Unexpected Horror: The Hash-Slinging Slasher (Patreon)
Content
This blogpost was written by none other than Josh Domanski, co-writer and designer of Liminal Horror. You can find more of their work at:
itch: https://unenthuser.itch.io/
bsky: unenthuser.bsky.social
Liminal Horror RPG: https://liminalhorrorrpg.com/
The year was 2002. Maybe. I’m not actually 100% positive on that part. Regardless, I had come home with a prize from the Mundy Branch Library: SpongeBob Squarepants - Nautical Nonsense and Sponge Buddies on DVD. This was the first DVD collection from the series to hit the home market, collecting 10 episodes from the first three seasons of the show, including classics like Ripped Pants, SB-129, F.U.N., and Club Spongebob. However, this collection also included something special: Graveyard Shift, an episode of the show that was produced during season 2, but would not actually premiere on television until later that fall during season 3’s run. This wasn’t something that was widely advertised at the time, and the DVD box doesn’t even make mention of the nature of the debut, so for some months I was the only one of my friends that had seen this mysterious new episode of the show.
Graveyard Shift centers around Mr. Krabs’ decision to keep the Krusty Krab open for 24 hours a day. To cope with the boredom, Squidward attempts to scare SpongeBob with a ghost story centered around the “Hash-Slinging Slasher”, which comes back to haunt them later that night when elements of the story start occurring while they’re alone in the restaurant. [Spoilers] It is later revealed that this was all a coincidence and was the result of a character who simply wanted a job at the restaurant. The episode ends on a gag where it is revealed that it was Count Orlok from the 1922 silent film Nosferatu that was the one flickering the lights (this later becomes a horror of its own after season 11, as Count Orlok ultimately returns 12 more times, cementing the show’s “creatively bankrupt” era, alongside further appearances in the spinoffs Kamp Koral and The Patrick Star Show).
In my adult life, my partner likes to occasionally keep the 24/7 SpongeBob channel from Paramount+ up just to have some background noise during work or chores, so suffice to say much of that show is permanently etched into my psyche. However, Graveyard Shift popped up again during a recent bout. And you know what? There’s actually a really good case study for learning to run better horror at the tabletop in there. Watch the clip below. Just the first segment.
Watch (5:15): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgIY_U6Npxg
Squidward has got some great instincts for telling a spooky tale! This is a really cleverly written and acted scene that highlights the art of spoken storytelling. What I’m going to do here is break down a few segments and provide some notes on how this can relate to tabletop horror specifically.
[Segment 1]
Squidward: Years ago, at this very restaurant, the Hash-Slinging Slasher used to be a fry cook… just like you, only clumsier!
So right off the bat, our Facilitator here has tailored the horrors specifically for his audience. It’s not just that the horror comes from a familiar place, it’s that the horror was once just like you! The implication is clear: this too could be your fate if you’re not careful… that is, if the Slasher doesn’t get you first.
[Segment 2]
Squidward: So now, every… what day is it?
SpongeBob: Tuesday.
Squidward: Tuesday night! His ghost returns to the Krusty Krab… to wreak his horrible vengeance.
SpongeBob: But tonight is Tuesday night!
Squidward: Then he’ll be coming!
Our Facilitator is riffing, coming up with the story on the spot. But in this moment, there’s the pause in narration, question to the player, then pivot to immediately incorporate the new information, increasing the impact of the horror. It’s not just that the Slasher worked here and was a fry cook, there’s also a chance he’s coming tonight! Our Facilitator isn’t just exposition dumping memorized prose, he’s remaining alert and adaptable, even if that means pausing the narrative for a moment.
[Segment 3]
Squidward: Then he taps on the window with his grisly spatula hand.
SpongeBob: No.
The choice of words here immediately conjures imagery. You can almost hear the clink of metal on glass. And it’s not just a spatula hand, it's a grisly spatula hand, a simple addition to the sentence that carries a horrific vibe with it.
Squidward: He opens the door… [foley screech]...
As a lover of making foley sounds with my mouth, the creaky door is a classic. You don’t always need a complex soundboard to capture the right vibes when you have the ability to make mouth noises.
Squidward: He slooowly… approoooaches… the counter!
Our Facilitator has altered his pattern of speech, dragging out his words and leaving space between them while tension is built.
Squidward: And you know what he does next?
SpongeBob: What?
Squidward: You really want to know?
SpongeBob: What?!
Squidward: Are you sure you want to know?
SpongeBob: What, what, what does he do?!
Squidward: He gets ya!
There’s two elements in play here. First, the Facilitator is asking questions about the potential outcome to the player. When you give your players space to contribute to the narrative, they may come up with even more horrid creatures to face or deadly consequences to manage than you had thought of yourself. SpongeBob is already consumed by fear at this point and they’re not playing a game, so he does not do that, but the opportunity was there.
Second, our Facilitator is really ramping up the tension here. Instead of revealing the horror, he drills down and pushes even further. With each question asked, thoughts of what could happen are flooding the player's mind, leaving him screaming when the tension is broken and the consequences revealed. This is the ebb and flow, knowing when to push, when to pause to ask questions, and when to reveal the true nature of the horror.
I’d recommend going back to watch that scene again with all of this in mind. Pay attention to the choice in words and how they’re delivered. With a bit of practice and intentionality, you too could run your games like this and be better off for it.