Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Bobby was still on the phone after giving them the address.

Sam already had the directions up, and Dean was holding the car keys, but Murphy stopped Bobby again before they actually left.

"First, get in touch with any hunters you know near Olivia."

Silence settled over the other end of the line.

"What do you mean?"

"If this is the incident I remember, something's already happened to Olivia, and she won't be the only one," Murphy said. "Dead people may start coming back and seeking out anyone connected to their deaths, or anyone who failed to save them. Salt and iron will stop them temporarily. Tell the hunters nearby not to stay alone, and preferably to leave their homes altogether."

She spoke quickly, sticking to the details that could actually help them now.

What the Witnesses were and which seal their appearance would break could wait until they were on the road. The important thing was to move the people who were still alive out of the places where they would be attacked.

Bobby caught the implication immediately. "Lilith?"

"Yeah."

She heard him rummaging through things on the other end.

Bobby didn't press her for an explanation. He knew plenty of hunters, including several in Olivia's area. Getting hold of them a few minutes sooner could make the difference between a warning and a funeral.

By the time Murphy pulled on her jacket, Sam had memorized the address and route. Dean went to collect their guns and salt rounds, and the three of them headed out.

Bobby called twice more while they were driving.

He'd managed to reach two of the hunters nearby. He told them to take salt and iron and get out of their houses. One had no idea what was going on but obeyed anyway. Others still weren't answering their phones.

Already, that was a little better than the situation Murphy remembered.

In the original course of events, people hadn't even realized other hunters were being targeted until after Olivia died. At least the warnings had gone out this time. They might not save everyone, but they wouldn't have to wait for a second or third body to know what they were facing.

As for Olivia herself...

Murphy didn't have much hope.

Reality had long since diverged from the story she remembered. In the past year alone, they'd changed plenty. Yet from Bobby's three days without a reply to the timing, the people involved, and the present circumstances, nothing about this particular incident had actually diverged yet.

If it happened as she remembered, they would almost certainly arrive too late.

Murphy leaned back in the passenger seat and watched the road streaming past the window. She couldn't shake her irritation.

There was something else worrying her more.

If the Witnesses could still rise, then what about the seal before that?

The First Seal shouldn't have had any opportunity to open. Dean was alive and well, driving right beside her. He had never gone to Hell.

But this time, nothing in Murphy's memories could give her an answer.

-

Bobby arrived more than ten minutes ahead of them and waited outside Olivia's house.

The front door was unlocked. No one answered from inside. The four of them took salt-loaded guns and iron weapons, entered together, and found Olivia in the disordered living room.

She was dead.

Murphy had tried to prepare herself during the drive, but seeing the body still weighed heavily on her.

The room showed clear signs of a struggle. The salt line on the floor had been broken, and an EMF detector lying near a table leg was still registering a signal. Olivia had apparently known she was dealing with spirits before she died. She simply hadn't been able to hold them off.

Sam and Dean examined the scene. What they found was essentially what Murphy remembered.

"Witnesses," she said. "They're dead people Lilith dragged back by force. They go after the people connected to their deaths. More than one came here."

Bobby sighed. He was more interested in what they could do about it now.

"There is a way to send all of them back at once. You're the one who finds it," Murphy told him. "I don't know the exact ritual."

Bobby called the nearby hunters again. The two who'd left their houses were safe for the moment, while another number still went unanswered.

There was nothing more to investigate at Olivia's house. After taking care of the necessary arrangements, the four returned directly to Bobby's salvage yard to look through his books.

On the drive back, one of the hunters Bobby had warned called again. He'd just caught sight of a friend who'd been dead for two years in his rearview mirror. By the time he'd turned to look at the back seat, it was empty.

At least one of those early warnings had saved a life.

Murphy still couldn't bring herself to feel relieved.

-

Back at the salvage yard, Bobby was about to go straight to his study to pull out his books. Murphy headed toward the basement instead.

"We should use that iron-lined room of yours," she said. "It'll be safer to research in there."

Bobby stopped dead.

