Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

BD - Legendar-Bee Poll

  • Retcon out Immortals 21
  • Keep Immortals 218
  • 2026-04-22
  • 239 votes
{'title': 'BD - Legendar-Bee Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Retcon out Immortals', 'votes': 21}, {'text': 'Keep Immortals', 'votes': 218}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 4, 22, 21, 44, 53, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 239}

Content

Ok, it appears the immortals are more controversial than I anticipated, to the point that folks are actively calling for a retcon. Thus, I will be given you all here on patreon the chance to influence the decision. We shall have a vote on whether to keep immortals or go for something else.

Be advised: if you elect for me to retcon the latest chapter, I’m going to say there will be no new patreon chapter on Friday, because I will need time not only to make the changes but also to reset. Not going to lie, a retcon like this is a big halt in momentum, so I’ll need time to ramp back up. I also don’t want to penalize the Royal Road readers for a choice they weren’t party to, so Royal Road will continue on and gain one chapter on the patreon. You will still be 5 chapters (so at least one week’s worth) ahead afterwards.

Now then, while I normally avoid spoilers and also prefer letting the story speak for itself, I would like to explain a bit more of my ideas for the immortals, seeing as they may never come to fruition anyways, and to answer the points raised about Belissar’s mentality.

So, the plan for the immortals would that this would be a continued step in the direction of the entire hive contributing to the fight of its warriors, which we’ve started with dancers and ministers. I envisioned not as one bee taking over the fight for the others, but as the whole hive granting its combined mana and life to its warriors even when not actively engaged. And, through the hive of hives and a monster bee empress…all hives could start to help. IE, the First of the Fifth’s swirled honey could become a battery to regenerate the Firstborn’s knights, or other such things, such that the hive of hives’ strongest warriors cannot be killed until the entire hive of hives falls. In fact, stuff like that was probably going to be necessary because I was thinking the army queen's hives, being smaller and less productive, probably don't have sufficient hive mana or honey stores to support Immortals on their own at the moment, so was going to be a moment where only the hive of hives made it viable.

It would also open the door for Belissar to select options that are otherwise guaranteed to die, such as the berserkers, and to lean more heavily into intentional sacrifice tactics, rather than only accepting unavoidable sacrifice.

I also did not plan for Belissar to pull back all non-immortal bees when he realizes not all of them can be made immortal. The bees would still fight and Belissar would still accept that casualties are possible, but a few of them could fight more aggressively and take on more risk to let the others fight more safely. IE, if we made the Firstborn’s knights or the new giant bumblebees immortals, they could charge right into the enemy and get right in their face while ignoring counterattacks, allowing the non-immortal bees to strike with impunity, or they could tank enemy attacks while the other bees fly safely behind them.

As for Belissar’s character growth, the way I see it is that Belissar will always want to protect the bees to the maximum extent possible, even if he accepts or embraces bee death as necessary. That’s ultimately a core part of his identity, no matter the extent to which he embraces bee sacrifice he will always prefer for bees not to die when given the choice. But well, yes, I can also see the point that perhaps you might want him to have to sacrifice bees every now and again, which would mean we would have to remove the choice to avoid those bee deaths. You monsters.

Another point is the question of the Thriae and how and when they might return to the story later on. That was not settled yet, but I will point out that Warriors are not the only types of Thriae, so there might be more avenues to acquire Thriae than this one. It would be something of a pivot for me to take them now, plus, you know, then we don’t get the whole prophecy-vibe with them advising Belissar in a way he wouldn’t expect and that may or may not end up better than getting them now. So, even if we don't select Immortals we may not end up with Thriae...yet, that is...

Bee-hemoths, the other option, are fine to pick…but come with the big caveat that their price tag + the environment and resources necessary to support them mean they’re just going to sit as an option in Belissar’s menus for a long time most likely. Who knows if Belissar will even have one by the time he might need some legendary firepower...unless, of course, Belissar had a way to rapidly expand his dungeon and maybe grow some world-tree levels of flowers and forests with some kind of giant plants. If only...

