Cal recognized were working the floor: posted at the gallery stairs and the staff hall with their backs to walls, watching the room. One of them was squat and short-necked with cauliflower ears, and he grinned when he saw Cal.

"Hah! The Fizzler returns—"

Ossric was cut off by the kitchen door banging open, and seven feet of brawny green Mycari strode through with a carving knife in hand. Thomas darted forward impressively fast, getting himself in front of his sister with both arms out and shaking from head to toe. Carolyn had gone completely still.

Sashi Hearthsong was between them before Borin had taken more than a few steps, and she crouched down in front of Thomas with her back to her husband.

"Oh, don't worry about that old elf, now," she gently chided. "He wouldn't hurt a fly unless it landed on his cooking. You're hungry, aren't you? Of course you are. There's bread not ten minutes out of the oven and butter aplenty. Come. Come and eat, yes? We'll set you right over there in the corner where Cal can keep an eye on you the whole time."

Thomas lowered his arms an inch. "F-Fresh bread?"

"All you can eat, young man." Sashi held out a hand to the boy and his sister.

Thomas looked up questioningly at Cal to receive a grin in response as he set Carolyn down. "Sashi is about as good as people come, buddy. And her husband's food—" Cal lifted his chin at Borin who had stopped beside the bar "—is a rare treat. You'll be safe, I promise."

The boy nodded seriously and then looked eagerly at his sister as he took two of Sashi's fingers. Carolyn opted to grab her brother's other hand instead of the one Sashi offered, but the innkeeper took it in stride and led them away.

While Sashi got the kids situated, Borin jerked his thumb behind the bar where his brother had joined him and Cal headed over. "Master Valorn," Christoph began, "we had begun to wonder whether you were simply a rumor." He glanced at the kids' table. "You appear to have made a habit of leaving people on our doorstep."

"What can I say? It's been that sort of week."

"Yes, well… we've certainly heard the stories of the imperial promenade, and the daring half-elf who had escaped the clutches of the evil rebels only to lead the Legion into a counterattack that saved the governor."

Borin grunted and elbowed his brother, all teeth. "I expected him to be taller."

"Ha! Sorry to disappoint," Cal replied, "but those are rumors only. The governor and Commander Cardea did most of the work." He looked around, assessing the common room and settling on Ossric. "It appears you've found work for some of my fellow prisoners. While I can't vouch for them beyond their ability and will to survive, I appreciate you helping any of them back on their feet. No one should have to live through what we did. Where is Corinne, though?"

Sashi came back then, tossing a towel over her shoulder. "She's gone, dear. Has been just over a week now. She had it in her head she needed some fresh air and a break from the family business for some reason and asked us to leave word for you. Ran off with some random caravan like she expected you to catch up, and I've been sick about it every night since."

"Did she vet them?"

"Of course not. Said she didn't have the patience for it. Fool girl…"

Cor… "Welp, then I'd better go get her."

"Indeed you should," Christoph interjected, scowling. "It seems you've been holding out on us, though I can't say I blame you. That is a very rare Spell."

"I take it the prisoners told you I can cast portal?"

"The prisoners told us much, not the least of which was your harrowing ordeal. You have our sympathies, Cal. Know that we're very glad you've returned to us safely." Borin squeezed Sashi close to him and nodded, while she reached over gently to squeeze his arm. "You'll have to tell us more about it when you have the time. As for your portals… yes, Nathaniel saw you step through when you dropped off your… associates. They were quick to talk when Borin offered some of his famous stew for the details. Poor Sashi about had a heart attack when she found out you were a mage of such skill."

Sashi swatted her brother-in-law's arm with the towel. "Hardly. Does Corinne know any of this?" Sashi asked, turning back to Cal.

"She's known for a long while—longer than anybody, now that I think about it." Cal rubbed the back of his neck sheepishly. "The plan was that I'd grab her with the Spell when her month ran out. She's expecting me, which is probably why she didn't think twice about walking off west with some strangers."

Borin grunted a word that was half growl, half laugh. "Kids."

"Now that the secret's out, I'm going to need a permanent room to keep in Mirathra so I can hop between here and Deadfall. And I'm afraid I'll have to sleep in it tonight and get Corinne tomorrow, because I couldn't so much as light a candle with my Mana until I get some rest."

"Of course, dear, but what of them?" Sashi pointed to Thomas and Carolyn happily munching away on the full platters of food the inn's staff had delivered.

Cal followed her eyes with a sigh and explained a little of what'd happened and why he'd brought them. Of the battle and the slaves. His fears of them being lost in the churn of corrupt Dominion bureaucracy after they had already lost their family to the elves.

"We'll naturally take them in for you," Christoph said with a smile. "It's only right that we help Corinne's closest friend in matters such as this. Just as I'm sure Corinne's closest friend will gladly help us with the rare logistical need from time to time."

Cal blinked before barking a laugh. "Ha! I can't even fault you there. Favors for favors, eh? That works for me. And speaking of business, how goes our little wheelchair endeavor?"

