Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 306117533.mp4

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Enjoy!

-Michael

Files

Previews only

Comments

uniflorus

awesome essay! whats the font you used for the titles? it's siick!

Jay Murray

Love everything you put out man seriously

Filip Kuligowski

Slight correction: in the Russian civil war the whites was name given to all the fraction in opposition to red bolsheviks, eg. Tzars royalists, not only Mensheviks

Noah DiTullio

Very cool video! I was watching a Sisyphus video and he brought up acid communism, seems like a topic you could do a great justice too. Keep up the great work!

Wolfgang

Your videos get better and better, and this one was no exception. Great vid

Owen G

Sucks this got blocked on yt, thank you for making it free here I was excited to watch it tonight!

camusque

Thanks a lot for making this free! I was looking forward to watching it. It was genuinely really thought-provoking and insightful. I'm Looking forward to more essays in the future.

Jessan D

Thanks for the free essay

Banzaifly

Wow, this was phenomenal.

Will Bryant

Can you stream patreon videos to your TV??

Au

The best page I have ever found on YT, of any genre. Truly incredible work.

888

This is Great

Broreale

A good summary, but when you get into the details your abstraction of the revolution and the civil war can cause some misconceptions, like conflating the Mensheviks, the other socialist parties, and the Whites. Also, 'kulaks' were always a horribly ill-defined group, running from grain speculators to peasants who simply held grain to feed themselves. They effectively became a tribal identity by Stalin's times, kulaks simply being the children of people the Red Guards said were kulaks. Lenin himself was an ascetic, but his party officials threw parties while peasants starved in the civil war. I don't blame anyone for dropping these ideas when making a 30 minute documentary about the insane Russian Revolution. Your message isn't diluted by it.

A C

So well done. Thank you!

Yeasin Reza

thanks for making it free..I came to Patroen only to watch the video

Riley Wayton

Although, I was sad my homie, Trotsky, wasn’t much mentioned (makes sense, wasn’t about him), this was one of the more concise videos I’ve seen on the history/ rise of Lenin in his Russia. Thanks you for posting this for free cause this proletariat is financially broke.

Josie

freaking using CIA numbers for the civil war. I'll believe those numbers when they have names attached to them that aren't part of one rich family (that earned execution).

Maxen Fleming

Given the turbulence of today's international politics and polarized takes mudding conversation I'm deeply grateful for nuance in this topic. I wish you luck in getting the video back on YouTube <3

jonah

born in the wrong generation :/

Wp

Fuck YouTube.

Dale Morrey-p

Thanks from me too for making this free here. I look forward to every one of your videos. After years of putting it off, I got a copy of Lolita because of your video. Thanks again.

Jakob Bruhspenning

Is there a way to download this video? I usually watch documentaries while commuting by train

nv_johan

Great video! You made this nuanced topic very comprehensible yet still thought provoking

Michael Romano

Thanks from an old peace freak pinko . How bout a study of Lester Mahkno (sp?) , the Ukrainian anarchist ?

endersul

Thank you for this

Colton LaSota

YouTube taking your video down made me another Patron. Be sure to thank the guy how took it down

Tarek Y

This is an awful misrepresentation of lenin’s values and communist thought in general

Sean Marzinotto

It was always quite interesting listening to my mother tell stories of her having dedicated classes weekly in school, dictated by the state, to teach children about the history of communism. She was born in and grew up in communist Albania. It wasn’t until the iron curtain fell and she came to Australia that she learned how the state twisted the story of communism. It was so ingrained that she said when they went on a class trip to Moscow to see Lenin’s body, their teacher teared up in the presence of it.

Chris G

I subbed to the patreon just to watch this again. They are all fantastic, but I was reading a book on soviet history on a plane just before seeing this video. The call to Action at the end was a brave, and very true, statement. I hope this makes it's way back on to Youtube for the sake of educating others. Thanks for all the amazing content.

Nelly Flanagan

I am surprised there is only one person saying this. I find that this take, while very well put together, is not as nuanced or balanced as other viewers purport. I would like to analyze the sources, which I expect to have a fairly noticeable and inherent Western European/American bias. Frankly, I think this is a topic that is simply impossible to cover fairly in thirty-five minutes, although this is a valiant effort. It is easy, but woefully misinformed (mostly on the part of viewers here), to conflate Leninism and Stalinism.

Comrade Trash Panda

Where are your sources/citations? I'd like to read them.

Reese's Pieces

Damn, I've never seen so much praise for Lenin.. im kinda disgusted..

Reese's Pieces

Definitely killed 10s of millions possibly 100s of millions.. especially if it's just Marxism.. lol