Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Why is it so hard for America to build things?

Bridges take years to construct. Housing costs are soaring. Transit systems are crumbling. And we’re struggling to update our infrastructure to prepare for the climate crisis. Even when there’s broad agreement that something needs to be done, collective action feels impossible. Why is that?

Today’s guest is Marc Dunkelman, author of Why Nothing Works, a book about the modern American experience of watching government fail. He argues that by giving too many people the power to say “no,” we’ve stymied our collective progress.

Marc and Sean discuss an inherent tension in American politics: the need for effective, centralized power and a deep fear of its abuse. They trace how that tension has played out across American history, from the clashes between Jefferson and Hamilton, through the New Deal’s Tennessee Valley Authority, to the backlash against figures like Robert Moses. Marc argues that our current system — born out of a reaction to too much top-down authority during the late 20th century — has produced paralysis, dysfunction, and a deep distrust of government.

Host: Sean Illing (⁠@SeanIlling⁠)

Guest: Guest: Marc Dunkelman ⁠(@MarcDunkelman)⁠, author of ⁠Why Nothing Works: Who Killed Progress — and How to Bring It Back⁠.

We would love to hear from you. To tell us what you thought of this episode, email us at thegrayarea@vox.com or leave us a voicemail at 1-800-214-5749. Your comments and questions help us make a better show. And you can watch new episodes of ⁠The Gray Area on YouTube⁠.

Listen to The Gray Area ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: ⁠vox.com/members⁠

This episode was supported by a grant from Arnold Ventures. Vox had full discretion over the content of this reporting.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Comments

Robin

Thanks for framing the conversation around scarcity through the Jefferson–Hamilton tension between federal power and state responsibility. Sean, it might be interesting to follow up with an episode on how the federal government’s dominance in income tax collection limits the ability of states and communities to raise revenue, just as they’re facing growing social challenges with limited or prescriptive federal support.

Sean Illing

Hey Robin, that's such a good point. Glad you raised it. The Hamilton–Jefferson frame does push you to think about where power and capacity actually live and revenue is a huge part of that story that we didn’t really get into. States and cities are expected to handle a growing list of social problems, but they’re often fiscally constrained and dependent on federal money that comes with a lot of strings attached. That mismatch between responsibility and capacity feels pretty central to the broader dysfunction we were talking about. Whether the answer is more federal centralization or a rethink of fiscal federalism altogether is an interesting question. We'll definitely think about this as a possible follow-up. Thanks for flagging!