But well, let’s be real. Given Belissar’s identity, it’s hard to imagine him not being at least heavily interested in immortals if they’re offered. So, if I’m going to retcon it, I probably just need to wipe immortals as an option and come up with a third choice that would probably be the one Belissar picks. Well, if it comes with a cheaper price tag than bee-hemoths and the Thriae still says don't pick her yet, that is, otherwise it’s up in the air. No idea what the new option would be yet…already used up my creativity on this first set of options so will need some time to think…

Welp, anyways, that’s just like, my opinion. We’ll put the question to the hive now! So, what’ll it bee?

Comments

Pyro4224

I like the immortals options, I had a thought that it could be a way for the lost hives to return, eventually. Through either a boon from the death aligned gods or as another option to build off of.

Durphymcbob

Ok with the current plan for the immortals i am much more on board. I was just afraid it was going to be give to every bee and loss of bees would no longer be a part fo the story. But giving to the a handfull of the desinated "Tanks" i can get behind. Maybe even give make it limited to them and the Named non-queen bees. It should be alot more limited, and the Squads of the immortal nights should bee given a special name for their squad and any individual bees given immortality should bee given names, as being brought up to that power makes them characters on par with Frelis, Beero, the First Dronecaster, and 4th of the 7ths First Minister. the Imortal Evolution should not be given out to every bee and sacrifice no longer being a risk. That was my main issue and worries Sorry if i came off a bit rude, i was just worried about the path the story would take with the immortals. but seeing that you are not going to to make make every bee immortal and only a few champions that is alot more of an option i can get behind.

Dotakiin

The other options are cool and I would like to see them at some point, but immortals was the pretty obvious pick here.

Bob Bryan

The immortals are fine. The beehemoths are to early for him to really use or make, yet. So definitely a later option. And the time warrior bees, would also be great but maybe a bit to early. Though I do hope they show back up soonish. Ironically they might need the most prep to be properly useful since they are the most different. But immortal bees are fine as they are their own thing and not the entire hive. Though I want to point out zom-bees should possibly be a future option.

Yeslek Nnamhctits

I love this. Thank you for the choice. Immortals feels like a fall back for bellisar. Personally, he has shown growth in acceptance of death, the queen of all death even noticed him. I think retconning them out will make a big difference, just in terms of his growth towards the balance of life and death. I really like the prophecy, however, and I hope it stays, I wouldn't be averse to him being made to wait for a legendary option, as the beehemoth offers some cool opportunities for all the other bees, especially the breezy and nomadic varietals

Jayden Martinez

Sorry people are being rude about it. I thought the immortal bees was a great idea, I trust you to make an amazing story no matter what!

Joel

I think the immortals are fine, but my worry is anytime a story starts to remove permanent death as a consequence for big characters, the stakes of any fight are lessened. We also have allies with close ties to death and immortality feels like its kind of spitting in death's face. Idk. I never recommend a retcon, but I do hope immortals are handled with care.

Linkneo5

Id vite to retcon if that meant he would choose the vastly more interesting Thriae, but if retconing means he chooses an unknown third option and it delays chapters then its best to keep as is.

Kira Hikari

Personally I like the idea of a few immortals. Frelis, Bero, the Pixie demigod(i'm seriously spacing on her name and don't feel like going back to find it for this comment) Bumblehelper's first Bumblebee bestie. The ones that would gut us if they died I'm on board on them being immortal. That being said. I have a couple ideas for possible Legendaries just in case they help you reset if the retcon happens. first off is a type of humanoid bees. There's an aurhor, Benjamin Medrano. He's got a series, the Beesong Chronicles, about a Bee Girl, her species is called Apis and its an adorable series. Apis characteristics are that they make their own equipment out of wax and propolis. They're equipment can't be used by non Apis, and they starts wing less before evolving to gain wings at a higher level. They need giant flowers like the bumbles to feed the hive and their Royal Jelly is a Panacea that is a universal antidote. Though it does take a tiny hive of 10,000 A full year to make a single dose. Apis have 2 arms, and 2 legs, 4 wings once they evolve them, and antenna. Their base armor is light armor and Rapiers but they can change their weapons depending on whether they evolve into a warrior, assassin, scout, etc. Healers/clerics are called Humblebees. They sing little songs to themselves. Once they break out of their cells they are fully formed and independent but about half the size of a full grown Axis. So no infants or babies. Also they have short lifespans. Workers live 3 years with warriors a bit longer, and so on and Queens have a full century natural life span. Queens are also at least a foot taller then any of the others. AH, to be clear I'm not recommending you try and just take Apis as the legendary...i dont want you in trouble with Medrano. Just hoping it helps with ideas for other legendaries.....