"Poorly." Christoph scowled. "The devices have been more difficult to manufacture than first expected, making the prototype costs near prohibitive. We find ourselves in a quandary. The price necessary to maintain profitability bumps up too close to requiring the means of those who could opt to pay for the necessary healing instead. I've not given up yet, though. If we can get the proper molds in place to streamline the components… the margin should be worth it."

"I'll leave it in your capable hands, then. Thanks for the update. Now, if you'll all excuse me—I really need to get some rest. I appreciate you looking after the kids. That Thomas has some serious grit."

"Perhaps he can one day be as skilled as you in the kitchen," the big chef rumbled. "I could always use another prep cook. You know, if you have time—"

Cal waved the smiling man off with a groan, made sure the kids got settled into their own room, found a room for himself with a window over the street and a bed turned down, and was asleep before he'd finished taking off his boots.

The next morning found Cal sitting cross-legged on the floorboards with his back to the wall, contemplating two different versions of a Spell that accomplished nearly the same thing.

Angelika Halmi's spellwork was a bit more elegant and naturally had the portions that included scrying, while Ondrel's seemed built to brute force some of the work through use of repeated runes.

He could name perhaps four glyphs in either of them. Naturally, there was the Control rune at the heart of each, holding everything in check until Intent fired it. Sequence, which he knew from the healers' work. Project, three times in the Ondrel version and twice in the Halmi. After that it was all simply… plagiarism he didn't understand.

Cal conjured displays of each side by side in his dreamscape and got to dissecting. Within ten minutes, the main difference jumped out at him.

There was a cluster in the Halmi design with no counterpart in Ondrel's at all. Eleven runes fed forward into the main body of the Spell off the Control rune before it connected with portions that were largely mirrored in Ondrel's. Logically, it made sense that it was what he was looking for.

He pulled the eleven runes out, set them alone in the middle of his mind, and started turning them into a Spell of their own.

It didn't take long.

[New Spell Gained: Farsight (D) - Novice]

He anchored it on the stretch of the Eastern Road where he had watched the Green Drift float peacefully through the forest, expecting Corinne to have made it closer to Deadfall by now, but needing somewhere to start. The view swung obediently up the road and back down, pivoting in place, but when he tried to walk it forward it wouldn't budge.

Guess it's a fixed point, just like with [Portal]. It's a shame, but I can't be too mad—I've learned a very useful new Spell! It uses a mere fraction of the Mana to scout that casting the entire Halmi portal Spell did. Looks like it's time to leapfrog!

Cal grinned at the empty room and got back to work, because while he'd accomplished his main goal, there was still another opportunity standing before him: improving efficiency.

With the scrying portion successfully identified, he was now able to compare the actual spatial mechanics of the two base Spells side-by-side. Unsurprisingly, the Halmi version seemed superior in almost every aspect where the blueprints overlapped. Almost. But there were some interesting things going on with Ondrel's runic package, and Cal got to theorizing. He had no idea what the runes and their layout did in detail, but if work back on Earth had taught him anything, it was how to come up with a proper Scientific Wild Ass Guess.

He spent the next two hours and multiple refills of his Mana pool playing Dr. Frankenstein until he finally managed to create a stable version that got the rune count down below both of the Spells he'd started with.

Cal cast it internally after he'd tested it extensively outside. It was easier to project from his spirit than either of the others, seeming to lend some credence to his growing theory that runic load contributed to the difficulty. It also cost him five to ten percent less Mana than creating a portal before had, which was another win, if minor.

[Your Portal (D) has been renamed to Safe Portal (D)]

[New Spell Gained: Portal (D) - Novice]

He sat looking at the notifications for a while. The World Soul had accepted his Intent to rename the stolen Halmi version using his own understanding of what the extra scrying runes were for. It'd also accepted his newly minted and efficient portal Spell without the scrying piece as something completely different. Neat.

Cal meditated back to full, then built the Halmi version—scrying and all—with each efficiency he had learned folded in. It snapped together faster than it ever had before.

[Your proficiency with Safe Portal (D) has increased to Adept]

Super neat!

That chime made him think back to what Vox had had waiting for him after the last couple of days' battles finally concluded.

[Your proficiency with Combustion (E) has increased to Adept]

[Your proficiency with Withering Touch (E) has increased to Practiced]

[Your proficiency with Power Shot (E) has increased to Adept]

[Your proficiency with Spiritual Pulse (E) has increased to Adept]

Now that my masteries have absorbed so many Skills, I almost feel like I'm getting cheated after such fights with these low gains. What the French, toast? He grinned to himself, knowing that saying that last sentence out loud would have elicited a groan from his wife.

He meditated to full once more then started searching for his friend.

[Farsight] was cheap, and cheap was convenient. He threw the first Spell just out of eyesight of where he'd started, found the road empty, turned the view west as far as it would reach, picked a spot at the limit of sight, and anchored the next cast there. The feel was identical to placing an endpoint inside the old preview: reach into the held window, set a pin, and fire. Easy.