Murphy walked a few more steps before noticing that no one was following. She turned and caught a rare look of genuine alarm on his face.

She'd lived in this house for a long time. She knew where Bobby kept practically everything.

But the underground room was different. Bobby had never told her about it, and the brothers apparently hadn't known it existed either.

"I never told you about that room," Bobby said, staring at her.

"Mm." She hesitated. "You still haven't gotten used to this?"

After everything they'd been through, he was accustomed to Murphy producing information from the future whenever she felt like it. Somehow this still caught him off guard. He'd secretly built the room himself and told no one where it was or what it was for. Now she had announced its existence the moment she walked in.

He was silent for a while, then gave up asking and told them to gather their things.

His reaction almost made Murphy laugh.

It had been a long time since she'd seen Bobby look like that because she knew too much.

The hidden, ghost-proof room was sturdier than Murphy remembered from watching it on-screen. Iron covered nearly every surface, and the protections were thorough. They carried in salt, weapons, and whatever books they might need, then got straight to work researching the Witnesses.

This time they didn't have to work everything out from the beginning.

Murphy knew Lilith had brought the spirits back against their will, and she knew it was possible to banish the entire group at once. But the original story hadn't shown enough of the ritual for her to reproduce it word for word. All she could do was help Bobby and Sam narrow the search.

With a direction to work toward, they made progress much faster.

Before long they found references to the distinctive marks carried by the Witnesses. They also confirmed that the spirits retained their memories of life. Their pain and resentment surrounding their deaths, however, had been deliberately magnified, driving them to confront anyone associated with how they died.

The only thing left to find was the way to send them back.

Bobby was the one who discovered it.

The instructions were buried in a very old book, and the result matched what Murphy remembered.

There was no need to track down the remains or possessions of every Witness. Completing the ritual in the book would sever Lilith's hold on the spirits and send all of the dead she'd forcibly recalled back where they belonged.

The problem was the final step.

The ritual required an open flame that would keep burning throughout, and once they started chanting they couldn't stop partway through.

The underground iron room was safe enough, but it wasn't built for lighting a fire and performing a ritual. They would eventually have to leave it.

Murphy had expected as much. Now that they had the right method, the best they could do was prepare thoroughly before going out.

Bobby stayed at the table to organize the incantation and materials. Dean and Sam checked the salt rounds in their guns again. Murphy sorted the required items into separate piles so they wouldn't have to hunt for anything once the ritual began.

They were still working when a faint sound came from upstairs.

At first it was only one soft footstep, muffled by the basement and thick iron walls. Another followed a little later, and then the sound stopped outside their room.

Someone began calling Dean's name.

Dean was loading his gun. At the sound of that voice, his hands slowed.

He recognized Ronald Reznik.

Murphy remembered the heavyset man well, too, mostly because he'd died so undeservedly.

Back then, Ronald had insisted there was a "robot monster" inside a bank. It sounded ridiculous, but he'd really seen something. It simply hadn't been a robot. It was a shapeshifter.

The police had eventually intervened, and Ronald hadn't made it out alive.

He'd regarded the brothers as two of the few people willing to believe him. In the end, though, he'd still died because of that case.

Now every bit of that resentment had been dredged back up.

Ronald's accusations came through the iron door in fragments. He kept talking about what had happened at the bank, blaming them for failing to help him and for letting him die while everyone else still thought he was crazy.

Dean listened, his expression darkening. But he knew opening the door would accomplish nothing. Eventually, he lowered his head and pretended he couldn't hear, pressing the rest of the salt rounds into his gun.

It wasn't long before another voice joined the first.

This one called for Sam, and it belonged to someone they all knew.

The real Meg Masters and the demon they'd later come to call "Meg" were two entirely different people.

While the demon possessed her, Meg's consciousness had remained trapped inside her own body. She'd had to watch it being used to murder and deceive. When the brothers finally exorcised the demon, her body was already too badly injured to survive.

The Meg outside remembered every part of it.

The power of the Witnesses had reduced all those complicated feelings to the fact of her death.

