Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

PICK 1 ANIME!!!

  • Classroom of the Elite 874
  • The Apothecary Diaries 627
  • Steins Gate 1092
  • Mashle 551
  • Magi 535
  • 2026-05-14
  • —2026-05-18
  • 3679 votes
{'title': 'PICK 1 ANIME!!!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Classroom of the Elite', 'votes': 874}, {'text': 'The Apothecary Diaries', 'votes': 627}, {'text': 'Steins Gate', 'votes': 1092}, {'text': 'Mashle', 'votes': 551}, {'text': 'Magi ', 'votes': 535}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 18, 0, 2, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 14, 0, 1, 35, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 3679}

Content

I posted the first episode reaction to all 5 of these series’ and I see a lot of love for them.

So I’m gonna do this poll to see what yall want the most.

Not saying I’ll react to these right now, but I can at least promise next month 100%. Which is only 3 weeks away.

But I definitely wanna pick up 1 of these next month

Comments

@lexGreen

Apothecary Diaries all the way!

Madara Uchiha

Pleaseeee classroom of the elite it's so hype

subaruthegoat__

Only 1? Brotha you HAVE to pick up Steins;Gate then. Apothecary Diaries is peak too, but Steins;Gate is just something else 🔥

Gavin Wong

Steins gate no question

bobby dyson

Hey nick I know this is irrelevant to the poll but could I make a request after you’ve done with the anime’s your watching could I recommend angel beats

NoahNotes

He doesn’t pay enough attention to watch Classroom of the elite or Steins Gate 😂

Electrorazor

One hell of a poll here Nicholas

LetMeTalk

Apothecary fans don’t disappoint

Ignacio Albiol

Steins Gate is the most overrated anime of all time lmao😭

Fourth Down Labs

Nick you know you want to react to Mashle don’t let the haters stop you 😂

Fuzecore

Nahhh only 1 that's not enought 😭

Mellow

Honestly I feel like Steins gate will win, but you’ll enjoy Magi and Apothecary Diaries more. Mao Mao is legitimately one of the best protagonists I’ve seen in a long while. Very refreshing. Steins gate is incredible and worth watching, I do hope you’ll still watch the others.

Jdj Jdjd

Mashle its only gonna get better bro

Diavolo

Ofc steins gate will win...

Gethin Jones

YOU HAVE TO PICK CLASSROOM OF THE ELITE

subaruthegoat__

Blame your fried attention span not the anime

NoTroubleBubble

Ion know nothin' bout non of these but I'm picking the one with the diary cuz that sounds hot. 🤣

slipstride

I'm fine with apothicary dairys steins or magi all are goates

Snoopy Loopy24

Watch them all one after the other, start with Steins gate and then Mashle etc

Ignacio Albiol

Nah, it's not even that good really, interesting plot good couple of characters but nothing special really

MIce1987

Apothecary Diaries is amazing.

gicutu

Let there be a miracle and magi gets chosen, magi fans unite pls

Tensa

STEINS GATE!

venti

Still waiting for 7ds😔

Ignacio Albiol

If you are new to anime it's incredible, when you are a veteran it's good I'll say but that's it, I think magi is way better it's not close but ok

Ocean Flan

Type of dude who totally gasses up Boruto and/or Solo Leveling and whines when One Piece doesn’t have aura farming every episode.

Asuna

STEINS GATE LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOO

Abdullah

Magi will not win. But Magi is the Goat

Menschgu

where jojos at

Edu Rodrigues

Can't decide between Steins Gate and Apothecary. Both are so good D:

Ignacio Albiol

Yes, it's way better than stains gate and nick will drop stains gate I'm certain

JonTalksTV

Classroom of the Elite is genuinely peak ngl. It has a pretty cult fanbase just like Steins Gate does, but the difference is I hear people tend to glaze SG a decent degree more that CotE so I suppose that counts for something lol

The Ganon Cannon

Stein's gate is so incredibly peak holy. You just gotta think of it like the first half sets up the second half.

The Ganon Cannon

Yeah, pretty sure the anime is unfinished for Magi.