He started running two threads, then quickly advanced to three. [Mental Mastery] let him hold one preview and scan it while the next was already casting ahead, so that the Spells chained past each other and the Eastern Road began to fly by. Cal found Legion patrols, individual wagons, riders, a lumber train, and merchant caravans. Every figure was searched for a chestnut ponytail and spear.

Seven days out from the city, he found eight wagons under way in the late morning sun and a girl in a travel-stained green tunic walking at the shoulder of the fourth wagon with her hand on the sideboard and her ponytail bouncing as she stepped, weapon of choice over her shoulder. Cal released a breath he had been holding since Sashi said Corinne had left.

Reality parted beside her and Cal stepped through the portal onto fused grey stone. Corinne shrieked, jumped sideways into the wagon, and then her face lit up in pure delight.

"Cal! You—but there are people—" He shot her a small shrug, finding it difficult to do anything beyond smiling so hard his face hurt. It was a relief to see her after everything he had been through.

She hit him at a dead run that nearly took them both down, wrapping him into a tight hug. "You're early! A few days early, how are you early, did Grandma tell you where I went, was she awful about it, she was awful about it wasn't she, and don't you dare tell me you were worried, I'm perfectly capable—" She pulled back and swatted his chest. "You opened it right next to me. In front of all these people."

"Cat's out of the bag back in Mirathra, Cor. There's no need to keep it hidden anymore."

"I have no idea what having a cat in a bag has to do with your keeping secrets, but I get the point." She pulled him back into a hug. "I'm just glad you're finally here."

The caravan had lurched to a stop. The driver Corinne was escorting hauled on his reins so abruptly the wagon behind nearly climbed its back, and all along the line heads peeked out from under hooded oilcloth cloaks. Somebody's pack mule brayed and a garron chuffed in reply. A swarthy man in a nice coat trotted down the length of the train, while a big man followed at his shoulder in studded leather with a longsword at his hip. Both were D-tier, with the warrior in the upper echelon.

"Sir!" The coat arrived beaming, hands gesturing grandly. "Sir. I'm Antoine, Antoine Baran, and this is my enterprise, and might I say—a Courier, out here on the road, and such a handsome one as that, what a—" He looked at the still glowing door of light with naked hunger. "—what a rare opportunity. Might I ask who you contract with? Only I, Antoine Baran, run this route four times a year and the thought of moving cloth by the hour instead of the month is quite the—"

"How did you end up with this caravan?" Cal asked Corinne, completely ignoring the obsequious man.

She glanced at Antoine and dropped her voice. "I needed out, Cal. Out of the city and out of the inn. The pressures of their expectations just got to be too much, and I still don't know what to do about inheriting it all, and Uncle Christoph kept finding me meetings, and I just wanted open road and sky and nobody who shares my last name for a while. So I took the first outfit going west back to Deadfall." She winced. "I… I didn't look into them. Not even a little. Which was dumb, I know it was dumb, but I knew you'd be coming, and—" She lifted her chin. "And I'm glad you did, because if I'd thought you weren't coming I'd have turned around and walked back to Deadfall on my own, which is also dumb."

"Cor?"

She pointed straight at who he presumed was the guard captain, suddenly tense beside Cal. "Last night Koresh asked me to spar after supper. I naturally said yes, because, you know, I like to fight."

"Naturally," Cal replied, but the big man had started to frown.

"And when we fought, he—he put his hands on me," she finished with a grimace. "It's not anything I haven't had to shove off a drunk for at the inn, but at least there Daddy is one room away and usually holding a knife." She edged over into him as she put distance between her and the big man. "It's different out here. It… it scared me."

Cal stared over at the men, and Antoine's smiling facade had frozen into a brittle caricature of itself. The guard captain had drawn himself up, jutting out his chin and settling his weight the way a man ready for a fight would.

You know, we could just walk back through the portal that's hanging open behind me…

The echo of Red's bloodthirsty laughter chose that moment to come to mind, and Cal could only grin darkly, fully in agreement with the sentiment. He stepped between them.

Have a good week, everyone.

Jon

Files

Comments

Bryn

Thanks for the chapter!

Msharlo1

I feel like Cor is a bit at fault here. While she is a victim, she went off with an unknown, unvetted party alone and the least horrible bad thing that could result from that happened. If it was just a few weeks earlier she might have ended up in the same camp as Cal. It begs the question of whether she is an adventurer who can protect herself or a non-combatant. It feels like this is the real world example of 'punching down' that Cal was warned of last chapter. He can punish the guard here, and even has some justification, but then the merchant hires someone to get revenge because he would also have 'some' justification. Where does it stop?

Msharlo1

It is also a bit strange that Cor, a high F/low E was sparring with a D tier to begin with. She mentions pushing him off, but if it was more on the sexual assault side of things than just an unwanted advance, would she have had any chance to resist?

Carly

Cal should definitely kick the guys ass, but I don’t think he should kill him. Then he can portal the caravan to hopefully assuage any hard feelings from the merchant for beating up his goon. In a lot of ways, Cor is a mirror of Cal but without the power to back up her confidence and impulsivity. As irritating as she can be with her poor safety decisions, I do think she’s an accurate representation of a young person who’s taking their first steps into the adult world, and being slapped with it’s harsh reality. Her knowing Cal we’ll get around and probably keep her safe for a little while if she takes jobs like this again, but it’ll also put a target on her back as being an easy mark for someone who seeks to control him. She’ll definitely need to get smarter and fast.