Fernando Oliveira

I like the immortals it fits belissar's character and is something that can be applied to many of the different bees available, yeah we can't make all of them immortals but this would open up belissar's options and give the bee army more ways to fight.

VitalAbyss

I like the immortals. It's not like it's going to be every single Bee. That's not how the evolution seems to work. So, I think they're perfect for Beely. I'm intensely interested in the Thriae, but can wait for that to be a good focused story beat. And, I assume, the Bumbles and the Heart of the Forests will grow to be a World Tree and Gargantuan. Which can be another story beat. All in all, perfectly fine with the direction of the story.

Sewing Chaos

Honestly I think it'd end up being a step back in terms of Belissars growth for him to focus on keeping bees "alive" and bee-hemeoths would bee more in line with wanting to make bees happy, and help them grow beyond. That said if we are doing a math min/max with time and mana, and not choosing the bee-hemeoths as with many other bee option it's clear that Belissar can quickly evolve his bees towards that end... Hmm as I'm typing this out I'm realizing that the immortal bees aren't as much of a backwards step for Belissars growth as I thought...

William Clark

It's basically a life link with the option for resurrect. Not that crazy overall.

Steven

I like the immortals seem to be good direction in the story

Icalos

No worries, you weren't rude and I know it's cause you care about the story. Regardless of if we keep immortals or not, I will keep in mind the points about Belissar's character growth and approach to death.

Lisa

I did not mean to be rude and I apologize if I was. I still don’t like it and would prefer a new option, but it’s clear that my opinion is in the minority, so I’m not going to harp on it. Thank you for considering the idea, though. I do really like your story. I can’t help on legendary bees beyond the space/time/knowledge abilities already suggested by various readers, but I commented a few ideas for less-legendary bees in the last chapter if you wish to use them.

Icalos

Nah, they weren't rude, they just care very deeply about the story and disagreed with one of my choices, and they did raise valid points. I've felt the same about other author's choices plenty of times, so can't complain haha. But thank you for letting me know you like it and the story! Always nice to hear!

Daniel Long

The way I read Immortals was that the damage one bee took was then spread across the whole hive, and the hive of hives. Damage that could be fatal to one bee spread over hundreds of thousands ...

Icalos

No worries, you didn't come across as rude to me and I know it's because you care about the story. Even if we keep immortals, I'll take your points on Belissar's character growth into consideration.

Thomas Todd

As cool as the other options are, I don't think it would make sense for Belissar to pick anything but immortal just based on his character. Not only that, it is also really cool. I'm picturing immortal bees as the tip of the spear, cutting down enemies through their sacrifice and then coming back to continue their eternal watch

Yami

I am fir keeping them 100%. But i do have a slight issue with the wording of them. As it stands it drains the hive of hives of mana and only after that starts using the honey. Which might be a problem -if a lot of the immortals were to die-because they use hive mana for spells and communication which would both break down. Oh and maybe they need a pain resistence perk?