She no longer cared whether the brothers had possessed any other choices at the time. She kept recounting what it had been like to be imprisoned in her own body, and how they'd failed to save her in the end.

Sam was visibly shaken.

He remembered what they'd done and why. He knew they'd had their reasons. But none of those reasons could bring Meg back to life. Explaining everything again through an iron door would change nothing either.

He forced himself to focus on the incantation Bobby was copying, checking each part for anything missing from the ritual.

The voices outside never stopped.

Later, Bobby heard his name as well.

This time, two young girls were calling him.

Murphy knew little about them beyond the fact that both had died during cases Bobby had worked on. Bobby clearly recognized them. His hands paused over the papers before he forced himself to continue.

No one inside felt like talking. Outside the iron door, the cries went on, growing steadily more furious.

The longer hunters lived, the more names like those they accumulated behind them. Lilith had brought the dead back precisely to make them suffer.

Fortunately, the iron walls held fast.

The dead could call their names and drag painful memories out of the past, but for now they couldn't enter the room.

After copying the final page of the incantation, Bobby looked up at the others.

They had nearly everything ready. The difficult part was still to come.

They would have to step outside.

By the time their preparations were finished, it was almost midnight.

At some point, the sounds outside had died away. The voices that had been echoing through the door had vanished, leaving the entire house abruptly silent.

That silence made them more nervous, not less.

Bobby tucked the copied incantation into his pocket and checked the ritual components one final time. They decided on the study, which had a fireplace and was both near the basement and well suited to the ritual.

The instant they opened the iron door, everyone was on alert again.

Dean led the way, with Sam watching their rear. Murphy and Bobby carried the supplies between them. They replenished the salt at every place they could seal as they went. Still nothing happened before all four made it into the study.

It was going far too smoothly for Murphy's liking.

The thought had barely formed when the overhead lights went out. The air turned frigid, and their breath began misting in front of them.

Ronald appeared at the end of the hallway.

Without an iron door between them, his voice was much clearer. He was still rehearsing the accusations he'd started earlier. Dean didn't allow him close enough to finish. He raised his gun and fired a salt round, dispersing the figure instantly.

There was no point arguing. They weren't here to settle old scores with the dead.

Bobby used that opening to light the fireplace. Murphy set the prepared materials beside him. Sam guarded the direction of the stairs, and he'd barely raised his gun when someone called his name from above.

The voice stopped him cold.

"Sam."

Murphy looked up, too.

The figure standing on the stairs was Andy.

She remembered his face. He'd had the ability to control minds and usually wore a lazy, easygoing expression. In the end, he'd died at Cold Oak.

Sam hadn't merely heard of Andy. He'd known him personally, and he'd seen his body after his death there.

There was nothing easygoing about the Andy standing in front of them now. Death and bitterness filled his expression. He descended the stairs slowly, never taking his eyes off Sam.

"I had a brother, too."

Sam's face changed immediately.

Andy and his twin brother Anson had both been chosen by the Yellow-Eyed Demon. Anson eventually lost control and began manipulating others with his power, until Andy had to kill him himself.

"I killed him with my own hands," Andy said. "And then I died, too."

Sam gripped his gun, unable to find an answer.

He understood that Andy's resentment had been unnaturally magnified, but that didn't make what he was saying any less difficult to refute.

Both of them had brothers. Both of them had died at Cold Oak.

The difference was that Sam had come back.

"You died too," Andy said from the foot of the stairs. "But Dean wouldn't let you stay dead."

That deal had shaped nearly every part of their lives over the past year. Sam knew better than anyone how he'd been given this second chance.

Dead or not, Andy knew about it now, too.

"He traded his life for yours." Andy's voice grew darker. "Why should you get that?"

Sam's breath faltered.

"Because I made that choice."

Dean cut in from the other side of the room, his voice suddenly cold.

He still had his gun trained on the hall, but half his attention had turned toward the stairs. He could endure Ronald accusing him of his own failures. Hearing Andy blame Sam for the deal was another matter.