AlexG

Oh, and should we know what she was wearing? And think of the guard’s bright future being put at risk by such accusations? A woman is never at fault for men choosing to assault them. And revenge can stop when every rapist and attempted rapist is put in the ground where they belong.

AlexG

Cool chapter! It’s interesting how rare and regulated spatial travel is in this society, but I suppose it’s a technology that’s inherently destabilizing on a political and economic scale.

Msharlo1

I would assume she was wearing leather armor for training and life on the road. Was this full on sexual assault though? I could see a scenario where the guard saw a young female running away from a privileged family, complaining about how restrictive said family was, and then agreeing to engage if physical activities (sparring) with him as indicators of interest. Then he makes an unwanted advance because he misinterpets the signs that usually indicate something else. Does that deserve death or whatever beating Cal could probably dish out?

Msharlo1

I feel like this is the type of scenario where Cal would get blackmailed by the merchant if he assaults the guard. Two wrongs don't make a right, and a cleverer way to get justice would be to teleport the caravan to Deadfall and then make trouble for the guard/merchant there. He has the backing of the legion there, wouldn't be putting the merchant at significant risk, and maybe also has the guild master (if he isn't secretly working with the elves). There is also the economic side of things where he has ties to a lot of local trade to punish the merchant.

Msharlo1

I feel like its like airplanes. They weren't regulated at first but now a days they have to be.

BlastYoBoots

As satisfying as it would be to see anyone who lays unwanted hands on a another pay dearly… and Corinne is being vague about how far it went, not that getting successfully shoved off wouldn’t leave him any less reprehensible, especially since the guy shows ZERO regret… I wonder if Cal’s new bloodthirsty habits are going to have him killing or almost killing this man (or even drawing it out into slow torture!) before Corinne tells him to *stop* and they have to reckon with the tension of his new PTSD and how eager he is to kill someone Corinne might NOT want to see killed, or have to deal with the societal consequences of having killed… Whether you think the man should get away even partially intact (I don’t, personally!) is immaterial— I’m just worried Corinne is about to see an extremely bloody vengeful side of Cal she isn’t prepared for, and Cal is going to have to reckon with how Corinne sees him in the aftermath, or how the caravaneers or some other domino effect of consequences might follow him for taking justice into his own hands where this society is (unfairly) unlikely to. Cal is going to have to see his next actions through the eyes of a friend who could have been his daughter back home, and I think it’s likely to show him that his [Mental Mastery] doesn’t mean he’s *emotionally* mastered his mind… He has some psychological healing to do that he’ll have to accept he needs at some point, and Perfect Memory is going to compound that difficulty.

Msharlo1

Another weird perspective on this is that Cal and Cor could totally look like bandits to the caravan members where Cor joins as an inside woman and is used to signal Cal a powerful spacial mage when they are far enough away from society. Soon after Cal's arrival Cor points out the caravan leadership and Cal starts grinning at the head guard like a maniac.

Msharlo1

Cal can also heal the guard after beating him to avoid fallout with the merchant.

Msharlo1

I agree about ptsd/blood thirstyness. I think the appropriate reaction here would be to use this tension to goad the unrepentant guard into a spar with Cal or let him go if he actually shows remorse/declines the spar (which I don't think he would) then heal him after beating him (with Cal maybe going a bit to far because he is unstable). And then, depending on the aftermath blacklist him/the merchant from Cal/hearthstone related business/people. Like, if you grope the local inn keepers daughter, her dad probably won't offer you a room.

Carly

I guess I haven’t really viewed deadfall as a safe place for him. I don’t see him having much pull in the Legion there. Yes, the commander likes him, but I don’t see him being able to pull much support at picking on a guard of a random caravan. I also don’t see the nobility handling his return very well, considering if word has gotten back to them about what he did to their contemporaries. Plus, I don’t know if I trust the guild leader. He’s the one who insisted Cal take the escort job in the first place, which makes me think he was in on it to begin with. If he’s still there, shit‘s gonna go down quick. A big brother, defending his sister against the unwanted advances of a man is gonna be far more understandable and forgiven by the merchant, then him cutting into his profit margins. One is a simple fist fight between individuals over a valid reason. The other is taking revenge on someone who wasn’t involved, and likely has far larger pull in the wider, merchant world. Word would definitely get out about Cal overstepping and punishing the merchant and that would get around to other caravans very fast. What is the merchant gonna blackmail him with really? Even in a world like this, if the merchant says, “yeah, he punched my guard in the face because he made an unwanted advance/touch on his sister,” almost everyone’s gonna understand that. No one‘s gonna take a merchant side in that scenario. Especially, if/when word gets out about all Cal’s done. Him punching the guard in the face is gonna be seen as showing restraint if nothing else. I also agree with some other people who have commented that if this guy seems like a D tier, then Cor really wouldn’t have had a chance of pushing him off. She may have had to push him off, but it does seem like he finally accepted her rejection, so killing him would definitely be too far. But we don’t have the whole story yet so we’ll have to wait and see!

