Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 700068476.mp4

Downloads

Content

In this video we catch up on some The Who Singles they released in 1966!

  • Happy Jack

  • Substitute

  • I'm a Boy

  • Pictures of Lily

Also in this video:

  • John Lennon - Serve Yourself

  • The Who, Michael Lindsay-Hogg - A Quick One (While He's Away)

Files

Comments

Ken Hunter

Really weird suggestion to add the John Lennon song to the wheel. Only a (very rough) home demo, never recorded in the studio afaik, and only makes sense in the context of reacting to Dylan's Gotta Serve Somebody. (He also did a home spoof of Knockin on Heaven's Door during Dylan's Rolling Thunder tour called 'Mama take this Makeup offa me' )

J Martin

wrong version of I'm A Boy. shame.

J Martin

Fairport Convention was the gateway for my american self into British Folk Rock. All their first 5 albums are 5 star for me. Led me to Steeleye Span, John Renbourne, Pentangle, Nick Drake

J Martin

Not sure how this 'cake' person became the arbiter of what to listen to... already several mistakes: the poor stereo remix of My Generation album, wrong version of Anyway Anyhow Anywhere, skipping the Quick One album, Substitute came out before those other singles, using the wrong version of I'm A Boy, probably missing the great bonus tracks on Who Sell Out... so far this Who journey seems very flawed

Scott B.

I don't agree with some commenters about your The Who coverage so far. On the whole it's been great. A Quick One is not their best album, but I wouldn't skip it and given that you've heard the live version of the title track, wouldn't you want to listen to the studio version too, which was used to great effect in the movie Rushmore. The original American version of the album was called Happy Jack and is better. I agree with the people who said you used the wrong version of I'm a Boy (a later remake rather than the original single version - both of them are great though, it's just that the original single is, most Who fans would agree, even better. But these are only minor criticisms; I thought this was one of your most enjoyable video posts ever. My only real complaint is using a lousy home demo version of Serve Yourself, rather than the brilliant one Lennon recorded accompanied with furiously strummed acoustic guitar (released on the album "Wonsaponatime") by a swimming pool in the Bahamas, where he'd sailed to alone singing sea shanties in the face of a storm thinking he was going to die. Sadly it was when he got back from this holiday to New York when he was shot.

M

What version of I'm a Boy is this? Is this the one on Meaty, Beaty, Big and Bouncy? I'd never heard it before.

J Martin

Yeah its from the MBB&B album. It was recorded a few months after the single version. For me it's too slow and drags on where the single version was pop perfection

J Martin

I don't get why people are hating on A Quick One so much. It's essential to the bands evolution as each member contributed songs. I'm sure Vito would have appreciated that Kieth Moon had 2 compositions where he got to showcase his wild drumming

J Martin

especially when there are great songs by John they haven't touched yet like Mind Games or Woman !

Ken Hunter

The thing I'm most shocked about listening this time through the Who discography is how many of their early songs are comic/comedy - at times they come across like a novelty act (albeit with great drumming and musicianship...). I'm a Boy, Boris the Spider, Happy Jack, almost all the Sell Out album, Pictures of Lily. Aigerim / Vito remarked about them not making best use of their gifts - musicianship, power, etc almost like they had some kind of identity crisis. Townshend seems to be trying to turn them into a second rate Kinks copy at this time. IMO Tommy is where they find themselves and start really producing what they are capable of. Someone (Bernie I think) remarked that they sound like a totally different band on that album, and I agree. It's where it all comes together. Some people don't seem to like it much (for unknown reasons?) , and prefer Sell Out, but I'll put money on Vito and Aigerim disagreeing on that. (Btw, agree with skipping the Quick One album. Heard it on other reactions and there is a reason Keith and John and Roger didn't write the songs for other albums - overall the songwriting was appalling.)

J Martin

Yeah I can see what you're saying. They definitely started out as a tough R&B and heavy pop act then after changing producers (from Shel Talmy to Kit Lambert, who was kind of eccentric) it seems they lacked direction, or rather were expanding in all directions. I think though that their live performances were still very explosive around this time as seen in the film 'the Kids Are Alright' and the Monterey performance