"Sam was already dead. He didn't get a say in it," Dean said. "If you want someone to blame, blame me."

Sam looked sharply at his brother, his eyes wet despite himself.

But Andy's anger didn't diminish.

The power controlling the Witnesses hadn't brought them back to reason things out. It had revived their worst memories and shoved every last grievance to the surface.

Yet none of Andy's experiences were inventions.

He'd killed his own brother and then died at Cold Oak. Sam had died there too, but someone had been willing to sacrifice his own life to bring him back.

It was a cruel difference to be forced to confront.

Sam tightened his grip on the gun. He couldn't forget the easygoing man he'd known or the way he'd died.

"I'm sorry."

It wasn't an apology for Dean's deal. It was for Andy.

Sam squeezed the trigger. The salt round struck Andy, and the figure dissolved at the foot of the stairs.

But the words "Why should you?" didn't vanish with him.

Dean glanced at Sam as though he wanted to say something else, but Bobby had begun chanting behind them. This wasn't the time to reopen old wounds, and Sam quickly resumed his guard at the stairs.

Murphy looked away and tightened her hold on her weapon.

Bobby hadn't been chanting long before the Witnesses outside seemed to notice exactly what he was doing.

Meg re-formed on the other side of the room, not long after the last salt round had scattered her. She broke through what remained of the salt line across the doorway.

Dean shot her apart again. Before the sound of the gunshot had died, Ronald was already back at the end of the hallway. The two girls from Bobby's past appeared in succession, blocking their other routes out.

Suddenly the study felt crowded.

Only then did Murphy fully appreciate the difference between knowing how an encounter would end and actually being surrounded by ghosts that wouldn't stay dead.

They'd avoided the pointless setbacks of the original events and prepared the salt, iron, and ritual in advance. Unfortunately, knowing what to do didn't make the Witnesses any less dangerous.

Salt and iron could disperse them for a while, nothing more. Until Bobby finished the incantation, they'd keep returning again and again.

Murphy stood guard to Bobby's right. She quickly emptied her gun of salt rounds, tossed it aside, and took up the iron rod she'd set within reach.

When Meg appeared again, she was already close. Murphy swung the rod and scattered her, but caught sight of another girl slipping past Dean and rushing straight toward Bobby, who was still chanting.

Sam shot the girl before she could reach him.

As the figure vanished, the wind inside the room grew stronger. Papers flew everywhere, and the flames in the fireplace leaned and bucked in the draft.

"How much longer?" Murphy couldn't help asking.

"Don't rush me!" Bobby answered without looking up. He never broke the rhythm of his chant.

He was on the final section.

Murphy could hear that much, and apparently the Witnesses could sense it too. They started throwing themselves at the room in a frenzy.

Every time salt or iron scattered them, they returned faster. A place that had been empty a second earlier suddenly contained another dead figure.

Andy reappeared beside the stairs.

Sam raised his gun as soon as he saw him, but this time Andy closed the gap before he could fire. He seized Sam by the collar.

"Why was he willing to give his life for you?"

Andy slammed Sam into the wall. Pain shot through his back, and his gun flew out of his hand.

Dean instinctively turned toward him, but Ronald reappeared directly in his path. Murphy was closer. She sprinted over and swung her iron rod into Andy's side.

Andy let go as the iron dispersed him.

"Sam!"

"I'm okay."

Sam steadied himself against the wall, bent to retrieve his gun, and took up his position at the stairs again. His eyes were still red and his face looked awful, but his movements were as quick as ever.

Murphy couldn't spare time for another question.

Meg was back. Dean's shotgun rang out again. The four of them were driven into a tight circle around Bobby and the fireplace, dispersing the dead with every swing or shot, only to face them again seconds later.

Finally, Bobby spoke the last line.

The fire in the hearth leaped upward.

All at once, the room that had been filled with gunfire, wind, and the dead shouting fell silent. Every Witness froze at exactly the same moment.

Murphy still had the iron rod raised. In front of her, Meg was already fading. Ronald and the two girls were fading too, their solid outlines breaking apart without re-forming.