BlastYoBoots

(EDIT: I GAVE THIS USER WAY TOO MUCH BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT, SEE LATER IN THREAD.) @Msharlo1 Corinne was undeniably “reckless” and has room to improve in keeping herself out of general danger, but YOU need to be aware that when you say “at fault” you’re crossing an immense red line you really shouldn’t. Is there a DISTANT possibility that this man stupidly misread social signals, advanced on someone without honestly realizing she wouldn’t reciprocate, and is dumb enough to square up to maintain his professional pride when he COULD be already learning to do better? That with another day to think, he MIGHT have sincerely apologized to Corrine and tried to make her feel safe from him? There may be a DISTANT possibility… sub one percent or less if this were real, though maybe 10% here because the narrative possibility that Cal is vengefully misunderstanding that Corinne *doesn’t want this man dead* would make for juicy storytelling. But please take note that your concern for the potential consequences of Cal’s actions here, your concern for the EXTREMELY distant possibility of honest misunderstandings (when visibly real damage was done and the one who caused harm MUST acknowledge it)… it’s making you LOOK as if you’re more concerned and sympathetic for the abuser than the abused, here. The way you’re phrasing things is unfortunately extremely common in today’s world, and leaves a horrible taste in the mouth. You can SEE how badly this shook Corinne that it’s one of the first things she had to say to him, that DAMAGE has been done to her by the experience— that the man has his chin high ready to defend his every choice— and it’s vitally important to put front and center that this man caused real and lasting harm and does not appear to WANT to acknowledge or undo the damage. In such a situation, your main concerns should be centered around the victim, and only with the harm and injustice firmly in mind ought you carefully bring up the possibility of restorative measures and how they are VERY contingent on the abuser (“““mislead””” or no) first accepting that they caused powerful harm to another person. Because if they CAN’T prove that they accept and regret that, we can’t possibly trust such a person not to continue doing irreversible harm to people, and that danger outweighs any ignorance you might speculate he has.

Msharlo1

To me it is a bit like kids who play in a construction site and get injured. The owners are at fault, as the guard is here but that doesn't mean that they are the only people at fault. I'm not particularily sympathetic to SA victims who ignore danger signs or refuse to seek help despite understanding how hard that can be. It is bad but so are so many other things like murder, slavery, extortion ect. This isn't a modern world, the societal expectations are different and the danger is very real. Did Cor do everything in her power to reasonably protect herself from known dangers? No. Given the cliff hanger we are left on the guard gets the benefit of the doubt however tragic that may be until he has some chance to speak after being accused and undoubtedly incriminates himself next chapter. Even with a full on 100% guilty verdict though, I don't see Cal as the lawful executioner of said verdict or death being the appropriate punishment. I would probably describe my viewpoint on this as Lawful Evil.

Thorlol

@Msharlo1 The problem is that you're explicitly saying Corrine is "a bit at fault" for what happened. She might have taken a risk by not thoroughly vetting the caravan, and she even admits that it was a stupid decision. But that doesn't make her responsible for someone else's actions. That's victim-blaming. And now you're even coming up with hypothetical scenarios to explain the captain's behavior. Where exactly does the chapter suggest that Corrine showed any sexual interest in him? Because she wanted to get away from her family and agreed to spar with him? That's quite a stretch. Even if he genuinely misinterpreted her intentions, that still wouldn't justify touching her inappropriately. Agreeing to spar with someone isn't an invitation for sexual advances. Trying to explain his behavior through signals she supposedly sent just shifts part of the responsibility back onto her. And here's another question for you: If a terrorist runs me over at a Christmas market, am I somehow at fault? Here in Germany, that's an actual risk. Not a particularly high one, but certainly not zero either. Does knowingly exposing myself to that risk make me partly responsible for my own death, or is the terrorist responsible for his actions? Knowing that something bad might happen doesn't make you responsible when someone else deliberately causes it.