CapriRisen

Noooooooooooo Magi, it was its one chance 😭😭

Airhead

But theres a specific order on steins gate to watch, u dont just jump from s1 to s2, i think u have to watch zero between, idk anynore tho i watched it a along time ago

No Swear

at least 2 :/ mashle and classroom

wildfi

ngl guys apothecary diaries is a good anime and all but knowing nich he won't really enjoy it and will probably drop it after a few eps

Shadebedlam

Please Steins;Gate, others are good but this one is special

Karatsuki

I don't really see Nick getting through any of these completely but I still have to vote for the best one

ramin

def pick up steinsgate, it has a slow start but it gets better and better. also make sure to watch in the right order for the best experience.

Teletubbies on PlayStation

Steinsgate isn't even that smart though unlike apothecary diaries where every other episode is a fucking Scooby-Doo mystery conducted by the Chinese Riddler He'll be fine

TheDarkWes

I hope classroom of the elite🙏🏼

Lock in

How does Magi get less than Mashle. No taste

NAMENON

Magi……

Diavolo

he's getting easily through mashle

EmyChwan

M A G I !!! IS PEAK! IS A MUST!

IamBaum

Seeing Magi in last place breaks my heart :3

brandon

How can Steins;Gate be the most overrated when Cowboy Bebop exists?

KJKC

Bro😂😂😂😂

scolux

Please pick up magi it’s the best one here next to apothecary Diaries

Brok3NJays

magi being cancelled doesn't mean it was a shit show u know....

Fuzecore

lmaoo we see the fit bro

Mr Evol

Hey now, there's no need to bring Cowboy Bebop into this.

Van Meurs

Why not just watch what you wanna watch

A

Magi is one of my favorite manga of all time with a beautiful anime and Steins Gate is also absolutely solid. I'll vote Magi just to hype it up more. It seems Steins Gate is winning so I can go to the other option I'd love you to watch

iAlpha Soul

Magi or mashle for me but magi peak

Echoe

who are these people why magi is at the bottom

DJays32

Making us chose 1 is evil

Joel

Yesssss steinsgate

BigMacGD

Steins;Gate is a fucking masterpiece and I'm so happy this community finally gives it spotlight for you to react on it. Awesome.

Shark Tiger

Honestly, I've got a good feeling that Madoka Magica reactions will happen judging by how Steins is performing.

Kouzen

I'm uniting

Kouzen

Bro, Magi

Lee

Steins Gate or Apothecary Diaries are my favourite shows! pls pick either of them.

Goat

COTE!!!!

alu_verse

I wish Magi could win- this is my ride or die series man, and I actually recommended an OST to you Nick awhile back from the series and you reacted to it..... god I wish but it won't happen with all of these amazing series up to bat :(((

Leb

Should’ve been food wars ngl

Bongart

No it's not. A poor attempt at adapting a good novel

JuneBug

it better be apothecary diaries istg!! I love that anime

JuneBug

Why would he drop it?

Teletubbies on PlayStation

Apothecary diaries is just a bunch of Scooby-Doo mysteries and I don't think he cares about something like that.

Naki

cringe

endo

Nicholas please choose the top 2 animes. 1 is not enough, Classroom & Apothecary are peak <3

Javier Alvares

Hahahahahha I understand that for people with difficulty paying attention and understanding, it can be difficult to see

Javier Alvares

I've seen approximately over 700 anime, so that argument isn't valid. I can't say one is better than the other because they're two completely different anime, but both are good. it's not like it's overrated. If people like it, give their opinions, and it ends up winning, it's because they like it. And even if you have your own opinion, the numbers don't lie: nobody will vote for something they think is bad to win.

Ignacio Albiol

I'm good, I've seen the TV show Dark😂

JuneBug

Yeah, that makes sense.

izi

Nick is not smart enough for steins gate 100$ he will drop it 😂

Lucas Araújo

It's sad to see magi in last, its probably the most unique shonen on the list and full of cool fights

OpMan

ehh they all seem mid to me

endo

PLEASE PICK TOP 2 ANIMES

Ocean Flan

Or you can y'know. Just enjoy every episode?