Andy lingered near the stairs a moment longer. This time he said nothing.

Sam stood watching him. The unnatural fury on Andy's face seemed to drain away, leaving a few quiet seconds before he, too, disappeared completely.

The wind died.

Loose papers drifted to the floor. The fireplace settled back to its ordinary flame.

Only then did Murphy realize her arm ached so badly she could barely raise it. She laid the iron rod on the desk and let out a long breath.

Bobby lowered the pages of the incantation at last.

The ritual had worked.

Once they were sure the house was quiet, Dean's first concern was checking Sam and Murphy for injuries.

Sam had hit the wall hard, but once he recovered he could move normally. Murphy had acquired two scratches on her arm, but nothing worse. Dean checked Bobby too, and finally allowed himself to relax.

This night had ended far better than Murphy remembered it ending before.

At least Bobby hadn't been dragged out and nearly beaten to death by angry spirits, and two of the hunters who'd received early warnings had managed to escape their attackers.

Murphy sat beside the table, flexing her aching, half-numb arm. During the fight she'd been too occupied to think about anything else. Now the question that had been haunting her since the previous afternoon returned immediately.

The Witnesses had appeared. Their seal had been broken.

What, then, had happened to the First Seal? Who had opened it this time?

Murphy was wondering whether she should call Castiel when Dean spoke first.

"Cas."

He waited a few seconds, then tried again, using Castiel's full name.

This time they weren't kept waiting long.

When a fifth person suddenly appeared in the study, Bobby whipped around in surprise. He'd heard plenty about angels from the three of them, but this was the first time he'd watched Castiel appear in his own home. He couldn't help looking him over.

Castiel showed no particular reaction. He took in the disordered room and the still-burning fireplace and reached the obvious conclusion.

"You've sent the Witnesses back."

"So you knew this was happening the whole time." Dean wasn't in the mood for games. "Was this a seal?"

Castiel admitted it without hesitation.

Until now Bobby had known only that Lilith was responsible for the spirits. This was his first time hearing about the seals.

Castiel explained the basics. More than six hundred seals held Lucifer captive. Lilith didn't need to break all of them. Breaking sixty-six would be enough to free him, and the rising of the Witnesses was one of those seals.

Nor was this house the only place under attack tonight.

Lilith was attacking other seals at the same time. Heaven had dispatched angels to stop her, but the battle stretched across too many fronts for them to arrive first every time.

Bobby went grim at the mention of Lucifer's name.

Murphy wasn't particularly surprised.

She knew all this already. It was the question she'd been carrying with her that she wanted answered.

Dean had reached the same thought. He leaned against the table, listened to Castiel's explanation, and asked, "And the First Seal?"

Silence returned to the room.

Castiel looked at him for a moment before answering.

"It has already been broken."

Murphy's last faint hope sank.

Sam glanced instinctively at Dean.

After a few silent seconds, Dean asked when the First Seal had been broken.

Castiel said it had happened some time before the Witnesses rose.

In other words, while they'd believed that changing May 2 had eliminated the most important first step, the First Seal had been opened by another route anyway.

"It was supposed to be me," Dean said.

Castiel didn't dodge the question.

"Yes."

In the original course of events, Dean would have died on May 2. His soul would have fallen into Hell, where he'd resisted years of torture until finally giving in and deliberately torturing another soul himself.

The First Seal would have broken the moment he did.

Murphy had known the future Dean was meant to face for a long time. For Sam and Dean, though, this was the first time they'd heard the whole of it.

Dean's expression worsened by degrees.

He'd prepared himself for dying and going to Hell. But enduring years of torment there until he was broken enough to start inflicting it on someone else was a different matter entirely.

Sam looked even more miserable. His fists tightened without his noticing.

If they hadn't changed what happened on May 2, Dean really would have ended up there.

"Who was it this time?" Murphy asked the question that mattered most to her.

Castiel looked at her and answered plainly. "I wasn't given that name."

She frowned. "Aren't you going to rescue them? Whoever they are, they're supposed to be a righteous soul."