BlastYoBoots

(EDIT: I GAVE THIS USER WAY TOO MUCH BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT, SEE THEIR OTHER THREAD THIS CHAPTER.) @Msharlo1 Be VERY careful, as I just replied in the other thread. You’re almost making it sound as if a bit of inn-blacklisting is enough to protect more women from permanent harm even if this man is unrepentant. Unless this man can prove he’s willing— no, EAGER— to work to UNDO the harm he’s already done for more reason than simple self-preservation, he *cannot* be trusted not to continue to deal lasting damage to others. The lasting psychological injury of something like he did isn’t worth keeping a person like this around if it risks spreading the damage, and to imply the minor consequences of his ostracization from inns and such to be enough to make up for THAT is… not a good look. Please be very careful with your wording. Here’s another angle you may not have considered: Corinne might be inclined to spare him and too shocked by the violent retribution to go through with it— but even in THAT case, unless the man proves truly inclined to repair and avoid future damage, Corinne might even turn out *wrong* to want him spared, enabling an abuser out of cultural habit without accepting the harm he’ll continue to do to others unchecked. The cultural acceptance of groping and casual psychological injury to women as an “acceptable” workplace hazard is not something Corinne is necessarily immune to, an internalized misogyny that doesn’t give proper weight to not only the damage already done but the damage this man would *most likely* prove perfectly capable of continuing to do to others unless his attitude changes so convincingly next chapter that we can be *sure* he understands and wants to avoid/undo any further harm to others. Please keep that in mind, too. There’s a chance that even if Cal calms down, it may turn out that the “right” thing to do here would be to walk out into the woods with this man, have them “finish their duel” out of view quickly and quietly, and make him disappear forever, regardless of what Corinne thinks or how it might change how she sees him. It’s not just about her own comfort, it’s also about reliably preventing harm to others. Cal comes from a world where the long-term injury of the emotional wounds abusers cause, and the cost to countless victims of allowing that behavior to be easily forgiven, is… well, not widely accepted unfortunately, but at least somewhat more widely understood. Imagine if Corinne begs Cal to spare the man here because she doesn’t feel like what she’s endured is worth killing him over, because she doesn’t want to see the man bled out over “so little”… dismissing the harm to herself, thinking she’s “stronger” than it… only for Corinne to find out a few months later that this man she begged Cal to let go kept hurting countless other women, or worse.

BlastYoBoots

@Msharlo1 WHOA. You’re “not particularly sympathetic to SA victims who ignore danger signs”?!??!? Jesus tap dancing Christ on a cracker?!? Holy hell, I’m guilty of giving you WAY too much benefit of the doubt. Please stay the hell away from everyone I love and care about.

Msharlo1

Both can be true. My criteria here is "Did you do everything reasonable to protect yourself?" If you are going to an area where terrorists are a real threat, for instance it is worth considering how prepared you are to deal with them, or if you legally can't be, (say because of gun control), what steps did you take to prevent attacks (like voting for anti terrorism legislation). If you aren't prepared to deal with that, staying home is the better option. The terrorist would still also be at fault and a lot more than a bit, but you would also still be dead. Similarly if a car malfunction caused you to get run over, the driver would be less responsible than a terrorist and it would be worth questioning which event happened. I'm not saying that the guard is innocent, but there is still a degree of reasonable doubt if such scenarios can be imagined. While inappropriate touching would be considered illegal/punishable by modern standards, it is mentioned in the chapter that this doesn't seem to be the case in the setting where Corrine states "It's not anything I haven't had to shove off a drunk for at the inn" and said drunks presumably did not get killed. (Though maybe not).

Valderan

Agreed on the dynamic. Also true with her decision making. It was always interesting to see how the most confident people in high school turned meek in the workplace as they got introduced to the grind. Its a different dynamic but they don't really realize that until they're dealing with something that is totally not their problem or fault and someone is making it theirs... And they gotta deal with it because its their job now. Its a wild lesson to kearn.

Thorlol

@Msharlo1 Oh boy, something is seriously wrong with you. But first things first. Your construction site analogy is bonkers. Imagine two scenarios. In the first, a child enters a construction site, climbs onto some scaffolding, falls, and gets injured. In the second, that same child enters the site, but this time a construction worker deliberately pushes them off the scaffolding. Would you seriously argue that the child in the second scenario is partly responsible for being pushed simply because they shouldn't have been there in the first place? And I find your statement about not being particularly sympathetic to sexual assault victims who ignore warning signs rather troubling. What specific warning signs did Corrine ignore that suggested the captain might behave inappropriately? And regarding your point about victims refusing to seek help, isn't telling Cal what happened exactly that? But there's one question I'd really like you to answer: If Corrine had thoroughly vetted the caravan beforehand, but the captain had done exactly the same thing, would she suddenly be completely innocent? If your answer is yes, why should her preparation determine whether she's partly to blame for his actions? If your answer is no, what exactly would she still be guilty of?

Msharlo1

The construction worker would definitely be guilty for pushing a kid. But its worth considering how that would play out if the construction worker then said something like "I was trying to get the kid off the scaffolding because it was dangerous". It is not a perfect 1 to 1 analogy for any form of SA, just an example of multi-party blame. I don't think Corrine vetting the caravan would have protected her in this particular scenario, but traveling with a known companion or avoiding interactions while traveling alone would help cut down risks. That said there was still plenty of risk even with those things being done. It is not a matter of being innocent or guilty so much as safe or reckless. Cor speaking out is a good example of a victim speaking out an she definitely merits consideration for doing so. That said, is she responsible for triggering a PTSD response from Cal (I think so), does that make her particularly guilty (I do not think so.)

Msharlo1

No, I'm not unsympathetic either. Policing wording to not victim blame can mean not adequately considering risk. Sexual assault is a bit like drunk driving in that punitive measures don't increase deterance which means it needs a more awareness and prevention based response.