CataFlan

I see a lot of comments, but not a lot of votes. For me it don't change if the immortals stay or not. What matters is the balance. If there are ways to limit the immortals and to bees die, so be it. If not? Maybe there's other options. If the legendary bees can only be narrowed to time, space or knowledge, maybe we can help broad this options. Space bee: can have a lot of options inside this sub-category, like: teleporters, dimensional slashers, space distortion venom, and etc. A space queen bee will be legendary, for sure. Time bees too can be legendary, of course, not the thriae, but like other elemental bees, have the time mana to accelerate or decrease the passage of time, but focused on the control of time, not with clairvoyance or prediction. It will be the fusion of time and knowledge. Knowledge bees can be ancient bees with knowledge of honey, plants, polem, trees, bees evolutions, environments, elements and etc. With perfect memory, they could be the perfect memory-bees for Belissar. Now we start with new options. Elemental bee: not like the fire queen or the water queen, but an advanced form of the slime queen where her entire body and all the bees of her hive are made of elemental mana. The option can be a mana elemental to be fused with the other elements. Think about the water elemental from Nenavann, but more like a fusion between elemental and bee. Keeps bee form, reproduces like bees, make honey, but their honey has more element than "honey". Dragon bee. Draconic bees with statuses more powerful, they don't reproduce like bees, it's a middle term between dragons and bees. They have high resistance to magic, high defense and an awfully high regeneration coupled with mastery over magic. Perfect if the immortal came after a long time. They grew in power with time, like dragons, that's why they don't reproduce often. Their honey is hard and not very nutritious to other bees, but essencial to dragon bees (hard like amber?). Use of the draconic flowers. Primordial bee: bees of the first hive of the first specie of the first bees. They keep their own lineage and don't fuse with other bee types. They have mastery of bee spells (not elemental bee spells) and can produce ambrosia but in awfully low quantity. Their honey are more nutritious and sweet than swirled honey and almost on par with ambrosia, but they can't produce it in large quantities. They can't survive without enough primordial honey, so they keep their hives short. IMO, immortals should stay, but if they don't make the cut, one of those can be used as another option to Thriae and Bee-hemoths.

Kenneth Welever

Just gonna put this here: Imortals is the only bee type that the hive can't work towards. The bumbles are already working towards bee-hemoth. And the future bees need to be later because they are faaaaaarrrr too expensive and tower changing. My only gripe is that Imortals is less a new monster than a hive induced buff ability.

CataFlan

What if to be immortal bees, they need to "evolve"? They can't evolve anymore, they are "fixed", for example, an immortal soldier can't evolve to be a lancer. A bumblebee can't grow, and etc? They are "photographed" and can't change anymore?

mapts

I think you should make it prohibitively expensive so each hive can only have like 1 of them. And then those individuals can act as champions somewhat. I also feel that it should do something to make them different in other ways. For example the stats they have are different from before they evolve. The legendary special stat should apply in some way to make them powerful. Like if you made a mage bee an immortal they would be extra powerful with magic. Or if an assassin bee was chosen they get a huge boost to their poison. Either way just having a couple of immortals doesn’t hurt the story in any way. And we can see bees obliterate strong opponents with their boosted sacrificial sting.

Findell

Eh the other two types of bees showed a known evolutional path. Which means that he can eventually make them on his own. The immortal choice seemed like it was only either by accident or something directly from the god of bees.

Ariamaki

Absolutely keep: Narratively it fits the logic and Belissar's history best, and the other two have very good reasons for not being picked. The only counterpoint I could think of was if you came up with a different bee type that wasn't truly immortal but had some other logic behind having "can use sacrifices freely / escape death frequently": A Molting Tele-bee for example, which can always shed its current body and teleport back to the hive. That fulfills a very similar role mechanically without the narrative complications of pure mana-fueled immortality.

A Very Lila Himmel

I shared the concern many others did with the immortal bees but I also have heard many authors talk about one of the worst mistakes authors can make is to completely change the direction of their stories because a plot point was unpopular with some of their readers. Sometimes the dislike and worry can be justified but when it is a point the author has planned as a significant part of the story, it can kill what makes the story unique and turns it into just another generic and forgettable story. I made the choice to trust Icalos to not destroy what made the story unique with adding immortals and I am much more reassured after hearing more of the plans for them. I do think care still needs to be given to ensure that the immortals don't break the story and development of all the characters and ensuring that the legendary bees stay special and don't just become a common plot armor to save on sacrifice.

joseph kelley

Keep but in my opinion you need to make it a ritual to make them and bee goddess needs to get in trouble thus feels a little like she is stepping on Death's toes

A Very Lila Himmel

As far as the other options go, I think it would be interesting if at least one of the bumblebee hives or some of the solitary bees evolved in the direction of the Bee-hemoth. I also think it would be interesting if Niobee ended up evolving into one of the Thriae. Her hive has become Sacred bees and I imagine that will have an effect on her. She has also thought about trying to become more human and becoming a bee/human hybrid being could be a way of accomplishing that without giving up her bee-ness. It could also be a way to get the Thriae into the tower without them becoming some sort of super warrior that dominates the battles.

granndfunk

I vote for Keep Immortals only on the condition we get at least one bee with the disposition of the Seekers from Chrysalis! We seek!