"Heaven is dealing with the other seals. I've received no orders to search for that soul."

Sam tried asking it another way. "Was the First Seal broken in the same manner this time?"

"Yes," Castiel said. "A righteous soul in Hell yielded and began hurting another soul."

So the mechanism hadn't changed at all. Only the person had.

No one spoke for a while.

Dean sat down, plainly miserable. He'd survived, but that hadn't erased the suffering originally meant for him. It had simply been inflicted on someone else.

"Lilith found herself a replacement?" he asked.

"Very likely."

"And you don't even know who it was?"

"I was not given the name."

Dean stared at Castiel for a while, then restrained himself from pressing any further.

He wasn't going to get another answer.

Murphy leaned against the desk and thought hard about what qualified someone as a righteous soul.

The description covered far too many people. It wasn't as though righteousness was an identity that could be recognized at a glance.

As she understood it, a decent, kind, faithful person, or someone willing to make sacrifices for others, might all qualify.

Even Dean and John had met the prophecy's standard of a righteous man in the original story. There was no way to narrow the possibilities to a single person from that description alone.

More troubling still, whoever had taken Dean's place might have died long before they realized the First Seal was in jeopardy.

Murphy mentally retraced the people they'd encountered since May. One name came to her almost immediately.

Nancy.

She went still. The case they'd spent two days investigating without success returned to her mind in a rush.

That night at the police station, Nancy had been terrified, yet she'd stepped forward anyway, volunteering to give her life so the people possessed by demons outside could survive. She was religious and genuinely kind. If someone like her didn't qualify as a righteous soul, Murphy couldn't think who would.

And after all that, Nancy had ended up being killed by demons.

She'd been abducted, kept tied up for a long time, and ultimately murdered. Even now, they had no idea why demons had specifically chosen a woman who'd gone back to an ordinary life.

The case that had made no sense suddenly offered a terrible possible explanation.

"I just thought of someone," Murphy said. "Nancy."

The other three understood almost immediately.

It had only been a little over a month since the case. None of them had forgotten. Dean's expression darkened further, and Sam lowered what he was holding.

"It's only a suspicion," Murphy cautioned before anyone could run with it. "We know demons took her. We don't know where her soul went after she died, and we certainly don't know if she's the one who broke the First Seal."

But even the possibility was sickening.

They'd never found any reason for demons to single Nancy out. If they added the requirement of a righteous soul, an awful lot of the loose pieces began to fit together.

Bobby frowned, considered it, and wrote down her name.

That was all they could do for now.

No phone records could tell them whether a dead person had gone to Heaven or Hell. Even Castiel didn't know who'd replaced Dean. Proving their theory immediately would be next to impossible.

Castiel didn't stay. Heaven still had other seals to defend. With the Witnesses dealt with here, he soon departed.

The four of them were alone in Bobby's house again.

Bobby reopened the old book, looking for any other reference to the First Seal. Sam sat down at the table and began compiling what they knew.

Dean didn't join them.

He'd only just learned what else he might have suffered in Hell, and he was understandably in no mood for research. Murphy wasn't in a hurry to talk to him about it either. Her own thoughts were still on Nancy.

Every time she turned the case over in her mind, it looked more suspicious. But suspicion wasn't proof.

Sam's pen paused when he wrote Nancy's name.

If the theory was right, then the demons had planned the whole thing from the start.

Castiel had no answer, and Murphy could only make guesses based on what they knew. The demons themselves, though, might know much more.

That thought brought Ruby to mind.

He'd been meeting her in secret lately, without Dean or Murphy knowing. Ruby might have had nothing to do with the First Seal. She might never even have heard of Nancy. Still, she understood Lilith's side of the conflict far better than they did.

Surely the question was worth asking her at least once.

Sam held his pen a moment longer, then set the idea aside.

He wasn't ready to tell the other two that he'd been meeting Ruby behind their backs.

On his page, Nancy's name was written directly beneath "First Seal."

None of them could say for certain that she was the one.

But at last they had a first name to investigate.

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.