BlastYoBoots

Continuing on Msharlo1’s blatantly unsafe stated attitude of being “not particularly sympathetic to SA victims who ignore danger signs or refuse to seek help despite understanding how hard that can be”, since they’re continuing to comment like they have an inch of moral ground to stand on… There IS no reliable help to “seek”. My mother has spent decades counseling SA victims and often helping them through the legal process. In today’s society, as an SA victim you are MORE LIKELY TO END UP FURTHER HURT IF YOU SEEK JUSTICE unless there is no other way forward or you’re prepared to ruin your life for a ridiculously slim chance of protecting others. Here in the U.S. the conviction rate for SA cases— the ones that are REPORTED and BROUGHT TO TRIAL— is less than 9%. (Compare that to *70% CONVICTION* for murder charges.) Years of effort and lawyer expense and the doubts of family and employers and pathologically-skeptical law enforcement, public smearing, reliving your trauma constantly and on the stand, all for a mere 9% chance that your abuser faces ANY consequences whatsoever and isn’t completely free to find a way to get PAYBACK against you when they’ve already proven capable of assault. And yet you’re “not particularly sympathetic” towards the up to 80% of SA victims (by U.S. stat estimates) who DON’T report their crimes to law enforcement? You blame THEM for not ruining their lives even further despite “understanding how hard that can be”? Do you have any idea how monstrous you sound? Do you maybe think it’s a “solved problem” in whichever country you live in, that modern law is sufficient? Say, have there been any very public examples of pervasive unpunished SA in society in the last handful of years that might cast doubts on your perspective??? I sincerely hope that nobody in your proximity ever has to fall victim to your callous disregard. You are dangerous to everyone around you.

Taylor

This is something I've been wondering about... how do attributes measure against each other? Meaning, two fully maxed pathers of the same grade, is their strength exactly the same? Can they both lift the exact same amount of weight? If you have a giant 7 foot tall dude that is stacked like the hulk with maxed strength and a 4'11" wisp of a girl, also maxed. Them both lifting the same weight feels weird... especially in the early grades. If their is variance in attribute effects from person to person I could see how as you grade up the differential becomes effectively meaningless if the increase is additive (low tier guy lifts 200 lbs, girl lifts 100lbs, high tier gains plus 2500lbs, guy lifts 2700 lbs girl lifts 2600 lbs) but if the increase is multiplicative then the differences would magnify. (Guy lifts 200lbs girl 100lbs, high tier bonus x10, guy lifts 2000lbs girl lifts 1000lbs) So, is there variance amongst equal attribute ratings? Is the tier up bonus additive, multiplicative, or something else?

Msharlo1

It isn't a solved problem in my country. It is less solved in a medival setting where power corruption and sexism is more rampant. Not believing that an inappropriate touch warrants a beating or murder does not make me a monster nor are they effective deterrent. The legal system should be professionally skeptic.

Msharlo1

"isn’t worth keeping a person like this around " to who? The caravan he is supposedly protecting (from beasts, bandits and slavers)? The merchant that hired him? The legion? There is a saying to the effect "Any law that can be broken at the cost of a fine isn't a law, it's a tax." And while barring him from establishments wouldn't adequately punish the guard, it would cause the merchant to regret hiring him and possibly cause him to be let go. That said, the legion isn't likely to see his actions as a crime and the caravan isn't likely to see Cal's actions as lawful. Edit: A lot of people jumped on my hypothetical scenario above, but imagining the guard to be a reprehensible monster also doesn't make it true.

Msharlo1

If you've read this far into the comment chain and think I'm a monster, can you honestly tell me that you think the answer to assault is more assault?

BlastYoBoots

You’ve made it abundantly clear both here and in your other thread that you assign a certain value to the harm caused to people by SA that you think is outweighed by the “benefits” the abuser likely contributes to society. You’re free to live with the social consequences of exposing to everyone just how small a weight you place on that harm. You’ll find most decent people place a much higher weight on it than you do, and I hope that opens your eyes someday before you end up helping to destroy someone who’s already been broken. People choose to leave this world every day because they got badly hurt only to find out the people around them think like you.

BlastYoBoots

So in an even more unjust medieval society than our own, where the law carries zero chance of protecting victims of assault… it’s “wrong” to go outside the system to protect the people it’s failing? Because killing a murderer would be murder? Because SA doesn’t do enough “real” damage in your eyes to be worth ending an unrepentant life to prevent it? It MIGHT turn out not to be warranted in this case… but you aren’t behaving like you believe there’s any version of what’s in front of us where it might be warranted at all. Your morality is profoundly warped. Yes, I’ve read this far into the comment chain, and yes, I still think you’re a monster. What’s that term you used for yourself again? “Lawful Evil”, that sounds about right.

Msharlo1

So then is the family member of the guard that takes out a hit on Cal, who unrepentantly murdered the guard also in the right? From the lawful evil prospective it is wrong to take the law into your own hands to kill the abuser because at present there really isn't a lot of legal room to stand on outside of Cal's personal belief in Cor's testimony and that is the perspective I am taking for this discussion because it is more interesting than saying the protagonist should become a murder hobo. Edit From the lawful evil perspective Cal should confirm the guards intent and that he is unremorseful to the group, taunt him into a spar, and THEN assault him. But the results of this would probably be lawful evil as well. It would satisfy Cal's ego but probably traumatize Corrine more. Kind of like the end of Guns Akimbo if you've seen it.