ED TRINH

So you want nicholas to react to steins gate lmao bro won’t understand the plot

Bommy

Never heard of steins gate. Gunna go look it up now

Light_356

Bro please, Mashle is legit so peak

Mincho

Steins Gate will make you feel things u didnt know u could feel

Jalen Green

classroom of the elite😎

volcano132

STEINS WINNING LES GOO

Jacob

Magi should definitely be second but Im very happy with steins gate, anyone who says it's mid/bad is just an iPad kid that has no attention span or critical thinking skills

God

The original comment is correct. COTE is all hype and no substance. Any character depth is discarded in favor of the MC aurafarming.

Rocco Canfield

Apothecary diaries needs to win‼️ its about time Nick reacts to a protagonist on par with his intellectual capacity.

Filip

Love Steins;Gate but not sure If it might be too advanced for Nick. I hope he does zero aswell

Pablo BS

Hell naaah it's mid if you have mid comprehension that all

Sanket Balia

Lol saying Magi is better just shows what type of anime you like not what's objectively better in terms of story and character.

joao quintal

how do so many people like steins gate? bet he wil just get bored lmao

Cayn

It should really be Mashle or Magi. 🤷‍♂️

Gonçalo Baião

STEINS GATE really guys???? you the the chance to see MAGI Reaction from Nicholas the GOAT anime from this list pls vote MAGI!!!!

Reiko

Steins;Gate would be more than great, although if it can't win... It is understandable

Anzel

atleast two bro all of these are peak

Jin Moris

not today brother 🙏🏼😭🙏🏼

Zander Massie

please classroom of the elite i beg

Sandwich

Evert single one of them is worth watch at some point

Bingo

mashel is a fun anime that you will just relax while watching.

Maxakari

STEINS;GATE! :O Let it be the time!

BigMacGD

brother, I have watched hundreds of anime and been an anime fan for 8 years now. Steins;Gate is still my favorite anime. Giving Steins;Gate spotlight is what it deserves, because it's still not talked about enough. Most people consider it a masterpiece and you are the exception, who thinks it's overrated. So stop crying lol.

Bob

I really would have wanted Erased, or Monster But Steins;Gate for sure

RadzioxxD

Yuta's pfp says it all

Ignacio Albiol

Ragebait has never been this easy🤣😭

Keita

Magi the GOAT Steins gate is easily one of the best anime for me but you have to be patient for the foreshadowing.

Snubby

steins gate is gonna win and i think it'll be a good watch, just a shame that some of the other shows on this list are gonna get canned and never picked up by nic any time soon.

Ethereal

People only call things overrated because they're mad that everyone enjoys the thing they don't like

M4I3X

I don't get why people would choose steins gate. Most people should know hat Nick isn't really the type to pay attention and then picking steins gate?

Sora

don't understand how classroom of the elite is 2nd to win on this... it's so cringe

boyjoy

Facts. Been watching anime since 2006 and it’s easily in my top 5.

Maxakari

Steins;Gate must win, it's the show of the intellectual chosen ones, and MAD SCIENTISTS. So coool.

gabe

How is magi last place

gabe

THANK YOU!!!!!!!!

Impulsife

NICK! CHOOSE THE ANIME YOU LIEKD THE MOST (MAGI)

Luis Matamoros

You got a whole ass season with three parts of doctor stone to finish Nick.

Pvrple

Stein's Gate and cote are both very different from stuff you've reacted to so far, really hope you will consider watching both, since it looks like Stein's Gate will win, but cote also has a fair amount of votes

Stanley King

Thank god steins gate won…

hanmaAkim

Lot of goat anime but waiting for years for steins gate ! Finely 😁

Oleksandr Rubtsov

Thank god Steins;Gate is on the lead now, such a peak series

Normadus

I can already feel the shitshow with Steins Gate. Nick wont understand shit and people will get mad and start bitching about every little thing

yan

i hope this is not a repeat situation like lotm.