GrandSageGand

Listen I saw the ideas you listed as soon as I read the option the first time, and it should be kept, but more importantly it is your story, your characters, your bees, don't let any of those hive burners nay say you, a recon would kill more than momentum, could kill the passion for the story and that would be a real crime, keep up the good work

CataFlan

WE SEEK! But bees who wants to die are silly non-bees likes!

Thatguy92_

Immortality is always tricky in any narrative to navigate, although whats offered by the Imortals isnt really legendary. In all honesty i think you just spooked people with the name and ill fitting description, this clarification really clears things up. Still voting for the retcon, not because i think its better but because im a gambler and that secret fourth option could be really sweet

Peter Smith

Keep the immortals, in fact make them decently cheap, however give them a limitation. They are legendary not mythic, a mythic immortal bee, cannot die so long as the tower stands, a legendary immortal can return so long as their core or remains are returned to the hive and sealed in honey to ressurect.

Ark

Maybe if they die they get reborn in a pre-made honey cell. They remember everything that happened but they need a bit before they can reach the level they used to be

HereForHFY

Adding my voice to the quire to agree that immortals is the obvious choice for Bellisar, his prime directive is to not let Bees die if he can avoid it, even if the Bee-hemoth would be a very obvious statement of power for when he meets the outside world again. Let them fly around on their silly little dragons, Beely's ride is bigger and nastier.

zombies wolking

Personally I’d like to see what the evolution path for the other options would be to get there free

Dire

No different from Niobee. I see no issue.

KDP

Keep the immortals. The whole point of reading a story is to follow the authors idea/vision as a big part of the tension and excitement is that you as a reader can't influence and don't know what will happen.

NethanielShade

Honestly I really want the beekin. Thriae. Whatever. But looks like they’re planned for the future anyways, so Immortals was the second best choice… even if it’s super boring, underwhelming, and not even a new monster type rather than just an extra perk. But I digress. Don’t retcon it out. Your explanation for the plans for the perk have me convinced it’s a good thing. It takes care of my absolute biggest gripe with the story: how much of a pussy Belissar is about any bees dying.

M

All been listed before, but author please be careful to: not lower stakes with making all loved chars immortal, or give Beely all he wants and not have to struggle and grow Keep inventing interesting intersting bee types/evos (immortal seems like a buff not a type) which we all love, especially when used in unexpected ways (builders learning weaving) Using time/space as a beat-all, best stories use time/space+hubris as a way to frame baddies and then let the hero show it isnt unbeatable for a reason.

andrew finn

Your reasoning narrative is most appreciated. Gainsayers butt-out. The flow is correct and sweet like honey.

Charlie Jones

Honestly, I don't believe Bees should be made immortals, I believe it should bee an independent Hive that only has a relatively small amount of them in balance to them beeing immortals. Then he can use them and when they are regenerating he would have to use regular bees. It could also bee seen as him only making his favorite bees immortal as well, but luckily we know the hive of hive is beeyond such trappings.

n00by_ME

I want a whole host of immortal Spear-Bee's (Forgot their name, the ones who "fall" from the sky in cross formation..) for a nice little "spray-and-pray" bee action. You could even go for a mystirious cultivator story vibe, like: "On that day Immortal's fell from the sky like rain." xD Jokes aside, I think a small host of Immortal Bee's are a good thing since it will allow for sacrificial tactics that Beely would never try under normal circumstances.

Claff

You're thinking of the lancers, I bee-lieve

Demolug

I am glad the vote is so heavily towards not doing the retcon. I know that, if I were Icalos, a forced retcon like this would have been pretty demoralizing to me, and sapped a lot of the enjoyment from writing.

n00by_ME

Yeah those! Thanks