BlastYoBoots

You DO realize that openly taking a Lawful Evil perspective in a setting with horribly unjust laws makes you seem like a ridiculous caricature of a human being, right? (You claim it’s the “perspective you’re taking for this discussion because it’s more interesting”, but that’s NOT what you said earlier— you said that this IS your life perspective, not just that you somehow think seeing Cal ignore systemic injustice would be inexplicably better for the story.) “But the serial abuser had a family!” Pound sand. Nobody here wants to entertain your perspective.

Msharlo1

I do lean towards it in real life as well. Cal murdering/assualting the guard isn't any form of good response, lawful or otherwise. That is the Chaotic Evil response. The good responses all roughly follow the relief, recovery, reform pattern. Get Cor out of there through the portal (relief), let her family know (recovery), prevent similar incidents from occurring through social reform (reform). Edit: Where does it say this guard is a serial abuser?

Malcolm

drop them all in a hole and steal their stuff!

Thorlol

@Msharlo1 What I find interesting is your repeated tendency to come up with hypothetical scenarios that might explain why someone acted the way they did. First with the captain, and now with the construction worker. But why? What does that actually change? Whether the construction worker pushed the child out of malice or out of some misguided attempt to protect them doesn't change the fact that he deliberately pushed a child off the scaffolding. He is responsible for the consequences of that action. His intentions might matter when judging his behavior, but they don't suddenly transfer part of the blame to the child. And I think your entire line of argument is going in the wrong direction. You keep bringing up how Cal might react and whether his response would be justified. But we don't even know how he's going to react yet. And even if Cal completely loses control and seriously injures or kills the captain, how would that change anything about Corrine's situation? The captain is responsible for his actions towards Corrine. Cal is responsible for whatever actions he decides to take in response. These are separate decisions made by separate individuals. Where exactly is the "multi-party blame" supposed to come from? Regarding your suggestion that traveling with someone she knows would have reduced the risk: Sure, it might have. But reduced doesn't mean eliminated. The captain could still have acted inappropriately even if Corrine had been traveling with a trusted companion. We can't simply assume that having someone familiar around would have prevented the incident. And there's another thing about your comparison between modern society and this supposedly more dangerous medieval setting that I think you're overlooking. This is a fantasy world with stats and skills. Physical appearance doesn't necessarily tell you anything about someone's actual strength or abilities. A woman who looks completely harmless could potentially be significantly stronger than the man approaching her, or possess skills that make defending herself relatively easy. Obviously, the same applies to a potential attacker. But that's precisely my point. You can't simply apply the assumptions of a real medieval society to a world where someone's actual capabilities might be almost impossible to judge by looking at them. A potential attacker would also have to consider that the person they're targeting might be far more dangerous than they appear. I'm not saying this makes the world safe. I'm saying that your comparison isn't nearly as straightforward as you're making it out to be.

Msharlo1

"But why? What does that actually change?" It is specifically to remove any reasonable doubt associated with the guard's guilt, as well as to show that the victim did not act in a way that was reckless to the point of endangerment. Did they do everything reasonable to prevent harm in the reality/society they live in. Not doing so doesn't make the guard/construction worker not guilty but it can make the victim 'at fault'/liable as well. Also, you can roughly tell how dangerous someone is in this world through several methods, most obviously being to scan their tier which provides a rough cap on their stats. There are also several visual indicators like, are they well armed or obviously affiliated with a noble?

Jim Heath

While I don’t think it’s going to happen immediately, I do see this as yet another step on the path AWAY from Corinne. Not because either of them want to lose the friendship! But Cal is advancing so much faster there’s just no way for her to keep pace. Cal’s priorities and needs are diverging from hers. Like.a young music star suddenly making it big - he remains her friend, but they no longer have much common ground.

Msharlo1

The value I assign is to the crime, not the criminal. Without assigning weight to crimes and thus adequate punishments, you seem as a moral as you are trying to make me out to be. Just murder everyone who does a single thing wrong regardless of intent? I don't think the guard is innocent, I'm just not yet convinced that the level of guilt he has warrants what seems to be coming. Especially in the eyes of people that are not Cal. I'll leave the rest for the other thread if you want to refute me or call me a monster.

Carly

@Msharlo1 Ooo you’re so right I hadn’t even thought of that side of it!

James

Jon, king of cliffhangers.

Benjamin Walsh

“The prisoners told us much”… usually people don’t rat out their saviors…

Benjamin Walsh

Cal made the first wheelchair as an apprentice… obviously he wasn’t concerned with cost and mass production, but something a novice can make should be easy for a master to replicate as a prototype.

Benjamin Walsh

"It's different out here. It… it scared me." - this seems really strange. Notwithstanding the whole running off on her own and her family just letting her… she grew up as a serving wench at an Inn, went through the mandatory legion training, was nearly killed by an ambush, and this is what scares her? And it’s the first thing she tells Cal? It comes across as very immature which she has never been before…