Ashamdon

I hope you will pick magi up anyway should you have the capacity at some point

sausage sausage

How is there more votes for Shitroom of the Elite than for Magi what is this audience 😭😭😭😭😭

idkwhy

I hope Mashle will win!

cthuluchan

mashle clears all of these shows and its not even close

Karatsuki

So confused on the tiers It says that Movies should be available on the warlord tier but Kung Fu Panda 2 is locked And I've seen some other post that are supposed to be for the next tier be available for this one aswell

aabitto

rage bait?

Jet Pack

Im anime fan almost 20 years. Since 2008 when I watched death note, 2009 naruto shippuden to now modern times and for me steins gate is number 1 with One piece so I agree with you

Nel Fănel

the goat has yeet to arrive, that s Hentai Tensai Shoujo time

AnimeCustom

Isn't Kung Fu Panda reaction coming out on Saturday? So no wonder it is still locked

KaasTosti

yo where's my seven deadly sins at 😭

Mediumg4

I know it wont win but magi is my favorite series so please

Ali Al-Gattan

classroom of the elite is not possible.. he can't concentrate that much

Kiza

I swear it's definitely not for him lol

Lucas Araújo

Im hoping he does magi because it's was the one that he most liked

Chelsi

Yeah magi please give that anime some love and attention its so good

Maxakari

Let's get Steins;Gate past the finish line! It's been wanted for so long, we finally have a shot this time!

sahel herrera

I here for Magi or Mashle since he seemed to like those and they arent just the popular anime of the season

Sanket Balia

the classic ragebait escape people use when seek attention and then get roasted and then try to act superior to protect your own ego, this seems to be a trend among a certain grp of people

Proto Mundi

Hope you watch all 5 of them. Everyone one of them has reasons to be watched.

Kiru bruh

i really hope that magi makes it

Larper088

PLEASE BRO STEINS GATE, i subbed just for that so I can vote

Larper088

The right order is to just watch and finish the 2011 anime, thats it. Steins gate 0 is just extra, sure its really good but its bad pacing to do it in the chronological order

Larper088

its not necessary to watch steins gate 0, but if you want to watch it, then you shouold first rewatch steins gate but this time in chronological order. But if you start with that order, pacing will be bad and it wasnt intended that way in the beginning.

ramin

yeah it‘s extra but it‘s canon and many people consider it to be even better than steinsgate. i watched it like this: steinsgate 22 eps, episode 23b, steinsgate 0 23 eps, steinsgate ep 23,24.

Airhead

I mean true yeah, but i understood abit more once i wat hed zero, its just meme af that lit 1 ep before last theres like a whole ass season XD

MysticKon

Mashle please!!! Its such a good overpowered series!

Ronan

STEINS GATE!!!!! trust me you'll love it

Ulti

sad that magi is so low, it should def be a top 2 or 3 pick

Crystalfied

Classroom of the elite and steins gate are my favorites along with mashle cus its just fun

Kevin Goolsby

I'm partial to Mashle but I know Steins is more popular and it's a great anime as well but a totally different feel. I think Mashle would be a fun alternative if he would pick both since Steins is such a heavy show to be able to decompress by watching Mashle after.

Zain Bali

can't believe people are recommending steins gate to Nick of all people, lmao. He will get so confused and won't enjoy it at all.

Binguette#66

Steins Gate finally winning omg

Fizz

Magi less popular than the rest but its so peak wish it could win 💔

Jay

Is Steins Gate finally going to win a poll 😭

CapriRisen

Can’t believe peak Magi tied with mid ahh Mashle for last 😭

CapriRisen

I mean he said he watched and enjoyed Orb and that’s probably the most engaging and perplexing dialogue ive seen in an anime. I think he’d enjoy it maybe 50/50 fs

CapriRisen

And comparatively i personally dont think steins gate is very confusing at all but then again it’s Nick

Oliwia Szpruta

So sad the apothecary diaries ended up third ;-;

Fizz

Its not abt how smart the show is its abt how much info he has remember and facts abt characters/the world, which nick struggles with even for normal shonen shows

Shank Mugen

Dang, missed the poll Would have voted for Apothecary Diaries Not sure if it would have made a difference But still